Subscribe to Santa Cruz Local feed Santa Cruz Local
Sound local news
Updated: 36 min 10 sec ago

PVUSD to hire outside contractor for superintendent search

5 hours 49 min ago

alt

The search to replace Superintendent Heather Contreras is set to be helmed by a contractor. (Amaya Edwards — Santa Cruz Local/Report for America)

WATSONVILLE >> Pajaro Valley Unified School District is planning to hire a contractor to lead its search for a new superintendent. 

Omaha, Nebraska-based McPherson & Jacobson was selected for the search, but a start date hasn’t been established. In a presentation to the board at a Nov. 9 meeting, the company stated it would find a suitable candidate for the job within 90 days.

Superintendent Heather Contreras is set to leave her post after her contract expires in June to become superintendent of San Luis Coastal Unified School District.

At the board’s Wednesday meeting, some people said they worry the contract is a bad use of funds, while most trustees said that hiring the firm will help gather community input while ensuring the best candidate can be found.

“I’ve been hearing in the community a lot about wanting transparency and wanting community involvement, and that’s exactly what these search firms will help the board do,” said Trustee Olivia Flores. “One thing our community needs to understand is that when you’re hiring a position at this level, there is a large amount of confidentiality involved.”

(function() { window.mc4wp = window.mc4wp || { listeners: [], forms: { on: function(evt, cb) { window.mc4wp.listeners.push( { event : evt, callback: cb } ); } } } })(); Stay informed on Santa Cruz County’s biggest issues. Santa Cruz Local’s newsletter breaks down complex local topics and shows residents how to get involved. Email address:
mc4wp.forms.on('subscribed', function(form) { // gtag.js if(form.id == '6954') { gtag('event', 'subscribe', {'event_category': 'newsletter_prompt', 'event_label':'top_of_story'}); } }); Leave this field empty if you're human: alt

Trustee Olivia Flores, right, and Superintendent Heather Contreras at a meeting in 2025. Both are set to leave their positions in the district in 2027. (Amaya Edwards — Santa Cruz Local/CatchLight Local file)

The firm said the cost of the search is not to exceed $28,100 and is hiring two California representatives to lead the effort: Vallejo-based lead consultant Nicole Anderson and Danville-based consultant Daniel Moirao. The company said it has conducted over 1,100 successful superintendent searches across 45 states.

“The people that gave me feedback said, ‘why are we spending money on this when we could hire from the inside and look at internal candidates as a board?’, which is our duty,” Trustee Gabriel Medina said.

During the meeting, Medina sought to add an amendment to the contract that would require the firm to look at internal applicants before extending the search for outside personnel, but the effort did not receive support from the rest of the board.

To guide the search, the company said it will work with the board to establish priorities and goals for the incoming superintendent’s first year. Possible criteria for a candidate could also include a focus on fiscal recovery and enrollment decline and an ability for multilingual community engagement, the firm said.

Flores addressed Medina’s concerns that the contract would limit the incoming board’s ability to make decisions. 

“I just wanted to assure the board that this search form will work for you, so whatever you would like them to do, they will work with the board,” she said.

She also said that she’s heard community members call for public input on the decision, but that guaranteeing confidentiality for candidates might limit how much the public can weigh in on the decision.

“There are probably some candidates who would be willing to be interviewed by community members, and this particular search firm has agreed to explore how that might be possible in conducting it so that it protects the anonymity and the privacy of the candidate, but it might not be possible to get the best candidate.” Flynn said.

Flynn also highlighted that it was McPherson’s focus and experience in gathering community inputs that made it the top candidate for the role.

The board voted 4-0-1 to move forward with hiring McPherson & Jacobson.

While Medina ultimately abstained from the vote, he indicated that the discussion had given him some reassurance. “What I’m hearing right now is that we’re approving the firm, but the next board gets to give direction as to what’s going to happen.”

Questions or comments? Email info@santacruzlocal.org. Santa Cruz Local is supported by members, major donors, sponsors and grants for the general support of our newsroom. Our news judgments are made independently and not on the basis of donor support. Learn more about Santa Cruz Local and how we are funded.

Learn about membership Santa Cruz Local’s news is free. We believe that high-quality local news is crucial to democracy. We depend on locals like you to make a meaningful contribution so everyone can access our news. Learn about membership

The post PVUSD to hire outside contractor for superintendent search appeared first on Santa Cruz Local.

ICE visits to Santa Cruz are increasing, prompting protests

Fri, 11/20/2026 - 09:17

alt

Legal observers wait outside Santa Cruz Main Jail. (Nik Altenberg — Santa Cruz Local)

SANTA CRUZ >> U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents have visited Santa Cruz at least seven times in the past month, with visits almost daily over the past week, according to public records and legal observers.

November has seen more reported visits to Santa Cruz than any month over the past two years. Nearly all the visits have been to the Santa Cruz Main Jail, reflecting a statewide push to take people released from county jails into federal custody. 

Your Allied Rapid Response, an organization that verifies reports of ICE presence, most recently notified the public of vehicles at the jail late Wednesday night through Thursday morning.

Agents also visited Nov. 17, 15 and 12, according to YARR and multiple people on scene. On Nov. 15, YARR observers reported seeing agents take a man into custody at the Shell station on Water and Ocean streets.

On Nov. 12, protestors were pepper sprayed by agents in the parking lot of Sew Sew Maria, across the street from the jail.

The protesters were blocking an ICE vehicle from exiting through one of the parking lot’s driveways. Other driveways were left unblocked, multiple witnesses said. 

A video shared with Santa Cruz Local shows an agent standing next to an SUV in front of Sew Sew Maria, ordering the crowd to move. After a protester is heard telling the agent to “go around,” the agent says, “Last chance — you’re going to move now so we can leave, or you’re going to get sprayed.” Two seconds later, he extends his arm, and the filmer yells “Oh, fuck,” and runs away. 

“He did not give us a second to talk or second to think, he just maced us,” a protestor in attendance told Santa Cruz Local. She identified herself by her middle name, Charlotte, because she feared legal repercussions for blocking traffic.

The officer also sprayed legal observers, said YARR volunteer Dave Wilson. “Even though they were standing on the sidewalk, they were exercising or well within the boundaries of exercising their First Amendment right to assemble, and not blocking anyone, they still got hit,” Wilson said. 

ICE spokesperson Jason Sweeney wrote in a Nov. 19 email that agents came on Nov. 12 to detain Mexican immigrant J. Refugio Morales Delgado, who was scheduled for release. Morales Delgado was arrested for battery of emergency personnel and other charges, Sweeney wrote, and has a final order of removal.

(function() { window.mc4wp = window.mc4wp || { listeners: [], forms: { on: function(evt, cb) { window.mc4wp.listeners.push( { event : evt, callback: cb } ); } } } })(); Stay informed on Santa Cruz County’s biggest issues. Santa Cruz Local’s newsletter breaks down complex local topics and shows residents how to get involved. Email address:
mc4wp.forms.on('subscribed', function(form) { // gtag.js if(form.id == '6954') { gtag('event', 'subscribe', {'event_category': 'newsletter_prompt', 'event_label':'top_of_story'}); } }); Leave this field empty if you're human:

Sweeney confirmed that agents used pepper spray after “agitators surrounded the officers’ vehicles and obstructed their exit,” adding, “We remind the public that obstructing law enforcement is a federal crime.”

Sweeney did not address claims that ICE sprayed legal observers on the sidewalk. He also declined to confirm any arrests in Santa Cruz County in the past month. The agency “routinely conducts operations across Northern California, including in Santa Cruz,” he wrote in a Nov. 13 statement.

