Nvidia clarifies when it will — and won’t —keep financing neoclouds
Rain, wind and thunderstorms roll into Santa Cruz County, and the wet week is just getting started
Why Do People Keep Dumping Buckets of Fish Into Montana’s Lakes?
This story was originally published by Vox and is reproduced here as part of the Climate Desk collaboration.
On a summer day in 1992, a man dumped a cooler full of a fish called yellow perch into Lake Mary Ronan, in northwest Montana.
We know this because two teenagers saw him do it; they wrote down his license plate number and called in a tip to the Montana Fish, Wildlife, and Parks department (FWP), which immediately dispatched biologists to capture and kill the perch with nets and poison.
The teenagers got a reward of $500 each for their efforts, while the man was charged with illegally introducing non-native fish into the lake, slapped with a small fine, and sent on his way. The law changed soon after: Now, intentionally introducing a non-native, invasive species to Montana’s waters is a felony punishable by as long as two years in prison or a fine of up to $25,000, or both.
“A decision made by one person can affect an entire interconnected ecosystem. It’s like an act of arson.”
But the perch? The yellow perch—at least two of them—survived, multiplied, and quickly went on to wreak havoc. They established dominance in the lake, wiping out its population of a native fish called the Westslope Cutthroat trout and causing other ecosystem disruptions. This hasn’t only happened here: Montana is filled with thousands of beautiful alpine lakes and rivers, nestled in the sort of rugged territory that sold people on the idea of the West. Yet, across the state, without permission, people keep dumping non-native fish into them.
The reason is simple: The introduced fish, according to some anglers, are more fun to fish than the stuff that’s already swimming around in Montana’s waters. But this guerrilla ecology—or “bucket biology” as some call it—risks upending delicate, longstanding ecosystems, harming not only native fish, but also animals that depend on them, like bald eagles, bears, and otters. It could turn Montana’s pristine waters into murky messes that also require millions of dollars in cleanup and additional maintenance every year.
And it’s not just a problem in Montana. Across the country, states are trying to stop people from filling lakes with fish that don’t belong. It’s a high-stakes issue with ramifications that can reach far beyond the underwater neighborhood of a single lake; efforts to stop illegal fish-dumping have now spawned everything from high-dollar bounties and dedicated fish forensics.
“A decision made by one person can affect an entire interconnected ecosystem,” said Craig Barfoot, Fisheries Program Manager for the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes (CSKT), which is based on the Flathead Reservation in northwestern Montana and oversees some of the most pristine aquatic habitats in the state. “It’s like an act of arson.”
Flathead Lake, about an hour’s drive south of Glacier National Park, is the sort of place postcards were made for. The 27-mile-long lake, half within the Flathead Reservation (and overseen by the tribes) and half managed by the state, is one of the cleanest, clearest lakes in the populated world—a survey last year found that the lake is clear down to about 36 feet—which draws all sorts of creatures to its shore. During a two-day visit in October, I saw a black bear ambling along the shore and a bald eagle sitting in a tree, tearing into a fish it had scooped out of the water.
This massive glacial lake “was ice about 15,000 years ago,” said Tom Bansak, associate director of the Flathead Lake Bio Station, a research station in the lake that’s run by the University of Montana. “Before western contact, there were maybe eight to 10 species of fish in the lake, which is not very many for a lake of its size.”
That changed starting in the late 1800s, when wildlife managers at the federal and state levels decided to start stocking lakes around the country with fish that were raised in hatcheries and released into the water for recreational fishing. For decades, states mostly made stocking decisions based not on local ecologies but rather on the kinds of fish people wanted to catch, filling them with nonnative fish like trout, bass, walleye, and pike. If you live in the United States, there’s a good chance the closest popular fishing spot is filled with stocked fish; at Flathead Lake, wildlife managers introduced around 30 different kinds of non-native fish, of which about a dozen established spawning populations, and today non-native fish outnumber native ones.
“Some of these people are spiteful in their desire to move fish around. People are mad at us, and they vocally say it.”
Eventually, state wildlife agencies began to realize that this sort of recreation-driven stocking can harm local ecosystems: In the 1970s, for example, Montana decided to stop stocking non-native fish in most of its streams and rivers. It still stocks plenty of fish, though, including a few non-native species, in some of its lakes and reservoirs, as do most other states.
For some people, however, that’s not enough. Some anglers believe the fish native to Montana, like bull trout, cutthroat trout, and sturgeon, just aren’t as fun to catch or as tasty to eat as, say, northern pike and walleye—both of which have been illegally introduced to the state’s waters in recent years.
Enter the bucket biologists. It can take as little as a bucketful of fish to alter the population of an entire lake, which means that if someone is bored of the fishing options at their local lake, they could unilaterally decide to spice things up with little risk of getting caught. Despite nonnative fish introductions now being a felony in Montana (and at least four other states), not a single person has been charged, let alone convicted there; that man the two teens saw at Lake Mary Ronan more than 30 years ago is the only person to have ever even been reported.
But fish and wildlife officials know it’s still happening because they keep finding non-native fish in the state’s waterways, and the most likely way they got there is by someone illegally dumping them in.
”They’re obviously avid anglers, and we probably know them,” said Sam Bourret, a fisheries biologist at FWP based near Flathead Lake. Investigating illegal fish introductions is Bourret’s speciality: The Great Falls Tribune called him the “fish detective” for pioneering a forensic technique that looks at chemical clues inside otoliths, fishes’ stone-like ear bones, to figure out where they might have come from. He’s also used data modeling based on conditions like elevation and fishing pressure to figure out which lakes might be most vulnerable to future fish introductions, which could help steer resources towards them and stop would-be bucket biologists.
From his time on the job, which has included many firsthand interactions with anglers, he can tell many of them are irked that they can’t stock the fish they want wherever they want them. “I do think some of these people are spiteful in their desire to move fish around,” Bourret said. “People are mad at us, and they vocally say it.”
Sometimes the culprit is less intentional. Non-native fish that are kept in ponds on private property (which technically require permits to build and stock but often slip by under the radar) can get into nearby rivers or lakes if the pond overflows during a storm, or by being picked up by a bird and then dropped into another waterbody. Earlier this year, FWP biologists on Bourret’s team removed 4,000 goldfish from a pond at a hotel on the edge of Montana’s Thompson River; the pond had been an attraction for families visiting the hotel with small children, who liked to scoop fish out of the water with nets. But goldfish can be disastrous for freshwater ecosystems, and the FWP wanted to be sure they wouldn’t slip into the adjacent river—and from there into a nearby lake.
But they often don’t get so far ahead of a potential problem. “Introduced fish probably go undetected often,” Bourret said. “We usually find out about them through a needle in a haystack catch. Once a population sets up in a lake, it’s already way too late.”
Monitoring species in the underwater realm of rivers, lakes, and streams is vastly more challenging than it is on land. “It’s a lot more obvious when a terrestrial animal doesn’t belong,” says Andrew Gilham, Fisheries Management Bureau Chief at FWP. “If you see a zebra in Montana, you’d probably think it’s weird. But if people see a brown trout, which is from Europe, it just doesn’t register in the same way.”
And that may even play into the general public’s understanding of just how much impact a few fish can have. “Some of it may just be that they don’t really understand the consequences that can follow illegal introductions,” he said.
Aquatic ecosystems are delicate balances, and in a healthy lake the populations of fish, predators, and small organisms like zooplankton and phytoplankton typically exist in a hard-won equilibrium. To simplify greatly, there are usually enough zooplankton to eat phytoplankton and prevent algal blooms, enough zooplankton-eating fish to prevent the zooplankton from eating all the phytoplankton, and enough predators to keep those zooplankton-eating fish in check—but not so many that the smaller fish get wiped out.
“If you see a zebra in Montana, you’d probably think it’s weird. But if people see a brown trout, which is from Europe, it just doesn’t register in the same way.”
Bucket biology, especially with voracious carnivores like pike, is a bit like tossing a fish-shaped grenade into the lake. If the newcomers establish a spawning population, they can compete for resources with the native fish or eat them directly, eventually causing something called a trophic cascade: a domino-like series of events that can upend an entire ecosystem.
What happens to fish in a lake can have huge effects on the creatures outside of it, too. In the Yellowstone region, Yellowstone Lake had long been home to a native fish species called the cutthroat trout. These fish would make long, winding spawning migrations through the Yellowstone lake and river system, where some four mammal species and 16 bird species—bears, otters, eagles, and pelicans, among others—would pluck them out of the water for meals. The migrating cutthroat were also important vectors for nutrients, which came from the fish’s poop and were important food sources for plants and algae growing in and along the waterways.
But then, in the 1990s, a non-native species arrived (likely through an illegal introduction): lake trout. Lake trout eat cutthroat, and without any predators of their own, they could feast on the smaller fish without anything to stop them. Once the lake trout appeared in Yellowstone Lake, they decimated cutthroat populations; according to a report from the National Park Service, by 1998, there were some 125,000 lake trout in the lake, and they ate somewhere between 3 and 4 million cutthroat that year.
Zooplankton in the lake, which the cutthroat used to eat, had a population boom, which led to a decline in phytoplankton. And the lake trout just stayed in the lake rather than migrating through the rivers and streams like the cutthroat did, which not only robbed those waters of the additional nutrients they brought, but also took a of a high-impact food source away from bears, otters, and birds. Bear and otter activity alongside the streams declined; while bears are opportunistic feeders and likely found another food source, the otters probably had a harder time finding something to supplement their diets. Bald eagle nests saw a sharp decline in their success rates after cutthroat disappeared, and osprey nest counts fell from 60 in 2001 to 3-5 from 2008-2015.
“We don’t want to just be moving things around willy-nilly,” said Niall Clancy, director of the Fisheries Lab at Salish Kootenai College. “Because one thing we learned is that we are bad at predicting the impacts—and there’s a good chance that something will go wrong that we didn’t think of.”
And, Clancy added, these sorts of introductions can cause financial cascades alongside trophic ones: FWP now spends millions of dollars each year to reduce invasive fish populations in the state’s lakes and boost native fish populations through hatchery programs. This, in turn, diverts money away from other programs.
Stopping illegal fish introductions is a nearly impossible task; catching someone red-handed would require vigilantly monitoring thousands and thousands of miles of shoreline in Montana. Instead, FWP and groups like the CSKT are investing in things like an educational outreach program and signs along popular waterfronts that exhort people not to dump live fish, warning that doing so is a felony.
FWP has also teamed up with groups like Trout Unlimited, a nonprofit that advocates for fish and waterway conservation, to offer massive rewards for information on bucket biologists. In 2017, for example, they offered a reward of over $35,000 for information related to the illegal introduction of walleye in Swan Lake, a lake about eight miles east of Flathead as the crow flies. But even the promise of a big reward hasn’t worked, and nobody has come forward yet. Instead, FWP declared open season on invasive fish like brown trout and walleye, requiring that anyone who catches one of the fish kill it rather than toss it back into the water, and then bring the entire fish into a FWP office so that biologists can study it.
“They’re part of our heritage and our culture, and when they’re gone, they’re gone. It’s like losing our language.”
Biologists at FWP are also exploring other solutions like following the lead of Washington state in introducing sterile non-native fish to lakes. This would reduce the populations of non-native fish by tricking fertile ones into wasting their mating efforts on fish that will never be able to reproduce.
For the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes, the issue goes beyond the science. “We have stories about the native bull trout and the native West Oak cutthroat going back to before colonization,” said Rich Janssen, head of the CSKT’s department of natural resources. “They’re part of our heritage and our culture, and when they’re gone, they’re gone. It’s like losing our language.”
At Flathead Lake, the lower half of which is in the Flathead Reservation, the fish that were introduced through earlier federal and state stocking programs largely settled into a state of coexistence with the native fish. That doesn’t mean they were completely harmless, however: They competed for resources with the bull trout and cutthroat, which led to a reduction in those fish. Today, the CSKT has placed restrictions on bull trout and cutthroat fishing, banning people from taking those fish except for religious reasons, and has stepped up efforts to proactively monitor for new non-native fish at Flathead Lake. They’ve also removed fishing restrictions for smallmouth bass and northern pike in tribal waters. Both species were illegally introduced to the lake and can not only outcompete the bull trout and cutthroat but eat them outright, so anglers are now welcome to take as many of those non-native fish out of the water as they’d like.
When I went for a swim in Flathead Lake this fall, the water was startlingly clear and calm, the surface broken every now and then by ripples from a passing fish or insect. But farther north, where the Flathead River meets the lake, a gauntlet of hungry pike lay in wait for bull trout making their way upriver to spawn. And as cold as the water was—it is a glacial lake, after all—it has also been warming with climate change, creating more pockets of warmer water for smallmouth bass to spawn in and shrinking the cold-water areas that the bull and cutthroat trout like.
I waved at a passing motorboat, which had a fishing pole stuck into a holder on its side. More and more people have been moving to Montana in recent years, attracted by the rugged nature and the allure of the West; new houses and docks have sprung up along Flathead Lake’s shoreline. But much like the pike and bass, their presence has been putting more pressure on the local landscape, and the newcomers could make the problem worse if they decide Montana’s fish aren’t as good as what they have back home. The future of the lake, and many others like it across the country, is murky. What it will look like depends, in large part, on what people decide to do with their buckets.
How to Fix the Country
When the 39th Congress convened on December 4, 1865, it was the first time the nation’s representatives had gathered since the Confederacy’s defeat and the assassination of President Abraham Lincoln. In the nine months Congress had been in recess, the Southern states had reconstituted their governments under the auspices of President Andrew Johnson, a Southerner whose commitment to the union was giving way to his virulent racism. From the sidelines, Lincoln’s fellow Republicans watched in horror as Southerners re-erected slavery’s scaffolding by restricting the freed population’s rights and condemning them to field labor. South Carolina and Mississippi elected Confederate generals as their governors. In Louisiana, former Confederate officers conducted state business in rebel uniforms.
