This RINGS OF POWER Season 3 Death Breaks Our Hearts
Quick Take
- In The Rings of Power season three, Arondir met his death, breaking our hearts.
- Arondir, played by Ismael Cruz Córdova, brought a very specific elveness steeped in compassion to the series that no other elf possesses.
- Arondir was also a representative character on many levels, and we wish he could have gotten a happy ending.
We thought that we were immune to having our hearts broken further by The Rings of Power after Adar died in season two. But we were foolish, really, to think that. In The Rings of Power season three, Arondir is killed by his adopted son, Theo, who has taken one of Sauron’s nine Rings for Men. Somehow, before the season began, we assumed Arondir wasn’t in any present danger. We suppose elves seem so naturally eternal that it didn’t seem seriously possible for one of them to die on us. Of course, being an original The Rings of Power character and not a character from the lore did leave Arondir in a certain amount of jeopardy. But DEATH? Did Arondir truly have to meet death in The Rings of Power? It shatters our hearts to know we won’t be seeing any more from this incredible character.
Prime Video
We’ve often described Arondir as the elfiest elf in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power. And we feel Arondir’s death leaves behind a hard-to-fill absence in the elven lineup on The Rings of Power. We love Galadriel, Elrond, Gil-galad, Círdan, and Celeborn—but they are all High Elves, and their stature makes them feel a bit less warm, in a sense. They’re naturally somewhat removed from the world and its hardships. Arondir was not only truly in tune with nature and growing things, but also had a capacity for love in his heart that struck us as truly Tolkienian. He was grounded in the world the way other elves are not, and he saw the potential not only in Elvendom, but in the Kingdoms of Men, and even in Uruk Nation, despite his many reservations and reasons to dislike them. There was a compassion in Arondir that struck us as befitting of Tolkien’s most goodly creatures of light.
Arondir actor Ismael Cruz Córdova shared with us, “Arondir has compassion, and he has curiosity, and I think that one comes before the other. I think curiosity can lead you to compassion. Curiosity can lead you to many, many positive places, really. And that’s what he’s had with Adar. And I think he has that with humans, and I think he brings that always to himself, distills that into a being.” Who will bring this necessary compassion to the table after Arondir’s death? It’s a question we’re not sure we have the answer to yet.
Prime Video
In The Rings of Power, the elves are occupied with many pursuits, with war, with fighting evil, with the machinations of politics and survival, but Arondir was always first occupied with love. More than most elves, he sought to understand the world around him and to let it into his heart. He cared, if anything, too deeply and for too many others.
And this sensibility seemed to come right from Cruz Córdova himself, who always wanted to be an elf. In previous interviews, Cruz Córdova told us:
I had a very long-standing desire to be an elf. And what drew me to be an elf is… I don’t know, nature or nurture, I can’t tell; it’s a chicken-and-egg kind of thing. I grew up in the mountains in Puerto Rico, very rural. I was very contemplative. I didn’t really have a lot of friends, and I was a little bullied in school, a little… I was quite bullied in school. But also my environment growing up poor, and we didn’t have a TV, and, so I spent a lot of time just outside and by myself. I was sketching, and playing with flowers, and making ink out of flowers, and climbing trees. And one of my best friends was a mango tree that I loved, absolutely loved. I would climb it every afternoon and do my homework there after school.
And once I got my hands on The Lord of the Rings and the movies, it felt so familiar. The elves felt so familiar to me, with the reverence that they have for nature, and the whimsy and the contemplation. I would look at the clouds and just try to figure out “What is that?” I was mesmerized by everything: these giants, and the sun, and the soil, and I still am. I respect and revere it. So yeah, that’s what drew me to want to be one.
And every aspect of these many variables that made Arondir and Ismael Cruz Córdova into the perfect elven character shows through on our screen. An actor doesn’t have to literally be an elf to play an elf, we suppose. But it certainly doesn’t hurt when that is the case, as it was here. We feel Cruz Córdova’s resonance with what it means to be an elf made Arondir more dimensional and believable, and drew us to his romantic, soft heart. It made us ache when Arondir, riddled with remorse, apologized to a tree before chopping it down. It made our hearts clench with grief for him when Bronwyn died. And it made us yearn for the beautiful ending where ARONDIR AND MARNÛKH ESCAPE GUNDABAD SIDE BY SIDE AND GO OPEN AN INN TOGETHER!!! (I am never letting this vision go, okay? Okay.) It made our hearts break when Arondir met his death in The Rings of Power season three, however beautifully.
Prime Video
It’s also critical to cheer on Cruz Córdova’s Arondir for being the first non-white elf in an adaptation of Tolkien’s texts. Cruz Córdova self-identifies as Afro-Puerto Rican and Afro-Latino as well as a “neurospicy” person, and the importance of his casting as an elf cannot be overstated. For too long, roles that should belong to everyone have been given only to the narrowest population of people. Seeing Ismael Cruz Córdova play Arondir was such a tremendously beautiful experience, and we truly mourn the ending of that representation on our screens. A representation that was so meaningful to so many groups. Truly, in the place of death, we wish that Arondir could have ridden off into the sunset of The Rings of Power filled with joy. We need more elves that represent all of us in mainstream fantasy series. And we really need them to get happy endings.
In our hearts, we know that after his death in The Rings of Power, Arondir got on the express train to the Halls of Mandos, where he was whisked right back to Valinor in the blink of an eye. And this express train better not make any unnecessary stops, so Ismael Cruz Córdova and Arondir can return to Middle-earth just in time to save the day on The Rings of Power—death be damned. Yes? Yes.
Namárië, Arondir. You will be missed.
The Rings of Power season three is now airing on Prime Video.
Rotem Rusak is the Editor-in-Chief at Nerdist. She is a great lover of the anti-hero and is always ready for a new ship to set sail. In her work, she likes to combine fandom passion with journalistic sensibilities. Follow her on Instagram.The post This RINGS OF POWER Season 3 Death Breaks Our Hearts appeared first on Nerdist.
Shipping giant Maersk probes 'IT security incident,' data theft
Shipping behemoth A.P. Moller-Maersk says it is investigating "an IT security incident" involving the potential theft of data from a legacy system.
In a statement issued on Wednesday, the Denmark-based shipping, cargo, and logistics giant confirmed it immediately launched an investigation into the attack and the affected system was secured.
"Our findings so far strongly suggest no sensitive data has been disclosed," the company said.
"The incident is isolated to a local system, and we have found no indication that there has been any impact on other Maersk systems or customer and partner systems that connect to Maersk through integrations such as APIs and EDI."
Maersk described the legacy local system as one "from a previous acquisition," and said it does not expect the attack to have an effect on operations.
Customers were reassured that they can continue to use Maersk platforms to manage their shipments as usual, and to expect updates from the company as and when they're available.
"Cybersecurity remains a constant, ongoing priority for Maersk," it added. "We have rigorous processes in place to identify and prevent incidents and minimize customer impact.
"As always, please treat any unexpected communications claiming to relate to this matter with caution and verify them through your usual Maersk contact.
"Thank you for your patience as we continue to investigate the incident."
Fortunately for those who immediately feel uneasy after hearing "Maersk" and "IT security" mentioned in the same breath, the wording of the shipping giant's disclosure suggests this intrusion won't be as calamitous as the NotPetya disaster in 2017.
Mimicking the Petya ransomware strain, NotPetya was an infamous destructive wiper malware strain that wormed its way across the global economy.
Western intelligence agencies attributed the malware to Russia's Sandworm group, an outfit believed to be part of the country's military intelligence service (GRU).
Maersk said at the time that it expected the attack to result in a circa $300 million bill, owing to remediation and rebuild costs.
Offering a sense of scale, Jim Hagemann Snabe, then chair of Maersk, told World Economic Forum delegates in 2018 that the company's rebuild encompassed 4,000 new servers, 45,000 new PCs, and 2,500 applications – which he said had been completed over just ten days.
In 2020, as exclusively revealed by The Register, Maersk went on to lay off around 150 staffers from its command and control center in Maidenhead, England. The staffers who lost their jobs had played key roles in the recovery. ®
The Democratic Tsunami Is a “Sea Change” for Reproductive Rights
A huge Democratic majority in Congress. Six new Democratic state trifectas and governorships. Five new Democratic attorneys general. At least 545 additional state legislative seats.
Reproductive rights leaders have spent the past week trying to wrap their heads around the enormity of the Democratic tsunami and how it could reshape the national abortion-rights landscape.
In states that have seen reproductive access drastically curtailed since the end of Roe v. Wade, newly empowered Democratic governors and lawmakers could repeal abortion restrictions, codify new protections, and work toward enshrining reproductive freedom in state constitutions. Democratic attorneys general could stop enforcing draconian laws that threaten abortion providers and helpers with prosecution and reject efforts to criminalize pregnancy loss.
In Congress, even with Donald Trump in the White House, Democrats will have vast new powers to pass federal abortion-rights bills, claw back cuts to Medicaid and healthcare funding, and block confirmation of anti-abortion federal judges and far-right cabinet nominees. They could use the budget reconciliation process to try to eliminate the 50-year-old Hyde Amendment, which bans federal funding for abortion—one of the repro-rights movement’s most cherished priorities. And in the likely event Trump tried to thwart these efforts, they could use his expected vetoes to attack Republicans in the 2028 elections. Democrats have an opportunity to make abortion and reproductive health a breakthrough issue “in a way they haven’t been able to before,” says abortion historian Mary Ziegler of the University of California, Davis. “If people want this kind of legislation, and the only thing preventing it from happening is who’s in the White House—that’s a good campaign message.”
Monica Simpson, executive director of the pioneering reproductive justice group SisterSong, realized just how much her world has changed when she flew home to Atlanta a few days after the election. “When I was walking through the airport, I realized, ‘Oh, snap, I’m coming back to a different Georgia’”—one in which Democrats flipped the state House and took every statewide office on the ballot. Seven out of the eight winners—from Gov.-elect Keisha Lance Bottoms to new Attorney General Tanya Miller to incoming Insurance Commissioner Keisha Sean Waites—are Black women. Almost immediately, Lance Bottoms pledged to tackle the state’s maternal health crisis, including expanding Medicaid and working to repeal a six-week abortion ban that has been deadly for Black mothers.
“Here is an opportunity for a new way of thinking about how we do our work, to be more visionary and imaginative and innovative about [helping] our community.”
Now, instead of fighting with conservative politicians, Simpson and her fellow advocates can start advancing policies aimed at counteracting decades of slashed budgets and attacks on basic healthcare. “Here is an opportunity for a new way of thinking about how we do our work,” Simpson says, “to be more visionary and imaginative and innovative about [helping] our community”—the complete opposite of the “very reactionary, defensive position” that’s been the norm for abortion rights groups in the South.
