Pete Hegseth Plays Major Victim Card in Weird Speech on Impeachment
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth claimed Tuesday that he was being threatened with impeachment for being too good at his job.
Speaking at a press conference at the Pentagon, Hegseth began by denying any wrongdoing and claiming that the United States had actually won victories in both Iran and Venezuela.
“For the first time in American history, a Cabinet secretary overseeing America’s military is being attacked, not for losing conflicts with our enemies, but for winning them. Condemned not for defeat but for military victory,” he said.
Of course, that’s not why he’s being impeached at all: Outgoing Republican Representative Thomas Massie’s 34-page impeachment resolution accuses Hegseth of committing a slew of impeachable offenses by illegally waging war against Iran, suppressing free speech, ignoring laws intended to minimize civilian casualties, and overseeing extrajudicial killings and the kidnapping of a foreign leader. Hegseth insisted that these were not only lawful operations, but victories.
Hegseth claimed that efforts to remove him were being championed by “one disgruntled and defeated congressman,” and that people in the media would never admit to the military’s successes because they “hate the president more than [they] love our country or our troops.”
Hegseth also argued that the impeachment efforts were targeting something bigger than just one delusional Defense secretary. “Make no mistake about what is happening. This is not about me,” he said.
“Put the secretary on trial today, and the men and women who carried out those orders tomorrow,” he added. “If they want to come for the warriors, they’re going to have to come through me.”
Hegseth’s feeble DARVO manipulation strategy crumbles under the slightest pressure. As valorous of a gesture as that may appear, the only person to blame for the crimes committed by U.S. service members is the guy who ordered them—and his boss.
Speaking of President Donald Trump, Hegseth compared his situation to the president’s previous two impeachments.
“Now they’re trying a third time,” Hegseth said. “This time against a member of his Cabinet. They will fail again. And if standing with President Trump puts me in that company, I’ll take that company every day of the week.”
If impeachment is a badge of honor to Hegseth, it’s no wonder he has such backwards ideas about victories and defeats.
Tuesday morning traffic: Head-on crash blocks San Juan Rd; Hwy 1 lane closed
This post is updated throughout the day to reflect the latest incidents. It was last updated at 6:31 a.m..
Here’s what’s happening on the roads this morning…
▼︎ new incidents
Road incidents as of 6:30 a.m. on November 10- Two vehicles were involved in a head-on collision at San Juan Rd and Ramadero Way in Watsonville / Pajaro at 8:44 p.m. on Nov. 9. One vehicle went off the road at high speed, and one driver was trapped inside. There were minor injuries. Emergency services responded, and both lanes were blocked for a while before the road was reopened.
- There was a traffic collision at Green Valley Rd and Melody Ln in the Corralitos / Freedom area at 6:25 a.m. today. It’s not known if anyone was hurt, and no details about the vehicles were given. The fire department responded to the scene.
- The #1 lane is closed on southbound Highway 1 between Park and State Park in Capitola / Soquel because of road or weather conditions. This was reported on Nov. 9.
- South Highway 1 at Park Avenue in Capitola / Soquel is facing closures because of paving work. The closure will last until Nov. 19 at 7:01 a.m.
- Highway 9 at Pool Drive in San Lorenzo Valley will have alternating lane closures because of bridge work. This will continue until April 30, 2027, at 6:59 a.m.
Disclosure: Traffic incidents are partially generated by artificial intelligence. We are constantly working to improve the accuracy and quality of our AI-generated content. However, there may still be errors or inaccuracies. If you have any questions or concerns, please contact us.
The post Tuesday morning traffic: Head-on crash blocks San Juan Rd; Hwy 1 lane closed appeared first on Lookout Santa Cruz.
Adobe adds more AI to its products and launches an MCP
Anthropic sets IPO price range of $70 to $78 per share to reach an implied valuation of $1.404 trillion
Worst press secretary ever wants another shot to woo Trump
You’d think that after flaming out in a job after just five days—in no small part because you repeatedly lied about your professional achievements—you might just move on. But not Katie Zacharia. Now, one should take this with the customary metric ton of salt given the source, but the New York Post reports that Zacharia was dawdling at Mar-a-Lago over the weekend…
Stanford's century-long AI study admits it's already out of date
Twelve years into Stanford's 100-year study of artificial intelligence, the project's third report raises more questions than it answers.
The 2026 AI100 Study Panel report acknowledges its limitations in its twelfth takeaway: "This report will be out of date by the time you read it."
But it's nonetheless a worthwhile exercise for those who haven't been paying close attention to the development of machine learning over the past few years and for policymakers who may benefit from a review of AI's metastatic growth.