So when Congress came together, the Republican majority had to decide how to move the nation forward. Would they let the South return to its old ways over the bodies of more than 600,000 soldiers, or would they seize the chance to shape a society of equals? To the Radical Republicans, a minority faction dedicated to equal rights, the end of the war represented a momentous opportunity. “We are making a nation,” Rep. Thaddeus Stevens, a powerful Radical, told his colleagues. He believed the country to be in a revolution, and the job of the 39th Congress was to perfect “a true republic.” “The whole fabric of Southern society must be changed, and never can it be done if this opportunity is lost,” he said that September.
But the 39th Congress faced a more immediate and existential threat: Abolition had undone the Constitution’s notorious three-fifths compromise, which had inflated white Southerners’ political power before the war. By not allowing the freed men the right to vote, abolition would now ironically hand white Southerners some 30 extra votes in the House and Electoral College—enough that they might win control of the federal government when combined with allied Northern Democrats. If that happened, ex-Confederates aimed to reinstate a form of slavery, compensate slaveholders for their lost property, and pay off Confederate war debts while blocking payments on the Union’s. The threat left two tasks for Republicans: democratize the nation and keep the former Confederacy out of power. These projects were inextricably linked.
Now, 161 years later, the increasingly unhinged second presidency of Donald Trump is threatening to end American democracy, just as civil war and the threat of Confederates returning to power did. Trump’s movement violently stormed the US Capitol to overturn the 2020 election, and, back in office, he has challenged the country’s ability to conduct free elections. He defies the law, unilaterally dismantling agencies, conducting executions at sea, sending masked agents to terrorize immigrants and citizens, and starting an illegal war with Iran. Since winning reelection, Trump’s wealth expanded by at least $2.7 billion, as criminals spend big to secure pardons and corporations curry favor by funneling money to his ballroom. Aided by a Republican-appointed Supreme Court majority, Trump has sicced the Justice Department on political enemies and weaponized the Federal Communications Commission to silence the press. In keeping with the world’s most abusive regimes, Trump’s administration has normalized violence, from the torturous conditions in its detention centers to the revival of the military firing squad. Rather than submit this unpopular agenda to the people, the administration attempted to rig our elections by gerrymandering, manipulating the census, blocking mail ballots, purging voters, and mounting specious lawsuits aimed at election administrators.
Despite these authoritarian tactics, the Democrats’ resounding midterm victories have forced Trump’s coalition out of power in Congress. If MAGA should lose the White House, the anti-Trump majority must decide whether it can proceed with mere tweaks to our democratic system—the path Democrats followed after Trump’s first term, when they failed to enact new voting rights legislation, only to see him return more dangerous than before—or make major reforms to vanquish Trumpism by creating a more small-d democratic government.
Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-Md.) believes it will take “something at the scale and velocity” of Reconstruction or the civil rights movement “to extricate ourselves from the wreckage and to get democracy and freedom moving again…As with both of those periods, the imperative is democratization and the dismantling of structures of white supremacy and authoritarianism.” With a Democratic-controlled Congress in 2027, he continued, “the lawmaking branch needs to reassert its powers and its prerogatives against a runaway autocratic president.”
As the presumptive next chair of the House Judiciary Committee, Raskin will be at the center of this fight. The former constitutional law professor believes the reason we have a federal government overrun by authoritarian tactics is that our political system allowed it. Our two-party system helped Trump consolidate Republicans, and he won his first term with a minority of the vote. Thanks to the Supreme Court, Congress is gerrymandered, awash in special interest money, and less accountable to voters. The justices, including three Trump appointees, helped the president return to power by bailing him out of prosecution for the January 6 insurrection—a plot to steal the Electoral College that was only possible because we don’t use the popular vote to begin with.
After the Civil War, Republicans had to bring democracy to the Southern states, but they did it to save the federal government from a takeover by the forces of racism and minority rule that animated the Confederacy. If there is another moment for major change, reform must serve the same purpose of ensuring that authoritarianism and racial hierarchy do not reestablish themselves for good.
Related
To Save Democracy, Pete Buttigieg Wants to Push “Big Policies, Quickly”
Democrats’ historic midterm gains delivered the party a mandate to start this process. In exit polls, voters said the state of democracy was a top concern, just behind the economy; nearly three-quarters said Congress hadn’t done enough to check the president. The scale of their victory may lull some Democrats into thinking our democracy is healthy, leading them to turn their backs on an agenda of repairing it in favor of things pollsters say are more popular. They would be wrong. The midterms provide a critical reprieve, a limited time in which to secure our democracy before it’s swallowed by the forces bringing it down.
Congress is a bit like Dorothy, waiting for the Wizard of Oz to send her back to Kansas, when all she needs to do is click her heels and get to work.
Given Trump’s veto powers, advocates see this coming Congress—the 120th—as a time to build momentum for major reforms through investigations and agenda-setting votes to ban gerrymandering, enforce transparency in political donations, and install anti-corruption measures that would rein in Trump. Democratic lawmakers may vote, not for the first time, to make Washington, DC, a state and push multiple bills to check Chief Justice John Roberts’ unrestrained court. But beyond all that, some politicians and reformers hope the next two years are the beginning of something much bigger, with the fast-approaching 2028 Democratic presidential primary set to be a proving ground for a fundamental remaking of our democracy. As lawmakers wrestle, like the 39th Congress did, with how far to go and how to prepare the public to accept big changes, the task might be easier than it seems: Americans already know our system is broken, riddled by corruption, and ready for renewal.
“The current administration has been able to destroy a lot very quickly. Our side should be prepared to build a lot very quickly,” Pete Buttigieg, the former transportation secretary and a possible 2028 presidential candidate, told me in late October. “This is just destined to be one of those times, if only because there’s so much rubble and ash around.” In 2020, Buttigieg put court expansion on the map as a Democratic presidential candidate. This past fall, as he campaigned alongside dozens of candidates during the midterms, Buttigieg aimed to show that reforming our political system isn’t only a good idea, but good politics, too. He urges fellow Democrats to seize the chance to “define what life is like in this country for the next 60, 70, 80 years. Seasons like that come around every now and then…We’re due for one right now.”
In the 39th Congress, moderate Republicans urged smaller changes and a rapid restoration of Southern states’ status in Washington, while Stevens and the Radicals urged major reforms. Ultimately, many of the Radicals’ arguments won out as circumstances proved them right. With Southern whites perpetrating massacres on freed Black people and threatening a ruinous return to power, moderates begrudgingly concluded that the slave states’ power must be subdued not only on the battlefield, but also through heavy federal enforcement of civil rights in the South.
The lawmakers were contending with many of the same questions we face today: Who is a citizen, and what rights do immigrants and other minorities have? Should one person’s vote count more than another’s? What is the right balance of power among Congress, the president, and the Supreme Court? And what power does Congress have to decide these questions?
The 39th Congress answered the call with decisive and unprecedented measures to protect democracy against post-bellum backsliding. It seized from the president the power to determine how Southern states would be governed and readmitted to Congress. It passed the 1866 Civil Rights Act, extended the life of the Freedmen’s Bureau, required Southern states to create multiracial governments under US military supervision, and enfranchised Black men in the District of Columbia, all by overriding the veto of the president. It changed the size of the Supreme Court to stop it from interfering with Reconstruction. It crafted the 14th Amendment seeking to ensure equality and entrench their party in power, and legislated over another Johnson veto to see that it was ratified.
If our current crisis presents Congress a moment of possibility, as it did in 1865, the best defense against Trumpism and the only shot at enacting lasting policy is first to recommit the country to a multiracial democracy, run by a Congress that better represents the people. Weak as it may appear, Congress’ powers remain vast. Today’s Congress is a bit like Dorothy, waiting for the Wizard of Oz to send her back to Kansas, when all she needs to do is click her heels and get to work.
Ben Hickey
Thaddeus Stevens—“practical about accomplishing ideals,” according to biographer Bruce Levine—understood that his quest to remake the nation depended on his party staying in power. On the first day of the 39th Congress, Stevens and the Republican caucus refused to seat the South’s representatives, which included, according to Levine, “the Confederacy’s vice president, six cabinet officers, 58 members of the Confederate congress, four Confederate generals, and five colonels.” Then they withheld their Washington stipends, forcing them home. The gambit opened the door to the 39th Congress’ achievements, including, most famously, the 14th Amendment. Stevens’ famous speech on Reconstruction laid out its bare-knuckled purpose: “to secure perpetual ascendancy to the party of the Union; and so as to render our republican Government firm and stable forever.”
“Doing good things requires politics, and Stevens understood that,” says Mark Graber, a University of Maryland constitutional law professor. “He was saying, ‘It turns out there’s a move we can make that will make this system both democratic and more racially egalitarian, and we should.’”
The 14th Amendment’s first section guarantees equality under the law for all. But according to Graber, whose book Punish Treason, Reward Loyalty details the motivations of the amendment’s framers, Republicans were most concerned with its largely forgotten latter sections, including its frontal attack on the South’s ill-gotten political power based on its newly freed Black population. To make sure their freedom didn’t buttress the political power of the Southern elite, Radical Republicans supported ensuring freed men could vote. But to the party’s moderates, Black voting rights weren’t yet feasible. The amendment put forward a compromise to reduce each state’s congressional representation by the share of eligible voters whose vote was “denied…or in any way abridged.” With the formerly enslaved making up about 40 percent of the South’s population, Stevens and his allies believed the threat would induce ex-Confederate states to let Black men vote.
While the provision was never enforced—the next Congress attempted to directly enfranchise Black people via the 15th Amendment—Stevens’ insistence on its inclusion showed his understanding that promises of equality mean little if the government falls to people committed to enslavement and domination.
It’s a lesson later generations would see borne out: The 14th Amendment’s promise of equal protection didn’t stop the South from imposing segregation, because Congress, presidents, and the Supreme Court allowed it; the 15th Amendment’s prohibition on voting discrimination didn’t stop the former Confederacy from disenfranchising nearly every Black person until Congress finally reasserted its authority with the 1965 Voting Rights Act. After Reconstruction, “even as things got worse for African Americans in the South, the Constitution never changed,” says Franita Tolson, dean of the University of Southern California’s law school. “It’s the political will that changed, the willingness for Congress to be overseer that changed.” In April 2026, the Supreme Court gutted the VRA, threatening to obliterate the 15th Amendment’s protections once again. Two months later, the court upheld the 14th Amendment’s birthright citizenship guarantee by a single vote—another demonstration that constitutional gains are only as secure as the people in power.
“Constitutions do not enforce themselves,” says Nikolas Bowie, a Harvard law professor. “Hoping that with a new amendment we will have a different political reality, and one that will respect the work that they were doing, turned out just not to be true.” Progress could be protected only by strengthening democracy such that a minority faction could not take control.
How to accomplish the same thing today is a topic of much discussion in Congress and in advocacy circles, among voting rights groups and academics. Much as events in the South pushed moderates in the 39th Congress toward aggressive reforms, Trump’s wreckage has major players sizing up ideas dismissed as pipe dreams just a few years or even months ago.
I wanted to find out what big ideas were percolating and how their backers view the odds of success. “There are political windows that open up that we cannot control,” says former Obama administration official Spencer Overton, who, as founder of George Washington University’s Multiracial Democracy Project, is convening civil rights groups and lawmakers in reform conversations. “We have to be ready.”
Our political system was designed 250 years ago for a small country dominated by white, landowning farmers. To become a successful, large, multiracial democracy, Overton argues, the US must overcome three interconnected “failure modes”: the Supreme Court, policy capture by special interests, and a Congress that doesn’t represent the people. If these three problems are not solved, he fears, the country will lose its democratic character and fail.
The Supreme Court, in Overton’s view, has become an instrument of white backlash rather than a fair legal arbiter. By encouraging partisan gerrymandering and destroying the VRA’s guarantee of minority representation, the court has effectively disenfranchised millions while insulating lawmakers from the will of their voters. By letting the wealthy drown politics with corrupting cash, the court made rich individuals and corporations the favorites of our political system. Cut off from those they are supposed to represent, lawmakers are more beholden to the powerful who help buy their seats. The court, Overton says, has not only weakened democracy’s connective tissue, but it has enfeebled our government’s ability to rise to modern challenges, such as artificial intelligence and job displacement.
“Our representative republic is not very representative right now.”
Buttigieg supports major changes to address all three failure modes: reshaping the Supreme Court, overturning the Citizens United decision that flooded politics with corporate and billionaire money, and changing House elections so members better represent the people. “Our representative republic is not very representative right now,” Buttigieg told me. “The distortions of money in politics, of gerrymandering, and a number of other antidemocratic features that have crept into our system have brought our country to a kind of a breaking point.”
“What I’m calling for looks like a lot of upheaval by the standards of the last 50 years,” he continued. “But it’s also deeply consistent with the last 250 years, where we used the tools that we had, from big political reforms to constitutional amendments, to make sure the system evolved with the times.”
It’s 11 p.m. in Budapest when Kim Lane Scheppele, a Princeton University expert on the role of courts in democracies, appears for our video call. Scheppele studied Hungary’s new constitutional court after the fall of the Soviet Union, but mostly avoided the country when it was under the sway of Viktor Orbán’s authoritarian regime. After an overwhelming April electoral defeat toppled him, Scheppele finally went back and saw old colleagues. “I’m a friend of judges,” she says. “I do courts.” But when it comes to the US, our Supreme Court “has become a menace to democracy,” Scheppele explains. “Congress has to cut the knees out from under it.”
Reconstruction-era legislators could have used this advice. While the 39th Congress did reduce the size of the court and kept Johnson from making any appointments who might undo Reconstruction, it ultimately failed to take more drastic action, leaving the court to later cripple the Reconstruction Amendments so that they no longer protected Black people’s rights and to invalidate most of Congress’ major laws to enforce them.