Repro leaders in other states long controlled by conservatives are grappling with similar feelings of excitement—and disbelief. “I’m a native Texan, and as long as I’ve been able to read, I’ve never lived in a blue state,” says Raven E. Freeborn, CEO of the abortion rights nonprofit Avow Texas, one of many groups that worked for the Democratic wave that elected James Talarico to the US Senate and Gina Hinojosa to the governor’s mansion. “And so, for me, this is, wow.”
It’s a moment that not even the most determined optimists in the repro rights movement saw coming. “If anyone tells you they planned for this, they expected it—they’re full of shit,” Mini Timmaraju, president and CEO of Reproductive Freedom for All, said on an Abortion Every Day livestream. Not that she’s complaining: “Voters delivered an unmistakable mandate for reproductive freedom majorities to deliver protections up and down the ballot,” she said at a press briefing this week. “Democrats must be bold and put Republicans on the record if they stand against the protections that an overwhelming majority of voters support.”
The biggest surprise of the midterms, of course, came in Texas. The state that has enacted the most radical anti-abortion policies in the country went for pro-choice Democrats up and down the ballot, from the governorship to the supreme court to the House of Representatives. Even the state Senate, which remains under Republican control, will have a new Democratic leader helping to shape its agenda, Lt. Gov.-elect Vikki Goodwin. (Incumbent Dan Patrick, the anti-abortion hardliner Goodwin defeated, is urging Republicans to strip her of the powers that have made him one of the most powerful lieutenant governors in the country.)
The day after winning his race, incoming Texas attorney general Nathan Johnson announced he would stop suing out-of-state abortion providers for sending abortion pills to the state—ending a practice that his predecessor, failed Senate candidate Ken Paxton, obsessively pursued. Johnson criticized the spread of local “abortion trafficking” ordinances that make it illegal to help someone access care, and he’s expected to pull the state out of federal lawsuits against Planned Parenthood and the Food and Drug Administration over the abortion drug mifepristone.
“I cannot tell you how powerful and important this is, given that Ken Paxton was essentially running the law firm for the anti-abortion movement out of the Texas attorney general’s office,” Timmaraju says. “This is a huge sea change.”
In Kansas, Attorney General Kris Kobach—whose extreme views on voting rights and immigration as well as abortion made him a MAGA hero—lost to an ex-prosecutor who claims zero interest in the culture wars. The election of Democrat Chris Mann likely means that Kansas’s participation in yet another federal lawsuit challenging the FDA’s approval and regulation of mifepristone is over.
New state trifectas offer the biggest opportunities for Democrats to expand acces to reproductive care. In Pennsylvania and Wisconsin, Gov. Josh Shapiro and Gov.-elect David Crowley have promised to use the powers that come with full control of state government to codify abortion rights and enshrine constitutional protections. In Michigan and Arizona, new trifectas will make it possible to fulfill the promise of abortion ballot measures that passed in 2022 and 2024 but were blocked from being fully implemented by Republican lawmakers.
Even in states where Republicans remain firmly in charge, Democratic gains could have real impact. In at least six states, Democrats cracked GOP supermajorities in one or both legislative chambers, creating new opportunities to thwart anti-abortion bills—and in the case of Ohio and Iowa, strengthening the hands of newly elected Democratic governors.
“This was a bold-change election,” says Nourbese Flint, president of the reproductive justice group All* Above All. “There is an opportunity to move [legislation] in the states in ways that have not happened before. Even in places where there is shared governance, that creates a whole new world, because where before, Republicans were able to [pass] policies without talking to anybody, now they can get blocked on it, they have to come back to the negotiating table.”
It’s also a moment full of new perils. Reproductive rights leaders are bracing for Trump administration officials, who tried to defuse abortion as a midterms issue, to start becoming more aggressive. “Once the midterms are over and it’s truly lame-duck time,” one unnamed conservative told the Washington Sun last month, “we’ve heard the gloves will be off.” The FDA, for example, is widely expected to try to clamp down on abortion pills, while the Justice Department could attempt to revive the Comstock Act, the Victorian-era obscenity law that, if enforced, would amount to a nationwide abortion ban.
But any such move would result in “serious blowback” for Trump and his political allies, says Drexel University legal scholar David Cohen. Since the Dobbs decision in 2022, voters have weighed in on 22 abortion ballot measures around the country, including three in Virginia, Missouri, and Nevada last week, with the pro-choice side winning 60 percent of all votes. “It’s pretty compelling evidence that the American people want abortion rights,” Cohen says. “Any other 60-40 vote we would say was a landslide.”
We have now had 22 statewide abortion ballot initiatives since Dobbs.The American people have spoken:
— David S. Cohen (@dsc250.bsky.social) 2026-11-04T15:42:34.024ZStill, with Stephen Miller elevated to Trump’s chief of staff and Todd Blanche in charge at the DOJ, abortion-rights groups are intent on fortifying their firewalls. “As long as Trump holds executive and veto powers, we have more work than celebrating to do,” says Brittany Fonteno, president and CEO of the National Abortion Federation. “The next two years will be a critical time to prepare for the kind of governing power that will deliver real and lasting reproductive freedom.”
Aside from Trump administration policies, All Above* All’s Flint says, one of the biggest risks that Democrats face—in Congress and the states, on reproductive rights and other issues—is not doing enough to address the real-world problems that drove so many people to vote blue.
“For all of the elected officials that are thinking, ‘Well, we’re just going to go back to things as usual,’ that is a dangerous precedent,” she says. “If we should take anything from [this election], it’s that people are hungry—and I would say almost desperate—to have actual change and to see [their leaders] fighting for something that is different than what we’ve had.”
“If folks feel like, they came out to vote and their lives got worse,” she adds, “I cannot imagine the backlash that is going to happen in 2028.”
Father pleads for help finding daughter swept out to sea at Panther State Beach
On a warm Tuesday afternoon, Kwanghyon Park, whose 24-year-old daughter, Senah Park, was swept out to sea at Panther Beach on Sunday evening, stood with family members atop the cliff overlooking the ocean. Cries and sobs rose above the sound of waves crashing against the shore
A photo of Senah Park the day she got swept out to sea.
Shortly after Kwanghyon Park spoke with Lookout Santa Cruz, around 30 family members and friends walked to the cliff overlooking Panther Beach to gather around Park, bowing their heads in prayer and embracing one another.
Over 30 family and friends gathered at the cliffs above Panther Beach to mourn the loss of 24-year old Senah Park. Credit: Kevin Painchaud / Lookout Santa Cruz
Kwanghyon Park, father of Senah Park, prays while surrounded by family and friends on Tuesday afternoon, Nov. 10, 2026, on the cliffs above Panther Beach. Credit: Kevin Painchaud / Lookout Santa Cruz
A California State Parks vehicle is parked Tuesday on the cliffs above Panther Beach as family members and friends mourn 24-year-old Senah Park, who was swept out to sea Sunday night. Credit: Kevin Painchaud / Lookout Santa Cruz
“Anyone who’s hiking or in the area, please keep your eyes open for our beloved Senah,” Park pleaded. “Just pray for us.”
Senah had come to Santa Cruz County with five friends to celebrate a birthday. After lunch at a Korean barbecue restaurant in San Jose, the group arrived at Panther Beach with firewood, drinks and a guitar. They walked down to a secluded cove and built a small bonfire.
Family members and friends gather to mourn 24-year-old Senah Park on the cliffs above Panther Beach on Tuesday, Nov. 10, 2026. The Keyhole, a narrow coastal passage through which Park’s friends escaped before she was swept out to sea Sunday night, is visible below. Credit: Kevin Painchaud / Lookout Santa Cruz
As darkness fell, four of the six friends decided to leave early. While making their way toward the beach’s Keyhole area, they were struck by waves that knocked them off their feet. Three made it back to shore, one with a dislocated shoulder. The last trace of Senah they saw was the light from her cellphone in the darkness, her father said.
The Keyhole, which connects to Panther Beach, where Senah Park’s friends were able to escape the rising tide. Credit: Kevin Painchaud / Lookout Santa Cruz
A 911 call was made around 8:40 p.m., Park said. Sheriff’s deputies arrived within minutes, and the Coast Guard joined the search closer to 10 p.m. Crews searched through the night and resumed Monday morning.
A sign posted at the entrance of Panther beach warning of the risk of becoming trapped during a high tide. Credit: Kevin Painchaud / Lookout Santa Cruz
On Tuesday, the Coast Guard announced it had suspended active search operations after an extensive effort Monday. Crews searched approximately 95 square miles over about eight hours using a helicopter, boats and a drone pilot. The Santa Cruz County Sheriff’s Office, Santa Cruz Fire Department and California State Parks also assisted. Officials cited the scope of the search and ocean conditions in their decision, saying the search could resume if new information emerges.
With the official search suspended, Park and his family turned to the public for help. Between 35 and 40 family members and friends had divided into four groups to walk more than 10 miles of coastline, searching for any sign of Senah.
A missing person poster with the photo of Senah Park posted above Panther Beach. Credit: Kevin Painchaud / Lookout Santa Cruz
Park planned to drive along the coast, distributing missing-person flyers and speaking with surfers, whom he hoped might spot something from the water or shore.
“She could be anywhere from Monterey to San Mateo,” he said.
Park said he did not know whether it would take a day, a week or longer to find his daughter. Standing above the ocean with loved ones, he asked the community to keep looking.
“Pray that her spirit is with God,” he said, “and pray that they bring her body back to us so she can have a proper burial.”
A friend of Senah Park looks out over the Pacific Ocean on Tuesday from the cliffs above Panther Beach, where Park was swept out to sea Sunday night. Credit: Kevin Painchaud / Lookout Santa Cruz
Screenshot
The post Father pleads for help finding daughter swept out to sea at Panther State Beach appeared first on Lookout Santa Cruz.
The best things I ate and drank in Santa Cruz County in October
Santa Cruz County business: Biotech company acquired; Joby lands more Air Force funding
Google gooses Python AI performance by... removing Python
"Train in Python, serve in C++" might as well be Google's motto when it comes to much of its ML work.
Python is easy for data scientists to wield, but keeping its interpreter in the serving pipeline can add overhead and deployment headaches. The industry-backed OpenXLA Project provides tools for compiling machine learning computations into native code for different processors.
The latest component of this setup to be open sourced is XSE, short for the XLA Serving Engine.