"The last five years constitute a watershed moment in the history of AI," said Professor Sheila McIlraith, chair of the AI100 Standing Committee, in a statement. "This report examines what led to the extraordinary capabilities of today's AI systems, and how they are reshaping society. As we look ahead, we anticipate continued increase in AI capabilities alongside transformative advances in science and medicine.
"Rapid change will challenge governments and industry to support and safeguard our people, our institutions, and our critical infrastructure. Both the benefits and the risks of AI technologies require the same clear-eyed scrutiny."
Established in 2014, the One Hundred Year Study on Artificial Intelligence (AI100) is overseen by a Standing Committee of AI experts and administered by Stanford's Institute for Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence (HAI). It's charged with producing reports every five years, the first of which debuted in 2016.
The 2026 report's other key points highlight the transformation brought about by increasingly capable machine learning software.
It identifies scaling as the engine of AI's advance, but also points to the growing cost and difficulty of obtaining training data as constraints on further progress.
The report likens AI's disruptive potential to that of the World Wide Web – without dwelling on the irony that the web itself is among the things being disrupted. It points to creative industries, computer programming, and mathematics as fields once deemed beyond the reach of automation that are now being upended.
Science, the report says, is being transformed by AI as it accelerates research timelines and opens up novel challenges. At the same time, the report cautions that "we will need to understand how AI-mediated information environments reshape collective cognition and moral behavior." The recent retraction of some 1,400 scholarly papers for failure to meet academic standards highlights the urgency of that message.
Then there's the AI investment boom and "fears of a financial bubble," which won't be assuaged by recent NASDAQ volatility and revelations about Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang's relationship with an alleged intelligence operative for China.
Concerns about the concentration of frontier AI development, the pressure AI puts on cybersecurity, and the active use of AI for military applications are also noted in the report.
So too are worries about what AI-generated media does to trust.
Item nine on the report's takeaway list is perhaps the most noteworthy: "AI is reshaping the lives of billions of people, yet the public has had little say in how it is developed and deployed."
The recent US midterms suggest voters are finding ways to make themselves heard about AI datacenters, even if that falls short of shaping broader AI policy.
Item ten posits that longstanding academic concerns about AI bias, ethics, and safety are beginning to converge with what until recently seemed like worries inspired by speculative fiction, such as AI agents hacking into companies without human oversight.
And item 11 frames the entire report by calling out the lack of a coherent regulatory response to AI: "AI governance is fragmented and increasingly framed in terms of national security, with little international consensus among states on its direction."
Those takeaways introduce the AI100 Study Panel's examination of 12 standing questions about what AI makes possible and how humans are handling it. Easy answers are in short supply.
But as the report's disclosure section makes clear, even the people taking the century-long view are using the technology to assess itself.
"Reflecting the progress in AI over the period this report covers, AI tools were used extensively in its production," the report explains.
"The report was written by humans, and its authors used AI primarily to transcribe and summarize meetings, support dictation, and check drafts for typos, consistency, duplication, tone, and structure. In some cases, AI suggested rewording of human-written text. AI was also used to compare this report with previous AI100 reports, identifying where expectations and reality have diverged or converged over five years. After completion, AI tools checked for inadvertent plagiarism and signs of AI-generated content." ®
Aura’s newest e-ink photo frame is even better and more affordable than its last
After challenging Google’s Android with Cyanogen, its co-founder takes aim at Windows for AI era
Spotify’s AI DJ gets new voices, personalities, and an option for less chatter
Mr. Wiener goes to Washington
A cartoon by Jack Ohman. Related | The midterms scrambled the map…
Ring, known for its doorbell cameras, launches a home security drone and an enterprise security robot
Chrome zero-day whack-a-mole continues as 2026 tally hits 8
Google has patched its eighth actively exploited Chrome zero-day of 2026, matching its total for the whole of last year with nearly two months still left on the calendar.
The latest flaw, tracked as CVE-2026-125350, is a high-severity use-after-free vulnerability in Chrome's XML component. Google confirmed in a security advisory published Monday that attackers are already exploiting the bug, although it hasn't said who's behind the attacks or who might be getting targeted.
"Google is aware that an exploit for CVE-2026-125350 exists in the wild," the company said, offering little else about the attacks.
The vulnerability was reported anonymously on November 6 and involves a memory management error that occurs when software continues using a pointer to memory that has already been freed. Such bugs can potentially allow attackers to corrupt memory and execute malicious code, although Google hasn't disclosed how this particular flaw is being exploited.
Google is keeping further technical details under wraps until enough users have installed the fix, a familiar approach intended to stop other attackers from getting their hands on a working exploit.
