SAP opens AI to on-prem customers, but cloud commitments could shut smaller firms out
SAP's commercial terms could put its latest AI tools out of reach for many customers, particularly smaller businesses running a single ERP system, the new chair of its German-speaking user group has warned.
Thomas Henzler, appointed chair of DSAG last month, told The Register that Joule Studio 2.0 – SAP's upgraded platform for developing and deploying AI agents to automate business tasks – is a leap forward.
Yet DSAG, which represents SAP users in Germany, Switzerland, and Austria, remains in talks with the vendor about the commercial conditions attached to access.
In July 2023, CEO Christian Klein told investors that SAP's "newest innovations and capabilities" will only be delivered in the public or private cloud using RISE with SAP, the vendor's lift-shift-and-transform program launched with partners and cloud providers in early 2021. Customers running ERP software on-premises, or hosting it with a hyperscaler outside RISE, will miss out, he said.
However, in May this year, SAP appeared to perform a U-turn. It said on-premises customers could access Joule 2.0 if they commit to a cloud "journey" through RISE with SAP, changing their support and commercial arrangements while migration projects are still underway.
Henzler told The Reg: "There is a gap between the customer's reality and SAP's strategy for the autonomous enterprise. A lot of customers are still planning to migrate to S/4HANA, and now the question is, 'what do we have to do to use SAP AI, and what does it mean regarding the cloud strategy?'
"Now it's a completely new strategy, a new approach, and a new underlying technology. The question is, what does it mean for existing projects, S/4HANA migrations, cloud migrations and so on? Is it necessary to rethink all the projects? Is there a big shift in the technology and architectures?"
The DSAG chair said the biggest challenge in connecting legacy on-prem systems, such as ECC, to the new Joule suite is the commercial model.
"Access requires a substantial RISE commitment and a minimum cloud-to-on-premise maintenance ratio. In practice, this creates a problem for customers with only one ECC system. To meet the cloud threshold, they have to convert their entire on-premises maintenance into a cloud subscription, which defeats the purpose of an on-premises connector. Consequently, the model only works for large enterprises with multiple SAP ERP systems that can, for example, migrate one system after the other to unlock AI for the rest," he said.
"In the end, to get the benefit you have to start a RISE with SAP migration. Therefore, the connector doesn't make sense for the majority of SME customers. From my perspective, this approach works only for large customers with multiple ERP systems, for example, if they take one system, move it to the cloud, and then another one. Then they can use AI, because they reach the needed ratio to use the on-prem connector. That is more or less a commercial approach. We need a solution for all customers, independent of the commercials."
The Register asked SAP to respond to Henzler's concerns. A spokesperson said: "The offering separates a customer's commercial commitment to cloud ERP from the timing of its operational migration. Customers that meet the applicable commercial and technical requirements can use supported AI capabilities with eligible ECC or on-premises SAP S/4HANA systems while modernizing their landscape. Eligibility is not determined by the number of ERP instances and can therefore also extend to single-instance customers."
There are thousands of SAP ERP users worldwide, including some of the world's largest businesses. Despite efforts to get them onto the latest iteration – S/4HANA – and in the cloud, where the vendor promised it could gather a greater "share of wallet" from customers, there has been a dogged resistance to these complex and time-consuming migrations.
Gartner figures for Q4 2024 showed only 39 percent of worldwide ECC customers – from a total of 35,000 – had bought or subscribed to SAP S/4HANA licenses. More recently, The Reg uncovered that SAP was about €2 billion short of its target for getting customers off on-prem support.
Customers still running older ERP systems face pressure to embrace AI-supported automation. Whether SAP's terms help them do that – or simply help move them onto RISE – remains the question. ®
Fox Goes Off Rails over Nvidia Mess as It Turns Humiliating for Trump
The scandal involving the Nvidia tech company is sharply dividing Donald Trump’s advisers. Faced with revelations about its leader Jensen Huang having an affair with an alleged spy who may have channeled AI tech to China, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent is pillorying Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick for failing to act to curb China’s access to Nvidia technology. It’s getting humiliating for Trump, who’s adrift and listless, exercising no leadership, even as he appears to have been far too solicitous of Huang, possibly for corrupt personal reasons. Meanwhile, Fox News is now running interference for Trump, as Media Matters documents. Fox personalities are portraying the scandal as a “set up” to get Trump and a conspiracy to regulate (gasp!) AI and data centers. We talked to former DHS official Juliette Kayyem. She explains why this scandal matters, why Fox is so worried about its impact on Trump, what this saga reveals about AI’s future, and how Democrats can seize this moment. Listen to this episode here.
Galadriel’s Hair: How THE RINGS OF POWER Expands Tolkien’s Lore
This post contains major spoilers from The Rings of Power season three episodes five and six as it discusses Galadriel’s hair. If you want to avoid them until you watch, you can check out our coverage of the first four episodes instead. Also read our spoiler-free review.
Prime Video
Quick Take
- The Rings of Power pulled from J.R.R. Tolkien’s deep lore to expand on why Galadriel’s hair is both special and why the orcs are also victims of evil.
- Galadriel’s hair might be one of the few remaining things in Middle-earth to carry the gold and silver of the Two Trees.
- Nerdist’s Take: Celeborn’s story about showing the orcs his wife’s hair highlights just how much they are also victims of darkness.
With apologies to Glorfindel, Galadriel has always had the greatest hair in all of Middle-earth. The overwhelming beauty of her elven locks famously enchanted Gimli the dwarf in The Lord of the Rings. He asked for a strand when she was giving the Fellowship gifts for their perilous journey. But that’s not only time J.R.R. Tolkien wrote about Galadriel’s tresses. Galadriel’s hair really is special, one of the few remaining things in the world to carry the gold and silver light of the gods themselves. And The Rings of Power used that deep lore in season three to highlight the sadness of the orcs.
New Line Cinema
In The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Rings, Gimli named Galdriel’s hair as his “desire.” He said it “surpasses the gold of the earth as the stars surpass the gems of the mine.” That was possibly literally true. J.R.R. Tolkien wrote about why in a piece titled “The History of Galadriel and Celeborn,” which his son Christopher published as part of the Unfinished Tales of Númenor and Middle-earth. In it, Galadriel’s hair is called “a marvel unmatched.” From Tolkien:
It was golden like the hair of her father and of her foremother Indis, but richer and more radiant, for its gold was touched by some memory of the starlike silver of her mother, and the Eldar said that the light of the Two Trees had been snared in her tresses.
The Two Trees mentioned in the passage about Galadriel’s hair are the Two Trees of Valinor. One was a tree of silver, the other gold. They once brought the light of the Valar (Middle-earth’s gods) to the world. The first Dark Lord, Morgoth, had the trees destroyed, but the fruit they bore became the Sun and the Moon.
Prime Video
The Trees’ light also lived on in the famed silmarils, three lost jewels of unmatched beauty crafted by Celebrimbor’s grandfather. He was Fëanor, the great elf craftsman ever. Sauron currently possesses Fëanor’s hammer and plans to use to melt it down to forge the One Ring because the hammer itself has the silver and gold of the Valar, just as the Two Trees did. And Fëanor might have found inspiration for his silmarils, and on The Rings of Power, his hammer, from Galadriel’s hair. It might also possess the light of God himself, which would explain why Gimli found himself drawn to it.