One-shot inferenceXSE is not so much suited for large-scale LLM inference (which would be better served by vLLM or SGLang), but rather for smaller, more sharply task-oriented models, of which there are plenty at Google.
"LLM serving gets most of the attention right now, but a significant amount of production inference is still ranking, recommendation, embedding, and vision models. These tend to be short requests with very high [queries-per-second] and tight latency budgets," Nathan Beach, Google director of product management, wrote in a LinkedIn missive Tuesday.
At Google, XSE already handles more than six million queries per second across services including YouTube Shorts, Google Ads, and Search.
These models aren't there for a leisurely chat. They rank results, recommend videos, and make other decisions on the fly, often without users noticing.
A Python interpreter mulling each request would be a bottleneck, if not the end of Google itself. In Google's tests on short requests, XSE delivered two to five times the throughput of its best optimized Python server, using a quarter of the memory.
No Python hereIn this setup, the ML boffins write their model code in Python, using Google's JAX to help with the sums. Google also plans integration with TorchTPU so PyTorch users can export models for C++ serving on TPUs. An export tool packages the model's computations in StableHLO, a portable intermediate representation, alongside its trained weights in an "XLA SavedModel."
Ready to precognate, the C++ serving runtime uses XLA to compile those computations into native code for the target silicon. No Python interpreter to see here.
XLA SavedModels can run on GPUs and CPUs – Google partnered with both Arm and Intel to develop the XLA ecosystem. But Google obviously thinks it'd be a lot cooler if you ran your models on its own line of TPU accelerators.
Python's sluggishness continues to be an issue for the ML community. Beyond XSE, other approaches have been taken, many of which involve jettisoning the Python code as quickly as possible. PyTorch offers a native C++ runtime called LibTorch. Also, Microsoft and its collaborators offer the ONNX Runtime, which supports an open graph format with Python bindings.
Even Python's own reference implementation relies heavily on C, with Rust now getting a foot in the door. ®
The 2026 Lookout List: Food & Drink Experiences
Nvidia’s in Bed With a Chinese Spy—and Trump’s in Bed With Nvidia
On November 8, Jensen Huang, founder and chief executive of the AI chip company Nvidia, admitted publicly that he got caught in a Chinese honey trap. Huang had an extramarital affair with Alice Huang (no relation; she’s sometimes identified as Huang Le, her Chinese name). Alice Huang was a top executive at a Singapore-based data center company called Megaspeed. The United States government believes Alice Huang is a Chinese spy and that Megaspeed illegally diverted to China AI chips purchased from Nvidia. (Megaspeed denies this.) The stock market thinks there’s something to these allegations; as I write, Nvidia is on track to lose nearly half a trillion dollars in market value since its chief executive copped to the affair. (He is unusually difficult to fire.) Huang himself is down more than $17 billion and must now make do on a net worth of $146 billion, and possibly a lot less than that if his wife divorces him.
Jensen Huang getting caught in bed with Alice Huang is certainly interesting. But President Donald Trump getting caught (figuratively) in bed with Jensen Huang is much more interesting.
Jensen Huang happens to be one of Trump’s closest advisers on tech matters. A Reuters reporter recalls seeing the Nvidia chief’s name pop up on Trump’s cell phone in December 2025. Trump took Huang on his May 2025 trip to the Middle East, on his September 2025 visit to the United Kingdom, and on his May 2026 trip to China. In this last instance Huang accompanied Trump on Air Force One at Trump’s personal request. We know that because Trump announced it on Truth Social, identifying the man as “the Great Jensen Huang.” On Monday Trump told reporters he’d phoned his Nvidia bestie earlier that day and asked, “’Did you have any idea that she was a spy?’ He said, ‘I had no idea that she was a spy,’ and I really believe him.”
Twice before Monday, and probably more like three times, Trump was told that Huang’s lover was a suspected Chinese spy. The first time was in October 2025, according to The New York Times. Trump “chose not to do anything with the information,” the Times reported, because he was “wary of disrupting Nvidia’s chip sales, which are helping to drive the economy and the stock market, and of further complicating the trading relationship with China.”
The probable second time Trump got told about Huang’s pecadilloes was in a memo that Secretary of State Marco Rubio drafted last spring, according to The Times. The memo in effect warned: Keep your distance from Jensen Huang. The Times reported that the memo was circulated to “top Trump administration officials.” But it’s impossible to believe Trump was kept out of the loop, because when Huang was initially excluded from the China trip (almost certainly for this reason) Trump objected and reversed that decision. According to a new Times report, Rubio told Trump verbally about Huang’s honey trap as Air Force One was preparing to leave for China. In the Times tally, Trump was told twice. In my (slightly more speculative) tally, Trump was told three times.
On Monday, Trump said he didn’t recall being told even once about Huang’s worrisome romantic entanglement. That suggests either that Trump is too senile to remember such things or too stupidly defiant to maintain a prudent distance. I lean toward the second interpretation because Trump is, somehow, still defending the guy. “I believe he’s suffering greatly,” Trump told the reporters. “He built a great company, American company, and I think he’s a very honorable guy. And I feel very confident that he’ll be in good shape.”
For Trump, all friendships are transactional. In Huang’s case, the chronology went like this. In April 2025, the Trump White House denied Nvidia’s bid to export H200 chips to China. In July and August 2025, Trump and Huang met. In August 2025, Trump announced he would allow the China sales in exchange for the United States receiving 15 percent of the sales revenue. In December, Trump announced he would allow Nvidia to sell the more powerful H200 chips to China, again giving the United States 15 percent of the cut. Around the same time, Nvidia donated $25 million to Trump’s White House ballroom project, requesting that the donation be anonymous. Somewhere in there Nvidia also donated $1 million to Trump’s inaugural fund.
Throughout this entire period—indeed, going back to 2024—the United States government suspected Nvidia’s chief Southeast Asia partner, Megaspeed, of diverting chips to China. At the time of Trump’s first export approval, it’s possible Trump hadn’t yet been told that Huang’s mistress was a suspected Chinese spy. But at the time of the second export, we know for a fact that he had been told. He approved the foreign sales anyway.
Meanwhile, in August 2025—the same month Trump and Huang met, and also the same month Trump announced the first of two decisions to ease up on Nvidia’s export controls to China—officials at the Department of Commerce who were investigating Metaspeed and Alice Huang received an email from Nvidia’s general counsel, Timothy Teter. In the message, Teter told the Commerce officials that he’d been given permission to contact them by their boss Jeff Kessler, a political appointee (undersecretary for industry and security) who, according to the Times, reports directly to Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick.
The Commerce officials politely declined to talk to Teter and forwarded his meddling emails to Kessler, who told them to handle the investigation by the book. But it seems clear Kessler and, in all likelihood, Lutnick, flirted momentarily with disrupting Commerce’s Metaspeed investigation, which eventually moved over to the Department of Justice. (In July 2025 Lutnick said of the Nvidia sales to China: “We don’t sell them our best stuff, not our second best stuff, not even our third best. The fourth one down, we want to keep China using it.”)
It shouldn’t surprise anybody that Trump sees national security as a commodity to auction off to the highest bidder. He’s done it before. In the case of Nvidia, Trump granted export approval conditioned on becoming America’s business partner (plus a patriotic supporter of Trump’s White House ballroom and inauguration). In the earlier case of some advanced AI chips desired by the United Arab Emirates that the Biden administration had placed off limits—including Nvidia H200 chips—Trump granted export approval to an entity that was already his own business partner, the UAE, which purchased a 49 percent stake in World Liberty Financial and then bought $2 billion in WLF stablecoin to invest in Binance. A mere two weeks passed between the latter deal and the Trump administration’s approval of the AI chips purchase.
This is all fodder for incoming Democrats interested in accountability, and maybe even some Republicans. In Nvidia’s case, Trump turned a stubbornly blind eye to his own government’s evidence that Nvidia’s partner Megaspeed diverted chips illegally to China. In the UAE’s case, Trump disregarded his own government’s evidence that the UAE was sharing missile technology with China. In both instances, Trump set a price that had nothing to do with protecting national security. People say that Trump is an inconsistent decisionmaker, and that’s true. But when it comes to corruption, Trump is very consistent. He always wants to wet his beak.
The Case Against Chuck Schumer
Scott Colom, the Democratic nominee for Senate in Mississippi, has been repeatedly asked a familiar hypothetical this election season: Would he support Chuck Schumer as Senate Democratic leader? When Fox News posed the question to him in October, few thought Colom stood a chance of taking down incumbent Republican Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith; he didn’t have much to lose by saying, in his deep-red state, “I don’t like that our party is represented by two people that live in the same borough.” But when MS NOW’s Jen Psaki asked Colom the same question several days ago, as it became increasingly clear that he had pulled off the most improbable victory in a midterm election full of improbable victories, he gave nearly the same answer: “It’s not a good thing that both leader Schumer and leader Jeffries both live in the same borough.”
It’s a clever answer, roping in his party’s other unpopular leader, House speaker-to-be Hakeem Jeffries, who lives about a 15-minute walk from Schumer in Brooklyn. Colom gave himself some wiggle room, which only seemed fair, given that Schumer recruited him for the race and dumped $2 million into the election to help push him over the line in its final weeks. Still, it captured the mood of the Democratic base. The party’s historic wave last week far exceeded expectations—but there is still an appetite for change. Many of the party’s voters and some of its elected officials in Congress, still upset at Schumer and Jeffries for their sluggish response to Trump’s abuses this term, don’t trust the two men to lead aggressively enough. Almost 60 percent of Democrats surveyed last month said they wanted “someone else” as their Senate leader, whereas just 22 percent wanted Schumer to stay in the job—hardly a ringing endorsement just before a massive electoral victory.
In other words, while the blue wave was partly a rejection of Trump and partly an endorsement of Democrats’ taking control of Congress, it’s hard to find evidence that any of it was driven by a desire to return Schumer and Jeffries, specifically, to power.
Colom is more circumspect than many of his fellow freshmen senators. Adam Hamilton, Abdul El-Sayed, Annie Andrews, Peggy Flanagan, James Talarico, Chris Pappas, and Juliana Stratton—all incoming Democratic senators—have all explicitly declined to support Schumer’s return as Senate majority leader. But so have some sitting senators. Bernie Sanders was unsurprisingly blunt on Tuesday, telling reporters, “I will not be supporting Chuck.” But Michigan Senator Elisa Slotkin, a noted moderate, has also come out against Schumer. “I’ve been very vocal that we need a new generation of leadership,” said at Crooked Media’s liberal Lollapalooza earlier this week. “We couldn’t have gotten a clearer signal than Tuesday.” (Granted, she’s also teasing her interest in the job.)