Once again, Scheppele says, “the Supreme Court is the villain in the story.” The Roberts court has created an imperial presidency. By giving Trump criminal immunity, the GOP-appointed majority has handed the executive branch a roadmap to break the law. The justices have repeatedly stepped in to trample Congress’ laws, and by placing agency control in Trump’s hands, further cleaved them from Congress’ will. In addition to destroying the VRA, over the past 16 years the court has methodically gutted a raft of important pro-democracy legislation, including campaign finance laws that stemmed billionaire and industrial power. These statutory murders demonstrate the futility of reforming our political system without reforming the court; any major change would run into the Roberts majority’s buzz saw.
While the justices stymie Congress, they’ve become the Trump administration’s fast pass to illegal action. In the past two years, Trump has pushed more than two dozen executive orders and policies that violate federal law, then rushed to the Supreme Court to ask the justices to let them take effect. And the court, often in unexplained emergency or “shadow” docket orders, usually does—on everything from defying congressional appropriations to dismantling the Department of Education. “It’s law school 101,” Scheppele says, that executive orders aren’t more powerful than federal law or constitutional safeguards. In what she calls a “constitutional revolution,” the “court is flipping the hierarchical relationship between” them.
Once a third rail, Supreme Court reform is now something Democrats are expected to take up as soon as the opportunity arises. Some proposals—like term limits and an enforceable ethics code—are very popular. “Five years ago, it was never realistic to be talking about things like term limits,” says Scott Fay, a Democratic consultant who works with civil rights organizations. “That is absolutely on the table now.” Key Democrats like Hakeem Jeffries have endorsed term limits; Hillary Clinton recently called for adding four justices.
“The lawmaking branch needs to reassert its powers and its prerogatives against a runaway autocratic president.”
Scheppele is part of a group of constitutional law professors, now numbering some three dozen scholars, who have spent more than a year crafting Supreme Court reforms. Their proposal would cap the number of active justices and give each president four appointees per term, both expanding the court and effectively imposing term limits. When the opportunity for reform arises, Raskin has a similar vision of fixing appointments to presidential terms and limiting justices’ time on the court.
It might seem surprising, but Congress has the power to do much or all of this simply by enacting a new law. Lawmakers can, as they have seven times before, change the Supreme Court’s size. They can decide which types of cases it hears, put restrictions on its emergency docket, create new courts to hear certain types of suits, or limit which laws are reviewable by the court. It simply hasn’t used these powers in a very long time. “What do we have to do to recover the power of Congress?” Scheppele asks. “The answer is kill off the power of the Supreme Court.”
Ben Hickey
By the time Thaddeus Stevens was helping lead the 39th Congress, the Pennsylvanian was an old man. While known for cutting rhetoric, his voice had grown so soft that his colleagues had to draw close to hear him.
But Stevens’ place atop American politics, and the radical ideas he championed after the war, were a lifetime in the making. Early in his career, he joined the Anti-Masons, a short-lived political party that railed against an elite secretive order that pledged to support its members over the needs of everyone else.
Such fealty sounds familiar. When the nation’s most powerful tech executives flanked Trump during his second inauguration, it was a visual demonstration of the links between Washington and the most wealthy. In 2024, Elon Musk, one of those guests, spent so much to reelect Trump that he essentially bought himself a White House job, which he used to enrich himself and destroy swaths of government; in the 2026 midterms, he spent about another half-billion to help Republicans. As an Anti-Mason, Levine explains, “Stevens was fighting against his version of that.”
“It is impossible that any practical equality of rights can exist,” Stevens said in 1865, “where a few thousand men monopolize the whole landed property…How can republican institutions, free schools, free churches, free social intercourse exist in a mingled community of nabobs and serfs?” Today, another small cohort of ultrawealthy people works to create a political system in which their portfolios swell while funds for the public good run dry. To accomplish this wealth extraction on the backs of most Americans, they buy influence in Washington. In 1974, Congress passed bipartisan campaign finance reforms after discovering that President Richard Nixon promised milk producers $100 million in subsidies in exchange for $2 million in campaign donations, but the Supreme Court soon rolled them back. Under Roberts, the court has eviscerated campaign finance limits, with the infamous 2010 Citizens United decision allowing infinite independent election spending. Later rulings opened up avenues to bypass donation limits to politicians. An estimated $12 billion was spent on the 2026 midterm elections, a fourfold increase from before Citizens United.
American democracy is buckling under this corrupt system. And because the Supreme Court cited the First Amendment to tear down these anti-corruption rules, it’s presumed that there’s little our representatives can do. Amending the Constitution to overrule Citizens United—a reviled decision in which five unelected judges undid the work of lawmakers representing 300 million people—is a near-impossible task, requiring two-thirds of Congress and three-quarters of the states.
But here’s the rub: Congress is bound by the court’s constitutional decisions only because it chooses to be. It could work around Citizens United and clamp down on election spending with a new law. That’s the takeaway of a buzzy new book, Supremacy: How Rule by the Court Replaced Government by the People, by Bowie and his Harvard colleague Daphna Renan, which points out there is nothing in the Constitution that empowers the court to overrule Congress.
“The primary court reform is that Congress needs to reassert its role as interpreting the Constitution and defend it from the court,” Bowie says. “Citizens United represents the Supreme Court’s interpretation of the First Amendment…If Congress wants to defend its own interpretation,” it has the power and tools to do so. For example, it could pass and protect new campaign finance rules by writing limits on how the court can review them—a version of what’s known as “jurisdiction stripping.” “Once Congress starts to do this,” Bowie says, it can begin to turn back “the restrictions on what kind of government we can have that have been imposed by the court.”
Bowie’s plan to tackle Citizens United is one route to a destination many reformers want to reach. Overton envisions Congress enacting court reforms alongside new campaign finance reforms, so that by the time its money-in-politics legislation reaches the justices, a newly constituted court will uphold it. As Raskin puts it, overturning Citizens United “will require either a new constitutional amendment…or a new Supreme Court to overturn the decision the way that the Roberts court overturned Roe v. Wade. ” The varied proposals share a conclusion: Congress is not handcuffed by this court decision and must pick a path out of the mess it created.
Like present-day anti-corruption reformers, the 39th Congress also faced criticism that its program was unconstitutional. In response, the 39th Congress found two critical sources of authority. One was the recently passed 13th Amendment, which the lawmakers interpreted not to just abolish slavery, but also to promote equality. (The court would soon sap it of this critical power.) The other was the Constitution’s guarantee clause, which abolitionist Sen. Charles Sumner dubbed a “sleeping giant.” It states concisely that “The United States shall guarantee to every State in this Union a Republican Form of Government.” The Supreme Court itself has ruled that defining a republican form of government is up to Congress, not the courts.
Renan says “there’s a lot of inspiration to be drawn” from how the 39th Congress used the clause. For example, she believes today’s Congress could root new voting rights laws in its language, or legislate that it bars unlimited election spending.
The professors’ lessons may seem academic, but Democrats in Congress have been thinking along similar lines. Raskin says Congress could use the clause to create anti-gerrymandering legislation. “It is not a truly republican, which is to say not a truly representative form of government, when the politicians choose the voters before the voters choose the politicians,” he explains. The For the People Act, a wide-ranging democracy reform proposed by Democrats in 2021, explicitly based its authority in the guarantee clause. It also would have routed challenges to the law away from conservative circuits overrun by Trump judges—a glimmer of recognition of Congress’ ability to control judicial review.
There’s a chicken-and-egg quality to fixing our ailing democracy. On the one hand, Congress has all these latent powers lying about. On the other, it has been so hobbled by special interests, corruption, and hyperpartisanship that its muscles have atrophied. To improve, Congress must become more representative of its constituents.
Trump’s calls for Republican state legislators to redraw congressional maps in 2025 illustrated the fundamentally riggable nature of winner-take-all districts. The Supreme Court’s April decision eviscerating the VRA could result in all-white Southern delegations for the first time since the 1960s. These changes have caused politicians, civil rights groups, and political donors to rethink how Congress is elected—leading to new calls for a system of proportional representation, or PR, that would, among other benefits, take the air out of redistricting battles.
“I don’t think there’s a single member of Congress that feels, personally, like it’s good that we have mid-decade redistricting where the map can change almost overnight,” says Dustin Wahl, executive director of the pro-PR group Fix Our House. “Including Republicans,” he added. “We are looking at 2029 as a potential moment to do something.”
“I probably hear two or three times a week now people pushing on PR,” says Fay, the Democratic consultant. “Post-Callais, post all the redistricting wars, it’s just become that much more serious.”
Proportional representation, explains Ben Raderstorf of Protect Democracy, a nonpartisan group combating the country’s authoritarian turn, would mean using multimember districts to elect House members, with seats allocated by each party’s portion of the vote. Today, if a candidate in a single-seat race loses with a third of the vote, their supporters’ votes are wasted. But in a three-member district under a proportional system, two seats would go to the majority party, and the candidate with 33 percent backing would go to Congress as well. Our current winner-take-all model muffles minority voting groups and incentivizes gerrymandering. But in a proportional system, minority blocs can still get representation; Republicans wouldn’t be locked out in blue states and Democrats wouldn’t be locked out in red states.
After nearly a year of study, Raderstorf says Protect Democracy determined that PR was the single reform that most “fit our mission of preventing the United States from declining into a more authoritarian form of government.” Because it would ensure many more voters are represented, advocates believe PR would not only reconnect House members to constituents, but it could also break the two-party duopoly, allowing parties with smaller vote shares to enter the House, opening the door to a more responsive coalition-style government and making it harder for a strongman like Trump to consolidate support. Internationally, most democracies use proportional systems, and some research shows that it has helped reduce factional tension in places like Northern Ireland and South Africa.
Ending gerrymandering and moving toward a proportional system is “an absolutely central fight of our times,” says Raskin, who has put forward PR legislation. “If we don’t,” he warns, “we are going to start ending up with all-Republican districts from states where Republicans control the legislature and all-Democratic districts in states where Democrats control the legislature.” Members of Congress accustomed to how they won office “are going to need to open up our minds,” he adds, but “there’s overwhelming public support for it, and I think we can make that happen.”
Today’s representation problem is not altogether different from the one the 39th Congress faced when the rollback of the three-fifths clause ended up benefiting white Southerners. After the 2020 census, explosive population growth, 95 percent among people of color, delivered Texas two additional congressional seats. But its 2025 redistricting allotted more than 70 percent of the expanded delegation to white Texans, who are just 37 percent of the population. Even as Democrats swept statewide offices in November, the map helped Texas Republicans hold 24 of 38 House seats.
Proportional representation boosters admit it is not a panacea. For one, it would reform only the House of Representatives and leave the Senate as an anti-majoritarian institution made up of two members from each state. Nineteenth-century Republicans got around this by making new states. The 39th Congress admitted Nebraska over the president’s veto. The prior year, it had readmitted Republican-controlled Tennessee. In 1876, Republicans in Congress would rush to admit Colorado so their party could get its electoral votes that fall. “Republicans,” Graber explained in his book, “regarded territorial policy and congressional Reconstruction as two sides of the same coin.”
Today, Democrats could do the same. After a vote in Congress, minority-majority Washington, DC, with more people than Vermont or Wyoming, could be made a state. Puerto Rico’s population of 3.2 million surpasses that of 18 states and should be given the option. Raskin hopes DC statehood will come up for a vote soon and says it is a top item the next time Democrats control both Congress and the White House. Four other territories have substantially smaller populations, but “if we’re not concerned about how small Wyoming is, why should we be concerned about how small the US Virgin Islands are?” Overton asks. “What’s good for the goose is good for the gander.”
The new states allowed post–Civil War Republicans to retain the presidency or at least one house of Congress for decades, securing Reconstruction policies like tariffs, war pensions, and railroad expansion. But new Western states were less committed to Black rights, and the party’s dedication to equality quickly atrophied in the face of economic recession and adverse Supreme Court rulings. Infamously, after 1876’s contested election, Republicans withdrew troops from the South, abandoning Black people there to subordination and mob violence.
“Our progress as a democracy is dependent on political will,” says Tolson, the USC dean and author of In Congress We Trust?, a history of lawmakers’ role in enforcing voting rights. “The Reconstruction moment taught that lesson very powerfully, because once political will was gone, it became very hard for the promise of the 39th Congress to carry forward, which is why things fell apart so quickly.”
When I asked Bruce Levine why he chose to write a Thaddeus Stevens biography, he told me that he viewed the Radical Republican leader as a hero because of his strong political will. As a young liberal in the 1960s, “what frustrated the hell out of me was the apparent cowardice of so many Democratic liberals, who just would not stand up and fight,” he says. “When I come across Stevens, I find somebody who’s out there swinging, who’s not afraid.”
But Stevens, he says, was also a product of his time: “It is the nature and power of the enemy that compels the Republican Party repeatedly to become more and more radical, not necessarily because they all want to, but because what they won yesterday can’t be preserved tomorrow unless they move forward.”
Stevens died within a year of the close of the 39th Congress. As his voice and body weakened, he knew that for all they’d accomplished, it hadn’t been enough. “I will take all I can get in the cause of humanity,” he said, “and leave it to be perfected by better men in better times.”
Once again, a moment of crisis has opened a window of opportunity. While campaigning this past fall, Buttigieg often closed speeches by asking his audience to consider this pivotal moment and imagine telling their children and grandchildren “what the hell was going on and…what we did to make it better,” as he told a crowd in Rochester, New Hampshire. “Back in the 2020s, we had the wealthiest people helping themselves to more and more power and the most powerful people helping themselves to more and more wealth. We put an end to that kind of corruption so that your generation wouldn’t have to put up with it.”
“The task before us,” he told another gathering, is to “honor our founders not by cementing their antique views on policy, but by emulating the scale of their ambition.”
As a wave election unlike any in 50 years showed, the public is starting to see these problems clearly: that the ultrarich should not be buying elections, that politicians should not be picking their voters, that the president should not be a king, and that a Supreme Court facilitating this madness must be checked. The founders gave us the tools to fix these problems, first among them a powerful Congress to channel the will of the people. To perfect our union, we must simply pick up these tools and put them to use.