The light of Ilúvatar, which was fading across the realms of elves in The Rings of Power season one, is something the orcs themselves also crave. When Adar was ready to unleash the darkness of Mount Doom to create a home for his children, he spoke to the orcs about how much he would miss the Sun. He was an elf Morgoth took and corrupted, but Adar never forgot the warmth of Valinor’s light. And though the orcs never truly knew Ilúvatar’s light, The Rings of Power used Tolkien’s deep lore about Galadriel’s hair to further show why the orcs are victims of evil, same as the rest of Middle-earth.
Prime Video
When Celeborn first met Galadriel in the woods that would one day become their home, Lothlórien, he cut a lock of her hair. Even an elf who likely saw the Two Trees himself couldn’t help himself when he first laid eyes on Galadriel’s hair. He tried to give it back, but she told him to keep it. (Which now feels ominous since Sauron needs the gold and silver of Valinor to forge the One Ring…)
Galadriel’s hair was still with Celeborn during his centuries locked away in Thangorodrim. One day he showed a strand of his wife’s locks to the orcs. It caused a riot. The orcs could not handle the beauty and light of the gods that it possessed, and they destroyed Celeborn’s lock of Galadriel’s hair extinguish the light in the darkness.
In The Lord of the Rings, Gimli’s “desire” made clear that Galadriel’s hair of gold and silver hair was special. The Rings of Power has not only explored why that was true, but why her hair also represented something much bigger than one elf. Her tresses were the embodiment of light and goodness itself.
The Rings of Power season three is now airing on Prime Video.
Mikey Walsh is a staff writer at Nerdist. You can follow Mikey on Bluesky at @burgermike. And also anywhere someone is ranking the Targaryen kings.The post Galadriel’s Hair: How THE RINGS OF POWER Expands Tolkien’s Lore appeared first on Nerdist.
UK MPs want AI watchdog with power to pull the plug on dangerous models
UK MPs want a watchdog with the power to pull the plug on dangerous AI models, rather than leave the likes of OpenAI and Anthropic to decide when they've gone too far.
In a report shared with The Register ahead of publication on Wednesday, a parliamentary committee is calling for an AI Safety and Security Bill that would give a watchdog powers to intervene while models are still being developed.
It could halt high-risk training and testing, block deployments, or suspend AI services if the risks can't be contained. LLMs are trained on billions of learned parameters and so developers can't always predict what a model will do in every situation.
The recommendations come from Parliament's Business, Innovation, Science and Trade Committee, which questioned researchers, former AI employees, and representatives from OpenAI, Google DeepMind, Anthropic, and Meta.
All four companies assured MPs they wouldn't release models they considered unsafe. The trouble is, they don't use the same yardstick for safety, and UK law doesn't generally require them to get an independent opinion before releasing anything.
"We cannot give today’s AI leaders unfettered freedom to behave like modern-day Dr Frankensteins, creating dangers beyond anyone’s control," said committee chair Liam Byrne MP.
Just as with aviation, pharma or nuclear safety, UK government want to rely on manufacturers' assurance alone, and want regulation.
"Our hearings exposed gaps in independent scrutiny, incident reporting and powers to stop unsafe systems. Once some models are released, they cannot reliably be recalled," added Byrne. "Protection must begin while systems are being built and tested."
The committee's report, Guardrails for Growth: Making AI Safe, identifies ten holes in Britain's approach to AI safety, including the lack of mandatory incident reporting, limited access for independent testers, and inadequate protections for whistleblowers.
The UK already has an AI Security Institute (AISI), which has made a name for itself testing some of the world's most powerful models, but its work depends on voluntary cooperation, and it has no authority to stop a company releasing a model that raises safety concerns.
MPs want AISI to continue its testing work while a separate regulator takes responsibility for enforcement. Developers of designated high-risk systems would have to provide evidence supporting their safety claims and give independent researchers access to examine them. Significant changes to a model's capabilities or safeguards would trigger further scrutiny.
Former AI employees also told MPs that raising safety concerns can come at a price. Restrictive contracts, commercial pressures, and financial disincentives can all discourage staff from speaking out, the committee heard. MPs want stronger legal protections for whistleblowers and compulsory reporting of AI incidents and near misses.
There's a fair bit of money riding on this, too. Using OECD productivity estimates, the committee calculates that AI could leave Britain's economy up to £400 billion larger over the next decade. It also sees an opportunity for the UK to make money from independently testing AI models, building on the expertise already established at AISI. MPs argue that stronger safeguards could encourage businesses, particularly smaller firms, to adopt the technology.
"AI firms must be required to substantiate their safety claims, independent experts must be able to scrutinize them, and a regulator must have the power to intervene when risks cannot be controlled," Byrne said. "Ministers, accountable to Parliament, must decide what risks the public should be asked to bear."
MPs want the new laws on the books in the next parliamentary session, and say Britain should use its turn at the G20 helm in 2027 to get other countries on board with tougher rules for AI testing, incident reporting, and risky model releases.
Whether ministers are prepared to hand a watchdog the power to stop AI development is another matter. The committee's recommendations aren't binding, and the government has yet to commit to the proposed legislation. ®
Is Sauron Queer? THE RINGS OF POWER Tackles Age-Old Question
- The Rings of Power tackles an age-old question surrounding The Lord of the Rings: Is Sauron queer? We dive into the evidence.
Before we begin, I present you with this tenet, which I believe to be universally true across fiction: Every immortal character is queer. The idea that you would live for an eternity but stay in some societally perscribed sphere of how you must conduct your life seems laughable at best. At some point in forever, the notion of trying something different, of trying everything, would likely call out to you. Add to that a total disregard for any society but your own whims, and well, the likehood of straying from a narrow vision of a heteronormative existence seems quite likely. And, obviously, that brings us to Sauron. An immortal Maia with a will to dominate all certainly paints a very inclusive picture of Sauron’s desires. Not to mention, it’s literal Tolkien canon that he was “seduced” by Morgoth. And now, we add to that some canon text from The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power and there’s a lot to unpack. Join us as we look at the age-old question, is Sauron queer?* Spoilers ahead, you have been warned!
Prime Video
*Obviously, queer-coding villains is not ideal queer representation. But as a queer person, I enjoy the notion that Sauron is queer and am embarking on this piece from that perspective. I feel like the Sauron’s indiscrimnant seducing is quite interesting and, in a sense, a rare vision of a truly pan character. And I support queer rights to wrongs. While some of Sauron’s queerness may initally stem from a place of equating queerness with evil in a way that is not productive, in today’s world he’s a fascinating, well-known character that I enjoy to claim as not only queer-coded, but actually queer. Of course, every queer person will feel in their own ways about these conclusions!
Can Sauron Love Anyone in The Lord of the Rings?For my personal defintions, queerness does not necessarily involve a romantic or sexual desire at all. In most cases, I would say that queerness is more truly encompassed by a feeling that a life lived does not fall in the confines of a “normal” existence, taking into account that we understand “normal” in our current period of existence as a societally approved way of life which is not queer. I think, in almost every sense, existing as an all-powerful immortal, shape-shifting force attempting to conquer all of humanity is naturally queer. But I think, in this case, it’s very interesting to consider the question, can Sauron love or desire anyone? Let alone do it in a way that we could note to be queer?