The case for changing horses at this moment is far from straightforward. The potential pitfalls are many, and obvious. The last thing the Democrats in Congress need right now, as they ride the unifying high of victory, is a nasty power struggle at the top that splinters the coalition. But it is clear that a significant portion of the Democratic base wants change and that the faith it lost in Schumer and Jeffries a year ago has not returned. The cleanest solution and the best path forward is for Schumer to step back.
That is partly because it seems unlikely that Jeffries will be replaced for a number of reasons. He is younger than Schumer, and would be the first Black speaker of the House. Any fight to succeed him would be fractious and likely would result in a similarly moderate figure in charge, thanks to the fact that the Democrats just won practically every district to the left of Atilla the Hun. Schumer, meanwhile, is 75, has been in this position before, and is synonymous with the party’s establishment.
Schumer could look at the political landscape and shrug off the petitions and unions and groups calling for his ouster. The electorate is often dismissed as ungrateful or ignorant; whatever you can say about Schumer, you can’t say that he held back the blue wave. But many Democratic politicians running for competitive Senate seats distanced themselves from him, and it was not merely performative. It was a key part of why they won: a signal both to their base and to persuadable voters that they were not stuck in the past. Schumer is, for many people who voted for Democrats last Tuesday, synonymous with everything they dislike about the party.
Still, the case for Schumer remaining leader is much more straightforward than the case for dumping him: Look at the scoreboard. The Democrats will most likely enter the 120th Congress with 56 senators, including ones from Kansas, South Carolina, and Mississippi. That’s a nine seat pickup, an extraordinary gain—and one that seemed downright impossible a year ago. Schumer, an election guru, played an important role in some of those pickups, handpicking Colom, a relative unknown in Mississippi, and coaxing Sherrod Brown out of retirement in Ohio. That’s pretty good. It’s also the kind of momentum you don’t want to disrupt without good reason.
But there is a good reason for dumping Schumer. He and Jeffries were both slow to pick up on their base’s anger last year, as they largely sat back and did little while Trump and his cronies wreaked havoc. They underestimated the potential for destruction, both from Elon Musk’s “Department of Government Efficiency” and from the president’s aggressive deployment of immigration agents and the U.S. military. At the same time, the one high-stakes fight they waged—last year’s government shutdown—ended in something close to total surrender.
You can argue that they nevertheless succeeded, given last week’s results, but how much can we credit Schumer and Jeffries for an election where everyone with a “D” next to their name outperformed expectations—in many cases simply because the president is an “R”? If anything, Schumer and Jeffries may have unintentionally created the conditions for the blue wave: Their sedate response to the start of Trump’s second term played an instrumental role in the rebirth of the #Resistance, which ultimately played an instrumental role in Tuesday’s results. Schumer’s record, moreover, was stellar but mixed. While his successes outweigh his missteps, there were missteps: His approach was almost catastrophic in Michigan and Maine, where he backed moderates (Haley Stevens and Janet Mills, respectively) who flamed out, and it looks now as if Louisiana and Florida could have been on the table with a push that never came.
The same can’t be said for the party’s base, which showed up everywhere. Those voters are now demanding change—and changing the Senate leader is the most obvious thing the party could do to satisfy that demand. Ideally, Schumer would come to this realization himself and announce that he won’t be leading his caucus in the next Congress—this would presumably be hard because it would also be tantamount to announcing his own retirement. But if that’s not the case, then it’s something that’s worth fighting over. That’s what this crop of Democratic senators was elected to do.
That’s risky, to say the least. The Democratic Party likely will not have more energy and solidarity in the next two years than it does right now, and a leadership fight would be divisive and messy. But keeping Schumer presents its own kind of risk, alienating voters energized by the possibility of pushing back against the Trump administration. The challenge right now is to prove to voters that the Democrats are actually up to the task that has been handed to them. Responding by empowering a figure who has already failed would undercut the historic wins the party made just a week ago.
Who Let Roy Cohn Off the Hook?
The photograph of Roy Cohn that graces the cover of Kai Bird’s new biography, American Scoundrel: Roy Cohn’s Dark Journey From Joe McCarthy to Donald Trump, was actually the author’s second choice. As Bird describes in the book’s acknowledgements, he was denied the right to use his preferred option, Robert Mapplethorpe’s stark portrait of Cohn’s cold-eyed visage that calls to mind a Halloween mask. In Bird’s accounting, the Mapplethorpe Foundation feared losing its nonprofit status if it licensed the photograph to appear on the cover of a book critical of the current president, Cohn’s most famous acolyte. This anecdote underscores two truths of living under our current regime. First, acts of self-censorship are likely outnumbering—and may prove as distorting as—restrictions that are officially imposed. Second, purportedly independent and robust institutions are facing unprecedented pressure to yield under the weight of competitive authoritarianism.
Those lessons are repeated numerous times throughout Bird’s energetic, readable, and meticulously-researched examination of Cohn, written with his wife and “Director of Research” Susan Goldmark. Bird is best-known for American Prometheus, a Pulitzer-winning biography of J. Robert Oppenheimer that inspired Christopher Nolan’s 2023 film. But his strongest work might be The Color of Truth, an analysis of the lives of McGeorge and William Bundy, bureaucrats essential to the Cold War liberal order who helped mislead the country into an unwinnable war in Vietnam. By his own accounting, Bird is a “biographer of the American establishment,” driven to understand the men (because it’s almost always been men) and systems that facilitated American global dominance following World War II. In taking on Cohn as a subject, Bird explores the other half of the story: in his telling, Cohn is the quintessential anti-establishment figure who has indelibly shaped the political culture of postwar America.

American Scoundrel assiduously charts Cohn’s path to fame and infamy, tracing his roles as federal prosecutor (supporting cases against Alger Hiss, William Remington, and the Rosenbergs), attack dog for Senator Joseph McCarthy, mob lawyer (with clients drawn from all of the New York underworld’s “Five Families”), celebrity divorce specialist (Si Newhouse, Gene Pope, Bianca Jagger), nefarious businessman, serial tax dodger, and conservative political operative (for, among others, Richard Nixon in 1972 and Ronald Reagan in 1980 and 1984).
Many of the anecdotes that drive the narrative have previously appeared on page and screen, including in Nicholas von Hoffman’s 1988 biography Citizen Cohn, the 2019 documentaries Where’s My Roy Cohn? and Bully. Coward. Victim., as well as Cohn’s own posthumously published 1988 autobiography (written with the journalist Sidney Zion). In their efforts to contribute to what could be seen as a picked-over subject, Bird and Goldmark have worked through a remarkable amount of new material, declassifying Cohn’s FBI file through a FOIA request, uncovering insightful archival materials (including a number of unpublished memoirs), and conducting dozens of interviews with key players. This research is all the more impressive because Cohn left behind no central archive; many of his personal papers were reportedly burned at the time of his death and his personal effects distributed to friends or sold at auction. (Two boxes of ephemera were purchased by R.E.M. lead singer Michael Stipe, who gave Bird and Goldmark access to them.)
These discoveries allow Bird to give the most complete accounting of Cohn to date. Though his conclusions are not markedly different from those of other biographers and scholars, they are founded on a richness of evidence that makes them more profound. The resulting portrait details a life of impunity. Seen from this angle, American Scoundrel is as much an indictment of the people and systems who failed to rein in Cohn’s criminality and corruption as it is a judgement of the man himself.
Roy Cohn was born in 1927, the only child of Albert Cohn, a Democratic district attorney (and later judge) aligned with FDR’s political machine, and Dora Marcus, a wealthy socialite whose family had made their money in banking. By all accounts, Cohn’s parents hated each other and often enlisted Roy in their various battles. But they both seemed to believe that their son was destined for great things. He sped his way through New York City’s most elite educational institutions (Horace Mann, Columbia College, Columbia Law School) and used his father’s connections to be named an Assistant U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York in 1948. Bird deftly traces the key cases that made Cohn’s name as an anticommunist crusader, including the successful prosecutions of William Remington and the Rosenbergs. These successes attracted the attention of the greatest red-hunter of them all, Joseph McCarthy, and in January, 1953, Cohn began an eventful 19-month stint as the lead investigator for the Wisconsin senator’s Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations.
Cohn soon became McCarthy’s right-hand man, running investigations, leading the questioning of witnesses, serving as the senator’s liaison to other government branches, and—perhaps most importantly—directing the public relations operation that kept McCarthy and his subcommittee at the forefront of the national consciousness. It was a role that threw him into the spotlight, with journalists blurring the line between news and gossip as they tracked his every move. Much has been written on the irony of Cohn fueling the Lavender Scare, the Cold War-era persecution of homosexuals, at the same time he was having sex with men. The infamous Army-McCarthy Hearings, broadcast to a national TV audience in the spring of 1954, exposed McCarthy and Cohn as bullies and severely damaged their political reputations. Cohn resigned from McCarthy’s staff and returned to Manhattan, where he crafted a second act as a pugnacious, well-connected, and unscrupulous attorney. Those successes would ultimately lead him back to the world of politics, and he held significant sway as a conservative fixer in the 1970s and 80s.
Throughout Bird’s narrative we see the constant failure of institutional leaders to punish Cohn for his illegal and immoral activities. President Dwight Eisenhower allowed McCarthy and Cohn’s investigations of supposed communists to continue apace, fearful that the then-powerful McCarthy would fracture the Republican Party. When the Army-McCarthy Hearings revealed that Cohn had fabricated evidence against enemies in the Department of Defense, the Eisenhower Administration declined to pursue charges of perjury against him, again for fear of alienating the right wing of their coalition. When, in 1973, a suspicious fire on Cohn’s yacht scuttled the vessel and killed one crew member, no charges were filed, in spite of the local sheriff’s “strong suspicion that foul play was involved.” The IRS moved glacially in investigating Cohn’s lifelong tax evasion. The City of New York took no legal action against Cohn and his business partner Paul Dano for their corrupt management of parking lots and subway newsstands from the mid-1970s to the early 1980s, quietly canceling the contracts instead of pursuing charges. The New York State Bar Association could have—and should have—sought to disbar Cohn far sooner than the early 1980s (Cohn ultimately lost his law license two months before his death from AIDS-related complications in August, 1986).