“The Trump Administration is utilizing all lawful options to carry out the largest deportation operation in history, just as President Trump promised,” the statement continued. “We will not apologize for defending the homeland.”

Other recent ICE activity

In addition to the visits this and last week, other recent immigration enforcement activity includes: 

  • Oct. 20 at the jail, according to records from the Santa Cruz County Sheriff’s Office. 
  • Oct. 24 at the jail, as previously reported by Santa Cruz Local.
  • Nov. 7 on Ocean Street, according to records from Santa Cruz Police. YARR reported that a man was taken into custody.

The Sheriff’s Office does not notify ICE of inmate release dates or participate in civil immigration enforcement, spokesperson Ashley Keene has said. In a Nov. 13 email, Keehn said she could not confirm whether federal agents have taken anyone into custody.  

Wilson and Charlotte both said they objected to ICE vehicles being allowed to park in front of the county building, across from the jail. The Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors approved in March rules that ban federal immigration enforcement officers from using county parking lots, parks and other spaces as staging areas for immigration enforcement. 

But agents “entering and parking vehicles in a parking lot does not constitute a violation” of local rules, county spokesperson Jason Hoppin wrote in a Nov. 13 email. The county “cannot prevent, interfere with, or impede lawful federal immigration enforcement activities,” he wrote.

Immigration enforcement elsewhere in Santa Cruz County may have slowed, records from local law enforcement suggest. Over the past two years, ICE has routinely notified law enforcement of visits to Watsonville and Freedom. But ICE has not given notification of a visit to South County since an Aug. 5 visit to Watsonville, according to public records. Santa Cruz Local continues to track ICE notifications to local law enforcement.

Immigration enforcement agents are not legally required to notify local law enforcement of their activity, and have visited the county without notification.

This summer, ICE stepped up enforcement and increasingly targeted people without a criminal record across Northern California, according to federal records compiled by the Deportation Data Project. In Santa Cruz County, most documented arrests have been of people with criminal charges or convictions, according to an analysis by Santa Cruz Local.

Reporting across the state has documented numerous recent clashes between protesters and federal agents outside county jails. In October, a protest of ICE presence at the Monterey County Jail resulted in a jail lockdown. On Nov. 13, two public defender attorneys were reportedly pepper sprayed by ICE alongside protestors outside the Santa Clara County Main Jail Complex. On Nov. 15, a pregnant protester outside Stanislaus County Jail in Merced was filmed being pepper sprayed and thrown to the ground by ICE agents. 

What to do if you see ICE

YARR has asked people to report possible sightings of immigration enforcement by calling  831-239-4289. Trained volunteers confirm the presence of ICE, and post confirmed sightings of ICE on Facebook and Instagram. Volunteers may connect with people who were detained and connect them with legal representation or other support. YARR also has a text service for alerts of confirmed immigration enforcement.

The organization has cautioned people not to post or repost unverified reports of immigration enforcement. People often misidentify local police or other law enforcement officers, Wilson said. Most notably, a raid on a farm near Pajaro carried out by multiple local and state law enforcement agencies was mistaken for an immigration raid on July 16. 

“Don’t post that stuff on social media,” he said. “Spread power, not fear.” 

Those approached by immigration enforcement:

  • Have the right to remain silent.
  • Have the right to see a lawyer before signing documents, and interpretation or translation into their native language. 
  • Do not have to open their door for immigration officials or law enforcement unless presented with a judicial warrant. Immigration agents may present an administrative warrant with an immigration official’s signature, but a judicial warrant must be signed by a judge.

See Santa Cruz Local’s guide for immigration resources for more information about rights and resources. Sus Derechos, a project of the Santa Cruz Office of Education and local nonprofits, has more immigration information and resources.

Questions or comments? Email info@santacruzlocal.org. Santa Cruz Local is supported by members, major donors, sponsors and grants for the general support of our newsroom. Our news judgments are made independently and not on the basis of donor support. Learn more about Santa Cruz Local and how we are funded.

Learn about membership Santa Cruz Local’s news is free. We believe that high-quality local news is crucial to democracy. We depend on locals like you to make a meaningful contribution so everyone can access our news. Learn about membership

The post ICE visits to Santa Cruz are increasing, prompting protests appeared first on Santa Cruz Local.

After 9 months, many HOPE Village guests return to homelessness on the Pajaro River

Wed, 11/18/2026 - 16:11

alt

Liz Zavala tends to her pets at her home on the Pajaro River levee on Nov. 15. (Nik Altenberg — Santa Cruz Local)

Key takeaways
  • HOPE Village is a temporary shelter program in Watsonville meant to provide wrap-around services and get people into permanent housing quickly. The shelter opened in February after a two year delay.
  • It is a 34-unit low-barrier navigation center — a temporary shelter designed to move homeless individuals into permanent housing quickly. It serves people living along the Pajaro River, which divides Santa Cruz and Monterey counties.
  • An investigation by Santa Cruz Local found that HOPE Village is significantly underperforming its stated goals for moving people into permanent housing.

WATSONVILLE >> On Sunday morning on the Pajaro River levee, there was birdsong and woodsmoke in the air. It was chilly, but Liz Zavala wore crocs, shorts and a sweater, as she refilled her cats’ food bowls and assessed if the tarps above her tent would hold in the coming rainstorms.

Zavala and her boyfriend have lived on the levee for most of the past six years, but this time was different. They had just moved back outside after staying for more than eight months at HOPE Village, a temporary shelter program in Watsonville meant to provide wrap-around services and get people into permanent housing quickly.

But after six months without securing housing, and multiple monthlong extensions still did not yield results, they were among nine people recently asked to leave by staff of nonprofit Community Action Board of Santa Cruz County, which operates the shelter.

On Thursday, they packed up and moved their belongings the four blocks back to the levee to rebuild a home among the trees. The next day it rained, hard.

“It was a nice vacation for a few months, but now we’re back out here,” Zavala said. “They said they’re going to still help us and provide services. So we’ll see if that happens but I don’t think if they couldn’t help us when we’re 5 feet away from them I don’t know how they can help us when we’re back out here.”

Zavala said on Friday her friend Nikki Mori was sitting in her tent in the rain, without a tarp, seemingly stunned to find herself back on the levee.

“It didn’t seem like they had any concern or anything by just kicking us out on the street,” Mori said Sunday. Mori, who’s lived on the levee for at least 10 years, said the housing navigation provided at HOPE Village was “nothing really, because they didn’t, they didn’t even work with me on that, really at all.”

An investigation by Santa Cruz Local found that HOPE Village is significantly underperforming its stated goals for moving people into permanent housing. In addition to the challenges inherent to the area, like limited availability of affordable housing and rental subsidies, interviews with former shelter residents and staff revealed other barriers to success, like staff turnover, a program design that doesn’t fit the needs of guests, a lack of connection between participants and case managers, and a steep learning curve for the nonprofit.

“This service delivery model is most successful when guests have some pathway to permanent housing,” wrote MariaElena De La Garza, executive director of Community Action Board, in an email this week. “Improved outcomes will rely on a community response to better support neighbors who have been disconnected and disenfranchised for so long.”