Prime Video
Well, no, and yes, and it’s complicated. In The History of Middle-earth, Vol. X: Morgoth’s Ring, Tolkien writes, “While Morgoth still stood, Sauron did not seek his own supremacy but worked and schemed for another, desiring the triumph of Melkor, whom in the beginning he had adored.” There does seem to be an implied warmth of feeling there, between Sauron and Morgth. The literal definition of adored is “to love someone very much.” And in this instance, it does seem like Sauron was, at least, at some point, a being capable of something like what we might recognize as something like love. Indeed, in the Unfinished Tales, Tolkien notes in a letter, “At the beginning of the Second Age, he [Sauron] was still beautiful to look at, or could still assume a beautiful visible shape—and was not indeed wholly evil.” And in being in some way good, Tolkienien logic implies the ability to love as not only possible, but very likely.
Prime Video
Turning to The Rings of Power, we see Sauron in conversation with his psyche as Celebrimbor, insist that he and Celebrimbor were “partners,” only to have Celebrimbor, but really Sauron, say that “the machinary of Sauron’s soul is missing a piece, the one that allows for a true bond, a true union. So in its place, you seek control.”
Sauron telling himself that he is broken for being unable to connect to another being seems to betray a desire for the ability to do such a thing, if not necessarily the ability itself. And that I might argue, isn’t nothing.
Sauron as the Seduced and the Seducer: Sauron’s Queerness in the Lore Of Morgoth and SauronLooking to the lore, we see Sauron often cast as the deciever, but also, on more than one occassion, as the seducer and the seduced. In The Silmarillion, Tolkien calls Morgoth’s overtures with Sauron a “seduction.” He writes, “Of old there was Sauron the Maia, whom the Sindar in Beleriand named Gorthaur. In the beginning of Arda Melkor seduced him to his allegiance, and he became the greatest and most trusted of the servants of the Enemy, and the most perilous, for he could assume many forms, and for long if he willed he could still appear noble and beautiful, so as to deceive all but the most wary.”
Now, we can draw the obvious comparisons to the devil when it comes to both Morgoth and Sauron and point to that being the cause for the word at hand. And the devil is known for seducing people. And those seductions are not always romantic or sexual, although, they also very much can be. But regardless, I think we can all agree that when the word “seduction” is used, most of the time, the ensuing relation is romantic or sexual. And Tolkien, who we so often speak of as choosing his words very carefully, must have been aware of that on some of level. Further, if we combine the idea that Morgoth “seduced” Sauron and “trusted” him and Sauron in turn “adored” Morgoth, we begin to make the shape of something that looks quite like a romance.
Of course, one might argue that a romantic relationship between Morgoth, a literal god, and Sauron, a primoridal spirit, is inherently queer because neither being is human in the sense of having a defined body and gender. But taking into account our perception of Sauron and Morgth as men, it makes the bond between them queer in a much more literal sense as well.
Of Celebrimbor and PharazônAnd Sauron, of course, relationship ended with Morgoth, goes on arrange quite a few seductions of his own: notably in Tolkien’s lore of Celebrimbor and Pharazôn. In the case of Celebrimbor, looking only at Tolkien’s writings, we see that in Appendix B, Tolkien notes, “Sauron endeavours to seduce the Eldar. Gil-galad refuses to treat with him; but the smiths of Eregion are won over.” There’s that word again! This time used indiscriminantly when it comes to the Eldar. But when it comes to winning Celebrimbor specifically, Tolkien writes in Unfinished Tales, “Sauron used all his arts upon Celebrimbor and his fellow-smiths.” Like “seduction,” “all his arts,” could have many meanings, but also, in among common usages of the term there’s an inherent application of charm implied, especially juxtaposed with a vision of seduction. On top of that, “When he felt himself to be secure he sent emissaries to Eriador, and finally, in about the year 1200 of the Second Age, [Sauron] came himself, wearing the fairest form that he could contrive.” So, Sauron made himself as beautiful or hot as possible and came to seduce Celebrimbor using all his charm and skills. Well, I think Tolkien said it all about the queerness that lurks here in Sauron.
But just in case, that’s not enough, in Letter 154, he mused, “But the Elves are not wholly good or in the right. Not so much because they had flirted with Sauron; as because with or without his assistance they were ’embalmers’.” Okay? Okay!
Prime Video
Similarly, when it comes to Pharazôn, The Silmarillion and Appendix B note a version of the following text, “Sauron, Ar-Pharazôn ‘The Golden’, twenty-fifth and last King of Númenor; named in Quenya Tar-Calion; captor of Sauron, by whom he was seduced; commander of the great fleet that went against Aman.” And Tolkien additionally notes that though Ar-Pharazôn was strong-willed, “Sauron was crafty, well skilled to gain what he would by subtlety when force might not avail. Therefore he humbled himself before Ar-Pharazôn and smoothed his tongue; and men wondered, for all that he said seemed fair and wise.”
Again, we have another vision of flirtation, complete with seduction and tongue smoothing, that feels especially salient when combined with, “Ar-Pharazôn was not yet deceived… Yet such was the cunning of Sauron’s mind and mouth, and the strength of his hidden will, that ere three years had passed he had become closest to the secret counsels of the King; for flattery sweet as honey was ever on his tongue, and knowledge he had of many things yet unrevealed to Men.” Seduction plus flirtation sweet as honey equals closest of counsels equals a quite a queer Sauron if you ask me.
And yes, he’s still looking “fair” in Númenor if you consult the History of Middle Earth, he’s even changed once more to appearance especially for Pharazôn and the island, appearing now “as a man, or one in man’s shape, but greater than any even of the race of Numenor in stature.” Changing your physical appearance to try to win over the will of another man… is yes, one of Sauron’s favorite queer behaviors.
On The Rings of Power Sauron Has a Slew of ‘Ex-Lovers’: Galadriel, Adar, Celebrimbor, and More Galadriel and Adar Share an ExOn The Rings of Power, we see Sauron’s seduction of Celebrimbor, with Pharazôn’s waiting in the wings, and gain two new stories of the same ilk: Galadriel’s and Adar’s. In Galadriel’s case on The Rings of Power, Sauron literally proposes marriage to her twice. And you might say, a marriage doesn’t have to be romantic, but before this proposal, he transformed himself into Galadriel’s perfect man, the man she most wanted and needed at that specific time, and became him just in time for them to share a deep intimacy unlike anything the pair of them had felt before.
Sauron literally says “Fighting at your side, I felt, if I could just hold on to that feeling, keep it with me always…” And Galadriel says, “I felt it too.” And she tells Sauron his past doesn’t matter to her, and then Sauron proposes literal marriage. Okay, so it’s pretty romantic no matter how you slice the Lembas bread… Especially if we add to that the recurring bed-time visions Galadriel has of Sauron in The Rings of Power season three, where she recounts his proposal and her husband, Celeborn, literally turns into him. That’s yearning, ladies and gentleman.
Prime Video
And sure, Galadriel is a woman, you might say, what’s that got to do with this? But honestly, the fact that Sauron is indiscriminate in his deep seductions on The Rings of Power makes him MORE queer, not less. It’s pure and unadulturated bisexual/pansexual energy, in its finest form—the kind I see in my queer friends, but rarely find well-depicted on TV. Your form doesn’t really matter to Sauron, he’s willing to seduce you for the love of the game and his own personal pleasure. Is that toxic queerness? Sure! But queerness nonetheless.
Prime Video
Because juxtaposed to Galadriel, we have Adar. Setting aside the weird psychosexual games Sauron and Adar play with one another at the beginning of The Rings of Power season two involving kissing feet, chains, and Sauron pretending to be submissive even though he’s really the dominant one in the duo, we have Adar describing his first meeting with Sauron, saying in a near-tearful, pained way you speak about a terrible ex, “I was in your place once, in the eldest of the elder days. Thirteen of us were chosen to be blessed of Morgoth’s hand with the promise of power, a new birth. I was led up to a dark and nameless peak, chained and left. And after what seemed endless thirst and hunger, I saw it. His servant’s face, Sauron’s face. And it was beautiful. He offered me wine, red as a blood moon. He offered me wine and on that dark and nameless peak. I drank it, I drank it all.”