The powerful politicians, businessmen, entertainers, and journalists with whom Cohn surrounded himself were wise to his misconduct but looked the other way because he had connections, was good for a favor, and demonstrated personal loyalty to them. Cohn was, by many accounts, an entertaining friend: witty, mischievous, generous, and a fantastic source of gossip. In the words of syndicated columnist Liz Smith, “I got a big kick out of watching him operate.” During Cohn’s disbarment proceedings Barbara Walters testified in his defense, highlighting her friend’s “integrity” even though she had extensive knowledge of his transgressions. Other New Yorkers who supported Cohn through during that investigation included William Saffire, Congressman Mario Biaggi, comedian Joe Adams, New York Post editor Steven Dunleavy, William F. Buckley, Jr., and Donald Trump. Even the use of the word “scoundrel” in this biography’s title seems winking, as if Cohn was a Victorian rogue or a kid who got his hand caught in the cookie jar, rather than a lifelong criminal.
The biography’s most troubling chapter recounts the story of Richard Kerr, an orphan from Northern Ireland who was pressed into sexual slavery by the leaders of Belfast’s Kincora Boys’ Home. In an interview with Bird and Goldmark, Kerr states that he was raped by Cohn in a Venice hotel in 1977, a few weeks shy of his 16th birthday. Kerr did not report the assault to authorities at the time, and this story has not been previously published. Its inclusion serves as a horrifying reminder of the long trail of trauma that followed in the wake of Cohn’s many misdeeds. “Roy was a party to this sordid business,” Bird concludes, his language oddly mild for behavior so evil.
In his Bird’s accounting, the key to unlocking Cohn is deceptively, damningly simple: he was a man driven purely by self-interest and greed.At points, the biography frustrates by failing to trawl the depths of Cohn’s character to craft a more complete psychological and intellectual portrait. He was a man of numerous, fascinating contradictions—a homophobic homosexual, an antisemitic Jew, a wealthy man who paid no taxes, a right-wing operative whose father was a key player in New York City’s Democratic machine, a lawyer who thumbed his nose at the law—and one could imagine a more robust excavation of the roots of his complexities. Many of those who knew Cohn did undertake such a quest, with Liz Smith remarking that, “To the end of his life [Cohn] remained this very strange Jewish son who was still trying to please his mother and father’s portrait over his piano.”
Bird’s conclusions are less Freudian. In his—accurate, I believe—accounting, the key to unlocking Cohn is deceptively, damningly simple: he was a man driven purely by self-interest and greed. “Fundamentally,” Bird writes, “he was an empty vessel. He had no coherent personal philosophy unless you count his shallow mirroring of Ayn Rand’s unadulterated selfishness.” His entire life was transactional, every action calculated with future payout in mind. In the words of journalist and friend Murray Kempton, “I early learned that Roy had no interior to speak of.”
However multifariously malevolent Cohn was, he may have become a historical footnote were it not for his association with his most famous client. Cohn met Donald Trump in 1973 at Le Club, a members-only restaurant on Manhattan’s Upper East Side. Trump and his father, Fred, were in search of an attorney to defend them from Justice Department charges that the Trumps had discriminated against Black renters. Cohn’s solution was to countersue for $100 million, charging the federal government with defaming his clients. The countersuit was promptly dismissed, and the Trumps eventually signed a settlement, promising to adhere to a consent decree designed to combat housing discrimination. Those inconvenient facts did not preclude Cohn and the younger Trump from calling a press conference and declaring victory against government overreach. (The Trumps breached the consent decree and were again charged with violating the Fair Housing Act in 1978.)
It was the beginning of a beautiful friendship. For the last 13 years of his life, Cohn took Trump under his wing, mentoring him in the ways of his world. Their alliance was the stuff of legend, and Cohn proudly displayed a photograph of Trump in his office. It was signed, “To Roy, My greatest friend. Donald.” In the words of investigative journalist David Cay Johnston, Cohn taught Trump a bevy of lessons that the 45th and 47th President of the United States has put into action:
Ignore the rules, do what you want to do, don’t leave a paper trail, don’t keep a calendar, never do things in writing, and if somebody gets onto you, rat out other people to save yourself. Delay, delay, delay, [be]cause grand juries have limited time, and you can run out the clock. And call in the news media. Make up a fantastic story. We’re just honest businessmen who are being attacked by these corrupt New York City police, or FBI agents, or especially the corrupt and heartless IRS agents. And that’ll be the news story. It’ll put the government on the defensive.
It may have even been Cohn who suggested that Trump apply these tactics to the realm of politics. In a telephone interview with Bird and Goldmark, Trump recalled of Cohn, “He had a lot of respect for me. He said, ‘You’re going to be President someday. If you want to.’ He said that many times.”
Four months before his death in 1986, Cohn posed for a series of portraits by the celebrated photographer Mary Ellen Mark. Though haggard and ravaged by disease, he was incapable of refusing the opportunity for publicity; the shots were later used to illustrate posthumous articles in Vanity Fair and Life, the latter titled “the Snarling Death of Roy Cohn.” In perhaps the best-known image from the sitting, Cohn broods in a Queen Anne-style wingback chair, his legs crossed casually, staring at the camera as he clutches a small American flag, the kind waved by spectators on Inauguration Day and at 4th of July parades.
The photo hinges on the juxtaposition of Cohn and the flag: his wan, scarred visage next to a symbol that is often used to evoke freedom, liberty, and hope. Mark’s photograph seems to suggest an essential dissonance between her subject and Americanness. This disparity is emphasized by those who have portrayed Cohn as a cancer on the American body politic, as a man who became powerful by flouting and ignoring the principles that define what it is to be American.
Cohn was an unheeded warning about the fragility of American institutions when confronted with unfettered greed and limitless egotism.And yet, for the first half of Donald Trump’s second term, Cohn and his actions appeared less antithetical to American identity and more like elemental expressions of it. His strategy of going on the offensive has proven remarkably destructive in the hands of a president who has attempted to bend and break cherished institutions, from the Supreme Court and the legislative branch to freedom of speech, an independent press, and the sanctity of the vote. In the midterms, voters rejected the particular brand of authoritarianism Trump represents. But the damage is hard to undo. Like Cohn, Trump has shown how vulnerable the American system of government can be, and how easily it can be undermined by somebody with the motivation to do so.
Cohn was an unheeded warning about the fragility of American institutions when confronted with unfettered greed and limitless egotism. His most momentous act was to demonstrate continuously the fundamental impotence of the establishment. Cohn’s ethical and moral failings are clear. But the most troubling thing about his life—and the life of his most famous protégé—is the ease with which he was able to subvert the systems that should have held him in check.
In this light, Cohn’s failings are not merely his own. They belong to all of us. And it’s up to all of us—regardless of political persuasion—to deal with their fallout.
The Job Qualifications for Hegseth’s Military? Straight. White. Male.
On Tuesday, House Republicans blocked a remarkable effort to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth led by a lone GOP legislator and supported by Democrats. The eight articles alleged that Hegseth violated the Constitution by waging war against Iran without congressional authorization, unlawfully capturing Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro, and launching strikes on suspected drug boats in the Caribbean, among other charges. But the impeachment efforts failed.
jQuery(document).ready(function(){prx("https:\/\/play.prx.org\/e?ge=prx_149_aecaccfb-29ad-4acd-b1f5-279db55cbbf1&uf=https%3A%2F%2Ffeeds.revealradio.org%2Frevealpodcast", "prx-1", "embed")});Subscribe to Mother Jones podcasts on Apple Podcasts or your favorite podcast app.
In his time as defense secretary, Hegseth has not only helped push the US into a deeply unpopular war with Iran, but he’s also started wars within the military itself. Under his leadership, the US military has ousted female and Black officers, blocked promotions for Black service members, reassigned the first woman to lead the Naval Academy, and targeted transgender service members and just about anyone who doesn’t fit his narrow definition of what constitutes a proper “warrior.”
“Black service members and Black veterans understand that we are either not welcome or we will exist within a permanent hierarchy in which white men are at the top,” says Kyle Bibby, a former Marine infantry captain and co-founder of the non-profit Black Veterans Project. “Particularly straight white men.”
On a special episode of More To The Story for this year’s Veterans Day, host Al Letson talks with Bibby about what life is really like for Black troops in the US military, how Hegseth has widened racial inequities under his leadership, and whether the armed services can ever become a true meritocracy.
Find More To The Story on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, iHeartRadio, Pandora, or your favorite podcast app, and don’t forget to subscribe.
Linux joins Heathrow's grounded fleet of information screens
UK travelers had more than fog to contend with this week, as Linux proved that if Windows could bork anything, it could bork it better.
Spotted by Andy Hinks at Heathrow Airport's Terminal 2, this information display has seen better days. While its neighbors offer walking times and terminal maps, it presents a sideways Linux boot log – useful only if your next connection involves mounting a filesystem.
There aren't many clues to what has befallen the machine behind the screen. The boot messages mention systemd, an Intel PRO/1000 network adapter, and an EXT4 filesystem on what appears to be a logical volume named LV_ROOT. Whether mounting that filesystem is the problem, or simply the last thing displayed before something else went wrong, isn't clear.
Heathrow's information displays clearly accommodate a mixture of technologies. Recent examples ran Microsoft Windows, which had - naturally - suffered a moment of its own. Linux can evidently be just as unreliable in the right hands.
The question is which Linux distribution is having its moment in the sun. Heathrow has been rolling out Raspberry Pi-based signage, although the Intel PRO/1000 adapter leaves the hardware behind this particular display something of a mystery.
Pi hardware makes sense for signage: it's relatively cheap – at least until AI ate all the RAM – and low-powered compared with a full-fat Windows PC. Heathrow's senior product owner for displays described the approach as a "reliable, secure solution that has a significantly lower hardware cost and are 30-40% more energy efficient than our previous hardware."
Readers might be interested to know that Heathrow has spent years working on its new screens. The product owner again: "We've completely re-engineered our content distribution system to be flexible and device-agnostic."
So Windows in one place, and Linux somewhere else. All rubbing along famously. Assuming, of course, the displays can show more than a virtual cough and splutter during boot. ®
New governor begins the ‘Becerra era’ by making nice with Capitol Democrats
This story was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for its newsletters.
Welcome to the “Becerra era,” where the incoming governor doesn’t share specific policy ideas, but really wants you to know that he’ll play nicely with Democratic leaders in the Legislature.
“We’ve tried to make it very clear, through the fact that we are standing here just a couple of days after the election, to say, ‘We’re going to work together. This will be a partnership,’” Democratic Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra proclaimed to a crowd of reporters in the Capitol rotunda last week.
“Get used to this,” he added, standing shoulder-to-shoulder with Senate President Pro Tem Monique Limón and Assembly Speaker Robert Rivas.