To Save Democracy, Pete Buttigieg Wants to Push “Big Policies, Quickly”
Pete Buttigieg doesn’t shy away from big ideas about how to improve our political system. Back in 2019, as a candidate for president, the former South Bend mayor put the idea of Supreme Court reform on the map when he refused to laugh off a voter’s question about adding justices. After serving in the Biden administration as transportation secretary, Buttigieg has emerged as one of the Democratic Party’s strongest voices for government reform, urging his compatriots to think big about not only what is desirable but possible.
As he considers a 2028 presidential run, Buttigieg spent months ahead of the midterm elections crisscrossing the country campaigning alongside more than 100 candidates. On the trail, Buttigieg talked about the high costs and economic inequality that helped drive eye-popping turnout, but paired that with a call to reinvigorate democracy. Our political system is kicking the legs out from under the proverbial kitchen table, he often told crowds.
For many Democratic candidates, the midterms became a referendum on corruption, as opinion surveys found voters viewed the growing wealth at the top as the corrupt, ill-gotten gains of collusion with politicians.
That consensus on corruption is just one step removed from the idea that the American political system itself is to blame. Political donations and election spending are less persuasive to politicians if they come in smaller quantities. And politicians in competitive districts are more likely to listen to their voters, while politicians gerrymandered into safe seats are freer to work for their donors rather than their constituents. Both of these problems have been exacerbated by the Supreme Court in the last 16 years, from the infamous Citizens United decision that let corporate money flood politics, to a series of decisions that gave a stamp of approval to extreme gerrymandering. Corruption is a problem, but it’s also a symptom of a failing political system.
“People are enthusiastic about political and economic change.”
So when I set out to write a story for Mother Jones about how a bold Democratic Congress and White House could remake our system to be more responsive to the people and to their will, I reached out to Buttigieg.
Buttigieg has endorsed the idea of proportional representation, which would replace single-member, winner-take-all House districts with multi-member districts; representatives would win seats in Congress based on their party’s portion of the vote, opening the door for new candidates and even political parties to enter government. He supports overturning Citizens United so that special interest money isn’t drowning our political process. And he supports reforming the Supreme Court by adding justices, imposing term limits, and possibly balancing the partisan affiliation of the justices.
Buttigieg frames his political advice in terms of “big swings” and “base hits” to describe major reforms and smaller policy victories. In January, Buttigieg will release a book, Next, examining how our country’s political system failed and the big swings necessary to fix it.
I reached Buttigieg in late October, when most observers suspected the Democrats would make a strong showing in the midterms, but hadn’t predicted the landslide that soon followed. The day we spoke, he was at home in Michigan between campaign stops. Our conversation, which has been edited for length and clarity, included discussing his focus on major reforms, what he hopes Democrats do with their new majority, why the next few years might be a singular moment for change, and the 2028 Democratic primary’s role.
Related
After the Civil War, a Republican Congress remade America. Now it’s Democrats’ turn.
You’ve endorsed major reforms to the Supreme Court, to fix gerrymandering through proportional representation, and a constitutional amendment to overturn Citizens United. You’re talking about reform on the campaign trail. What is your diagnosis or description of what’s gone wrong in our democracy?
The bottom line is that our representative republic is not very representative right now. And the distortions of money in politics, of gerrymandering, and a number of other anti-democratic features that have crept into our system have brought our country to a kind of a breaking point. You can only see so many policies that have widespread support fail to become reality before it affects your belief in the system.
This would be a problem anywhere. But our democratic system is so foundational to who we are as a country. It is to us what neutrality is to the Swiss. And if we don’t have that, it’s harder to explain what America even is.
I think of you as the politician who’s talking about big reform ideas, and that goes back to 2020. And I’m curious if there’s any event or influence that makes you that guy.
Part of it is the experience of growing up and serving in a part of Indiana where you could see how many areas of majority agreement there were that still weren’t reflected in the political system. When I think about being in a bluer city and a redder state, where so many economic issues, in particular, were things you could actually get most people to agree on. And then you look at what’s actually happening in the state house, and certainly in Washington, and you see that it just doesn’t reflect that at all. I think that that experience made me want to ask why.
Nothing’s perfect, but in local government, I lived in a world where if something worked, you did more of it. If something failed, you changed course. And generally, better policies won out over worse policies. And sometimes it feels like the opposite is true in Washington. When I actually got there and spent the years that I did in the cabinet, of course I was proud of what we got done for transportation and infrastructure, but I also saw firsthand in a way that was really radically upsetting when it came to our institutions, that it really is a system programmed to fail in so many ways. And most importantly, that it doesn’t have to be this way. A lot of these things can be changed. A lot of these things can be changed by statute.
Were there any such failures that drove you nuts, that you’re thinking about right now?
Watching the child tax credit fail. I don’t know how you could experience that and not be outraged. It was done as an emergency measure to help prop the economy up during COVID. They do this extension of the tax credit, and it cuts child poverty in half in a year. It’s one of the most effective policies ever for doing what it’s supposed to do. And you would think if something works that well, you would do more of it. And instead, they couldn’t get it extended. And thinking about all the reasons why that was the case, I think, really pointed to the role of money in politics and the distortions in our system that make it unrepresentative.
East Palestine. I went there to lay out safety reforms that would help make sure that that couldn’t happen again. And everybody, to my face, said that they were for them. There were quite a few Republicans who said they were for them. It was a bipartisan bill. To this day, it hasn’t passed, and I think a lot of that has to do with the role of money in politics and the fact that the legislators who could actually pass it have more to worry about from donors and from primary challengers than their own people. So it just doesn’t move.
I’m not gonna ask about your 2028 plans, but you are playing a role right now, helping other candidates, but also bringing this idea of ‘We can do big reforms’ to the fore. And I wanted to know what you think of the 2028 Democratic primary as a bigger opportunity to do that?
I’ve described everything I’m doing this year as a twofold quest. Part one is to get good candidates elected and support good causes. And the other part is to persuade my party to have more ambition about big swings and about ensuring that the future (if we get a chance to shape that future) isn’t just a warmed-over version of the prior status quo—which I think really is a temptation that will arise in the Democratic Party if we get the majority that we’re hoping for. The most important process for adjudicating what ideas are on the front burner in the party is the 2028 primary.
Do you get a specific reaction either from candidates or from voters about reform?
There’s a bit of advice you will get from consultants and strategists saying, “Don’t talk too much about reform. Nobody wants to hear it. It’s got to be all about the economic issues. If you talk about reform, it makes you sound academic and kind of removed from reality.” What I’ve found is that people are enthusiastic about political and economic change. You don’t have to educate people that these problems in our political system are a big part of why we can’t have nice things in this country. And so, just as sure as I talk about getting everybody healthcare or fairer taxes, there is a roar that comes out of the crowd when I talk about getting money out of politics and dealing with Citizens United and ending gerrymandering. Like, people get that the kitchen table is in trouble, partly because of that political system kicking the legs out from under the kitchen table, which is how I sometimes put it in my stump speeches.
When you talk about reform, it can get you branded as this academic voice. But, I’m thinking about this crowd in Butte, Montana. We got 1,000 people in Butte fired up about money in politics. They have this initiative going on the ballot. They get it. [The initiative, which passed, seeks to work around Citizens United.] When I was in Orangeburg, the Black civil rights community, of course, doesn’t need any lessons on how economic justice is connected to political fairness or unfairness, right? So people in every corner of the country get this more than the kind of strategist class gives them credit for, in my opinion.
You have talked about both big swings and base hits as a way to describe the major political reforms such as proportional representation and Supreme Court reform versus smaller scale achievements. What would your ideal balance be? When is a moment for a big swing versus a base hit?
The important thing is you have to pursue both at once, and this is where we should learn from the right. In the ’80s, social conservatives were contesting school board races and also laying the foundations to demolish the right to choose by changing the entire texture of the American judiciary, which is a generational project. And it worked for them. We should be thinking the same way, that we don’t have to kind of choose between launching these big efforts that could take 10 or 20 years to pay off, and doing things in the here and now.
Sometimes you can do it all at once. On wages, I think the base hit is raising the minimum wage, which we haven’t done since 2009. I think a bigger swing, or at least a triple, would be to index it so you don’t have to go back to Congress every time it needs to be adjusted. But when I think about other reforms, a big swing is obviously on campaign finance reform, the holy grail is to end Citizens United through some combination of a better judiciary and perhaps a constitutional amendment. But there are things we can do about transparency in campaign finance tomorrow.
This is a time to have many shots on goal. Instead of a season of hand wringing about what exactly gets to go into HR1 and what 500 amendments go with it, I’d love to see a rapid fire sequence of 10 or 20 discrete clean bills on important things, some of which are very immediate, like wages or child tax credit, and some of which are reform, like gerrymandering, and some of which are toward more of a big picture policy, like universal health care. Just start pressing on all of these things at once.
Of course, campaigns are good for really big swings and really big ideas. And one reason I’m proud of what we did to help popularize Supreme Court reform in 2020, which was a fairly lonely place for me to be as a candidate back then. It’s not that eight years later it’s become reality, but it’s that certainly eight years later it’s become more mainstream in the party, and we had a hand in popularizing it. So I think campaigns have a dual responsibility. Obviously, you’re in it to win and put forward ideas that you can follow through on, but it’s also a chance to get ideas into the bloodstream that may take longer to ripen. I mean, if you think about the last really good run we had at campaign finance reform, I’d argue, [is] because John McCain won the New Hampshire Republican primary on that issue in 2000. No, he didn’t become president, but he did return to the Senate with more political capital to deliver what became the McCain-Feingold reform, which to this day is the high water mark of doing something about money in politics in our lifetime.
Do you want Democrats to push for some of these really big home run swings if they have a trifecta in 2029, things like Supreme Court reform, or proportional representation, or getting rid of gerrymandering?
Yes, I think we should advance these big policies quickly. Because another thing you can see is that the current administration has been able to destroy a lot very quickly. Our side should be prepared to build a lot very quickly. This is, I think, just destined to be one of those times, if only because there’s so much rubble and ash around. The post-Depression and post-war period, where lots of things happen at once that will define what life is like in this country for the next 60, 70, 80 years. Seasons like that come around every now and then. We had one in the mid-century last century. We’re due for one right now.
You said something at the Atlantic Ideas Festival about how when the system doesn’t work people just vote to burn it down, and you get a president like Donald Trump. It seems to me like a campaign or a message talking about the ways we can fix this is sort of the opposite of that, like the mirror image of this burn-it-down cynicism.
If they can burn a lot of things at once, we can build a lot of things at once. One of the most elegant and important qualities of our system is that it includes the tools to change that system for the better. One of our biggest contributions as a nation to constitutionalism was this idea of amendments. This idea of a self-renewing system, or at least a renewable system, is extremely important. In a way, what I’m calling for looks like a lot of upheaval by the standards of the last 50 years. But it’s also deeply consistent with the last 250 years, where we used the tools that we had, from big political reforms to constitutional amendments, to make sure the system evolved with the times and could better support us. The need for that is present even in ordinary times. But now with these novel challenges coming our way, from what’s happening in the information ecosystem to obviously what’s going on with AI, its more important than ever to have a system that can keep up.
The last question is if you think your focus on reform is catching on and that more people are going to be talking about reform, maybe starting in the next few months?
I hope so. I hope to show that this can be good politics as well as good policy. When you lay out big ideas, also it just prompts a lot of other people to respond. Even if they disagree, at least it gets that into the conversation. So I think that’ll happen more. Look, coming out of the gate, especially with a new congressional Democratic majority, obviously the front burner has to be all about putting money in people’s pockets and making life a little easier as concretely and as swiftly as possible. But I think that we need to pair that with these bigger reform efforts.
I used to think that the job [in politics] was to persuade people of our policies. Increasingly, that’s happened. Like, one thing we’re still getting used to as Democrats is that what we have to say about taxes, safety net, healthcare, so many issues, is already popular—which wasn’t how it was when I was growing up. The question really does shift to not convincing people that these things are right, but convincing people that you’re going to get any of it done, because of course so much of this stuff hasn’t happened.
One last note: Look at Project 2025, one of the main subjects of all the post-election handwringing among Democrats after 2024. The iterative process that led to that started in 1980. So if we were setting out to do a Project 2050, we’d already be behind by comparison. It’s really important for us to look at how the other side does ambitious, immediate concrete action and long term big think at the same time. And if they can do it, we can do it.
The Lookout List: Shopping & Retail
Where can you find the best shopping in Santa Cruz County? Readers voted, and these 2026 Lookout List Shopping & Retail winners and runners-up are their picks, from bookstores, boutiques and gift shops to florists, kitchen stores and thrift stores. Find more Lookout List winners here.
Find your favorite… Activewear / Gear Store Art Supply Store Art/Gift Shop Bookstore Boutique Cookware & Kitchen Supply Dispensary for Deals/Promos Dispensary with the Widest Selection Fireplace & Stove Store Florist for a Bouquet Florist for a Wedding or Party Furniture Store Indoor Plant Store Jewelry Store Mattress Store Musical Instrument Store Outdoor/Patio Furniture Store Record Store Selection of Greeting Cards Shoe Store Shop for Comics & Collectibles Shop for Gamers — Video, Board, or Card Games Store for a One-of-a-Kind Gift Store for Local Apparel Thrift/Vintage for Clothing Thrift/Vintage for Home Decor Favorite Activewear / Gear Store
Elfin Saffer, assistant general manager at Pacific Wave. Credit: Kevin Painchaud / Lookout Santa Cruz
Winner: Pacific Wave
1502 Pacific Ave. and 623 Swift St., Santa Cruz
Shoppers call Pacific Wave an “OG surf shop” with “the best and most unique Santa Cruz activewear” and a “super rad selection year over year.” One fan noted that the local family behind it supports local athletes and offers “a very good return policy.”
Runner-up: Bubble Lounge Boutique30 Rancho Del Mar, Aptos
Shoppers praise Bubble Lounge’s “incredible variety of merchandise,” cute clothing and great owner.