Prime Video
What was that about Sauron? Oh yeah, he was “beautiful” and Adar willing drank of his offered wine and allowed himself to be seduced. And this could be totally platonic but it sounds queer as hell… Did I mention both Adar and Sauron were basically crying after this story concluded? When I asked Sam Hazeldine, who plays Adar, if he thought Adar was in love with Sauron on The Rings of Power, he noted, “Yeah, I think so. I mean, I think Sauron has that kind of, just as Galadriel found with Halbrand at the beginning without knowing it, she was just drawn into this kind of lie, this deception. He creates what you want, he appears as you want him to be, for Celebrimbor as well, as Annatar, as the Lord of Gifts. And so I think, yeah.”
And that idea of “being in love” becomes especially salient when we pair it with the conversation Galadriel and Adar later have about Sauron. Adar first accuses Galadriel of being “consumed” by Sauron the way “one always is when he has wormed his way inside your mind.” Galadriel denies that she yielded to Sauron, but Adar clocks her, saying “sooner or later he sees you, who you are, but who you wish to be. His eye bores a hole and the rest of him slithers in. For a while he even makes you belive that his power has become yours. Irresistable power, that makes every desire’s fufillment seem inevitable. An ocean of color against which everything else feels forever thereafter…” And Galadriel finishes, “a dull grey.”
Now removing some of the overt darkness, what Adar describes is the feeling of being in love with someone: seeing them, understanding them, knowing what they want, trying to fufill their desires. And what the pair concludes with is that the loss of that love is painful to them in THE EXACT SAME WAY. I think it’s very clear in this conversation that both Adar and Galadriel were or are in love with Sauron on The Rings of Power and are essentially going through a “dull grey” breakup without him. And as Charlie Vickers says, even when Sauron is in a role to win over a person, he is still fully and completely Sauron and he really feels and experiences whatever that form of him does in that time. And so on some level, if Adar and Galadriel were in love with Sauron, he was in love with them, whatever that word means for him precisely. (Which I think varies, but we’ll get into that in a little bit.)
Prime Video
Also, on The Rings of Power, Sauron literally “gives Adar children.” Which I mean, on the face of it, is pretty freaking queer, no matter how precisely these children came to be. If Sauron promised Adar children and gave them to him then Sauron and Adar are the parents of these children. You feel that queer Sauron energy? I feel it.
Ross Ferguson/Prime Video
The Queer Seduction of Celebrimbor and Beyond
Ah, SilverGifting. As a queer person, I’m just going to say that Charles Edwards’ Celebrimbor, whatever he was intended to be, is 100% what is colloquially known as “an old gay.” That’s just the truth of that performance. And we love it! And then the idea that for Celebrimbor, Sauron transformed himself into Annatar, ehm, a blonde twink with a hairbow, I mean, there you have it. But setting aside those notions, which you may or may not agree with, the idea that Sauron chose his physical form with the idea of pleasing or wooing Celebrimbor in mind, means he wanted to use his body to appeal to the other man. And that is, yes, more queer Sauron behavior.
Prime Video
Prime Video
Then there’s the fact that the relationship between Sauron and Celebrimbor is every bit a toxic love dynamic. Celebrimbor is always trying to please Sauron or Annatar, and he’s always being gaslit into feeling like he’s fallen short, but love bombed just enough to keep him in line. Sauron literally traps Celebrimbor away in his mind where only he has access to him. It doesn’t get more twistedly romantic than that, especially as Sauron insists, as so many abusive husbands often do, that Celebrimbor is forcing his hand into hurting him. That it’s not Sauron’s fault. Of course, abusers of all kinds do that, but Sauron and Celebrimbor are evoking something specific.
The showrunners of The Rings of Power even note, “The nature of this relationship and its closeness, and the even the sexual tension in it, has been a source of speculation by may fans of the source material for many years. Anytime you’re dealing with such powerful emotions as seduction and deception, I think it’s easy for your imagination to go there.”
Prime Video
And, of course, there’s once again the idea that in The Rings of Power season three, Sauron so desires to call what was between them a “partnership” and he KEEPS CELEBRIMBOR’S CORPSE IN THE CORNER for crying out loud. You might call it a trophy, but it certainly doesn’t feel like one when Celebrimbor is berating Sauron inside his mind. It feels more like Sauron cannot let Celebrimbor go.
We’ll finish off this section with Sauron commenting to Khamûl, his new Ring-servant in The Rings of Power season three that he is “the fairest of the nine.” Now, he may have meant the ring itself was the fairest of the nine, but the way he was smiling at Khamûl sure did make it seem like a flirtation.
If Sauron’s Love-Language Is Domination, Then His Will to Dominate All Is Pretty QueerUltimately, though, especially as Sauron continues down his dark road, that all these visions of love or an idea like it mutate for Sauron into a different mechanism, another ardent expression of passion, domination. As Tolkien writes in The Silmarillion, “The Enemy in successive forms is always ‘naturally’ concerned with sheer Domination.” And when Sauron forges his One Ring, it is said that into”he poured his cruelty, his malice and his will to dominate all life. One Ring to rule them all.” And this desire to dominate “all things in Middl-earth,” Tolkien even terms as “lust” in The Silmarillion.
We all have our love languages, and Sauron’s just happens to be breaking the will of another as he binds them to his own and exerts a great deal of influence over them. (Which, in a sense is all the components of love, arranged in the worst ways possible.) To him, “that’s bliss.”
Dominating Galadriel and Dominating Celeborn Were Equal Bliss to SauronFor more on that, we turn to Sauron himself. Whom, after kissing Celeborn in episode six of The Rings of Power season three, tells us and Celeborn, “And I thought it was bliss when Galadriel submitted to my will.”
Prime Video
Oop, there it is. The direct comparison of Galadriel submitting and Celeborn submitting and the “bliss” of the seduction or the breaking of the wills, or whatever it is that gets Sauron hot and bothered, really paints a picture of Sauron’s version of queerness. And I guess that boils down to equal opportunity domination, that just so happens to sometimes come with kissing. It really speaks to a kind of openness to all, which I enjoy to read as a kind of bisexuality or pansexuality. Fiction often really struggles to properly portray what it’s like when queer people are simply open to whomever catches their fancy. But I feel like Sauron’s declaration is pretty damn close. Galadriel submitting to his will is bliss. Celeborn submitting to his will is bliss. It’s all just bliss for Sauron. And we love Sauron’s queer rights to wrongs.
There’s also really something in the word bliss, which calls to mind both marriage and sex at the same time, that’s truly wonderful. And not for nothing, but before Sauron could get cracking on the bliss, he and Celeborn had to exchange fluids. Hrm.
The Celeborn and Sauron Queer Kiss in The Rings of PowerOkay, I think we rushed right past something TOO quickly. Sauron literally kisses Celeborn on The Rings of Power. Which, ghouls and goblins, I have to tell you, is a queer thing for Sauron to do. And he didn’t just kiss Celeborn as Galadriel to extort information for him, which would have been queer enough, but kind of in celebration, after he has already gotten Celeborn to tell him what he need to know to forge the One Ring, and notably, purposefully, as himself.