Together, Becerra, Limón and Rivas — known collectively as the Big Three — will hold the ultimate decisionmaking power over California’s policy priorities. So far, all three have refrained from committing to any concrete legislative proposals on the major issues that lawmakers will confront when they return in January.
California policymakers must navigate new federal restrictions, including cuts to Medi-Cal, the state program that provides healthcare to disabled and low-income Californians, that could cause more than 1 million to lose coverage starting Jan. 1. Lawmakers also need to resolve a debate over who pays for the damage from wildfires caused by utility equipment after a last-minute deal failed this year. Then there are the mandates voters gave Democrats this election cycle to rein in artificial intelligence, root out corruption, lower everyday costs and increase available housing.
Becerra’s pledge to partner closely with the California Legislature from the get-go marks a pivot from Gov. Gavin Newsom’s signature approach: jamming big policy proposals down the Legislature’s throat as legislative deadlines approach, using the time crunch to generate urgency while leaving as little room as possible for opposition to surface.
The tactic backfired earlier this year when Newsom tried to push through major changes to the way utilities and insurance companies bear the cost of damages when utility equipment sparks wildfires. But for years prior, his last-minute maneuvers resulted in legislation to speed up infrastructure construction by limiting legal challenges and to carve out exemptions to environmental review for urban apartments and other projects.
Rivas – whose district includes part of Santa Cruz County – acknowledged that legislators have been irritated by Newsom’s last-minute jams for years, despite the speaker’s repeated efforts to communicate that early engagement is key to winning lawmakers’ support.
“It’s pretty clear, based on the engagement we’ve had thus far, that it’s going to be a different type of relationship than what this Legislature has experienced over the past eight years,” Rivas said.
“I fully expect and trust the governor-elect when he says that he’s going to do his best to work with the Legislature and do his best to not drop stuff on us unexpectedly.”
Assembly Speaker Robert Rivas during the swearing-in ceremony for Senate President Pro Tem Monique Limón in the Senate chambers at the state Capitol in Sacramento on Jan. 5, 2026. Credit: Miguel Gutierrez Jr. / CalMatters/Pool
Becerra’s experience as an assemblymember and member of Congress enables him to be an “empathetic partner” to Limón and Rivas, said Richard Stapler, a Democratic political strategist and former senior aide to state Sen. John Laird of Santa Cruz. Having served as the leader of the congressional Hispanic caucus, Stapler added, Becerra can appreciate the difficulties of managing a diverse caucus where members have conflicting priorities and policy ideas.
“The success of his governorship will largely ride on his ability to have a sound, thoughtful working relationship with the Legislature,” Stapler said.
Former Assembly Speaker Anthony Rendon said some tension between the two branches of government should be expected, no matter how harmonious they appear. He said when lawmakers chafed at what they called overreach from Newsom or his predecessor, Gov. Jerry Brown, it was often because they had given up their own power to push back, such as when lawmakers left Sacramento in the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic.
“It’s easier for one person to act than an entire body,” he said.
Since advancing from the primary as the sole Democratic candidate for governor, Becerra has met individually with several legislators, as well as the Senate and Assembly Democratic caucuses.
Last month he joined Assembly appropriations committee chair Buffy Wicks, Democrat of Oakland, on a tour of a new transit-oriented affordable housing complex made possible through a 2025 housing law.
Wicks, who has made housing policy one of her signature issues, said she told Becerra she plans to reintroduce a bill that died this year that will seek to increase the construction of condominiums — an important entry option for new home buyers — by updating state construction defect liability laws that have made developers reluctant to build new condos altogether.
“Because he’s been a legislator, he understands the pace and cadence of a legislative body, and you know, he also understands how we get very attached to our ideas — we get married to our bills, as they say,” Wicks told CalMatters. “Having more collaboration at the front end I think is going to be important and certainly welcome from the Legislature.”
When Sirat Attapit first started as director of legislative affairs in then-Attorney General Becerra’s office in 2017, her new boss instructed her to try to meet with all 120 California legislators and develop a rapport.
“Coming in as a former legislator … he really wanted to build a relationship with them,” Attapit told CalMatters earlier this year.
She described Becerra as finely attuned to the smallest details of policy proposals. He would direct staff to mark bills as having a “fiscal impact” on the state even if it would only cost a few thousand dollars, or part of a full-time employee’s time, per year.
Becerra previously said he hopes to reduce the number of bills legislators introduce so the state has a clearer and more cohesive legislative agenda. Lawmakers showed slight restraint in 2026, introducing just under 1,850 bills as compared to the more than 2,100 they introduced in 2024 and 2025.
“That requires me to come to them early,” he told KCRA last month, “to talk to them, so they don’t feel like they have to plow forward and then find out at the end that I didn’t like what they were doing.”
Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra addresses the media during a news conference at the state Capitol on Nov. 5. Credit: Miguel Gutierrez Jr. / CalMatters
Becerra has repeatedly played it safe, avoiding specifics on his agenda and instead opting for broad promises to prioritize issues like “affordability” and “fighting for working families” by making sure that “everyone pays their fair share.”
When asked if he would commit to reversing Newsom’s rollback of healthcare benefits for undocumented immigrants, which he seemed to endorse in an interview with KQED, Becerra bristled and lectured reporters for “playing politics” by asking him to make commitments before he knows all the details, such as the latest budget projections.
“Guys, don’t play this game about asking me to commit, because I didn’t get elected doing that,” Becerra said. “A lot of other folks make these wild promises, and they’re not the governor-elect.”
Pressed for details on how Becerra would differ from Newsom, Rivas said he didn’t know if their policies would diverge. Like Becerra himself, the speaker pointed mostly to the governor-elect’s experiences as a former lawmaker and a son of immigrants.
One area where the three Democratic leaders have signalled early agreement is the Fair Share tax proposal, an idea pushed by liberal lawmakers to tax large corporations whose workers make so little that they qualify for public benefits like Medi-Cal.
Facing federal cuts and budget deficits, Newsom began cutting Medi-Cal in recent years with lawmakers’ approval. Some in the Legislature pushed instead for the tax to backfill revenues. But Newsom is generally unwilling to raise taxes, and the Legislature compromised by instead directing the state to study how to implement such a tax. A report by the Department of Finance is due in March.
Sen. Lola Smallwood-Cuevas, a Los Angeles Democrat who chairs the Senate labor committee, said she discussed the Fair Share plan with then-candidate Becerra early in the year. When she ran into him at an event for Black leaders last month, she said he told her he was all in on the idea.
“He stopped me and he said, ‘I really want to work on Fair Share. I want to get that done. I believe that that is important to how we move forward coming out of Trump’s attack on our healthcare system,’” she said.
“That was very encouraging, that he remembered the conversation, he remembered me raising that point, and that he sought me out,” she said.
Sen. Lola Smallwood-Cuevas chats with a lawmaker during a floor session at the state Capitol in Sacramento on Aug. 29, 2024. Credit: Florence Middleton / CalMatters
Rivas said he, Limón and Becerra have a “natural alignment and a willingness to do something” on the issue. But all three are waiting to see what the finance department recommends before proposing anything concrete.
Legislative leaders were more restrained on another idea that Becerra proposed during the campaign, this one to require utilities to give low-income households two hours of free electricity during low-usage daytime hours.
Limón said she believes such programs work “in the short term” to give families facing high power bills some relief and that her caucus “has always welcomed every idea.”
Rivas said he still needed to consult Assembly Democrats on the details.
“Could there be alignment?” he said. “Possibly.”
Have something to say? Lookout welcomes letters to the editor, within our policies, from readers. Guidelines here.
The post New governor begins the ‘Becerra era’ by making nice with Capitol Democrats appeared first on Lookout Santa Cruz.
Every Major Character Death in THE RINGS OF POWER Season 3
- The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power is back for season three, and that means more character deaths are on the horizon.
- While some characters on The Rings of Power are protected from death by Lord of the Rings lore, others are not so lucky.
- We’ll keep track of all the major character deaths this season.
The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season three has returned for its darkest season yet. Sauron’s forces are everywhere, and the Dark Lord is gearing up to forge his ultimate weapon, The One Ring. In every corner of Middle-earth, battles rage, and across the ocean in Númenor, civil war threatens as well. In a season full of so much evil and conflict, it’s no surprise we see more than one major Rings of Power character meet their death. To help you keep track of all the characters who meet sad ends, we’re keeping note of every major The Rings of Power Season 3 character death we see. Here’s who we’ve lost so far.
Every Rings of Power Season 3 Major Character Death:- Eärien Is the First Major Character to Die in The Rings of Power Season 3
- Arondir’s Death Is the Most Painful Death Yet on The Rings of Power
- More Deaths Are Surely Coming
Prime Video
Eärien is the first character to meet death in The Rings of Power season three. Eärien dies in The Rings of Power season three, episode two, jumping out of a window to her doom rather than betraying her father, Elendil, and Queen Míriel after King Pharazôn learns she betrayed him and became a spy for the Faithful.
How Does Eärien Die in 3.02?The daughter of Elendil and sister of Isildur, Eärien has been a complicated person on The Rings of Power. In seasons one and two, we watched Eärien lose faith in Queen Míriel, both because of a long-bred hatred of elves in Númenor and because of the apparent death of her brother Isildur in Míriel’s ventures into Middle-earth. Against her father Elendil’s wishes, Eärien sided with Ar-Pharazôn. And when she learned of Míriel’s palantír, or elven seeing stone, she used this knowledge to help Pharazôn exile Míriel. But in late season two, we see her realize that her actions have consequences she may not enjoy.
In The Rings of Power season three, we quickly learn Eärien has turned on Pharazôn and become a spy for Míriel, Elendil, and the Faithful in order to atone for her behavior in earlier seasons. She pretends to be evil to offer Míriel and the Faithful information and save lives where she can. But unfortunately, Eärien’s position as a spy is what leads to her death in The Rings of Power season three. Pharazôn sets a trap for her, Elendil, and Isildur, telling Eärien he will attack the West of Númenor, where the Faithful have taken refuge. Eärien, of course, takes the bait, and Pharazôn, Belzagar, and Kemen trap her in a room. They demand she tell them where Queen Míriel is and defect to their side, willingly or not. But Eärien has found strength and some kind of faith in these past years. She walks to the window, musing that perhaps dying to defend a righteous cause “is a blessing,” a callback to a conversation she had with her brother Isildur earlier in The Rings of Power season three, episode two, before she jumps to her death.