The patch arrives in Chrome 157.0.8103.50/.51 for Windows and macOS, and 157.0.8103.50 for Linux. The update also addresses eight other security vulnerabilities, including high-severity flaws affecting WebGL, FileSystem, GPU, Compositing, and the V8 JavaScript engine.
The release fixes another use-after-free bug in Chrome's XML component, CVE-2026-125346, which was reported by Arni Hardarson of Neonix Security in October, though Google hasn't indicated that this second vulnerability is being exploited.
The latest discovery adds to what's becoming a rather long list of Chrome zero-days this year. By June, Google had already patched five actively exploited Chrome zero-days, including flaws in its V8 JavaScript engine, Skia graphics library, and WebGPU implementation. The list has only grown since then, with two more V8 bugs fixed in September and the latest XML vulnerability bringing the total to eight.
That puts 2026 level with 2025, when Google also fixed eight Chrome zero-days exploited in the wild. Whether the browser maker can make it through the remaining weeks of the year without adding another to the pile is anyone's guess.
Google says the latest update will roll out over the coming days and weeks, but users can check manually by heading to Chrome's Settings menu and selecting About Chrome. With attackers already making use of the vulnerability, it's probably worth doing that sooner rather than waiting for Chrome to get around to it. ®
Grizzlies fall short to Santa Lucia Division co-champion Marina | High school football roundup
There was a lot on the line for the Marina High football team going into last week’s home and regular season finale against Pajaro Valley High.
For the first time in the program’s short 15-year history, the Mariners were on the cusp of clinching the Pacific Coast Athletic League Santa Lucia Division title or at least earn a spot in the Central Coast Section playoffs.
They accomplished both with a 49-35 victory over the Grizzlies in league action Nov. 5.
“We came into this season, we had a rough start,” said Marina senior Logan True after the game. “I ain’t gonna lie, I didn’t think we were gonna do it. After that Greenfield game, something changed. Everything clicked together, and this is what happens when it clicks.”
Marina (7-3, 6-1), which will share the Santa Lucia Division title with Greenfield High, earned the No. 2 seed in the newly established Division VI bracket that is made for schools competing in a ‘C’ or ‘D’ league.
They will host No. 3 Independence (9-1, 6-0), champion of the Blossom Valley Athletic League’s West Valley Division, on Friday at 7pm.
Clinching a league title and going to the playoffs is something that True’s brothers, Isaiah (2024) and Kaleb (2026), never got to experience. Which is why this moment in time is beyond extraordinary for him.
“It’s a great feeling,” Logan True said. “We’re putting Marina on the map. Both of my brothers went here, they played football. They never did this, so I’m doing it for them. I’m doing it for my family, doing it for everybody in Marina.”
Pajaro Valley was hoping to play the role of spoiler once again after it handed Greenfield (8-2, 6-1) its lone loss in league play nearly one month ago.
“I guarantee you, they [Marina] weren’t expecting to get that from us,” Pajaro Valley head coach Ray Myers said. “That was the way we played all year long. We’ve never given up.”
But the Grizz dug themselves too deep into a hole in the first quarter, which included a 74-yard touchdown reception by True.
The speedy wideout caught a 1-yard bubble screen, juked a group of defenders and sprinted near the sideline to the end zone on the first play from scrimmage.
The Mariner special teams unit came up clutch on a surprise onside kick that was recovered by junior Ace Sledge. Moments later, senior Marcel Covita had himself a TD that put them ahead at 14-0.
Pajaro Valley’s offense also gave away the ball on a fumble lost, and the special teams unit nearly recovered a surprise onside kick of its own but a penalty was called for a player touching the ball within the 10 yards of reaching the restraining line.
“Our game plan, as it is always, is to hold on to the football and keep the ball out of their athletes’ hands,” Myers said. “I thought we did a good job of that tonight, but the turnovers kind of give them extra possessions that they can have on there.”
The Grizzlies stayed within reach thanks to a pair of rushing touchdowns from senior Adrian Valadez, who finished with 119 yards on the ground. His bulldozing 5-yard TD run cut the deficit at 20-14 just before halftime.
“We knew it was going to be a good run game, heavy run team,” True said. “We just knew we had to go through, run through somebody, and stop the run.”
Easier said than done. Teammate senior running back Adrian Mendoza finished with a game-best 238 yards rushing and three touchdowns on 39 carries.
He also tried his best to keep PV afloat in what turned out to be a high-scoring affair.
“It’s always been our thing: just running it hard and just giving it all we can,” Mendoza said. “It’s a lot of teamwork, everyone has to do their parts, fix every little mistake and stuff.”