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Art Supply Store Winner: Palace Art & Office Supply1501 41st Ave., Suite K, Capitola
Artists say Palace “always has what I need,” with the largest assortment of supplies, “so many fun art tools” and a knowledgeable, friendly staff. One fan called it “nostalgic.”
Runner-up: Lenz Arts142 River St., Santa Cruz
Artists call Lenz “truly an artists mecca,” a locally owned shop that’s “thoughtfully stocked” with “everything every print artist needs” and staff who know their supplies.
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Art/Gift Shop Winner: Paper Vision1345 Pacific Ave., Santa Cruz
Shoppers call Paper Vision “a classic,” and one has been buying cards and calendars there for more than 30 years.
Runner-up: Artisans & Agency1368 Pacific Ave., Santa Cruz
Shoppers say Artisans is “usually the first place I check when I need a special gift,” with a “very thoughtfully curated selection” of truly “made in Santa Cruz” items. Bonus: it gives teachers a discount year-round.
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Bookstore
Credit: Kevin Painchaud / Lookout Santa Cruz
Winner: Bookshop Santa Cruz
1520 Pacific Ave., Santa Cruz
Voters call Bookshop “a local institution,” “iconic” and “one of the best in the country,” with an amazing selection, great staff picks and free events with local authors. As one put it: “The winner and still champion.”
Runner-up: Grey Bears Book DenCapitola Mall, 1855 41st Ave., Capitola
Book lovers call the Book Den the “best used bookstore in Santa Cruz,” a spacious, organized shop with great prices and good vibes from its volunteers. Several noted that every purchase supports Grey Bears.
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Boutique Winner: Pacific Trading Co.1224 Pacific Ave., Santa Cruz
Shoppers say Pacific Trading’s clothing is “unique, stylish,” with something for every occasion and a friendly, helpful staff to help you find it.
Runner-up: Bubble Lounge Boutique30 Rancho Del Mar, Aptos
Fans say Bubble Lounge “has the best staff, cutest clothes, and great positive environment and energy,” with a huge variety of brands and styles.
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Cookware & Kitchen Supply
A new collaboration between Toque Blanche and French cookware brand Le Creuset brought an expanded selection of products to the Santa Cruz store. Credit: Kevin Painchaud / Lookout Santa Cruz
Winner: Toque Blanche
1527 Pacific Ave., Santa Cruz
Cooks say Toque Blanche carries “the largest kitchen inventory ever,” from gourmet cookware to olive oils, with a helpful staff. One fan gave a shout-out to Mike: “He’s helpful, knowledgeable and always happy to see me.”
Runner-up: World Market450 River St., Santa Cruz
Shoppers love World Market’s “items from around the world,” easy shopping and loyalty rewards program.
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Dispensary for Deals/Promos Winner: The Hook Outlet1129 Mission St., Santa Cruz
Customers say the Hook has “the best deals around,” with super-kind employees and a “great staff that tell you the deals.” As one put it: “The Hook it up!”
Runner-up: KindPeoples3600 Soquel Ave. and 533 Ocean St., Santa Cruz
One customer praised KindPeoples’ “great staff and selection.”
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Dispensary with the Widest Selection Winner: Treehouse3651 Soquel Drive, Soquel
Customers say Treehouse has “a really nice curated menu,” the best ambience and selection in town, special events and a drive-thru.
Runner-up: The Hook Outlet1129 Mission St., Santa Cruz
Customers say the Hook’s “prices are great.”
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Fireplace & Stove Store Winner: Woodstove & Sun510 Soquel Ave., Santa Cruz
Customers call Woodstove & Sun “honest people” with knowledgeable help, a good selection of fireplaces and great follow-up service.
Runner-up: Santa Cruz Fireplace and Hot Tub1111 Water St., Santa Cruz
One customer bought a gas insert there and praised the “great products and service.”
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Florist for a Bouquet Winner: The Flower Shack614 S. Branciforte Ave., Santa Cruz
Customers say the Flower Shack has “great taste in assembling flower combinations,” with the best selection and prices. “They reliably make my husband a hero by pulling together a bouquet I love without him needing to tell them anything,” one wrote.
Runner-up: Susi’s Flowers25 Rancho Del Mar, Aptos
Customers call Susi’s “the standby when it comes to the perfect bouquet,” with beautiful arrangements.
Lookout Staff Pick
The Flower ShackSometimes, it’s been a long week and I’m feeling down, but then I remember that just like Miley Cyrus, I can buy myself flowers. And when I do, it’s often at The Flower Shack. It’s also my go-to spot when I want to buy a friend flowers that scream, “you’re the best and deserve a fabulous birthday” or “life is hard but here is a gorgeous bouquet to temporarily distract from the sadness.” It’s an all purpose kind of place, where I know I can go in and ask the lovely floristry staff to help me put together a bouquet that fits whatever my needs are that day. They also work with many local growers, so their flowers are seasonal and unique. These are not your much-maligned carnations or doghouse roses; these are ephemeral pieces of art.
Jessica M. Pasko, Business Columnist
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Florist for a Wedding or Party Winner: The Flower Shack614 S. Branciforte Ave., Santa Cruz
Fans call the Flower Shack crew “amazing folks” and say they “just love what they put together.”
Runner-up: Seascape Flowers5 Seascape Blvd., Aptos
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Furniture Store Winner: SC412701 41st Ave., Soquel
Customers praise SC41’s quality, selection and beautiful pieces “we will enjoy for ever,” and one credited designer Laurie Hannum with helping choose furniture for their living and dining rooms.
Runner-up: Couch Potato3131 Soquel Drive, Soquel
Customers say Couch Potato is affordable and local, with a variety of styles and colors and “great people, great products!”
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Indoor Plant Store Winner: Dig Gardens420 Water St., Santa Cruz
Plant lovers say Dig has “a HUGE variety of indoor plants,” a beautiful gift shop and helpful workshops, and “the scent in the air is always amazing” thanks to the candles burning.
Runner-up: Botanic and Luxe110 Cooper St., Suite 100F, Santa Cruz
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Jewelry Store Winner: Dell Williams Jewelers1320 Pacific Ave., Santa Cruz
Customers call Dell Williams “legendary” and “old Santa Cruz reputable,” a woman-owned store with “high end beautiful pieces,” great repairs and free cleaning.
Runner-up: Super Silver1301 Pacific Ave., Santa Cruz
Shoppers say Super Silver has “the widest selection with the best prices,” with so many style options and a knowledgeable, welcoming staff.
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Mattress Store Winner: Bay Bed and Mattress1378 Soquel Ave., Santa Cruz
Customers love Bay Bed’s local, handmade custom mattresses, with zippered covers that let you swap out foam and springs as they wear. “Will never buy a bed anywhere else,” one wrote, and others praised owners Dan and Rene Denevan as “super kind and conscientious.”
Runner-up: SC412701 41st Ave., Soquel
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Musical Instrument Store Winner: Sylvan Music1521 Mission St., Santa Cruz
Musicians praise Sylvan’s “impeccable stringed instruments,” best selection and best service, and say Al “has been in town for ages.” “Bought my Uke here – very happy with!” one wrote.
Runner-up: The Starving Musician1003 Pacific Ave., Santa Cruz
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Outdoor/Patio Furniture Store Winner: Dig Gardens420 Water St., Santa Cruz
One fan who voted for the store praised Dig’s “lush surroundings.”
Runner-up: Outdoor Supply Hardware1601 41st Ave., Capitola
Shoppers say they’re “most likely to find affordable outdoor furniture here,” in a large, uncrowded store with plenty of parking and the “best customer service around.”
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Record Store
Micheal Sheely, who’s been working at Streetlight Records for 10 years, inspects a used record for scratches before pricing. Credit: Kevin Painchaud / Lookout Santa Cruz
Winner: Streetlight Records
939 Pacific Ave., Santa Cruz
Music fans call Streetlight “a great classic,” a mainstay for decades whose staff “know their music.”
Runner-up: Redwood Records320 Cedar St., Santa Cruz
Fans praise Redwood Records’ great vibe and say the “events they host are the best.”
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Selection of Greeting Cards Winner: Paper Vision1345 Pacific Ave., Santa Cruz
Longtime customers say Paper Vision has cards “for every freaking occasion,” and they find things there they don’t see anywhere else.
Runner-up: Bookshop Santa Cruz1520 Pacific Ave., Santa Cruz
Shoppers enjoy Bookshop’s fun, interesting variety of cards for different occasions.
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Shoe Store
Downtown’s Sockshop and Shoe Company has something for every foot. Credit: Kevin Painchaud / Lookout Santa Cruz
Winner: Sockshop & Shoe Company
1515 Pacific Ave., Santa Cruz
Shoppers call Sockshop “stunning,” with “by far the best selection of shoes and socks” and a knowledgeable staff that puts “kindness and care” into every interaction. “I have over a dozen pair of shoes from here and have never been disappointed,” one wrote.
Runner-up: Bunny’s Shoes1350 Pacific Ave., Santa Cruz
Shoppers say Bunny’s has been “locally owned for years and always very cool shoes,” with unusual brands that are stylish and comfortable.
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Shop for Comics & Collectibles
Atlantis Fantasyworld owner Joe Ferrara, who was an extra in the original movie, shows off a replica of the comic book that the Frog brothers covet in the film. Credit: Kevin Painchaud / Lookout Santa Cruz
Winner: Atlantis Fantasyworld
1020 Cedar St., Santa Cruz
Fans call Atlantis “the only real comic shop in Santa Cruz,” and a few mentioned its “Lost Boys” fame.
Runner-up: Comicopolis829 Front St., Santa Cruz
Fans call Comicopolis a “Santa Cruz institution” with “great stuff I can’t find elsewhere.”
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Shop for Gamers — Video, Board, or Card Games Winner: Sword and Board GamesCapitola Mall, 1855 41st Ave., Suites J07-J08, Capitola
Gamers praise Sword and Board’s friendly owners, who “sell at MSRP, a rarity these days,” along with great tournaments, a free gaming room and a welcoming community for players at every level. “My second home!” one wrote.
Runner-up: Game Santa Cruz1101 Cedar St., Santa Cruz
Fans say owner Wes has built “an amazing, supportive, wonderful community,” with a curated selection of board games and tabletop RPGs and a cozy shop full of hand-crafted lanterns and antique furniture. “This place is magic,” one wrote.
Credit: Kevin Painchaud / Lookout Santa Cruz
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Store for a One-of-a-Kind Gift Winner: Artisans & Agency1368 Pacific Ave., Santa Cruz
Shoppers love Artisans’ original local art and jewelry, and say “you can find a gift for all tastes!”
Runner-up: Om Gallery1201 Pacific Ave., Santa Cruz
One voter praised Om Gallery’s “best atmosphere.”
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Store for Local Apparel Winner: Berdels1233 Pacific Ave., Santa Cruz
Shoppers praise Berdels’ “best selection of men’s and women’s clothing.”
Runner-up: Pacific Wave1502 Pacific Ave. and 623 Swift St., Santa Cruz
Shoppers say Pacific Wave sells “all the best local gear” from “so many local brands,” with a friendly staff.
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Thrift/Vintage for Clothing Winner: Just ThriftinCapitola Mall, 1855 41st Ave., Suite H3, Capitola
Thrifters say Just Thriftin has “cool stuff that you can’t find anywhere else,” flexible pricing and friendly, helpful staff, plus “a great and moving back story.”
Runner-up: Caroline’s Non Profit Thrift Shop8047 Soquel Drive, Aptos
Shoppers praise Caroline’s great selection at reasonable prices and the mission behind the local nonprofit.
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Favorite Thrift/Vintage for Home Decor Winner: The Abbot’s Thrift6164 Highway 9, Felton
Runner-up: Just ThriftinCapitola Mall, 1855 41st Ave., Suite H3, Capitola
Fans love Just Thriftin’s “crazy fun selection” and nostalgic decor that “reminds me of my childhood,” with a locally owned shop that gives back to the community.
Back to all Shopping & Retail categories
Get the winners in your inboxEach day’s Lookout List winners will be announced in Morning Lookout, our free weekday newsletter. Sign up so you don’t miss your favorites.
Sign upWinners are also being announced on Instagram. Follow along for daily reveals.
Follow @lookoutsantacruz
The post The Lookout List: Shopping & Retail appeared first on Lookout Santa Cruz.
Police arrest 15 over £1.5M 'we'll recover your losses' scam targeting elderly
Fifteen people have been arrested over an alleged scam that squeezed more money from investment fraud victims by offering to help recover their losses.
City of London Police searched 17 London addresses on November 11 and apprehended 14 men and one woman. All have since been released on bail. Investigators say the suspected fraudsters posed as regulators to persuade previous victims that compensation was available.
Reports submitted through the UK's Report Fraud service helped investigators trace the compensation pitch to around 3,000 recipients since October 2025.
Most victims were elderly, police said. The offers arrived by letter and email, promising redress for earlier investment losses.
City of London Police said the victims were initially targeted by a range of investment scams related to art, carbon credits, land, whisky, wine, and pensions, and that some took place more than a decade prior to their re-victimization.
Targets were directed to a company that demanded a holding fee before supposedly reclaiming their money. Police say those who paid were left further out of pocket.
"Today's action sends a clear message to those who target vulnerable people for financial gain: you will be pursued and will face robust action," said Nik Adams, deputy commissioner at the City of London Police.
"Behind every fraud report is a real person whose trust has been damaged, and in some cases, whose life savings have been stolen. We know the impact of these crimes can be devastating.
"This case highlights the importance of reporting fraud through the Report Fraud service. Information provided by victims helped investigators link reports together, uncover the wider conspiracy, and identify those involved. It is a powerful reminder that every report counts and can play a vital role in bringing offenders to justice."
The investigation also extends beyond London, with police identifying locations linked to the case in Kent and Hertfordshire.
The searches resulted in officers seizing cash, drugs, and other high-value items, including a watch worth around £230,000, with the total haul valued at more than £2 million.
Police put losses identified so far at £1.5 million and expect that figure to rise as the investigation continues.