(function() { window.mc4wp = window.mc4wp || { listeners: [], forms: { on: function(evt, cb) { window.mc4wp.listeners.push( { event : evt, callback: cb } ); } } } })(); Stay informed on Santa Cruz County’s biggest issues. Santa Cruz Local’s newsletter breaks down complex local topics and shows residents how to get involved. Email address:
mc4wp.forms.on('subscribed', function(form) { // gtag.js if(form.id == '6954') { gtag('event', 'subscribe', {'event_category': 'newsletter_prompt', 'event_label':'top_of_story'}); } }); Leave this field empty if you're human: alt

Nikki Mori left HOPE Village on Thursday, Nov. 12 after more than six months at the temporary shelter did not result in a permanent housing placement. (Amaya Edwards — Santa Cruz Local/Report for America)

Returning to homelessness

HOPE Village is a 34-unit low-barrier navigation center — a temporary shelter designed to move homeless individuals into permanent housing quickly. In this case, the program serves people living along the Pajaro River, which divides Santa Cruz and Monterey counties. 

The shelter operates as a partnership between the two counties and is mostly funded by an $8 million state grant that Monterey County staff obtained in 2023. After facing opposition from neighbors, the shelter opened in February two years behind schedule.

Since then, four of the at least 50 people who have stayed at HOPE Village have moved into permanent housing, according to the County of Santa Cruz’s homeless information system. Two people entered substance use treatment, two moved in temporarily with family and one person died. 

At least 10 returned to homelessness, but the total is likely higher because last week’s exits had not yet been recorded. Community Action Board did not provide updated numbers this week, saying the system is updated periodically. They did not specify when the last update occurred.

Monterey County’s grant application set a goal of having 60% of shelter guests exit into permanent housing, which was likely ambitious. Statewide, 27% of participants leaving similar shelters went to permanent housing while more than half returned to homelessness, according to state Encampment Resolution Fund data. 

Still, at HOPE Village the rate is significantly lower. About 12% of exits were to permanent housing, according to county data and information provided by Community Action Board.

alt

HOPE Village is on First Street in Watsonville. (Nik Altenberg — Santa Cruz Local)

So far, seven residents have been “housed,” according to De La Garza, but the count included people who entered treatment or moved in temporarily with family. She said the two key challenges they face are shelter guests’ lack of income and “an extreme lack of truly affordable housing options in our region.”

However, the shelter’s housing navigator — a role that is tasked with helping people plan, make a budget and apply for housing — resigned in June and has not been replaced. 

That work now falls to the two case managers. De La Garza said the change was supported by funding partners and that case managers “help in the search for housing and other placement options.” Staff at both counties also assist with connecting residents to permanent housing, she said.

The caseloads at HOPE Village are within the limits described by Santa Cruz County’s Housing for Health Partnership, which says 15-20 people per case manager is acceptable. 

“There are so many steps out of homelessness for people who have lived unsheltered for 5, 10, 15 years,” she wrote. “HOPE Village is a good early step that meets guests where they are.”

De La Garza also said that for the residents who left last week, “the timing was unfortunate due to the weather.” Residents are told about the six-month limit when they arrive, she wrote, and have several check-ins with case managers before they are asked to leave.

alt

Liz Zavala discusses her impending departure from HOPE Village in an interview Nov. 4. (Nik Altenberg — Santa Cruz Local)

For her part, Zavala said she felt the housing navigator at HOPE Village was helpful, while her case manager was not. She said she saw her casemanager on average once a month, while Santa Cruz County’s guidelines recommend once a week.

A steep learning curve

Community Action Board has deep ties and experience serving homeless people in the Pajaro Valley, but HOPE Village is its first foray into operating a 24-hour shelter. 

“It can take years for people to really build up a new program and have it mature and working as well as possible,” Robert Ratner, director of the County of Santa Cruz’s Housing for Health Division, said in a phone call on Monday. “We’re still kind of early on in the evolution of the program.”

Mike Kittredge, HOPE Village’s former director who left in September, said in an Aug. 19 interview that the organization’s inexperience was a challenge. He also said success depends on residents.

“You’re going to get out of this what you put into it. So if you don’t put much in, you know, we can’t house you,” Kittredge said. “We’re not here to do ‘for’ people. We’re here to do ‘with’ people.”

(Kittredge did not respond to a follow up request for comment this month.)

alt

Clothes hang to dry on the levee on Nov. 15 after heavy rains came through the area over the weekend. (Nik Altenberg — Santa Cruz Local)

Ratner said effective case managers know how to navigate the systems and help push clients through bureaucratic “sludge.” But the technical skills are just part of the recipe: “it starts with that connection and relationship-building and trust, and people feeling like you really care about them.” 

He also said the challenges described by residents at HOPE Village are not unique, and there is room to improve homeless services and navigation centers across the board.

‘Instead of helping me, they put me down’

Back on the levee Sunday, a cat’s tail flicked from the opening of Zavala’s tent on a flat spot about 10 feet above the river. She and her boyfriend began rebuilding their spot weeks earlier, knowing the extensions would run out.

Marco Martinez, whose tent sits about 20 yards downstream, said he felt he had just begun to make progress with Watsonville Works, another Community Action Board program that partners closely with shelter guests, when he got notice his six months were up. He was one of a handful of guests left on Thursday.

“I just kind of lost track again, I had to be worried about where I’m gonna be staying out here,” Martinez said. “I appreciate they gave me somewhere to stay for six months, I really do. But help-wise, like for me to succeed in life, they didn’t help me at all.”

Martinez had several complaints about his stay: “no housing manager or navigators like that to help us. It was, it was bad. Like I don’t know. It was just real bad. Instead of helping me, they put me down.” He added that he felt judged by staff.

alt

Marco Martinez sits in his tent on the levee on Nov. 15. (Nik Altenberg — Santa Cruz Local)

“I had an attitude or whatever, but it’s just the way they would approach me wasn’t cool. Like I wouldn’t feel comfortable. Like it wasn’t somebody I could talk to,” he said.

De La Garza wrote that staff “are committed to providing dignity and humanity.”

Like several people Santa Cruz Local spoke with, the shelter’s program structure didn’t fit Martinez’s needs or lifestyle. He said it was “real strict.” For example, people said they had to ask a staff member if they wanted food from the kitchen after meal times were over. Martinez said he would prefer to have access to a fridge on his own schedule.

Zavala explained it simply: “There’s like no time on the levee.” 

“It’s just kind of going by the sun,” she said, adding that shelter staff seemed to expect people who had spent years in the “no man’s land” of the river to adjust to strict rules and routines overnight. “That’s what I think is the part where they don’t understand.”

Ratner, the county homelessness director, said “anytime you change someone’s routine and habits it’s a big ask, and sometimes it’s underappreciated.”

‘One day at a time’

HOPE Village is funded through June 30. De La Garza wrote that they are “currently meeting with partners to discuss next steps and any potential changes.”

For those back on the levee, next steps are still being figured out. 

“I don’t give up hope. God still gives me the opportunity to live another day,” Martinez said. “So it’s just getting back on track. One day at a time.”

He gestured to Mori and Zavala. “This is my home right here. These are my people. This is my family. So this is what I’m with right now.”

alt

Nikki Mori poses for a photo Nov. 15. (Nik Altenberg — Santa Cruz Local)

Reporters Amaya Edwards and Alonso Daboub contributed to this story.

Questions or comments? Email info@santacruzlocal.org. Santa Cruz Local is supported by members, major donors, sponsors and grants for the general support of our newsroom. Our news judgments are made independently and not on the basis of donor support. Learn more about Santa Cruz Local and how we are funded.