Mendoza made it a one-score game at 42-35 with a little more than two minutes remaining in the contest. That’s as close as they would get, though.
After the sound of the final buzzer, the Mariners ran onto the field to celebrate a historical feat that the Grizzlies have yet to do.
Pajaro Valley finished with a 4-6 overall record, and placed seventh in the Santa Lucia Division standings this 2026 fall season. Four of the defeats were by seven points or less.
“It felt like a roller coaster. It was really fun,” Mendoza said. “A lot of wins and losses, but overall, I think it was a pretty good season.”
The future is looking bright for the Grizzlies and Myers, who expects a majority of his players returning to work in the spring. He is scheduled to teach a strength and conditioning class during the offseason to keep them in shape for next fall.
“I can’t wait to get in the weight room,” Myers said. “We got a little bit of a taste of it in the season here. But man, we’re really going to get after it and get stronger.”
Monte Vista Christian 20, at Watsonville 14 (OT): Johnny Finney recorded the game-sealing interception for the Mustangs in a thrilling comeback win over the Wildcatz in PCAL Mission North Division play Nov. 6.
In the extra period, senior Jordan Ramirez ran 15 yards for the go-ahead touchdown. He led the ground game with 145 yards rushing and one score on 27 carries, while teammate Brandon Hagen added 27 yards on five rushes.
Through the air, senior quarterback Evan Vessey completed 10 of 18 passes for 90 yards with one touchdown and one interception. James Tipton caught four passes for 45 yards, and Ramirez snagged three receptions for 24 yards. Senior Emilian Tenwinkel hauled in three receptions for 21 yards and one score.
Junior linebacker Reece Walker led the defense with eight tackles, followed by Zach Moran and Hagen with six apiece. Blaise Borjon contributed five tackles, Finney racked up four, and both Gabe Figliomeni and Rocco DeBernardo tallied three.
Hagen also recorded one forced fumble and two sacks, while Borjon also had a pair of sacks. Walker, Moran, Figliomeni and DeBernardo each added one sack.
The Mustang defense had no answer early in the contest as Watsonville struck first in the opening quarter. Senior Mark Flores broke loose for a 63-yard touchdown run, putting them ahead at 7-0.
The ‘Catz extended their lead when senior quarterback Edwin Cornejo connected with junior Noel Navarro on a 22-yard scoring strike.
MVC responded with a pair of field goals by kicker Massimo Melo from 29 and 33 yards out, pulling his team to within eight points.
They leveled the score on the opening play of the fourth quarter. Vessey found Tenwinkel for a 4-yard touchdown pass, and he hauled in the two-point conversion to tie the score at 14-all.
MVC finished the regular season with a 7-3 overall record, and placed third in the Mission North Division standings with a 3-2 record in league play.
They missed out on an at-large bid for the CCS playoffs by one point, which was determined by the High School Ratings website.
Watsonville finished with a 3-7 overall record, and tied for fifth in the Mission North with a 1-4 record in the league standings.
At St. Francis 34, Scotts Valley 14: The Sharks recorded their first league win of the season with a stunning win over the Falcons in PCAL Mission North Division play Nov. 7.
With the win, St. Francis (3-7) improved to 1-4 in the league standings to tie with Watsonville (3-7, 1-4) for fifth place this 2026 fall campaign.
Scotts Valley (5-5) was eliminated from CCS postseason contention after suffering its second consecutive loss in league play, and finishing with a 2-3 record in league play this season.
Ransomware threat blares from Vanderbilt University computers during cyberattack
Classes at Vanderbilt University are proceeding as scheduled today, although access to most university systems remains restricted following a cyberattack claimed by ransomware group BYOD.
Vanderbilt announced on Monday morning that it was dealing with "an active cybersecurity incident," and that the fallout may affect university devices, systems, and cloud-based services.
The Nashville-based university initially told students and staff to shut down university devices and disconnect from campus Wi-Fi. It warned them to watch for unexpected prompts, altered files or permissions, unfamiliar applications, and unsolicited authentication requests.
Campus computers reportedly began playing an audio threat attributed to BYOD. Student newspaper The Vanderbilt Hustler cited posts on campus social network Fizz showing the message.
"You have been compromised by BYOD," the recording said. "We suggest you reach out to us as soon as possible. Instructions have been placed on your desktop. Failure to communicate will result in this estate being brought to the ground completely. Make the right choice or rot with the wrong one."
By Monday evening, Vanderbilt had restored access to campus Wi-Fi, but warned that access to most systems remains restricted.