View this post on InstagramAnd sure, it could be all for the humilation. But I just have to tell you that non-queer folk do not transform into a lady they’re kind of obsessed with in order to kiss her husband to get some information out of him. They surely would go about it another way. And they’d definetly skip the kissing as themselves. A step they’d never even get to though because this way of doing things would NEVER occur to them. There’s just no way you’re a cis-het straight man and you do that. You have to be queer. And so, Sauron is queer.
Charlie Vickers Agrees Immortal Boredom Does Lead to Exploration…But to bring it all back to my original point, Charlie Vickers lays it all out for me about Sauron and his immortality. He says, “I see the bliss bit [to Celeborn] as him basically saying, ‘It’s a fun thing.’ Because Sauron has been through so much. He’s seen everything. He must be so desensitized to everything. That finding pure… entertainment must be really hard for him.”
Prime Video
And what was it we said? Oh yes, that any immortal character like Sauron must be defintionally queer because in the span of FOREVER, you’d likely be ready to try anything… to try everything.
Sauron Is QueerI rest my case.
The Rings of Power season three is now airing on Prime Video.
Rotem Rusak is the Editor-in-Chief at Nerdist. She is a great lover of the anti-hero and is always ready for a new ship to set sail. In her work, she likes to combine fandom passion with journalistic sensibilities. Follow her on Instagram.The post Is Sauron Queer? THE RINGS OF POWER Tackles Age-Old Question appeared first on Nerdist.
Time for frustrated M365 customers to stage a 'distributed denial of satisfaction' action
I briefly helped with Microsoft Australia’s PR efforts in the early 2000s, when IE 6 and Windows were so bug-prone they essentially represented a welcome mat for hackers and required a deluge of patches admins couldn’t handle. Microsoft responded to that mess with a message about security being a shared responsibility involving people, process, and technology.
A quarter of a century later, Microsoft’s business practices still make its customers reluctantly share the cost of its failings – most recently last week’s massive M365 outage.
To protest that mess, Microsoft customers should create a new cloudy meltdown – on the pages the software giant uses to process applications for compensation after it fails to meet service level agreements.
Yes, you read that right: “applications.” When Microsoft experiences an outage, customers must apply to get the service credits they’re entitled by finding the “Outage ID” related to each incident. The application page is buried deep in the Microsoft 365 Admin Center and the Outage ID is recorded elsewhere. Microsoft appears not to offer a facility for bulk uploads, so the channel partners who manage so many M365 implementations have extra work to do.
That’s outrageous because the implicit promise of the cloud is that it delivers more value for less effort. Yet Microsoft requires users to do extra work to seek redress for its mistakes.
Cloud also delivers fat profits for investors. Which is probably why Microsoft, which can clearly bill its customers regularly and reliably and therefore knows which services they use, hasn’t done the work to link its uptime meters and billing systems so it can automate crediting customers after outages.
I understand Microsoft thinks AI is quite good at that sort of integration. Maybe its enormously reduced workforce will need it to get the job done.
But rather than vibe-coding its way out of this, decency demands Microsoft quickly decide that all users impacted by last week’s automatically receive service credits, rather than asking them apply for their entitlements.
If Microsoft doesn’t get proactive, the magnitude of this outage represents a moment in which its customers can show the software giant it must do better – perhaps by filing so many applications for credit that managers who oversee Redmond’s systems and finances can’t help but notice a spike of activity.
Thinks of this as a distributed denial of satisfaction attack signaling that Microsoft can't solve this particular outage with a glib apology and a blog post. ®
THE RINGS OF POWER Begins One of Middle-earth’s Most Important Friendships
This post contains major spoilers from The Rings of Power season three, episodes five and six. If you want to avoid them until you watch, you can check out our coverage of the first four episodes instead. Also read our spoiler-free review.
Quick Take
- The Rings of Power season three showed the first meeting between two of Middle-earth’s most important figures, Elrond and Isildur.
- The two friends will stand together against Sauron as part of the Last Alliance of the Second Age.
- Nerdist’s Take: The Rings of Power‘s beauty is not in the destination but the journey, an idea best exemplified by the meeting of Isildur and Elrond.
We know how the Second Age of Middle-earth will end on The Rings of Power. One man’s choice will lead to the war of the Third Age told in The Lord of the Rings. But Prime Video’s series is not about the destination; it’s about the journey. It’s showing how the Last Alliance banded together to stop darkness from covering the world. And now it’s shown us where that pact began, with the first meeting between two of Middle-earth’s most important figures, Elrond and Isildur.
Prime Video
Elrond Goes to Númenor to Honor the Memory of His Brother
In The Rings of Power season three, Gil-galad went to Númenor to try and convince his fellow monarch, Ar-Pharazôn, to join the war against Sauron. But High King Gil-galad did not go alone. He had a secret weapon to negotiate with the men of the famed island, Elrond. Elrond’s twin brother Elros was the first King of Númenor. Long before Isildur was even a thought, at the end of the First Age, after Morgoth’s defeat, Elros and Elrond had a choice. The Valar told the two half-elves they could live as mortals or elves. In a flashback, The Rings of Power showed why each chose as they did.
Elros thought it a great honor to serve as his friends’ king. He also thought it was an opportunity to help guide men. Elros knew they would fall, but he thought the men of Númenor could serve as a “beacon of hope.” He thought those men might even help save Middle-earth a second time one day. But all his brother Elrond could see was the certain death that awaited his twin.
Prime Video
How Do Elrond and Isildur Meet in Númenor?
When Elrond arrived in Númenor, many, many centuries after his brother had received “The Gift” of Eru Ilúvatar, his face was everywhere. Númenoreans looked at Elrond in awe because the visage of their renowned founding monarch was all over the island. But while they saw the face of Elros in his elf brother, Elrond did not see his brother in them. That only began when he went to Elros’ statue seeking counsel.
That monument, honored nightly with candles, is a sacred spot where the Faithful have met in secret. They are trying to save Númenor from men who have strayed from the path Elros tried to set them on. It’s where Elrond met Isildur, the man who will stand beside him at the end of the Second Age.
Prime Video
Why Is Isildur and Elrond’s Relationship Important in The Rings of Power and The Lord of the Rings
Isildur is a very, very distant relative of Elrond. He comes from the line of the Andúnië, which itself comes from the line of Númenorean kings that began with Elros. But it’s not blood that binds the two. The one aspect of his brother Elrond could not find in those men is Elros’ unquestioned faith in the Valar. But we know few men are as loyal and as faithful to the gods as Isildur. He will take a seedling from the sacred White Tree Nimloth to Middle-earth to carry it forward. There he will help the Faithful continue to live and prosper and to serve the Valar long after Númenor sinks. And his descendant Aragorn will fulfill Elros’ hope when he leads men, elves, and dwarves to stand together against Sauron once again thousands of years later.
Sadly, we know why Sauron will return. Isildur will cut the One Ring from the Dark Lord’s hand at the end of the Second Age, likely where The Rings of Power will conclude its story, but he won’t have the strength to destroy it.
In Peter Jackson’s The Return of the King, Elrond will take his friend into the heart of Mount Doom and beg his friend to cast it into the fires of Mordor after he the One Ring of Sauron’s hand. They will have a dramatic confrontation above the lava, that will ultimately end with Elrond watching the Ring overcome Isildur and turn him to darkness.