Learn about membership Santa Cruz Local’s news is free. We believe that high-quality local news is crucial to democracy. We depend on locals like you to make a meaningful contribution so everyone can access our news. Learn about membership

The post After 9 months, many HOPE Village guests return to homelessness on the Pajaro River appeared first on Santa Cruz Local.

Scotts Valley Police Chief sued for sexual harassment

Tue, 11/17/2026 - 10:51

alt

Scotts Valley City Hall on Nov. 10. (Amaya Edwards — Santa Cruz Local/Report for America)

SCOTTS VALLEY >> A Scotts Valley Police Department employee is alleging Police Chief Jayson Rutherford sexually harassed, discriminated and retaliated against her in a lawsuit filed Sept. 29 in Santa Cruz County Superior Court. 

The lawsuit details multiple incidents between 2024 and early 2026, including allegations of sexual harassment, groping and a power imbalance that, according to lawyers, led to retaliation. Referred to in the lawsuit as Jane Doe, she worked as an emergency dispatcher and Rutherford was her supervisor for approximately two years, according to the lawsuit. 

Rutherford did not respond to repeated requests for comment. The defendants must respond to the lawsuit in court within 30 days of Nov. 5, according to Doe’s lawyer, Megan Mackie. According to the online court portal and Doe’s lawyer, Rutherford hasn’t yet provided a response.

Rutherford has been police chief since March, after serving as interim chief since November 2025. The Scotts Valley Police Department’s public information officer, Captain Scott Garner, did not respond to requests for comment. 

Rutherford is being sued for sexual harassment, sex discrimination, retaliation, failure to prevent discrimination, harassment and retaliation, failure to provide reasonable accommodation and failure to engage in a timely, good-faith interactive process. The lawsuit also names the City of Scotts Valley, Scotts Valley Police and Rutherford as defendants. 

The lawsuit alleges the city failed to thoroughly investigate Doe’s claims.

(function() { window.mc4wp = window.mc4wp || { listeners: [], forms: { on: function(evt, cb) { window.mc4wp.listeners.push( { event : evt, callback: cb } ); } } } })(); Stay informed on Santa Cruz County’s biggest issues. Santa Cruz Local’s newsletter breaks down complex local topics and shows residents how to get involved. Email address:
mc4wp.forms.on('subscribed', function(form) { // gtag.js if(form.id == '6954') { gtag('event', 'subscribe', {'event_category': 'newsletter_prompt', 'event_label':'top_of_story'}); } }); Leave this field empty if you're human:

In a Nov. 11 email, Scotts Valley Interim City Manager Stephanie Hill stated that the city could not comment on the case, but said Rutherford continues to serve as chief. She added that the city “takes allegations of this nature seriously.”

Doe, who has worked as a dispatcher for Scotts Valley since 2017, shared details of her experiences in an interview with Santa Cruz Local last week.  

“I’ve dedicated almost a decade of my life to this department, and it’s been really hard to reconcile that and everything that transpired,” she said. “It’s been a very tough journey and far from the end of it.”

Doe said that she was hesitant to come forward because of how small of a town Scotts Valley is.

“I never really imagined myself in this type of position, but I think that staying silent would have been a disservice to not only me but anyone in a similar situation to me,” she said.

alt

Scotts Valley Police Department on 10. (Amaya Edwards — Santa Cruz Local/Report for America)

Lawsuit allegations against Rutherford 

The lawsuit describes a flirtatious dynamic between Jane Doe and Rutherford that began in 2024 when he was her supervisor, and ended around December of last year.  

While most of the conversations were consensual, according to the lawsuit, Rutherford’s position and authority created an unequal power dynamic between them. Things took a turn early this year after Rutherford entered a new relationship and stopped responding to Doe’s messages. After that, Doe alleges, Rutherford began avoiding her at work, treating her dismissively and excluding her from work conversations.

A large portion of the complaint discusses a job promotion that Doe ultimately did not get. Doe alleges she was overlooked for an emergency dispatch promotion in March, after another employee received the position despite having less work experience. Doe claims that she didn’t receive the job due to her sex, and her previous relationship with Rutherford. 

According to the complaint, Rutherford was the one who made the final decision in the hiring process for the dispatch promotion. Doe is currently on disability leave and is looking for another job. 

Additionally, the complaint describes two different physical encounters in 2025 between Rutherford and Doe. The first incident in the lawsuit occurred in March at a department appreciation dinner in Santa Cruz, when Rutherford allegedly brushed his arm against Doe’s breasts, pulled open the waist of her skirt and looked down at her underwear. 

He then refused to walk her to her car because of how others at the dinner might perceive it, the complaint alleges. 

The following month in April, Rutherford allegedly grabbed Doe’s buttocks multiple times at the gym they both attended. According to the lawsuit, Doe reported the encounter to a department officer that day, and told her supervisor, Chloe Graham, that she and Rutherford had been communicating for several months. Doe asked Graham not to repeat the information, and Graham agreed to keep it private. 

Graham shared with Santa Cruz Local that she could not comment on the lawsuit or answer any questions, per the city attorney’s advice.  

“I really hope that other women can take from this that you don’t have to tolerate this sort of treatment in the workplace, and that regardless of how it’s always been you can speak up and you should speak up because it will only empower others to do the same,” Doe said.

The lawsuit also discusses the city’s alleged refusal to accommodate Doe’s medical leave, which she sought due to work-related stress, depression and anxiety in April of this year. Doe remained on leave when the city launched an investigation into the harassment allegations against Rutherford.  

According to the lawsuit, the city’s external investigator, who was hired to look into the sexual harassment allegations against Rutherford, denied Doe’s request to provide written responses to the ongoing investigation instead of participating in a live video interview in September. She was on medical leave at the time. 

As a result, the city moved forward with its investigation of Doe’s complaints against Rutherford without hearing her testimony and only relied on the available evidence, according to the lawsuit. The current status of the city’s internal investigation is unknown. 

Questions or comments? Email info@santacruzlocal.org. Santa Cruz Local is supported by members, major donors, sponsors and grants for the general support of our newsroom. Our news judgments are made independently and not on the basis of donor support. Learn more about Santa Cruz Local and how we are funded.

Learn about membership Santa Cruz Local’s news is free. We believe that high-quality local news is crucial to democracy. We depend on locals like you to make a meaningful contribution so everyone can access our news. Learn about membership

The post Scotts Valley Police Chief sued for sexual harassment appeared first on Santa Cruz Local.

A new Santa Cruz Warriors arena could get city funding

Mon, 11/16/2026 - 17:48
alt

The Santa Cruz Warriors play at the Kaiser Permanente Arena on Spruce Street. (Stephen Baxter — Santa Cruz Local file)

Santa Cruz City Council 

SANTA CRUZ >>  A new stadium for the Santa Cruz Warriors could receive public money, according to a preliminary agreement to be considered by the Santa Cruz City Council tomorrow.

For 15 years, the city has leased the existing area on Laurel Street to the Warriors. Santa Cruz Seaside Company owns the land beneath the arena and leases it to the city. 

The Warriors and city leaders have long discussed the development of a new area on the site of the existing building or nearby. The Downtown Plan expansion, a roadmap for development south of Laurel Street approved in 2025, includes such an arena. An economic analysis commissioned by the city stated that the arena could bring new jobs and visitors Downtown, and help increase the city’s property and sales tax income.

Tomorrow, the City Council is set to consider a new memorandum of understanding between the city and the Warriors that calls for a joint effort to determine a location for the new arena and propose a way to fund it. 