RELATED ARTICLE
13 Details We Learned Visiting THE RINGS OF POWER Season 3 SetPharazôn, Belzagar, and Kemen, selfish as they are, couldn’t imagine Eärien would choose death over betraying her loyalties and heart. And that’s where they fail to understand the true power of faith and love. And why they will ultimately never win. Eärien’s final episode of The Rings of Power season three is a beautiful one, and her death is truly powerful.
Arondir’s Death Is the Most Painful Death Yet on The Rings of Power
Prime Video
In The Rings of Power season three, episode four, Arondir’s death arrives way too soon. Sadly, Arondir is stabbed to death by the character he considered a son, Theo, at the orc prison Gundabad and on Sauron’s orders. We really wish Arondir didn’t die.
How Does Arondir Die in 3.04?With few other options in the war against Sauron, Arondir and Galadriel accompany the orc, Marnûkh, to the dark prison of Gundabad. Marnûkh claims the only remaining Elven Smith from Eregion, who worked with Celebrimbor and knows the secret of the Elven Rings, is in Gundabad. When the trio arrive, they find the Elven Smith dead, but Galadriel’s husband, Celeborn, her neighbor, alive. As the foursome tries to escape, everything falls apart.
Prime Video
First, Sauron arrives on the scene with his brand-new Nazgnagôl, or Ring Servant, in tow and begins to search for Galadriel in the dungeon. The Nazgnagôl finds Arondir, Celeborn, and Marnûkh first, and this spells the beginning of Arondir’s death sequence in The Rings of Power season three.
The Nazgnagôl approaches Arondir, and Galadriel begs him to run, but Arondir insists he will not run from the shadow. Strangely, the Nazgnagôl appears to agree with Galadriel. When the Nazgnagôl removes his mask, we learn that it’s really Theo, who has accepted one of the Rings for Men from Sauron and has become a future Nazgûl. Although Theo tries to tell Arondir to run, saying that Sauron doesn’t really care about his fate, Arondir refuses to go. Instead, he reaches for Theo, asking him to take off the ring and saying he won’t leave him again.
RELATED ARTICLE
The Fate of Theo in THE RINGS OF POWER Season 3 (Exclusive Interviews & Images)Theo is really close to listening to Arondir, but then Sauron appears and orders Theo to “Kill him.” And Theo does immediately, under Sauron’s thrall; he stabs Arondir in the stomach, ending his life. Arondir’s death sequence in The Rings of Power season three is truly beautiful, but we feel like he didn’t have to die. Why The Rings of Power, why? We take heart that Arondir, one of the purest of Tolkien’s elves, will surely go to the Halls of Mandos after death and be reincarnated in Valinor in no time at all.
More Deaths Are Surely Coming
Prime Video
Are there any original characters left in the world of The Rings of Power? If so, they should hide away and take care. It definitely feels like anyone who isn’t protected by the lore in The Rings of Power season three is marked for death. We feel like the bloodbath has only just begun.
If you’d like to learn more about this Middle-earth adventure, you can pick up The Fall of Númenor: And Other Tales from the Second Age of Middle-earth and read more about Tolkien’s vision of the time when the show takes place.
The Rings of Power season three is now airing on Prime Video.
This post has affiliate links, which means we may earn advertising money if you buy something. This doesn’t cost you anything extra, we just have to give you the heads up for legal reasons. Click away!
Rotem Rusak is the Editor-in-Chief at Nerdist. She is a great lover of the anti-hero and is always ready for a new ship to set sail. In her work, she likes to combine fandom passion with journalistic sensibilities. Follow her on Instagram.The post Every Major Character Death in THE RINGS OF POWER Season 3 appeared first on Nerdist.
AMD: Where we're going we don't need (as much) DRAM
AMD's latest sales pitch: Up to 99 percent of the performance with half the DRAM, provided you're willing to buy a Mext license alongside your shiny new Epyc server.
This is made possible by using AI models to load memory pages in and out of cheaper NVMe storage before your operating system or apps ever know they need it — kind of like SWAP or a Windows page file, but smarter.
AMD acquired the tech from Mext back in June, and according to former CEO Gary Smerdon — now CVP of business development at AMD — the tech could cut enterprise server costs by as much as 83 percent by replacing costly RDIMMs with flash storage. Of the initial 145 systems the software has been deployed on so far, he estimates customers have already saved $5 million in avoided DRAM costs.
"Conservatively, 60, 70, even 80 or 90 percent for very large memory systems, of the cost of a server can be in memory," he explained.
Everyone's favorite buzzword to the rescueEven in systems with high memory utilization, where (say) 95 percent of the memory is "in use," a lot of it isn't actively being used, he explained. He cited a Meta research paper that showed that between 50 and 80 percent of memory pages hadn't been touched in five minutes, ten minutes, or even longer. "Five minutes to Epyc is an eternity."
Mext technology aims to offload those infrequently accessed pages to flash. The challenge, Smerdon explains, is that while flash may be 50x cheaper per bit, 30x lower power per bit, it's also 500x slower.
This is why most folks, when provisioning VPCs or servers, generally avoid swapping out to disk wherever possible: it kills application performance and sends service level agreements out the window.
So for Mext's tech to work, it needed to ensure that any pages offloaded to storage were back in DRAM before they're needed. Kind of like running an errand in the middle of the workday – so long as you're back before your boss needs you again, they'll never know you left your desk.
The problem was that the "R" in DRAM stands for random. Predicting which pages the system was going to need at which time isn't exactly trivial. The solution? (Brace for it.)
"We realized we could use AI to monitor the system and proactively push those pages back into DRAM, so that as far as the application or the operating system knew, they were there the whole time," Smerdon said. In other words: "We transparently make flash appear as DRAM."
So, "instead of buying two terabytes of DRAM for your Epyc-based server, you could buy one terabyte of DRAM, and then the next terabyte comes with Mext."
To do this, AMD’s Mext employs a number of machine learning algorithms.
"The workhorse model is a transformer derivative model, just like ChatGPT or Claude or the other famous models, but instead of predicting, for example, in the case of text, what word is next, what we're doing is predicting what page of memory is going to be required next," Smerdon explained. So long as the pages are in DRAM before they're needed, the pages don't even need to be in the right order, he added.
Training the models to predict memory access patterns accurately presents its own challenges, which, Smerdon says, makes pre-training the models impractical.
Instead, they take a single Epyc core and train the model "in under one second," he explained. From there, the model is further refined and retrained over time until it is able to predict accurately where the pages need to be and when they need to be there.
All of this training, he emphasizes, takes place on the CPU core — no GPU required, which means essentially any Epyc customer can take advantage of the software platform.
While no GPU may be required, it's worth noting that in virtualized environments, the software requires one core per VM or VPC, so the overhead scales with virtualization. Container runtimes presumably don't suffer from this same limitation. We've reached out to AMD for clarification.
99 percent of the perf, half the DRAMAccording to AMD, the technology actually works. Initially, Smerdon says, the company targeted memory-hungry applications like electronic design automation (EDA) and content creation, but later expanded to support latency-sensitive applications like databases and agentic AI pipelines.
"When pages of memory are cold, we can push them off to flash, and there's literally no impact on performance," he said.
Smerdon is overstating things just a little here. Depending on the application and how much memory is offloaded to flash, there is a performance penalty.
According to tests against Synopsys' PrimeTime EDA suite, he claims, half the memory can be offloaded to flash using Mext and the system still achieves 95 percent of the performance of DRAM. With 25 percent DRAM and 75 percent flash, performance fell to 80 percent of the DRAM-only baseline in AMD's tests.
EDA tools are extremely memory-hungry, but the amount of data the cores are working on at any given moment is often measured in megabytes. This is why AMD's Epyc X-chips remain so popular with EDA customers and why Mext targeted it initially.
In other scenarios, like Apache Spark, AMD's Mext team says it is seeing 99 percent of the performance even after replacing half the DRAM in the system with flash.
While implementing the tech may cost some performance, AMD is betting that customers will be willing to make that compromise in exchange for substantial DRAM savings, as memory remains constrained thanks to the AI datacenter buildout.
Right now, AMD is working to integrate Mext into its broader enterprise portfolio. The software, we're told, will be exclusive to AMD hardware and will be offered as a license sold through OEM partners.
Systems running Linux require only a kernel driver to take advantage of the software, while a separate RAM View application is being offered to help enterprises understand which systems and workloads it should be enabled on.
The chip designer says it's currently in the first phase of its Mext rollout, which means working with OEMs like HPE to ensure systems are so-called "Mext ready." In the second phase, the company aims to begin selling licenses for the software and shipping Epyc platforms with RAM View preinstalled.®
UK's 'buy British' tech ambitions hit reality as less than £1 in £6 stays at home
The UK government talks a good game about buying British, but less than £1 in every £6 spent with its biggest technology suppliers goes to British firms, according to research exposing how much Whitehall relies on foreign tech.
A report from the Institute for Public Policy Research (IPPR) found that while 42.5 percent of spending with the public sector's 150 largest technology suppliers appears to go to UK companies, that figure collapses to just 15.4 percent once you look beyond where those businesses happen to be headquartered.
A UK headquarters doesn't necessarily make a company British. Some are owned from overseas, others have most of their staff abroad, and many simply resell technology from US giants such as Microsoft.
In fact, 43 percent of the spending attributed to UK-headquartered suppliers goes to resellers. Bytes and Softcat alone account for around £2 billion, making them two of the three biggest recipients of public sector technology spending.
Once researchers traced reseller contracts back to the companies behind the products, the US emerged as the biggest beneficiary, accounting for £9.2 billion of the £19.2 billion spent with the largest suppliers.
And the money isn't exactly being spread around. Just 150 companies receive 83 percent of public sector technology spending, with the largest 15 accounting for almost half. Smaller suppliers aren't getting much of a look-in either, receiving just 12 percent of government technology spending compared with 27 percent of spending across government as a whole.
Competition is another concern. According to IPPR, 89.9 percent of government IT contracts over the past 12 months had no published record of how many suppliers bid for the work, making it difficult to assess how competitive those procurements were.
Things get murkier when AI enters the picture, naturally. Government spending records show relatively little money going directly to the likes of OpenAI and Anthropic, but that doesn't mean Whitehall isn't buying their technology. Much of it is bundled into existing cloud agreements, enterprise software licenses, and partnerships.
One example is NHS England's rollout of Microsoft 365 Copilot to 505,000 staff, which IPPR says was carried out under a national licensing agreement signed in June 2023, before Copilot was even generally available.
That means AI tools can reach hundreds of thousands of public sector workers through deals negotiated before those products were on the market, potentially leaving rival suppliers without an opportunity to compete.