In Tolkien’s writings, there is no Mount Doom confrontation between Isildur and Elrond. Instead, Isildur leaves the battlefield with it directly. Elrond and Círdan do counsel him to destroy it, but the whole scene is much less intense. Years later, he will finally realize he cannot be trusted with such power. When he does, Isildur will decide it is his friend Elrond who must take it, but he won’t make it to Rivendell to give it to him. The One Ring will be lost until two hobbits go fishing many years after Isildur’s death.
As for how The Rings of Power will handle these final Second Age moments between Elrond and Isildur, we imagine they will live between the two versions. Prime Video’s show exists somewhere between movies and books, after all.
The Journey Is What Counts for Elrond and Isildur on The Rings of PowerWhat won’t be lost with the One Ring is what Elros gave Middle-earth. He had a dream. It’s a dream the Faithful will fulfill twice. And each time they stand against Sauron, they will prove Elros made the right decision to stand among mortal men doomed to die. Just as he was right when he told his twin he’d always be with him. Elros might have died, but he lived on in the people he felt honored to lead, he lived on Isildur, who is exactly where Elrond needs to find him. An elf and a man will walk the path Elros dreamed of together. We just saw their first step along the way.
The Rings of Power season three is now airing on Prime Video.
Mikey Walsh is a staff writer at Nerdist. You can follow Mikey on Bluesky at @burgermike. And also anywhere someone is ranking the Targaryen kings.The post THE RINGS OF POWER Begins One of Middle-earth’s Most Important Friendships appeared first on Nerdist.
Road Wage
Santa Cruz City Council to consider permanent arena for Warriors
Aquatic Roadkill
Maternity Crisis
NEWS BRIEFS
Free Will Astrology
Who Is Elros in THE RINGS OF POWER? Elrond’s Mortal Twin Brother, Explained
- The Rings of Power season three introduces us to Elrond’s mortal twin brother, Elros.
- Elros plays an incredibly important role in The Lord of the Rings lore becoming the first king of Númenor.
- Elros is also incredibly important to Elrond’s journey in The Rings of Power, inspiring his actions in the Second Age.
The Rings of Power Season three introduces a new character with a familiar face in the form of Elrond’s brother, Elros. The Silmarillion summarizes this critical Tolkien character thusly: “Son of Eärendil and Elwing, who at the end of the First Age chose to be numbered among Men, and became the first King of Númenor.” The book adds that, as king, Elros is called Tar-Minyatur, which is High Elven for “Star-foam.”
Prime Video
If that sounds confusing, we get it. In fact, there are a lot of confusing names and places in Elros’ story. Let’s break down who Elros is and clear up why this guy who “chooses a mortal life” is so important, not just for Prime Video’s The Rings of Power, but for the story of The Lord of the Rings, thousands of years later, too.
Are Elros and Elrond Twin Brothers?Let’s start with a quick clarification. Elros and Elrond aren’t just brothers. They’re twins. That’s why Elros is also played by Robert Aramayo, who has already played Elrond for three seasons of The Rings of Power.
While The Rings of Power is set in the Second Age of Middle-earth, the twins are born in the dark final days of the First Age. (The same period summarized in the opening sequence of The Rings of Power Season 1, Episode 1.) Elrond and Elros separated from their parents (more on them in a minute) at just six years old when they’re captured by their enemies in an Elven civil war. Rather than kill them, though, their captors have pity on them and raise Elrond and Elros, setting them up for two parallel but very different lives.
Were Elros and Elrond Elves or Humans? They Are Actually Half-ElvenElros’ parents are Eärendil and Elwing—two of the most famous people in Tolkien’s legendarium. Eärendil and Elwing are also both half-elven, a term for anyone with both mortal and elven blood in their veins. These two bring together several bloodlines, including Human heroes—specifically a group of good mortals called the Edain. Their family tree also has royal Eldar (aka Elves) and even an angel (or “Maiar,” as they’re called in Tolkien’s world). This is where you get the term “Half-elven,” and it’s why Elros and Elrond get to choose if they want to live a mortal or immortal life.
Prime Video
The Silmarillion sums all this up by saying, “Now Elros and Elrond his brother were descended from the Three Houses of the Edain, but in part also both from the Eldar and the Maiar.” The book adds that death itself is a gift from the Creator God in Tolkien’s world (named Ilúvatar), and that the Valar (i.e., his angelic guardians of the world) didn’t have the right to take away that gift.
Why Did Elrond and Elros Get to Choose Their Fates?Elrond and Elros’ father, Eärendil, performed acts of great bravery in the First Age of Middle-earth. He sailed to Valinor to plead for assistance in the war against Morgoth, calling on them on behalf of both elves and Men. In exchange for his important act, the Valar agreed to let Eärendil and his sons choose whether they wanted to become mortal whose fate is twined with human fates or an immortal whose fates is twined with the fate of the elves.
In The Silmarillion, Tolkien writes, “And he [Manwe] said: ‘In this matter the power of doom is given to me. The peril that he ventured for love of the Two Kindreds shall not fall upon Eärendil, nor shall it fall upon Elwing his wife, who entered into peril for love of him; but they shall not walk again ever among Elves or Men in the Outer Lands. And this is my decree concerning them: to Eärendil and to Elwing, and to their sons, shall be given leave each to choose freely to which kindred their fates shall be joined, and under which kindred they shall be judged.”
So, in the complicated case of the partially mortal, partially immortal Elros and Elrond, each individual was ultimately allowed to choose the fate they wanted. Elrond chooses immortality and lives among the elves, but his brother opts for the mystery of death joining his fate with humanity.
Elros Founds Númenor in The Lord of the RingsTolkien doesn’t give a definitive motivation for Elros choosing mortality. But again, the concept of death as a “gift” is important here. It isn’t until later that Elros’ descendants (Like Trystan Gravelle’s Ar-Pharazôn) start to see death as a bad thing.
Prime Video
Along with the nuanced mystery of death, there’s also the fact that Elros, you know, gets to be a king if he chooses to chase his humanity. And this isn’t just a possibility because he comes from a noble, long-lived lineage. His human kingship is certain from day one because Elros has the trump card of all trump cards: he’s appointed to rule by the gods. The Silmarillion explains, “[Elros] the Valar appointed to be the first King of the Dúnedain.” That means, early in the Second Age, Elros is chosen to lead an expedition of the Edain that sails from Middle-earth to found and live on the newly created island of Númenor. He guides them on their way, following the stars from his boat (hence Elros’ title of Star-foam), and leads them as they start to build a new life on their blessed and protected island home.
Aramayo himself sees Elros’ motivation for choosing a mortal life as closely connected to the people he’s appointed to rule. In an interview with Polygon, he said, “Elros was very close to the people that he led,” adding that Elros thinks “he’s the best person to [lead his people to Númenor].”
How Does Elros Die?It’s also worth pointing out that, despite all the mortality stuff, Elros doesn’t “die” in the way you might expect. He chooses a mortal life and then, like Aragorn long after, gives up that life willingly in the end. The Silmarillion says, “Elros lived five hundred years, and ruled the Númenóreans four hundred years and ten.” The book “Unfinished Tales” adds, “he remained unwearied until he was five hundred years old and then laid down his life … having ruled for 410 years.” That line “laid down his life” isn’t a metaphor. The Númenórean kings are able to surrender their lives and enter death willingly before they become decrepit and lose their faculties due to old age. It’s something Elros models first after almost half a millennium ruling as king.