The agreement states that: 

  • The arena would be funded with private investment and public money. A possible source of public funding is a newly-implemented tax district Downtown that sets aside a percentage of future increases to property tax revenues, staff wrote in a report on the agreement. That tax district does not establish a new tax or increase existing taxes. 
  • The plan for the arena project may include other types of development, including housing, shops, parking and public space. 
  • The Warriors and the city would determine who will own and operate the arena. 

If the City Council accepts the agreement, city staff and the Warriors would begin looking for a location and making a funding plan. 

Questions or comments? Email info@santacruzlocal.org. Santa Cruz Local is funded by members, major donors, sponsors and grants for the general support of our newsroom. Our news judgments are made independently and not on the basis of donor support. Learn more about Santa Cruz Local and how it is funded.

The post A new Santa Cruz Warriors arena could get city funding appeared first on Santa Cruz Local.

Mid-county rail trail in limbo as deadline grows closer

Mon, 11/16/2026 - 17:00

alt

Segment 7 of the rail trail preserves the tracks and runs from Depot Park to Westside Santa Cruz. The final part of the segment finished construction in 2025. (Nik Altenberg — Santa Cruz Local file)

SANTA CRUZ >> A year ago, an effort to build a stretch of the Coastal Rail Trail from Seabright to Aptos was at a crisis point. Millions of dollars over budget, staff suggested saving money by building the trail on the tracks, instead of beside it. The idea was fiercely opposed by advocates of passenger rail, who wanted the tracks to stay in place. The deadlock threatened to severely delay the project and risk state grant money. 

Last December, Santa Cruz Mayor Fred Keeley and Santa Cruz County Supervisor Manu Koenig united to advance a “peace plan” for a trail atop the tracks through mid-county. But it sidestepped the politically untenable process of railbanking, a federal process normally used to build a trail on an unused rail line.

Nearly a year later, the peace plan is in limbo. Federal regulators have indefinitely postponed a decision on a request to reclassify the tracks as an inactive rail line — the first step towards carrying out the compromise. Local rail advocates are asking regulators to deny the reclassification on the grounds that it could lead to a permanent end to rail service along the corridor. 

The federal case has become the latest battleground for a long-running conflict over the future of the rail corridor, and the latest obstacle in a years-long effort to start building the mid-county portion of the trail, between Seabright and Aptos. County staff have said the delay could again endanger the state grant money, putting the entire project at risk.

(function() { window.mc4wp = window.mc4wp || { listeners: [], forms: { on: function(evt, cb) { window.mc4wp.listeners.push( { event : evt, callback: cb } ); } } } })(); Stay informed on Santa Cruz County’s biggest issues. Santa Cruz Local’s newsletter breaks down complex local topics and shows residents how to get involved. Email address:
mc4wp.forms.on('subscribed', function(form) { // gtag.js if(form.id == '6954') { gtag('event', 'subscribe', {'event_category': 'newsletter_prompt', 'event_label':'top_of_story'}); } }); Leave this field empty if you're human: ‘Peace plan’

Initial designs in 2022 for segments of the rail trail between Santa Cruz and Aptos included two possibilities: an “interim” trail in place of existing tracks — to be replaced if plans for passenger rail service came to fruition in the future — and an “ultimate” trail beside the tracks that would allow both a train and a trail.

In 2023, the Santa Cruz City Council, in charge of Segments 8 and 9 from the Westside to Live Oak, voted to pursue the ultimate trail. In 2024, the Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors, in charge of Segments 10 and 11 from Live Oak to Aptos, voted the same. The estimated cost for both projects was $43 million over budget, so supervisors ordered a cost-saving redesign.

But by 2025, costs for the project had ballooned further, and the commission risked losing $68 million in state grants if the project was delayed again. Commissioners voted to fill a $72 million shortfall by carrying out the peace plan and pursuing the less-costly interim trail.

Crucially, the so-called “peace plan” put forward by Keeley and Koenig did not include railbanking, a federal process that would allow removal of the train tracks. Rail advocates have strongly opposed railbanking on the grounds that it would harm efforts to build passenger rail on the line.

The polarizing debate has really not moved forward an actual, real, truthful conversation.
—Mikey Cohen, board president of Bike Santa Cruz County

In early 2026, commission staff said they could build the interim trail without railbanking. This week, Executive Director Sarah Christensen said that the plan is to reclassify the rail line as discontinued, and build the trail on the railway without railbanking.

Discontinuance

Most of the rail has not seen traffic in years, but it is still federally classified as part of an active freight line. The first step in allowing the interim trail requires changing that.

On June 15, the freight carrier, St. Paul & Pacific Railroad Company, filed with the Surface Transportation Board to issue a discontinuance for most of the Santa Cruz Branch Rail Line. Once the line is discontinued, an entity affiliated with the transportation commission could take over from St. Paul & Pacific as the rail carrier, Christensen said.

(Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific Railroad, LLC, filed to replace St. Paul & Pacific as the carrier for a 2.5-mile portion of the line near Watsonville that is actively used for freight.)

Multiple people wrote to the Surface Transportation Board opposing the discontinuance, including former heads of the Regional Transportation Commission Linda Wilshusen and George Dondero.

alt

Roaring Camp Railroads, based in Felton, operates a rail line that connects to the Santa Cruz Branch Rail Line in Santa Cruz. (Nik Altenberg — Santa Cruz Local file)

Local pro-rail groups Equity Transit and Friends of the Rail and Trail, or FORT, also opposed the filing. The discontinuance “is an effort to cast aside the will of county residents” for a trail alongside rail, FORT wrote in a Nov. 13 statement to Santa Cruz Local. The group has urged the commission to design a trail that keeps the tracks in place, or to solve the budget shortfall by building a shorter or narrower trail next to the tracks.

Several opponents of the move, along with the railway’s lawyers, wrote that discontinuance alone cannot allow the interim trail as originally designed, with the tracks removed. But Christensen, the commission director, maintains that it can. But, she said, it’s possible that the new trail will be able to keep the tracks in place.

The legal process that would normally be used to create an interim trail is railbanking, a federal process for allowing a trail on an unused rail line while preserving rail easements for future use. The procedure allows the rail carrier to stop service, and a separate entity to steward the corridor as a trail. Railbanked lines can be later reactivated as railroads.

But locally, railbanking has become a political minefield. It is heavily opposed by Roaring Camp Railroads, which operates a rail line between Felton and Santa Cruz and intends to stay connected to the state rail network. Lawyers for Roaring Camp wrote to the Surface Transportation Board that while they do not oppose the requested discontinuance, they fear it is part of a larger plan to abandon the line.

Fred Forstall, a former Surface and Transportation Board analyst, wrote that the filing is “wholly inappropriate” because the rail line has not been properly maintained, and the move would cut off the Felton line. “In the cold, hard light of day the situation more closely resembles an unauthorized abandonment,” he wrote to the Surface Transportation Board on June 25.

Christensen said that the commission is confident that building the interim trail on the discontinued line is legal. The commission is not pursuing railbanking, she added.

The Surface and Transportation Board declined to comment on the ongoing case.

alt

The rail corridor runs by Schwan Lagoon in Live Oak. It is planned as Segment 9. (Nik Altenberg — Santa Cruz Local file)

For cyclist advocate Mikey Cohen, board president of nonprofit Bike Santa Cruz County, the fight over the federal filing reflects deep local divisions over the future of the rail corridor. 

This week, Bike Santa Cruz County released a 23-page report on the mid-county rail trail based on public documents and interviews with staff. It concludes that the interim trail is the only way to complete the project as planning for passenger rail continues. Cohen said he hopes that people from all sides of the debate can find common ground.