The report, Locked In: A Realist's Agenda for Digital Sovereignty, warns that Britain's dependence on American technology could become particularly troublesome if Washington restricts access to advanced AI systems. It points to recent US restrictions on Anthropic models and limits on early access for Britain's AI Security Institute as evidence that such concerns are no longer entirely hypothetical.
The government has already committed £500 million to a Sovereign AI Fund, but researchers reckon throwing money at homegrown technology companies won't be enough to loosen Silicon Valley's grip.
Instead, they want Whitehall to negotiate technology contracts as a single customer, make it easier to switch suppliers, and work with countries including France, Germany, Japan, and South Korea to secure access to advanced AI.
Roa Powell, senior research fellow at IPPR, said: "But we cannot do it alone, and building domestic capability can't be our only bet. The UK should be working with other middle powers, pooling our buying power to shape markets and using shared leverage to secure access to frontier AI."
Darren Jones MP, who wrote the report's foreword, made a similar argument, saying Britain should work with international allies rather than attempting to build everything itself.
"We can change how the state buys technology, back industries where the UK has a genuine opportunity to lead the world, and shape markets – but we can't go it alone. We need to join with natural allies like France, Germany, Japan and Korea and make ourselves indispensable together," he said.
Whitehall might have grand plans for digital sovereignty, but it's going to be a tough sell when so much of its technology comes from across the Atlantic. And with AI already bundled into software contracts worth billions, US tech giants aren't making it easy for the government to shop elsewhere. ®
You’ve Watched the Origin of a Nazgûl in THE RINGS OF POWER (Exclusive)
Quick Take
- The Rings of Power season three takes us into the origins of a Nazgûl as we watch Theo accept a Ring of Power from Sauron and descend into darkness.
- Nerdist spoke to The Rings of Power season three’s showrunners JD Payne and Patrick McKay and Theo’s actor Tyroe Muhafidin about Theo’s dark turn.
- We also have two exclusive images from The Rings of Power season three that center on Theo’s journey.
Tolkien’s world is a bittersweet one. Although often full of hope, joy, and love, The Lord of the Rings does not tell us a fairy tale where everything concludes with a “happily ever after.” Darkness is very real, incredibly seductive, and truly dangerous. And at many points along the way, darkness wins out against light. Following in the footsteps of other Middle-earth tragedies that have broken our hearts, The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season three reveals to us what we’ve really been watching when it comes to Tyroe Muhafidin’s character Theo, the origin story of a Nazgûl. Although at times it seemed like Theo could sway toward good or evil, in The Rings of Power season three, we see him seal his fate as he accepts one of Sauron’s nine Rings for Men. And thus Theo begins his journey toward becoming one of Sauron’s most feared warriors: the Ringwraiths. We at Nerdist spoke exclusively with Tyroe Muhafidin and The Rings of Power’s showrunners, JD Payne and Patrick McKay, about Theo’s dark journey—and we’re excited to share two exclusive images to go along with our conversation.
Prime Video
“With Theo, what you realize this season is that what you’ve been watching over three seasons of Rings of Power is the origin of a Nazgûl.” Payne and McKay share with us when we discuss Theo’s journey in the series. It’s a story we can now return to retroactively, with this new understanding in mind, and get a whole lot more out of. Walking this heavy road with Theo also lets The Rings of Power do what it does best: add new depth and nuance to a Middle-earth concept we thought we knew. We’ve loved seeing it happen with the orcs of The Rings of Power. And now, we’re excited to peer more closely into the psyche of a Nazgûl: a Tolkienian being of evil that in previous works has been little more than the flutter of a menacing dark cloak, a sense of acute danger, and the thudding footfall of a heavily breathing horse.
The showrunners continue, “We thought about what somebody would have to suffer, or what they would have to lose, that might make them susceptible to this choice and make that seem like the right path to them. So Theo is a villain who hopefully has some real dimension to him now that you’ve been on a journey with him to that choice. It’s on brand for what we try to do, which is that it’s not just black and white; it’s about what makes someone decide to choose that path.”
And even now that Theo has chosen to accept a Ring of Power from Sauron and begin his journey into evil, he hasn’t been immediately erased as a character. There’s still a rich struggle we see percolating inside of him. “I think what we’re always trying to do is find complexity of villainy and complexity of heroism.” Payne and McKay note, “For example, we had Adar; he’s not an elf, he’s not an orc, he’s somewhere in between the two. The people who are wearing the Rings, the men wearing the Rings of Power for men this season, they’re not Nazgûl yet. We’re actually calling them ‘Nazgnagôl,’ which, according to our language experts, means not Ringwraith but Ring-servant. Tolkien was obsessed with the way that language evolved over time. And so we thought that with the Nazgnagôl, you could see how they evolve into Nazgûl. So the Ring-servants evolve into Ringwraiths. And we get to see one of these Nazgnagôl in Theo, before he becomes one of the things we know from the Third Age. The Nazgnagôl are still in the process of transformation.”
But ultimately, Theo’s turn to evil is necessary for the series’ authenticity. It wouldn’t be a realistic story if none of our named characters succumbed to the strong temptations placed before them. And these outcomes should cause us pain and sadness, make us feel a loss, if the show has done its job right. Payne and McKay underscore the idea, sharing, “The reality is in Middle-earth, when evil is powerful, some people fall to it, some people pick the wrong side, and it’s not a happy ending, but it’s an ending that we felt was warranted. The story is a tragedy in this world. Sauron is becoming more and more powerful, and that means some people will join him, and that shouldn’t feel great.”
Prime Video
And it certainly does not feel great. Especially not when Theo’s allegiance to Sauron and status as a future Nazgûl brings us an immediate and immense tragedy to The Rings of Power season three: the death of Arondir. On Sauron’s orders, Theo slays his almost father-figure and his last possible connection to goodness, stabbing him through with a sword and killing the elf who has come to mean so much to us over the last three seasons. Arondir’s death scene at Theo’s hand is both epic and beautiful. And, in our exclusive behind-the-scenes image from The Rings of Power season three, you can get a sense of how real all the action was, even in our world. But even still, we would trade all incredible intensity for even one more episode with Arondir. RIP.
Tyroe Muhafidin tells us that killing Arondir in The Rings of Power season three evokes an incredibly mixed set of feelings in Theo, and he doesn’t hesitate to get dark in discussing Theo’s emotions. He reveals, “I think in general, the feeling of taking a life for Theo is, I want to say it’s an addictive thing for him. I think that was his first moment of feeling a real sense of power over someone. There’s that moment where he cuts an orc’s tongue out, and he enjoys it. He loves that sensation of control. And I think the first taste of killing sets off a domino effect in him. I think when he stabs Arondir, he gets that initial rush of adrenaline, and he loves it. But I think that, while it’s so great in the first moment, it’s almost an instant regret and guilt that he feels. And I think that’s the biggest toss-up with him this season is figuring out that guilt and whether he’ll accept it and live with it, or use it to try to fight this direction.”
Prime Video
But we know fighting against a Ring of Power is no easy task… Especially not when you accepted it in the first place because you agree with Sauron’s reasoning for why you should have one. Muhafidin reveals that Theo strongly resonates with Sauron’s view of good and evil in The Rings of Power season three. And that’s that there’s no such thing as good and evil at all—there’s only power. Those who are strong enough to hold it can dominate, while those who lack it are weak and become dominated. And after being dominated his whole life, Theo is done with that aspect of existence.
RELATED ARTICLE
The Fate of Theo in THE RINGS OF POWER Season 3 (Exclusive Interviews & Images)Muhafidin confirms Theo’s philosophy in The Rings of Power season three: “I think Theo does believe that there’s no good and evil, only power. And that’s because I think he sees the power of the Númenóreans, and he knows that to the world the Númenóreans are supposed to be a good force, and they’re known for being strong. But all he knows now of the Númenóreans is betrayal, pain, and suffering. So he knows that they aren’t good either. But they’re powerful. And he wants to retaliate, and the only way he can see to beat them is to be more powerful. And I think Sauron really convinces him that no one is good. The elves, they are the good guys, but when Theo was growing up, his whole childhood, he was oppressed by the elves and was looked down upon, and he felt their power over him, and he had nothing. And so I think his lines of good and evil have become blurred because the good guys have been evil towards him.” And it is hard to argue against that, especially with Sauron in your ear.
And speaking of what Sauron has been whispering to Theo in The Rings of Power season three, we thought we heard him say some very interesting words. Sauron tells Theo that he is born to be “a conqueror, a sorcerer… A King.” And now that Theo is a Nazgnagôl on the way to becoming a Nazgûl in The Rings of Power, that sounds highly suggestive to us. While watching The Rings of Power, we always have to keep our eyes out for the origin stories of lore characters. And the leader of the Nazgûl, the Witch-king of Angmar, who just happens to be a conqueror, a sorcerer, and a King, is a character whose identity Tolkien never revealed.
Prime Video
Could season three be setting Theo up to be the Witch-king of Angmar? Tyroe Muhafidin offers only this on whether his character will become the chief of all Nazgûl in The Rings of Power: “It’s been discussed. I talk about it with the showrunners a lot, but they’ve got their plans that I don’t know, and I try to poke and figure it out, but they know what’s up.” And we will too… But only when the time is right.
Ultimately, Muhafidin just wants people to feel something authentic when they see Theo’s journey in The Rings of Power season three. He offers, “I hope people enjoy the performance. I poured every last drop I had into this, and I lived this role for eight months, and I really gave it everything. I think what I want people to take away is that not every story is going to be a happy ending, and there really are some people who are living in tragedy, and that is just their life, and it’s really unfortunate. So where you can, be grateful for the role models you have around you that give you good guidance.”
Although one chapter has ended for Theo on The Rings of Power, another has only just begun. And whether he becomes a full-fledged Nazgûl, the Witch-king of Angmar, or somehow manages to escape back to the light, we can’t wait to see where Theo goes in the rest of season three and beyond.
If you’d like to learn more about this Middle-earth adventure, you can pick up The Fall of Númenor: And Other Tales from the Second Age of Middle-earth and read more about Tolkien’s vision of the time when the show takes place.
The Rings of Power season three is now airing on Prime Video.
This post has affiliate links, which means we may earn advertising money if you buy something. This doesn’t cost you anything extra, we just have to give you the heads up for legal reasons. Click away!
Rotem Rusak is the Editor-in-Chief at Nerdist. She is a great lover of the anti-hero and is always ready for a new ship to set sail. In her work, she likes to combine fandom passion with journalistic sensibilities. Follow her on Instagram.The post You’ve Watched the Origin of a Nazgûl in THE RINGS OF POWER (Exclusive) appeared first on Nerdist.