How Is Elros Related to Aragorn, Elendil, and Isildur in The Lord of the Rings?Elros connects to several important Human heroes in both The Rings of Power and The Lord of the Rings. Elendil (Lloyd Owen), Isildur (Maxim Baldry), and Anárion aren’t heirs to the throne of Númenor, but they’re noblemen and long-lived members of Elros’ royal house.
Prime Video
Eventually, when Númenor is destroyed, they lead a group of ships to the mainland, where they set up two kingdoms, Arnor and Gondor. Their descendants lead those kingdoms during the Second and Third Ages, and it’s their descendants that eventually connect all the way to Aragorn, son of Arathorn. That’s why Viggo Mortensen’s character is shouting names like “Elendil” and “Isildur” in battle an age and a half later — and it’s why he can claim the throne of Gondor.
New Line Cinema
Why Is Elros Important for Elrond in The Rings of Power Season 3?
Along with giving Aragorn a claim to the throne of Gondor thousands of years later, Elros has an important indirect influence on The Rings of Power season three. His loss is still poignantly felt by his immortal brother, Elrond, millennia (or at least centuries) after they’ve been parted by death (the specific timeline is tricky with showrunners JD Payne and Patrick McKay’s compressed timeline).
Prime Video
For Aramayo, playing both Elrond and Elros in The Rings of Power, he drew from this tragic forced parting as part of what has shaped Elrond in the present. “Loss is such a part of his journey,” he said (via Polygon). “Loss and Elrond, they just… seem to be a big part of what Tolkien wrote for him.” The actor added an interesting connection, saying, “Númenor is his brother in the same way that Rivendell is Elrond.” When you boil it down, these brothers, one immortal, the other mortal, separately establish two of the most important strongholds in all of Middle-earth history — and both play different-but-critical roles in this next chapter of Prime Video’s epic Tolkienian Second Age saga.
The Rings of Power season three is now airing on Prime Video.
Jaron Pak writes about movies, TV, games, comics, and all things nerdy for Nerdist.The post Who Is Elros in THE RINGS OF POWER? Elrond’s Mortal Twin Brother, Explained appeared first on Nerdist.
Amy Reimagined
Drawn Together
Word Fest
Humans First
We Talk THAT Kiss with THE RINGS OF POWER Cast & Creators (Exclusive)
Quick Take
- The Rings of Power Season 3’s cast and creators break down Sauron and Celeborn’s kiss.
- Charlie Vickers, Jamie Campbell Bower, Patrick McKay and Charlotte Brändström tell us about Sauron’s motivations and Celeborn’s inner turmoil about the kiss.
- We also get a fun behind-the-scenes story about Charlie Vickers, Jamie Campbell Bower, and Morfydd Clark filming the moment.
Well, who could have predicted this? The Vampire Lestat failed to bring me a queer kiss between two named characters, but somehow The Rings of Power season three delivered. Yes, in The Rings of Power season three, episode six, Celeborn and Sauron kiss. And they don’t just kiss as Sauron pretending to be Galadriel, either. No, they kiss as Sauron and Celeborn. And, you know what, I accept this offering on my altar from my favorite show. Of course, queer-coded villains and stolen, manipulative kisses should not be the be-all and end-all of queer representation on our screens. But if I ask myself, who is happy about this? I’m going to say, queer people in fandom, especially those who ship DarkSilver. And if I ask myself, who probably isn’t happy about this? Well, you know. But as a person with one foot firmly in transformative fandom who is definitely pleased with this kiss in The Rings of Power season three, I had to ask Charlie Vickers, Jamie Campbell Bower, and Showrunner Patrick McKay for all the details.
Prime Video
Charlie Vickers Explains Why Sauron Went In for the Celeborn Kiss
Charlie Vickers, who plays Sauron, laughs when I ask about the Celeborn and Sauron kiss and says, “It was a lot of fun. I mean, I get to kiss Jamie!” Who wouldn’t want to kiss Jamie? I opine. And Vickers nods, delighted, “Exactly.”
But when I push to unpack all the elements of the kiss in The Rings of Power: Sauron becoming Galadriel, kissing Galadriel’s husband as his ex, extracting the information from Celeborn, kissing him again as himself… We get a bit more serious. Vickers shares he really considered the sequence, especially the part where Sauron transforms back into himself only to kiss Celeborn again, truly needlessly, if information extraction was all he was in for. He reveals, “I think it is like Sauron is twisting the knife. I thought about it a lot because he’s got what he wanted by that point. Celeborn has confessed. He’s told him how he can forge the One Ring. And at that point, Sauron could be like, ‘Thank you,’ change back into Sauron and walk away. But I think Sauron kisses Celeborn to humiliate him, to just really push the knife into… It’s like an ego boost for him almost, like a power thing.”
‘It Was Bliss,’ Charlie Vickers Breaks Down Whether Sauron Is Open to a King and QueenWe then briefly meditate on the vision of Sauron’s line to Celeborn after the kiss: “And I thought it was bliss when Galadriel submitted to my will.” Which, I think, reveals something quite queer about Sauron. I ask him if Sauron would be open to having both a King and Queen by his side. Vickers laughs and says that when it comes to Galadriel and Sauron, “I thought about this a lot, with Sauron basically pitching his rule to Galadriel over and over again. I think that it’s kind of like… They would be King and Queen, but… he would call all the shots. And so I think ultimately he would’ve ruled by himself, and I don’t think it would’ve worked in the long run… For him to share power.” What about the short run, though? Inquiring minds must know.
A trio for the ages. pic.twitter.com/aI8LuMU2Ds
— The Rings of Power (@TheRingsofPower) November 17, 2026Speaking on the Celeborn part of the equation, Vickers tells me what I already knew: That an immortal being like Sauron needs to keep things interesting because he’s been alive for so long. Vickers explains, “I see the bliss bit as him basically saying, ‘It’s a fun thing.’ Because Sauron has been through so much. He’s seen everything. He must be so desensitized to everything. That finding pure… entertainment must be really hard for him.” When one has been around since the dawn of time, experimenting to find bliss is the name of the game. Realizing he’s gone maybe a little too deep into character, Vickers laughs and apologizes. But I support Sauron’s queer rights to wrongs. It is my strong belief every immortal is queer at heart, if for no other reason than they’d get bored otherwise. That one’s for you DarkSilver fans, and all fans of queer Sauron, free of charge.
Jamie Campbell Bower Explains What the Kiss Scene Does to Celeborn on The Rings of PowerJamie Campbell Bower, meanwhile, tells me about Celeborn’s side of the story when it comes to the Sauron kiss. He echoes Vickers’ thoughts, noting, “Charlie and I have spoken about it a lot, and I think that Charlie feels like it’s this kind of final knife twist into Celeborn where he’s like, ‘Got you, got you.'”
Prime Video
And Bower teases the moment has a huge impact on Celeborn that doesn’t quickly fade, “I mean, I think that my immediate reaction as the actor was, there’s this level of like, ‘Oh fuck, I’ve given away the one thing I had to hold onto.’ And that continues for me. That feeling continues for me throughout the subsequent episodes.” A feeling the Bower defines as “Guilt. It’s total guilt. I’ve done the one thing that I shouldn’t have done. I’ve given away the secret, and it’s like, ‘damn.'”
Does Celeborn Know He Is Kissing Sauron and Not Galadriel?Bower also confirms that Celeborn sees Sauron in the scene; that Sauron isn’t just reappearing for the audience but for Celeborn himself. Celeborn fully knows he’s been deceived by (and kissing) the enemy. And the kiss wasn’t happening just in his head.