Knowing the details of an earlier scam doesn't make a caller trustworthy, police warned. That information can be used to sell victims a second fraud.
Report Fraud has also highlighted substantial losses in other scams affecting older people.
Fraudsters exploiting positions of trust stole a reported £93.8 million during 2025/26. People aged 70 and over lost more than £51 million, with relatives, friends, carers, and others entrusted with their finances among the perpetrators. Report Fraud received 3,812 reports in this category.
"The impact of fraud extends far beyond financial loss, especially when it is carried out by those who are trusted by the victim," said Mark Evans, president at the Law Society of England and Wales.
Similarly, at the end of October, Report Fraud said £24.3 million was stolen between January and August 2026 through AI-augmented investment scams, with people aged 60 and over accounting for nearly 80 percent of reports.
However, it's not always the elderly in scammers' crosshairs. Those in the 30-39 age bracket accounted for the most reports in one of the most lucrative frauds affecting Brits in recent times.
Payment diversion fraud, which tricks victims into paying a criminal's bank account instead of the intended recipient's, resulted in £101 million in losses in the 2025/26 financial year, according to Report Fraud's figures. ®
Transcript: Fox Goes Haywire on Nvidia Mess as Trump Humiliation Grows
The following is a lightly edited transcript of the November 18 episode of The Daily Blast podcast. Listen to it here.
Greg Sargent: This is The Daily Blast from The New Republic, produced and presented by the DSR Network. I’m your host, Greg Sargent.
Donald Trump’s top advisers are at war over Nvidia, the big AI company at the center of a major national security scandal involving its leader, Jensen Huang. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent is sharply criticizing Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick for not doing enough to block Chinese companies from using Nvidia’s chips. Trump has been sucked into this scandal, and Fox News is now frantically running propaganda on his behalf, insisting it’s mostly orchestrated by Democrats and the media. That’s a good sign that this poses a serious threat to Trump. And it really does, revealing that Trump is exactly the wrong guy to have as president when something as big as AI’s future is involved.
To really grasp what’s at stake here, we’re talking to Juliette Kayyem, a former DHS official in the Obama administration, who’s been writing well on that topic at her Early Warning Substack. Juliette, thanks for coming on.
Juliette Kayyem: Thanks for having me again.
Sargent: So, to briefly sum up: Nvidia’s leader, Jensen Huang, had an affair with Alice Huang, no relation, who U.S. officials believe was a Chinese spy at the time. Trump was briefed on intelligence concerns about Alice but didn’t do anything. Alice Wong’s company, Mega Speed, appears to have been moving technology to China. Juliette, can you explain why these revelations are something we should all care about?
Kayyem: Yeah, this is about sex, but it’s also about national security, so I’ll focus on the latter. So, just to give people a sense, Nvidia has a close to 90 percent market share of what you might just call the architecture behind what animates AI. So we talk about semiconductors, but you don’t have to get into the technicalities of it.
We have won—in the sense, when I say, like, the U.S., you know, in this fight with China—the U.S. has advanced production and manufacturing of something that the Chinese would want. There are laws prohibiting selling to China. There’s loopholes and all sorts of stuff, but I’ll just say the general rule is that it should be prohibited.
In the process of Nvidia’s, like, absolute surge to own the bones of AI, Jensen becomes a rock star. He is untouchable. And he’s friends with Trump. He then is known to be sleeping with a woman who the intelligence agencies view as an asset of the Chinese. At the same time, her company is clearly benefiting from sales that are, we believe, eventually going to the Chinese. So she becomes sort of a pass-through.
Now, whether she is truly a Chinese asset or not is still unclear. It could be that they colluded to bypass these laws and then ended up sleeping together. But in the process of all of this, more affairs come out, and Jensen is kicked out.
Sargent: Can you explain the relationship between Trump and Jensen? Why does Trump need him? How has Trump benefited from him?
Kayyem: So, like many AI CEOs, he believed that Trump was going to be the last president. So he starts sucking up to Trump, paying for the ballroom, paying for—well, honestly, we don’t know what, but at least we know that there were significant investments in all of Trump’s pet projects.
We know Trump owns individual stock in Nvidia. And so there’s a sort of embrace of each other. He travels with Trump. He’s part of the boys of AI groupings that Trump is always holding. He went to China with him.
For the last three to six months, we know that the Trump administration, and Trump specifically, have known of this affair—that, you know, however it began, at best, it’s a honeypot situation, right? Because then he’s just duped by a beautiful woman. At worst, the two of them colluded to bypass U.S. laws.
Sargent: Well, basically what’s at stake here is whether China is going to be able to use Nvidia’s technology to catch up in the AI race, right?
Kayyem: Exactly right.
Sargent: Right. So Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick is taking a huge beating for doing too little to crack down on this technology transfer to China. Scott Bessent is taking the opposite side, and I guess Trump is sort of adrift in the middle. What should the posture of the United States, and of Trump, be right now, exactly?
Kayyem: The United States should prohibit such sales to China, and enforce those laws that are already on the books, and those that need to be strengthened to prohibit the kind of sales that were possibly going on with Nvidia or any other company. This is an enforcement issue and a legal issue.
Sargent: And I think that, with Trump in control of the executive branch, we can’t even be sure that anybody seriously is looking into what actually happened here, right?
Kayyem: That’s right. And he’s gone back and forth in terms of whether he thinks Jensen should stay or go. The AI titans are, you know, pushing for him to come back in. Jensen has said he’s willing to go back in. And so I can’t say that we have much guidance right now. It’s only what we’re hearing of the fights in terms of the Cabinet. We certainly know where the new Congress and Senate are going to be on this.
Sargent: Well, Fox News has turned this into a story about how Democrats and the media are out to get Trump. Matt Gertz of Media Matters had a good rundown on this. Fox’s Jesse Watters said this about Jensen.
Jesse Watters (voiceover): And the Democrats did not like him. He was anti-doomer, remember? He—no guardrails, no nothing, just let AI rip. But now, all of a sudden, you have people like Liz Warren using this situation to take down Trump and regulate AI.
Fox’s Greg Gutfeld, meanwhile, called the story orchestrated, said it aligns with efforts to stop AI data centers.
Greg Gutfeld (voiceover): This was a plot to get rid of Jensen Huang, the same way they’re targeting Elon Musk. Here you have two people that are responsible for the innovation of technology that is going to change our future, and people are out to destroy them. I think this is orchestrated. I don’t know what it’s about. Maybe it is to slow down the pace of innovation, allowing China or other competitors to catch up. And it aligns perfectly with the attempts to stop data centers.
Sargent: And Sean Hannity accused Democrats of “hypocrisy” because of something involving Congressman Eric Swalwell, who resigned some time ago. Hannity bashed Democrats for wanting to investigate the Trump administration’s handling of this. What do you make of all that?
Kayyem: They’re obviously in denial about what happened during the blue wave. Like, they sort of view this as a conspiracy against Trump. Most Americans are nervous about AI, skeptical about its capacity, think it needs to be regulated. Data centers have just become something that they can touch and feel, because most Americans don’t understand how AI works.
I think Jensen is similar, that it’s like, OK, now I can sort of see what’s going on—a total megalomaniac billionaire who’s giving away state secrets and getting sex in the process. So I think Jensen and data centers are the manifestation of a real, wide, bipartisan nervousness that the private sector, with the help of this administration, is just throwing this technology into the world and saying, live with it. And I think Americans are like, you know what? I don’t know how I can fight back, but I can vote.
Sargent: Yes, I think you’re absolutely right. I also think Fox is doing this because they know Democrats are taking over Congress and they’re going to have subpoena power. And this Nvidia scandal is the sort of thing that suggests we have no idea how deep Trump’s corruption and malfeasance really go.
The Trump administration is really vulnerable, in the sense that if Democrats start seriously subpoenaing private sector actors who had questionable or even corrupt dealings with Trump and the administration, then you’re going to suddenly get a real wellspring of stuff that would be harder to get to if you were going after executive branch actors.
Kayyem: Hey, what privilege are they going to assert? I mean, what is Trump—Trump could pardon everyone, I guess, but that’s going to take political might. But that’s the way in. And Jensen just gave them a really, you know, great opportunity to do it, right? I mean, in other words, that’s why I think they’re panicking.
I think also, Greg, like, I think, you know, all the media has been around this idea that she’s a honeypot. And I have to say, there’s a growing sense in the national security world that that might be too simplistic.
That in fact, while, yes, they were together, Jensen always wanted to open up the Chinese markets. I don’t think he needed to sleep with someone to discover that. And so, in a weird way, I wonder if they are much more co-conspirators than that he was a victim. But, you know, these guys have such ego. He wants back in.
Sargent: And isn’t there more to find out about Trump’s relationship with Jensen? That’s what I’m trying to get at as well, which is, this is the kind of scandal which makes you think, holy shit, we didn’t know about all this yesterday. It’s the kind of thing where all of a sudden these things pop out that are just horrifying, and hint that there’s always more underneath the surface.
Kayyem: Just think about this process, right? The Trump administration is told about Jensen’s vulnerability. The Chinese likely knew that, right? That the White House knew. And they also saw that the White House didn’t do anything about it. So if you’re the Chinese, you not only have a vulnerability with Jensen, you now have a good vulnerability, in the sense that you now have a White House that’s going to let you do this. I mean, that is crazy.
Sargent: Yeah, that is crazy. So, Juliette, with Democrats taking over Congress, what can they be reasonably expected to establish about this whole thing? In other words, if you were running these oversight operations, what would you want Democrats to try to figure out?
Kayyem: Go after the boards. Subpoena these board members, because they got very rich, they had no oversight, they weren’t caring about the shareholders, they weren’t controlling the CEO. And how did these kinds of sales occur without them ever wondering, why are we selling $400 million worth of inventory to a woman who has, you know, three employees?
So I would go after the boards, because they are vulnerable. They are legally liable, and they will not have the protections, or, you know, the superstar status, of Jensen. You’re on a public board, babe. You own it.
Sargent: Right. So what you want Democrats taking over Congress to do is, A, get to the bottom of who Jensen is and what he’s really doing, and B, get to the bottom of what is really going on with these technology transfers to China.
Kayyem: Yeah, I think that’s exactly right. And I think the boards, because these are public companies, really become a way in, because you’re going to get people who will be, I think, more transparent than obviously the administration, which will either try to not have to testify or lie. And so I think it would be an interesting tactic. That’s how you want to do it, to make a case that these companies cannot manage themselves.
They absolutely cannot. Just a little tidbit: The board, up until the day they announced the acting CEO, never had a chairman or chairwoman. It was, like, just a blob of fancy people. I was like, how do you not have a chairman? How do you not have a leadership role? It’s just because they were just there to make Jensen and themselves richer.
Sargent: I think you really hit the essential point here, which is that Democrats need to use this moment to show to the public, to the American people, that these people can’t be trusted to manage something of this magnitude.
Michelle Goldberg had a good point in the Times, noting that Trump keeps saying that we can’t regulate AI because it’ll allow China to catch up with us, but here he seems to turn a blind eye to something that is very much aiding China in doing that.
I think, Juliette, ultimately the big story here is that Trump has exactly zero conception of what the AI race could unleash, and has exactly zero interest in thinking about what we should be doing to harness it, right?
Democrats have this opening here to become the party that really is going to steward all this, whereas Trump and the Republican Party are basically just MIA.
Kayyem: Yeah. And I think, I mean, look, we know that the AI titans tied their future to Trump. We owe them nothing. Over the last two years, we have seen them suck up, pay, denigrate progressives, denigrate the left, run away from DEI, troll us.
And so, in terms of, you know, these titans, I have long thought they are putting a dangerous commodity into our market. Some of them should be in jail if something very harmful happens. So I think that is very, very important for the Democrats to own. And they have the American public on their side. The AI titans chose, and now they’re seeing that the American people were not with them.
You see a lot of them—my favorite is Palantir’s Alex Karp. Alex Karp, who—I mean, people can’t see me, but, you know, I’m doing the—that’s a man with a lot of energy, if you know what I mean—has spent two years essentially using his platform to vilify, surveil, undermine democratic movements in the United States. And now that they overcame that, he is now, I’ve always been a Democrat. Well, guess what?
I mean, it’s like the funniest—it’s not funny. I would say, on your point about what the Democrats can do, or where Trump is: Trump thinks AI is a widget, you know. I mean, in other words, he looks at it as a market, right? Do I gain, and do my people gain, from this commodity?
But it’s a dangerous commodity. And he knows that the more regulation, the more friction that occurs, maybe people make less money. He doesn’t have a philosophy of AI. He has a philosophy of the market. And now, you know, the consumer—us, the voter—is pushing back.
Sargent: And you know what? That’s exactly why the tech titans attached themselves so corruptly to this guy, for the very reasons you laid out, because he would essentially give them a free hand. And now, boy, is it looking like they miscalculated after that midterm, huh?
Kayyem: Yeah, the smartest boys in the room. I mean, it is remarkable, the way that they managed the politics of this. Because part of it is they’re all arrogant, and, you know, if Elon’s in the room, they want to be in the room. But part of it is, I think—I mean, you probably see this world, and I get glimpses of it—they are so in their own cocoon that they literally can’t see that there’s a world out there.
It’s not that, you know, they’re horrible and they’re myopic, but they just don’t have the kind of experiences that you and I have. In many ways, they have all the money in the world, and they’re more limited than most people who are living in the world and seeing what’s going on.
Sargent: Absolutely. I think a very clear illustration of that was Elon Musk being absolutely shocked at this enormous turnout against them. Juliette Kayyem, awesome to talk to you. Folks, if you want to get more of Juliette’s stuff, check out her Early Warning Substack. Juliette, thanks for coming on.
Kayyem: Thank you so much.
Why Chris Van Hollen Would Be a Better Leader Than Chuck Schumer
You can watch this episode of Right Now With Perry Bacon above or by following this show on YouTube or Substack. You can read a transcript here.