Ceasing all work towards passenger rail is “not a working solution, because it seems like you have a majority of people that do support moving forward with a train,” he said. At the same time, “train advocates are kind of making it sound like [passenger rail] is just around the corner,” and “that if you remove the tracks, that the train will never come.”

He added, “the polarizing debate has really not moved forward an actual, real, truthful conversation on what’s actually going on, which is why we wrote this report.”

Path forward

Engineers are still designing the interim trail, including the version that would keep the tracks in place. But it’s unlikely that such a “hybrid” trail would be feasible, said county planner Rob Tidmore — it would be more expensive and would make meeting safety requirements more difficult. 

The designs should be done in a year, and the project could be ready for construction in 2028, he said. 

That would miss a deadline set by the California Transportation Commission, which awarded the grant money, to be ready for construction by June. Christensen said that the regional transportation commission is planning to ask the state commission for an extension. 

Christensen and Tidmore said that a trail on top of the tracks does not mean an end to the passenger rail process, and that rail construction is at least 20 years away. “The interim trail has funding now,” Tidmore said. “It has funding that’s very much at risk if we don’t build the trail now.”

In 2024, the transportation commission estimated that rail construction could start by 2032. But the estimated timelines have changed following the release of the conceptual report for rail service released in 2025, Tidmore said. The report estimated a $4.3 billion price tag to build the rail corridor. 

“It’s just a very, very long-term project, much more so than if it were like a $500 million project,” he said.

Meanwhile, the process of raising money for the environmental review of passenger rail has been slow-going, Christensen said. This year, the commission has been unsuccessful in at least five grant applications for the project, she said.

Beyond the question of railbanking, and the plans for passenger rail, the most immediate challenge for the rail trail is the uncertain timeline of a ruling from the Surface Transportation Board. There is no deadline for the board to make a decision. 

#wpforms-34606 { --wpforms-field-size-input-height: 43px; --wpforms-field-size-input-spacing: 15px; --wpforms-field-size-font-size: 16px; --wpforms-field-size-line-height: 19px; --wpforms-field-size-padding-h: 14px; --wpforms-field-size-checkbox-size: 16px; --wpforms-field-size-sublabel-spacing: 5px; --wpforms-field-size-icon-size: 1; --wpforms-label-size-font-size: 16px; --wpforms-label-size-line-height: 19px; --wpforms-label-size-sublabel-font-size: 14px; --wpforms-label-size-sublabel-line-height: 17px; --wpforms-button-size-font-size: 17px; --wpforms-button-size-height: 41px; --wpforms-button-size-padding-h: 15px; --wpforms-button-size-margin-top: 10px; --wpforms-container-shadow-size-box-shadow: none; } Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.How do you think the regional transportation commission should move forward with plans for the mid-county portion of the trail? EmailNameFirstLast regional of for Can we publish your response? *
  • Yes, with my full name
  • Yes, without my name
  • No
( function() { const style = document.createElement( 'style' ); style.appendChild( document.createTextNode( '#wpforms-34606-field_5-container { position: absolute !important; overflow: hidden !important; display: inline !important; height: 1px !important; width: 1px !important; z-index: -1000 !important; padding: 0 !important; } #wpforms-34606-field_5-container input { visibility: hidden; } #wpforms-conversational-form-page #wpforms-34606-field_5-container label { counter-increment: none; }' ) ); document.head.appendChild( style ); document.currentScript?.remove(); } )(); SubmitLoading

Questions or comments? Email info@santacruzlocal.org. Santa Cruz Local is supported by members, major donors, sponsors and grants for the general support of our newsroom. Our news judgments are made independently and not on the basis of donor support. Learn more about Santa Cruz Local and how we are funded.

Learn about membership Santa Cruz Local’s news is free. We believe that high-quality local news is crucial to democracy. We depend on locals like you to make a meaningful contribution so everyone can access our news. Learn about membership

The post Mid-county rail trail in limbo as deadline grows closer appeared first on Santa Cruz Local.

Toxic algal blooms blamed for beached whales, sick sea lions from Santa Cruz to Monterey Bay

Sat, 11/14/2026 - 05:00

alt

Marine Mammal Center team rescues a California sea lion on Avila Beach. (Giancarlo Rulli — Marine Mammal Center)

Story at a glance
  • Monterey Bay was the epicenter of an outbreak that hit sea mammals hard, but scientists say it’s hard to know what caused it to be so severe.
  • The Marine Mammal Center has documented 317 cases of domoic acid poisoning this year, the largest outbreak in its 51-year history.
  • The biotoxin comes from blooms of algae and can poison marine animals like sea lions, whales, and birds.
  • Responders said blooms that typically follow a fairly regular seasonal pattern are beginning to flare up at unexpected times of the year and last longer than usual.
  • Experts say that the toxin is a risk mostly for wildlife and recreational shellfish harvesters, but commercial seafood remains safe.

SANTA CRUZ >> The daily cacophony along the Santa Cruz coast reveals the waters are home to cacophony of natural voices — sea lions bark at Steamer Lane, coastal birds pierce the air with screeches and onlookers gasp and point as whales spout in distant seas.

But another, lesser-known marine resident has quietly been wreaking havoc in recent months — an algae that produces a deadly chemical called domoic acid, a biotoxin that can make marine animals seize and die. This year’s outbreak has been tied to the deaths of at least two humpback whales and a record-setting year for sea lion strandings.

Responders at the Sausalito-based nonprofit Marine Mammal Center said this year is already the worst in 51 years with more than triple the usual number of reported sea lions in need of help. For three months this summer the center’s teams were responding to more than a dozen reports of sick sea lions per day across the 600 miles between Mendocino and San Luis Obispo. Santa Cruz and Monterey counties emerged as the epicenter of this year’s outbreak, which began in July and reached its peak in late August.

The monthslong outbreak appears to now be receding, but responders say what used to be a seasonal problem lasting a few weeks is now being observed throughout the year. They say even chronic low levels of exposure can worsen problems like malnutrition and ship collisions, as disoriented animals struggle to feed and avoid vessels.

(function() { window.mc4wp = window.mc4wp || { listeners: [], forms: { on: function(evt, cb) { window.mc4wp.listeners.push( { event : evt, callback: cb } ); } } } })(); Stay informed on Santa Cruz County’s biggest issues. Santa Cruz Local’s newsletter breaks down complex local topics and shows residents how to get involved. Email address:
mc4wp.forms.on('subscribed', function(form) { // gtag.js if(form.id == '6954') { gtag('event', 'subscribe', {'event_category': 'newsletter_prompt', 'event_label':'top_of_story'}); } }); Leave this field empty if you're human: An unseasonally long bloom

Responders at the Sausalito center are tracking blooms like these, which are beginning to occur outside of regular, seasonal spikes and stick around longer. Scientists also warn the bloom could move north, threatening the state of marine life up the coastline.

“We’re seeing flare ups year round. We’re seeing flare ups in the winter and the spring. That makes things that much more difficult to plan for,” said Giancarlo Rulli, the Marine Mammal Center’s associate director of public relations. “This disease is insidious. It’s unpredictable.” 

In a typical year, his team rescues 75 to 90 animals for domoic acid poisoning, which they treat with fluids, clean fish, and anti-seizure medication to help flush out the toxin. This year, they documented 317.