Charlie Vickers, Jamie Campbell Bower, and Morfydd Clark Had a Blast Filming the KissMorfydd Clark, Jamie Campbell Bower & Charlie Vickers 🖤 pic.twitter.com/uzJQFYyxBS
— Morfydd Clark News (@morfyddclarknws) November 17, 2026But as Jamie Campbell Bower, the person, filming the kiss scene with Charlie Vickers and Morfydd Clark was a blast during The Rings of Power‘s production. Bower chuckles at the memory and notes, “It was brilliant to shoot. It looks great. Charlie had the iPad and had to kind of arrange himself perfectly, because Morfydd and I were first, and so Charlie had to get himself into the exact position.” It sounds like this love-triangle trio shared many laughs behind the scenes.
Patrick McKay Explains How the Sauron/Celeborn Kiss Arrived on The Rings of PowerTo conclude, The Rings of Power showrunner Patrick McKay shares that the idea of a kind of panning reveal was actually an integral part of the vision of the season. He noted of the kiss scene, “I do remember very early on, we had the idea of an extended interrogation and torture. And then we had an idea at a certain point that Sauron could use his deception. And I remember pitching the camera moving around to reveal. And then we would even pitch that when we pitched the studio, what the season would be. So that’s an idea that came very early in the writers’ room, but I can’t remember who pitched it. So I’m going to say it was Justin Doble, our amazing EP writer-producer.” Shout out to Justin Doble!
Prime Video
As to why a Celeborn and Sauron kiss in The Rings of Power season three, McKay reveals, “Well, what I would say is, my co-showrunner JD Payne, and I, we really challenged ourselves this season. We wanted to have greater psychological depth. We wanted to have more interiority in the characters. We wanted to have more complex relationships. And I think some of these things come out of thinking, ‘What are the possible dynamics that could emerge from it?'” And what dynamics they are, indeed.
View this post on InstagramUltimately, we have to agree with Executive Producer Charlotte Brändström, who concludes our conversation by saying, “The trio scenes are special.”
And that’s what the cast and creators had to say about that DarkSilver kiss. For more on what I had to say about it, stay tuned for my article coming soon, which tackles the age-old question, “Is Sauron queer?”
The Rings of Power season three is now airing on Prime Video.
Rotem Rusak is the Editor-in-Chief at Nerdist. She is a great lover of the anti-hero and is always ready for a new ship to set sail. In her work, she likes to combine fandom passion with journalistic sensibilities. Follow her on Instagram.The post We Talk THAT Kiss with THE RINGS OF POWER Cast & Creators (Exclusive) appeared first on Nerdist.
What Does Sauron Need to Forge the One Ring in THE RINGS OF POWER?
This post contains major spoilers from The Rings of Power season three, episodes five and six, and discusses what Sauron needs in order to forge the One Ring. If you want to avoid this information until you watch, you can check out our coverage of the first four episodes instead. Also read our spoiler-free review of the season.
Prime Video
Quick Take
- The Rings of Power revealed exactly what Sauron needs to forge the One Ring and why he needs Mount Doom to craft the powerful piece.
- Sauron tricked Celeborn into telling him that the secret to the elven rings was gold and silver from Valinor.
- Nerdist’s Take: The light of Eru Ilúvatar continues to be the most powerful force in all of Middle-earth, even when used for evil.
Sauron was always going to forge the One Ring on The Rings of Power. Now we finally know how he will craft Middle-earth’s most famous piece of jewelry. In season three’s sixth episode, he tricked Celeborn into revealing the secret to forging the One Ring: gold and silver from Valinor. Though it seemed like that secret died with the last surviving elven smith from Eregion at Gundabad, she told Celeborn that Celebrimbor made the three elven rings by using that precious metal from Valinor, the realm of the gods. Rare as gold and silver from Valinor is, Sauron already has some in his possession in the shape of Fëanor’s hammer. More importantly, he knows the one way to harness both to forge the One Ring. And it’s why Mount Doom is also the only place anyone can destroy the One Ring.
Prime Video
How Did Sauron Discover the Secret Needed to Forge the One Ring?
The Deceiver lived up to his moniker when he appeared in the form of Galadriel to fool Celeborn into revealing the secret he held inside of him. The elf had made his fellow captive, Maitalle, tell him everything she knew about his wife, including the story of forging the Elven Rings. After all, Galadriel arrived at Eregion towards the end of season one and was part of the creation of the three rings. Thus, she brought the forging of the Rings of Power into the tales the elven smith told Celeborn during their time together in Gundabad.
Using his Galadriel disguise on an already weakened Celeborn, Sauron convinced Celeborn to reveal this secret of the rings and learned exactly what he needed to forge the One Ring. (But not before sharing a kiss with Celeborn.)
What Does Sauron Need to Forge the One Ring?As mentioned, to forge the One Ring, Sauron needs gold and silver from Valinor. These ingredients have been eluding Sauron in all his ring-forging attempts so far, leading to Rings of Power that don’t control, but only destroy. In this way, Sauron’s previous ring attempts seem to have been unbalanced, containing too much darkness.
In the case of the Elven Rings of Power, Galadriel gave Celebrimbor the dagger that once belonged to her brother Finrod. He died fighting Sauron during the First Age. Galadriel’s quest for vengeance blinded her to Halbrand’s true identity until it was too late. But she finally seemed to let go of her all-consuming anger when she sacrificed Finrod’s dagger, so Celebrimbor could help the elves restore the fading light of the Valar to their realms in Middle-earth. Celebrimbor was able to do that with the three elven rings he crafted because Finrod’s dagger had been made in Valinor itself. The gold and silver it possessed were pure and powerful. It was also made by Celebrimbor’s grandfather, the greatest elven smith ever, the famed Fëanor. He created the silmarils and the palantiri. And he did so with his legendary hammer, which Sauron already possesses. A hammer made of… gold and silver from Eregion… Uh oh.
We have to say, we find it fascinating that Fëanor, whom Celebrimbor so wanted to surpass as he forged Rings for dwarves and men, is also in a roundabout way now responsible for the forging of the One Ring as well.
Prime Video
With Gold and Silver From Valinor and the Powers of Mount Doom, the One Ring Will Soon Be Forged
The specter of Celebrimbor, which had haunted and mocked Sauron earlier in season three, returned in episode six of The Rings of Power as the Dark Lord realized the key to forging the One Ring. Fëanor’s hammer has both pure gold and silver from Valinor. But forget a forge, not even dragon fire could “stain the surface” of it. Metals you can’t melt are no use in forging any gold ring, let alone one so powerful it can rule them all. But Sauron has something that can melt the hammer: Mount Doom. And that means Sauron has everything he needs now to forge the One Ring.
We’ve always known Sauron would forge that evil entity in the fires of Mordor. It’s why the only place anyone will ever be able to destroy the ring is in them. The very thing that will give Sauron the power he craves so much will also be what ultimately destroys him. And when Sauron is destroyed, something pure and good from Valinor, the greatest power the world ever knew, a power Sauron will soon lock away in his ring, will burn free. Not even the One Ring can be made without the light of Eru Ilúvatar.
The Rings of Power season three is now airing on Prime Video.
Mikey Walsh is a staff writer at Nerdist. He would reject the One Ring because he’s not a big jewelry guy. You can follow Mikey on Bluesky at @burgermike. And also anywhere someone is ranking the Targaryen kings.The post What Does Sauron Need to Forge the One Ring in THE RINGS OF POWER? appeared first on Nerdist.