Longtime Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen is challenging New York’s Chuck Schumer for Senate majority leader. In the latest episode of Right Now, Leah Greenberg, co-executive director of Indivisible, explains why her group is pushing for Van Hollen. She argues that aggressive resistance to Trump in 2025 helped build the wave that resulted in Democrats’ huge wins in the November elections. Schumer wasn’t forcefully opposing Trump in the first few months of his second term, she argues. In contrast, she praises Van Hollen for his leadership, in particular flying to El Salvador to protest the deportation of Kilmar Abrego Garcia.
Santa Cruz fin whale: What we know about its death, burial and necropsy results
Felicis leads $7.5M bet on Unsiloed AI to make enterprise documents usable by AI agents
ULA says Vulcan lacked the oomph to get Amazon satellites to orbit
United Launch Alliance (ULA) says poor booster performance appears to have doomed Sunday's Vulcan mission, which lost an Amazon Leo satellite payload on the rocket's return to flight.
ULA's initial assessment points to trouble almost immediately. "Early indications are that just after liftoff the launch vehicle experienced low booster performance," it said. As a result, stage separation occurred at too low an altitude, and the rocket was not traveling fast enough for the payload to reach orbit.
The second stage appeared to perform well, with its RL10 engines operating as planned, but that wasn't enough to make up for the shortfall, and the mission failed. ULA lost telemetry approximately ten minutes into flight.
An investigation is underway, led by ULA and overseen by the US Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), which had to activate two Debris Response Areas where debris was falling. The agency directs aircraft to leave these areas, and others are prevented from entering.
Previous flights had been blighted by problems with the solid rocket boosters, designed to give the rocket a kick at launch. Those issues prompted a stand-down while investigators examined the cause. This time, ULA said: "All indications are that the solid rocket booster performance was nominal, following nozzle improvements implemented for this launch."
Attention therefore turns to Vulcan's liquid-fueled core stage, powered by two Blue Origin BE-4 engines, though that does not establish an engine fault. Fuel delivery or another first-stage system could also be responsible, and the investigation is ongoing.
The BE-4 also powers Blue Origin's New Glenn rocket, which exploded on the launchpad during a ground test in May. In August, Blue Origin boss Dave Limp said that the issue originated at the main oxygen valve on one of the BE-4 engines. Modifications were made to deal with the problem.
The upper stage's apparently normal performance may offer some reassurance to NASA, although the investigation remains at an early stage. The agency dropped the delayed Exploration Upper Stage earlier this year and is pursuing a stretched Centaur V alongside its existing interim cryogenic propulsion stage as options for Artemis IV.
NASA is targeting Artemis IV for early 2028 and Artemis V for later that year.
ULA said: "We truly understand the impact this has on our customers and are committed to returning to flight as safely and quickly as we can."
The failure also dents ULA's otherwise impressive launch record. A predecessor of Vulcan, the Atlas V, has a 100 percent success record for payloads reaching orbit. However, it uses Russian RD-180 engines, a dependency the US wishes to remove. ®
Santa Cruz County business: Boulder Creek lands federal investment designation; Santa Cruz Gives campaign kicks off
India’s Humyn Labs raises $47M to feed U.S. robotics companies the data they need
UK.gov JV gets £178M Home Office hosting deal. Without competition
The Home Office has awarded a contract worth £178 million to a public-private hosting services joint venture - without competition - to support critical national infrastructure.
According to a notice published last week, Crown Hosting Data Centres (CHDC) won the seven-year contract to support "essential national infrastructure underpinning the Home Office's most critical systems, including border security, the Police National Computer (PNC), and core intelligence environments."
CHDC is a joint venture between the Cabinet Office, which owns 25 percent, and Ark Data Centres Ltd, which owns the rest. It was set up in 2015 for the express purpose of providing hosting services for the government.
The award was made through an existing framework agreement, set up in February 2022, awarded to CHDC without competition via a Voluntary Ex-Ante Transparency Notice.
The service is set to support Critical National Infrastructure, although the notice does not reveal specific services requested.
Mention of continued support for the Police National Computer may raise eyebrows. The Home Office is managing the transition of the aging legacy system to the Law Enforcement Data Service (LEDS) under the National Law Enforcement Data Program (NLEDP).
A notice in December 2024 said that the Home Office was "focused on the development and adoption of LEDS products to replace existing PNC capability across all police forces and other non-policing PNC consumers, enabling the retirement by March 2026 (the point at which PNC support will expire)." The government had previously set a target of decommissioning the PNC in 2022.
The Register has asked the Home Office to clarify why Crown Hosting support is necessary beyond this date.
The PNC – which is based on mainframe technology dating from the 1970s – was at the center of a scandal in 2021 when a technology failure led to the loss of 413,000 records of evidence.
The incident, which left then Prime Minister Boris Johnson floundering in Parliament, was the result of a scripting error in code designed to weed out records to be deleted from the PNC, a system running on a Fujitsu BS2000/OSD SE700-30 mainframe-based at a datacenter in Hendon, London.
In 2022, the Cabinet Office awarded a contract worth up to £250 million to CHDC, also without outside competition. ®
How the Telephone Changed the World
“How does a technology, an invention, a machine, change the people who adopt it? Can it be said to alter modes of living or reshape society?” A pair of curious academics posed these questions after the New York Telephone Company fire of 1975—a subterranean inferno beneath Second Avenue that resulted in an outage of phone service on a then-unprecedented scale. The fire had knocked out service to 173,000 phones in Lower Manhattan for six weeks, upending communication in the neighborhood and radically altering the lives of its residents.
In their survey (ironically conducted later by telephone), the researchers learned that residents had altered their behavior by resorting to pay phones, using messenger services, fretting about how to contact others in an emergency, wondering whether to knock on each other’s doors unannounced, and sending “courtship letters” to prospective love interests. The telephone, the researchers concluded, was key to people’s sense of connection and control.

More than 50 years later, in a perpetually connected digital world, it’s not hard to imagine dependence on a singular device—even though, as James Gleick, author of The Telephone, notes, “When the telephone was first invented, people really had no idea what it was going to be good for.” During our recent conversation, which was edited for length and clarity, we discussed how Alexander Graham Bell’s invention—the basis for AT&T, once the world’s largest company—became the dominant communications technology of the twentieth century, altering worldwide commerce, language, and social habits, and then receded into the background at the end of the century as wireless technologies took over.
Lorraine Cademartori: What drew you to the tale of the telephone at this moment?
James Gleick: I’d actually started working on this book more than 30 years ago, before we had cell phones, before we had the internet, when the telephone was almost dying but it was a very standard and familiar object. I began to realize it had changed our social lives; it had changed the organization of our economy, it had changed what was already then-modern life in ways that we were utterly unaware of, because as an object it had become so ordinary that it had faded into the background of our consciousness.
And then, everything started to change. And so I thought well, this is boring.
I had boxes from the AT&T archives in New Jersey, which are now long gone. But as somebody writing about tech and about science, I was excited by the new stuff. The internet arrived. And what the telephone was just changed dramatically. And it didn’t change overnight into the thing it is now; it took time. Some people will remember when the first mobile phones were gigantic, they were unwieldy, and you mostly had to worry about keeping it charged. And then there were pagers. And most of this stuff appears at the end of my book; it was only five or six years ago that it occurred to me to go back to it; that the story had new meaning because of all these changes … and because the original book that I had started writing did in fact lay the foundations for the world we’re in now. And so the story is just as surprising and I hope even more relevant than when I started out.
L.C.: Part of the story told in the book is the race to “invent” the telephone—the drama between Elisha Gray and Alexander Graham Bell. But they didn’t foresee how the telephone would be used.
J.G.: It seems obvious that what [the telephone] is good for is talking to people; having conversations. But what people—and this was almost universal—thought was, oh, you can send the sound of somebody’s voice, or you can send the sound of music, electrically, across wires, so obviously what we should do is put one telephone in the concert hall, and you’ll have your telephone in your house, and so you can listen to concerts. Or you can put the other end of it in the church, and you can listen to sermons from your pastor instead of getting off your butt every Sunday. Or you can listen to lectures. In other words, they thought it was going to be radio. They thought it was going to be a broadcast medium.
But of course, the sound quality was terrible, and you didn’t really want to pick up this heavy device and listen to an opera that was being performed. Conversely, the ease and sheer pleasure of being able to just speak, and somebody else could hear you, turned out to be incredibly powerful.
L.C.: There are some great scenes in the book—bribes for patents, the Hartford drugstore owner who started running multiple lines into his drugstore, farmers using barbed wire for party lines.… Yet ultimately, AT&T and the Bell company emerged as a monopoly.
J.G.: The power of that monopoly and the unshakability of it is hard for people to remember today. There was populist opposition, and there were competing telephone companies. But in the end, the bankers and financiers won, and the Bell system monopoly was sanctioned by the government on the theory that the government would regulate it and keep prices down. And the fact is, people grew comfortable by and large with the Bell system monopoly. They were aware—because it was true—that the United States had the best and most broadly spread phone service of any country in the world. People lived their entire lives as customers of the Bell system.
L.C.: Tell me if I’m wrong in seeing some parallels between the AT&T monopoly and Bell Labs to Silicon Valley now.
J.G.: Well, Bell Labs was actually a great thing. Anybody who cares about science and looks at the history of Bell Labs has to admit, no matter how fervent of an anti-monopolist you are, that they ran Bell Labs largely for the benefit of science. Today, large corporations like Microsoft and Google have their own research labs, but they are very much focused on the bottom line. I forget how many—10, 11, 12 Nobel Prizes—were awarded that were not directly related to telephone research [at Bell Labs]. And the most important of them, the one that could have benefited the telephone company more than all the rest combined, was the invention of the transistor, but it also very quickly became available for the whole world to use.
L.C.: Was that part of the deal with the government? That AT&T would simply be the carrier?
J.G.: [Part of the deal], especially as the decades went on, was that the phone company wouldn’t be allowed to get into the brand-new computer business.… Even before AT&T was broken up, people could see that it would be a bad thing if the telephone company was allowed to extend its monopoly into this new and growing field.
So, in a way, we can look back at the Bell monopolies through rose-colored glasses. And I’m worried that—if you look at how quickly the AI companies are forming conspicuously, with no attention at all to the public good, almost unabashedly in the pursuit of personal profit, for the benefit of wannabe oligarchs like Sam Altman and Elon Musk—I find it all somewhere between depressing and terrifying.
L.C.: There are ways that people adapted their behaviors to the telephone—the adjustments to language, the development of the word “hello” …
J.G.: People do find their own uses for new technologies. People often outwit the designers and manufacturers of new technology and use it in ways that those inventors or marketers hadn’t anticipated. And this is certainly true of the single phone that we all now carry around in our pockets. … People find their own habits of texting, and using emojis and enjoying podcasts or whatnot.… So [now] we’re in a much wilder, more unbridled world than some people expected.
But I don’t want to be too Pollyannish about that, because, of course, it’s just as true that the free and democratic internet that I saw coming 30 years ago, that I believed was inevitable, has really been taken over by centralized platforms.
I still think it matters whether you’re talking to a person or you’re talking to a bot, even though there’s a whole industry that has grown up to confuse us.L.C.: Is there any lesson from the story of the telephone that we can map onto today’s technological landscape?
J.G.: Brought to the surface by the story of the telephone is how eagerly, how humbly, as a matter of necessity, we human beings crave connection.… In this era of ubiquitous communication, when we do have a thing we call a phone on our person at all times, we truly are more connected to our fellow creatures than ever before. And I also believe that with all the … incessant attacks on our concentration and demands for attention and all the distractions, we are still able to find a kind of community building, a kind of communion with other individuals that is wonderful.
It is, I believe, extremely important to—maybe I’m a naïve humanist in this way—I still think it matters whether you’re talking to a person or you’re talking to a bot, even though there’s a whole industry that has grown up to confuse us, and to persuade us that those bots have personalities and are, in many contexts, as good as humans. I don’t believe that, and I think it’s important to resist.
Trump Has a Secret ICE Slush Fund—and His Plan for It Is Unnerving
By all indications, Stephen Miller is set to respond to the biggest electoral wipeout in a half century by doubling down on unchecked anti-immigrant thuggery. Miller is privately vowing to expand his mass deportations, and Donald Trump has elevated him to White House chief of staff, where he hopes to execute his scheme from commanding new heights.
Unfortunately, Miller will have far more resources than you might expect to carry out his predations. That puts new pressure squarely on the incoming Democratic congressional majority to take those resources away from him.
As of right now, Immigration and Customs Enforcement still has an eye-popping $91 billion in funds on hand to spend on deportations between now and the end of Trump’s second term, a striking new report from the American Immigration Council finds. Importantly, the report—which The New Republic obtained before its release—shows that this is all no-strings-attached funding, which means ICE can spend it without any serious guardrails or constraints.
Where did this money come from? The report details that in 2025 and 2026, the GOP Congress passed two major chunks of funding for ICE, $75 billion in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act and $38 billion in the Secure America Act. The report looks at recent government spending data and concludes that of this money, only $17 billion has been “obligated” (spent or committed) from the 2025 bill and only $5 billion has been obligated from the 2026 measure.
That leaves a total of $91 billion left for spending on mass deportations and other ICE activity between now and 2029, the report concludes. The office of Senator Jeff Merkley, the next Budget Committee Chair, believes this calculation is accurate. As Merkley told me in a statement, the GOP Congress basically handed ICE “an enormous slush fund to wreak havoc in our communities.”
That’s right. Because all that funding originally passed without serious constraints, the huge amount that remains is now functionally a slush fund for ICE recruitment, deportations, long-term detention, and the stockpiling of paramilitary equipment.
“ICE still has essentially a blank check of tens of billions of dollars to use with no conditions attached,” Nayna Gupta, policy director of the American Immigration Council, told me. “Unless Congress acts, ICE will continue to expand its agenda, which has been lawless, violent, and undermined public safety.”
Democrats are already discussing how to claw this money back next year, and the report details many paths toward that end.