“It was at a point where we just were not able each day to get to every single one,” Rulli said. “We’d have to pick it back up the next morning.” He added that while the acid can be flushed from an animal’s system, permanent brain and heart damage can’t be treated.

alt

Transporting a California sea lion with domoic acid poisoning in San Luis Obispo County. (Giancarlo Rulli — Marine Mammal Center)

Locally, UC Santa Cruz’s Marine Mammal Stranding Network saw a similar surge in affected animals. Between June and September, it responded to 75 strandings, nearly as many as it handled in all of 2025. 

Robin Dunkin, faculty director of the stranding network, said that most years the blooms are short lived, with a seasonal spike that drops within weeks. “This year, it’s been prolonged. It just kept going all summer,” she said.

In addition to sea lion strandings, two humpback whales found beached earlier this summer were confirmed to have domoic acid in their tissues. “One of them had very high levels that is very much a smoking gun for domoic acid toxicity,” Dunkin said.

The Marine Mammal Center and stranding network also responded to the recent death of a fin whale at Cowells. The whale was severely emaciated and exhibited signs of long-term illness, but Rulli said it’s too early to determine a cause of death and that subsequent testing is needed to see if domoic acid played a role.

Effects on marine life and people

Domoic acid is produced by microscopic algae called Pseudo-nitzschia. From there, it moves up the food chain: local shellfish, sardines and anchovies take up the toxin when they ingest algae. When sea lions, whales and birds eat those fish, the toxin can accumulate in their tissue at dangerous levels. Poisoned mammals become disoriented and erratic, and can experience seizures, and long term exposure can result in permanent brain and heart issues.

“It’s really a problem for the wildlife because of course they can’t read the signs,” said Raphael Kudela, a professor at UCSC’s Institute of Marine Sciences. “They have to eat the shellfish, or the anchovies or what have you, even if it’s toxic.”

Some have speculated that domoic acid was behind the sea lion attack in Capitola, though responders emphasized that there’s no way to confirm it and that approaching wild animals always poses a risk. 

Kudela said that beyond the reported strandings, “there’s probably many more cases where it’s just interfering with their ability to survive in the ocean,” he said.

alt

A juvenile humpback whale found deceased near Watsonville on June 5. (Marine Mammal Stranding Network — UC Santa Cruz)

In humans, the effects are known as amnesic shellfish poisoning and usually happens when people eat mussels and oysters with high levels of domoic acid. Poisoning can cause headaches, confusion and seizures. 

Kudela noted that the risk to humans is generally much lower because of state seafood testing. “If you’re eating commercial fish or shellfish, it’s perfectly safe,” he said. 

Clarissa Anderson, a biological oceanographer at Scripps Institution of Oceanography, said the biggest risk to humans lies with recreational harvesting of mussels and oysters. The state’s recreational mussel quarantine runs from May to October, “but we do see some blooms in the winter,” she said. 

Challenges tracking domoic acid

Anderson and Kudela stressed that there’s no single trigger for domoic acid outbreaks, which makes it hard to explain what set off this one. “We’ve never been good at predicting them,” Anderson said. 

Current models can track a bloom a few days ahead once it begins, but forecasting a good or bad season months out is a much bigger challenge as each event is unique.

alt

A microscopic view of algal bloom. (Marine Mammal Center)

“There’s a dozen things that could cause domoic acid to be produced,” Kudela said, explaining that factors like sunlight, water temperature and nutrient levels can all play a role in harmful blooms, and that it can be difficult to decipher the exact cause. “Is it cold water or is it warm water? It turns out it’s both,” Kudela said.

Beyond that, Anderson noted that a bloom alone doesn’t mean mass poisoning. It also takes the animals’ prey being in the right place to take up the acid and then be eaten.

“It can be a mixed bag. We’ve had weird domoic acid events where only birds got sick, because maybe all the anchovies were at the surface.” Anderson explained that in other instances, deeper blooms and clusters of fish could target sea lions, which forage deeper than birds.

Looking ahead

Kudela confirmed what Rulli’s teams at the Marine Mammal Center have seen on the ground: outbreaks that used to follow a set rhythm — from March to June and again from August to November — are starting to occur at odd times throughout the year.

“It’s really changing its pattern, which makes it difficult to predict what’s going on. That’s primarily probably due to a combination of sort of interannual variability and climate change,” Kudela said. “It’s just the ocean is not the way it used to be.”

As far as El Niño’s possible effects on this, Kudela said it tends to suppress domoic acid in Southern California but makes blooms more likely from Santa Cruz northward, and that another intense bloom could emerge in early December. Anderson, the oceanographer, noted that as a warm Kelvin wave moves up the coast, any blooms are likely to be patchy, appearing in isolated bays rather than along the whole coastline.

alt

A California sea lion in treatment for domoic acid poisoning. (Jillian Pastick — Marine Mammal Center)

New tools developed by Kudela’s team could give responders more anticipation before blooms hit sea mammals. The detection methods use chemical “alarm cues” released by copepods, tiny crustaceans that eat the toxic algae, and can forecast toxic blooms up to seven weeks ahead. 

In the meantime, Rulli urged locals to stay alert and inform response teams of sick or distressed marine mammals. He advised locals to stay at least 150 feet away, keep pets leashed and call the Marine Mammal Center’s hotline at 415-289-SEAL (7325).

He emphasized that sea lions are a “sentinel species” for ocean health. “Their health is our health,” he said. “When they’re coming ashore sick, it should be a real flag for all of us.”

Questions or comments? Email info@santacruzlocal.org. Santa Cruz Local is supported by members, major donors, sponsors and grants for the general support of our newsroom. Our news judgments are made independently and not on the basis of donor support. Learn more about Santa Cruz Local and how we are funded.

Learn about membership Santa Cruz Local’s news is free. We believe that high-quality local news is crucial to democracy. We depend on locals like you to make a meaningful contribution so everyone can access our news. Learn about membership

The post Toxic algal blooms blamed for beached whales, sick sea lions from Santa Cruz to Monterey Bay appeared first on Santa Cruz Local.

Supervisors get first look at possible taxes for roads

Mon, 11/09/2026 - 16:02

alt

Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors set to discuss road conditions at a November meeting. Supervisor Manu Koenig has previously these concerns to the board. (Amaya Edwards — Santa Cruz Local file/Report for America)

Board of Supervisors meeting
  • 9 a.m. Tuesday, Nov. 10 at 701 Ocean St., Room 525, Santa Cruz.
  • Join on Zoom or call 669-254-5252 , meeting ID 160 123 6676. The meeting will also be streamed on Facebook.
  • To comment ahead of the meeting, email BoardOfSupervisors@santacruzcountyca.gov by 5 p.m. Monday. 

SANTA CRUZ >> For years, Santa Cruz County’s rural road conditions have declined, as a decadeslong maintenance backlog competes with emergency repairs for limited tax money.

The county needs to spend $20 million more per year just to keep roads at their current condition, not including future disasters that could affect roads, county staff wrote in an agenda report.

On Tuesday, the Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors is set to receive an update on possible ways to fill the gap and improve rural roads. 

Some county leaders have suggested setting aside a percentage of the county’s General Fund for roads. But county staff wrote that such a policy would result in heavy cuts to other services, like public safety and health care.

(function() { window.mc4wp = window.mc4wp || { listeners: [], forms: { on: function(evt, cb) { window.mc4wp.listeners.push( { event : evt, callback: cb } ); } } } })(); Stay informed on Santa Cruz County’s biggest issues. Santa Cruz Local’s newsletter breaks down complex local topics and shows residents how to get involved. Email address:
mc4wp.forms.on('subscribed', function(form) { // gtag.js if(form.id == '6954') { gtag('event', 'subscribe', {'event_category': 'newsletter_prompt', 'event_label':'top_of_story'}); } }); Leave this field empty if you're human:

Instead, staff recommended the county raise more money for road repair. Many of the options would require voter approval, either through a regular election or a Proposition 218 ballot for property owners. Some ideas include:

  • Replacing a half-cent sales tax set to expire in 2030 with a three-quarters-cent sales tax, and prioritizing the quarter-cent tax hike for road spending. The tax hike could raise $5.6 million annually for roads.
  • Raising the transient occupancy tax by 1 percentage point, bringing it to 13% for hotels and 15% for short-term rentals. The increase could raise $1.2 million annually, some of which can be used for roads.
  • Raising the property assessment for County Service Area 9D, which covers much of the unincorporated county. The annual assessment of $56.40 per improved parcel and $28.20 per vacant parcel has been unchanged since 1983. Increasing the assessments in line with its purchasing power in 1983, to $211.72 and $105.86 respectively, could raise $7.3 million more than it does now.
  • Issuing up to $37 million in bonds backed by County Service Area 9D money. 
  • Creating a new County Service Area for rural roads with an annual $150 assessment on rural parcels. It could raise $4.5 million annually.
  • Forming an Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District, which could dedicate a portion of future property tax growth to roads. There is no estimate of how much money it could raise.

Next summer, county staff are set to bring forward more detailed findings and funding proposals. The county has created a dashboard showing how it currently receives and spends money for roads.

At the Tuesday, Nov. 10 meeting the board is also set to discuss:

  • A six-month pilot program to coordinate social services and health care for 20-30 homeless people frequently arrested by law enforcement. The program would give participants leaving jail a “warm handoff” to people or programs who can help connect them with supportive services. 
  • A proposed regulation to compel owners of registered historic buildings to sufficiently maintain their buildings and prevent demolition. 
  • A report on Measure Q spending. A county dashboard maps the projects funded by the tax.
  • See the full agenda.

Questions or comments? Email info@santacruzlocal.org. Santa Cruz Local is supported by members, major donors, sponsors and grants for the general support of our newsroom. Our news judgments are made independently and not on the basis of donor support. Learn more about Santa Cruz Local and how we are funded.

Learn about membership Santa Cruz Local’s news is free. We believe that high-quality local news is crucial to democracy. We depend on locals like you to make a meaningful contribution so everyone can access our news. Learn about membership

The post Supervisors get first look at possible taxes for roads appeared first on Santa Cruz Local.

Housing proposals move forward in Seabright, Live Oak

Mon, 11/09/2026 - 12:36

alt

A parking lot north of Santa Cruz Bible Church is the proposed site of a townhome complex, shown in June 2025. (Tyler Maldonado — Santa Cruz Local file)

SANTA CRUZ >> Two proposals for new housing are moving forward, even as neighbors push back against developments they say are out of place in single-family neighborhoods.

Frederick Street townhomes

Thursday, the Santa Cruz Planning Commission recommended approval for 19 townhomes near Arana Gulch to be offered for sale.

The project at 528 Frederick St., next to Santa Cruz Bible Church, was downsized from a prior proposal in August 2025. That version included 23 townhomes and would have removed 11 “heritage-sized” trees. The new plan keeps more of the land as open space, and removes five heritage-sized trees.

The new plans include:

  • Four three-story buildings.
  • Four homes priced below-market rate for low- or moderate-income households.
  • 38 parking spaces. 

Following the planning commission’s unanimous vote, the Santa Cruz City Council is set to consider the project for final approval. State housing laws greatly limit the city’s ability to block or change the development.

Submit comments or questions about the project on the city’s website or contact Senior Planner Rina Zhou at rzhou@santacruzca.gov.

(function() { window.mc4wp = window.mc4wp || { listeners: [], forms: { on: function(evt, cb) { window.mc4wp.listeners.push( { event : evt, callback: cb } ); } } } })(); Stay informed on Santa Cruz County’s biggest issues. Santa Cruz Local’s newsletter breaks down complex local topics and shows residents how to get involved. Email address:
mc4wp.forms.on('subscribed', function(form) { // gtag.js if(form.id == '6954') { gtag('event', 'subscribe', {'event_category': 'newsletter_prompt', 'event_label':'top_of_story'}); } }); Leave this field empty if you're human: alt

The site is on Frederick Street in Santa Cruz. (BDE Architecture)

7th and Brommer

A 100-unit below-market-rent housing proposal near the Santa Cruz Harbor is moving forward without a public vote, instead using new rules that allow approval by county staff. 

The Santa Cruz County Zoning Administrator on Friday morning held a public meeting about the project at 7th Avenue and Brommer Street. The property is owned by the county and would be developed by San Diego-based nonprofit Community HousingWorks.

The project includes:

  • One four-story, 55-foot-tall building.
  • 46 one-bedroom units.
  • 27 two-bedroom units.
  • 27 three-bedroom units. 
  • 66 parking spaces.

All but one manager’s unit will be priced for households earning between 30% and 60% of the area median income, set annually by the state. Twenty-five units will be set aside for residents with intellectual or developmental disabilities. 

The project has received federal funding, and is therefore subject to an environmental review to comply with the National Environmental Policy Act. County staff will consider that review and public comment before issuing a building permit and coastal permit. 

For questions or comments, contact county planner Jonathan DiSalvo at Jonathan.DiSalvo@santacruzcountyca.gov.

Housing context

Attendees at both meetings raised concerns about the new developments’ size and potential impacts on neighborhood privacy, traffic and the environment. Increasingly, state housing laws have incentivized or required local governments not to be swayed by such concerns.

The Frederick Street townhouse project is on privately-owned land in a neighborhood zoned for the kind of small-scale multifamily housing being proposed. The city is therefore legally obligated to approve the project if it meets certain objective rules — and the city cannot impose new rules after an application is submitted. The owner did not fully take advantage of state density bonus laws that would have cleared the way for a larger development.

The 7th Avenue property is owned by the successor agency to the county’s Redevelopment Agency, a former tax-funded effort to promote urban revitalization and affordable housing. Redevelopment Agencies were dissolved statewide in 2012, and successor agencies are now responsible for the money and land they acquired.

Both projects count towards local state-set requirements for the construction of new housing. If a city or county does not allow enough housing, it can lose more local control over development or face a lawsuit. The state laws aim to reverse decades of rapid population growth without comparable housing growth — a pattern many housing policy experts consider central to the state’s housing affordability crisis. 

Still, many new developments across the county have faced strong opposition from neighbors. 

Leah Boone was one of more than a dozen people who spoke during Friday’s meeting about the 7th Avenue proposal. She echoed her neighbors’ concerns that the new homes could add congestion to the street, especially during evacuations. 

“We all know someone who’s moved away due to affordability issues in our area, and we all know we need more housing. This is about residents who feel the county has seemingly not considered them,” she said. “It’s not cheap or easy to live here, and all of this makes it harder.”

Questions or comments? Email info@santacruzlocal.org. Santa Cruz Local is supported by members, major donors, sponsors and grants for the general support of our newsroom. Our news judgments are made independently and not on the basis of donor support. Learn more about Santa Cruz Local and how we are funded.

Learn about membership Santa Cruz Local’s news is free. We believe that high-quality local news is crucial to democracy. We depend on locals like you to make a meaningful contribution so everyone can access our news. Learn about membership

The post Housing proposals move forward in Seabright, Live Oak appeared first on Santa Cruz Local.