The first is for the Democratic House to simply pass a measure canceling the unobligated appropriations. That’s the cleanest option, but as the report notes, it would have to pass the Senate (it’s not certain 51 Democratic senators would support this, though they might), and if it did, Trump would veto it, leaving the fund in place.
That’s why the second path—attach a clawback of the money to a different appropriations bill that Trump and Republicans want—should also be considered. A third approach involves attaching riders to Department of Homeland Security funding that impose tough restrictions on various types of ICE enforcement. These could bar racial profiling, indiscriminate and warrantless ICE arrests, and enforcement in sensitive places, among many other things.
“Congress can make a meaningful difference right away in how ICE is behaving just with the appropriations process,” Gupta says. All these paths could end in government shutdown fights, something Democrats should prepare for right now.
There is a strong case for the Democratic House to pass a complete clawback of the ICE slush fund and then see how far it gets. True, some Democratic members in districts carried by Trump might balk, fearing Republicans will accuse them of “defunding ICE.” But they shouldn’t.
ICE is hideously unpopular. And those Democrats can say they want to channel the money to, say, health care spending; Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries hinted at this Tuesday, suggesting such funding should be “redirected.” Taking taxpayer funds away from the widely-hated ICE raids and using them to provide material benefits for voters would be a popular stance.
What’s more, Democrats worried about the politics of “defunding ICE” can say they oppose funding immigration enforcement with no strings attached, as opposed to an end to all immigration enforcement. Being for accountability, especially after this election, will resonate with the very voters who powered the blue wave. Skittish Democrats can also call for clawing back the slush fund and then support passage of baseline Department of Homeland Security funding with many serious restrictions built in.
All these positions should be pretty easy sells. Stephen Miller wants you to believe otherwise: Someone close to him has been furiously leaking to reporters that there will be no moderating ICE operations in the slightest. This is supposed to make Miller look as if he’s operating from a position of strength. But it’s actually one of weakness.
Indeed, Miller’s reading of the post-election landscape borders on delusional. Axios reports that Miller now wants to rebuild the shattered Trump coalition by winning back young and nonwhite men, including Latinos. Miller apparently believes they were driven away primarily by the Iran war and by costs and won’t care if ICE brutality rages on.
Naturally war and prices were major factors. But as I’ve argued, MAGA figures are heavily invested in blaming only the war and costs for their electoral debacle because it insulates mass deportations and MAGA ethnonationalism from blame. In a new analysis, G. Elliott Morris shows that ICE activity may have helped drive key constituencies to Democrats, including the young and nonwhite voters Miller wants to win back.
Adding to Morris’s analysis, it’s plausible that revulsion at the underlying ideological vision of a purified nation achieved via mass ethnic purges—that is, disgust with the white nationalist project, not just the ICE operations—also helped move many voters. Tellingly, podcast bros like Joe Rogan who have turned on Trump aren’t just pillorying ICE’s tactics. In his widely-discussed response to the election, Rogan—who reaches a huge audience of young men who deserted MAGA—said the only crime many undocumented immigrants have committed is “they don’t have the right paperwork.”
In other words, most Americans grasp that these immigrants are only guilty of trying to better their prospects and have a reasonable claim to a place in American life. The exit polls show that huge majorities say that immigrants are good for our country. Miller, a bone-deep ideologue and unrepentant ethnonationalist, cannot fathom that anyone, let alone most Americans, could possibly believe such heresies.
The consensus position for Democrats should be a simple one: ICE cannot continue in anything remotely like its current form. In fact, not doing everything possible to zero out ICE’s massive slush fund might be politically worse for Democrats. It could allow ICE to continue its operations with quasi-impunity and make Democrats look weak and feckless.
Democrats were elected, at least in part, to put a check on an authoritarian president. ICE—with its masked kidnappings, its fascistic paramilitary displays in U.S. cities, its recruitment pitches celebrating ethnonationalist sadism, its killings of U.S. citizens—is the most glaring example of his lawlessness. Miller wants it to continue operating in exactly that way. Democrats: It’s time to break ICE for good.
The Crusading Legal Drama With AI In Its Sights
People hate AI. In a polarized United States, where vanishingly few issues unite public opinion, a majority of Americans thinks artificial intelligence sucks. Nearly 90 percent say they’re more concerned than excited about AI development, both in superintelligence and data center construction. Sixty-four percent think AI is developing too fast. A survey from Anthropic found that only 15 percent of Americans “trust AI companies to make decisions about how AI is developed and used.” Sixty-one percent of likely voters this September said they oppose the construction of new data centers. In March, an NBC News poll showed that AI was less popular than ICE. Massive protests featuring an improbably diverse cast of characters have risen up wherever data center projects threaten the land. Parent organizations across the country are working to get screens out of schools. One poll this fall found that 68 percent of Americans have used at least one AI tool, and 59 percent think it should be strictly regulated. Even among many AI users, it seems, there’s a feeling that this stuff needs to be controlled.
This is AI populism, and it’s going viral. The tech journalist Jasmine Sun sees it as a sprawling movement rooted in resistance to this top-down transformation of our economy and social fabric. It’s a worldview rooted in a lack of trust in arrogant institutions that have foisted this tech upon us at our jobs, in our schools, and in our neighborhoods against our will. Rooted as much in critiques of AI creep as it is in pure resentment, the movement is on the ascent.
There might not be a better duo to tackle AI populism in a big-ticket work of pop culture than Robert and Michelle King. For nearly 20 years, the Kings have been producing TV series that nimbly straddle the line between broadcast appeal and niche obsession. Their flagship series, The Good Wife, was the ultimate crossover—pulling huge network viewership numbers as well as praise and accolades from prestige TV gatekeepers. (It’s one of a very small number of network dramas to make The New York Times’ recent list of the best 100 TV series of the twenty-first century.) Their record since then has scaled up and down from boutique to big tent, with cult favorites Evil and The Good Fight streaming on Paramount+, and Elsbeth becoming a Thursday-night CBS blockbuster. Now, they have returned with Cupertino, a blue-sky procedural precision crafted for the vast, heterogeneous AI populist demographic. The central characters here are not tech CEO antiheroes, as in AMC’s The Audacity or HBO’s Mountainhead. Instead, the protagonists are a (relatively) likable, familiar type—a pair of renegade attorneys ready to ride into battle against murky corporations. Tech backlash has never been this snappy or this joyful.
Cupertino flips a hilarious and humanistic middle finger to our robot overlords. In the show’s first episode, we quickly meet Michael Price (Mike Colter) and Olivia Siffre (Rachel Keller), both of whom have just been let go by a fictional AI giant called S-Talk. Price, a high-end attorney, had been a founding partner of the firm, but he’s been fired on a false charge of leaking internal company information; Siffre, a first-year law school grad, has been fired after being sexually harassed by another of S-Talk’s founders. Two protagonists, freshly fucked by the AI barons. The two find each other and join forces to address the myriad injustices done upon them by their former employer. In the course of this quest, they realize how closely entangled (and invested) the Silicon Valley legal community is with that area’s corporate denizens—it’s impossible to fight back against these companies because everyone already kind of works for them.
So, exiled and enraged, Price and Siffre start their own firm, a boutique band of cast-offs who have the sole purpose of representing the exploited underclass of the AI industry, from former employees to artists whose intellectual property has been stolen. (They’re eventually joined by Christy [Ella Stiller], who signs on as an assistant and investigator after being fired from S-Talk herself.) Price frames it as a David versus Goliath situation in which the Davids also just happen to make boatloads of cash from the settlements these companies dole out to avoid going to court. This philosophical mix of cynicism and idealism—and the attendant moral conundrums that inevitably follow—are the show’s imaginative driving force.
Price, Siffre & Associates’ foes of course bring their own propulsive cynicism to the table. In the universe of Cupertino, the AI companies are powered by a mixture of greed, delusion, and genuine brilliance. At the tippy top of this hierarchy are the founders, the executives, and their energetic legal teams, pursuing market dominance at any cost. Their lawyers are slick and savvy operators, particularly Nichole Ferebee (a terrific Renée Elise Goldsberry), Michael’s ex, who alternately antagonizes and admires her old flame.
The founders, though, are mostly scuzzbags and morons. Some, like S-Talk’s leader, are hoodie-clad coders, awkward and breathtakingly arrogant, enjoying power they are not socially equipped to wield. They behave like entitled children, but their tantrums affect the whole world. Some, like the CEO of a drone company whose July 4 display accidentally killed a guy, are expensive-suited opportunists. They see the AI boom as a gold rush—they bend rules and pivot business strategies on a whim to exploit gaps in the market. They lack even the reckless optimism of the true believers. The valley is full of con men and men who have conned themselves.
Then, there’s everybody else. Cupertino’s heroic population of AI industry malcontents covers a broad swath of new archetypes: There’s the stoner coder being scapegoated by his corrupt company; the overqualified AI trainers being paid peanuts to refine a company’s raw product; the sick young woman at the mercy of an AI to determine whether she gets a liver transplant; the grieving mother whose son followed a chatbot’s instructions to kill his father and her husband; the people all over the world being paid to prompt new chatbot models to seem more human; and Olivia, who’s had her voice and personality plagiarized for a pornified AI personal assistant. The firm even briefly represents a client who may or may not be the very first artificial general intelligence, or AGI, and who wants to sue his creators to restore his safety guardrails. Even the AI hates these assholes.
Then, there’s Natalia Boutella (Busy Philipps), the ex-wife of a Silicon Valley magnate, who decides to fund Price and Siffre’s operation in order to get back at him. Natalia agrees to invest as a lark but soon declares herself a partner—she has a languishing law degree from the days before she was a socialite—and her presence serves to both distract and galvanize the fledgling firm. She sets up a punching bag for herself in the office and brings the same whimsy and pugnacity to cross-examinations.
The AI industry, in Cupertino, can look like a shining vision of technological utopianism, from all of the gorgeous glass and wood architecture to the picturesque vistas seen from the windows of nearly every office. But just beneath the surface is a vast and growing number of people, actual people, who have been harmed in ways both traditional and innovative by an industry that doesn’t care about them. Price and Siffre’s office space serves as a nice metaphor for this divide. The building was the massive unfinished headquarters of a start-up that went bankrupt before construction could be completed. The lawyers have a spectacularly gorgeous lobby, but, behind the curtain, it’s all concrete and exposed wiring. They’re building up their resistance brick by brick, office by office, within the abandoned husk of Silicon Valley ambition. It’s a bracing and bubbly understanding of AI populism, one that insists on counting the human cost of the race for artificial humanity. Mark Zuckerberg’s famous slogan used to be, “move fast and break things.” The industry is moving fast, and Cupertino is a punchy comedy about all the broken people left in its wake.
In a philosophically minded dispatch from the AI-skeptical Pro-Human Assembly headlined by both Bernie Sanders and Steve Bannon in September, the writer Becca Rothfeld sketched out the stakes of this debate and this movement. “Staving off the A.I. apocalypse,” she wrote, “can only matter if there is something, anything, worth preserving.”
Cupertino never loses sight of this something. In the show, interpersonal relationships are the irreducibly human thing that keeps everything else going: As much as its subject is AI populism, it is also—like all the Kings’ series—a surprisingly moving and sometimes sexy workplace drama. The chemistry among its performers, their ambivalent but energetic solidarity, is the show’s real center. At any moment, for instance, Colter, Goldsberry, and Philipps form either a steamy love triangle or two overlapping buddy comedy duos. In one episode, after celebrating a win, Natalia romantically propositions Michael. Michael replies that that’s not a good idea. “No, it’s not,” she says, “but I want it anyway.” For these characters, there’s a thin line between ethical fire and unregulated passion. It’s a compelling way to think about activism; it also makes for outstanding TV drama.
It’s not all sexual tension. Many episodes feature our principals drinking together after hours in the empty office, talking with hope and hunger about the task before them. Early in the season, Olivia, a devout Christian, holds off on toasting one of their wins with a $3,000 bottle of champagne boosted from a client’s private jet. But Christy prods her on. “This is an event, us corrupting her,” she says. “How is it?” Olivia replies, “Bitter.” They’ve all been disillusioned by an industry they’d trusted. To fight this corruption, they have to become corrupt themselves. But the stakes are clear. They’re aiming to stave off the apocalypse, and they know what’s worth preserving. Cheers!
Anthropic Goes Public. AI Might Go Pop.
This week, Anthropic goes public. Many estimates put the AI company’s valuation at more than $1 trillion, which would make it one of the biggest initial public offerings in history.
jQuery(document).ready(function(){prx("https:\/\/play.prx.org\/e?ge=prx_149_19060832-2660-4555-ac53-a45d84352e35&uf=https%3A%2F%2Ffeeds.revealradio.org%2Frevealpodcast", "prx-1", "embed")});Subscribe to Mother Jones podcasts on Apple Podcasts or your favorite podcast app.
But Anthropic’s IPO also comes at a time when there are real concerns that the AI boom is a massive bubble—one that could take down the stock market and the economy with it. And we haven’t even mentioned the very real concerns about AI’s more existential risks to the planet and humanity that many critics warn are possible.
Science and tech journalist Jacob Ward has been reporting on the AI industry through a critical lens for years, even warning of AI’s red flags months before the launch of ChatGPT in his book, The Loop: How AI Is Creating a World Without Choices and How to Fight Back. But today, he says one of the things he didn’t fully grasp was the zealotry he now sees from AI’s top leaders.
“I didn’t understand just how near-religious they were gonna be about committing to this sort of utopia they seem to believe is on the far side of all of this,” Ward says. “And the ways in which they’re willing to kind of openly talk about, ‘We could destroy the labor economy. We might even kill people, but it’s all gonna be worth it.’”
On this week’s More To The Story, Ward talks with host Al Letson about how China is the true wild card in the AI race, what keeps him up at night about the direction of artificial intelligence, and whether Anthropic’s massive spending spree is truly sustainable.
Find More To The Story on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, iHeartRadio, Pandora, or your favorite podcast app, and don’t forget to subscribe.