"We know this has disrupted important work and caused frustration across the university," it said. "Vanderbilt Information Technology is working with government agencies and other partners to manage this situation."
Students were told to attend classes as scheduled on Tuesday and contact instructors about flexibility on coursework deadlines. Staff were instructed to report to work normally.
Vanderbilt's Athletics department said that its ticketing system was unavailable, and that students were unable to claim tickets for the college's football game against Alabama on Saturday.
BYOD claimed responsibility for the attack on Vanderbilt on Monday, along with extensive data theft.
"If you could not tell already, your databases are locked [and] we have your entire estate and research data," it said via its leak site.
"Over 1 million SSNs, full names, email addresses, phone numbers, student and employee records, full takeover of your DC, whatever was on your network, we possess."
Vanderbilt has not confirmed BYOD's claims about the extent of its access or the data allegedly stolen.
BYOD may be a familiar name to some. The group previously claimed attacks on the University of New Mexico and Trump Mobile's customer database.
BYOD also claimed responsibility on Monday for an attack on Texas Health and Human Services. The agency has not publicly confirmed an incident and did not immediately respond to our questions. ®
Cyberattacks threaten to make open-source AI a little less open, Hugging Face exec warns
Smart meters to cost the UK billions: 2G switch-off means replacing 12-13 million
Between 12 and 13 million UK smart meters could stop working properly when 2G and 3G networks are switched off by 2033, and replacing them all is likely to cost around £4 billion ($5.3 billion).
Smart meters have long been a controversial topic thanks to the British government's botched rollout of the technology; they were supposed to be fitted into 80 percent of households by 2020.
But numerous delays and technical hitches, such as consumers finding their meter stopped being smart if they switched energy supplier, hindered progress.
Now, a report from connectivity biz Wirepas, "The European Connectivity Trilemma," shows that it isn't just Brits who have problems, but that other European countries also have their share of smart meter issues and that no two countries have adopted the same approach.
The UK's issues center on the fact that early meters used 2G or 3G cellular connections to transmit energy usage back to the supplier. These continued to be fitted until 4G versions began arriving at the end of 2024, the report says.
This issue was covered by The Register back in 2023, and again in 2024.
However, the government had already announced measures to phase out 2G and 3G networks by 2033 several years earlier, back in 2021, so it was known that any meters being fitted would have a limited lifespan.
In fact, 3G services have now already been withdrawn by the networks, and they all plan to phase out 2G ahead of the 2033 deadline. BT/EE will begin closing its network from May 2029, VMO2 will start the same summer, and Vodafone aims to switch off in spring 2030.
The report claims the UK now faces two substantial areas of expenditure as a result. The first covers newer, second generation (SMETS2) meters, where only the communications module needs swapping out, but even this is likely to cost £1.3 to £1.4 billion (c $1.7 to $1.9 billion) before the hardware cost of each new hub is even factored in.
The other is for an estimated 7 million older, first-generation (SMETS1) meter installations, which have the cellular comms hard-wired in, so the whole meter typically needs replacing. The report authors estimate this will cost another £2.1 billion to £2.45 billion ($2.8 billion to $3.3 billion), at an indicative replacement cost of £300 to £350 per installation.
This results in the estimated £4 billion in gross replacement costs, which will ultimately feed into household energy bills, adding to the very costs the government is currently trying to reduce.
We asked the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero (DESNZ), which oversees smart meters, for comment.
While some of these older meters would naturally have been due for replacement as part of normal asset renewal cycles, the cell network shutdown makes the replacement program unavoidable and dictates when much of the expenditure must occur.
According to the report, the SMETS2 replacement largely applies to central and southern Britain, as second-gen meters in the north use a long-range radio network and are not subject to the 2G/3G cut-off. However, the issue of older SMETS1 meters applies nationwide.
Wirepas' interest in all of this is that it specializes in IoT connectivity and is pushing NR+ as a solution to the issue. Based on the DECT-2020 New Radio standard developed by the European Telecommunication Standards Institute (ETSI), this is designed to be scalable and operates in the license-exempt and globally available 1.9GHz part of the spectrum.
When 4G technology reaches the end of its life, (which isn't likely to happen until the 2040s, and there is no planned date) the UK's smart meters will need to be replaced once again, the report asserts. However, this is sufficiently far in the future that it is unlikely to trouble policymakers anytime soon. ®
Transcript: MAGA Rages as Trump Lets Slip Damning Truth about GOP Loss
The following is a lightly edited transcript of the November 10 episode of The Daily Blast podcast. Listen to it here.
Greg Sargent: This is The Daily Blast from The New Republic, produced and presented by the DSR Network. I’m your host, Greg Sargent.
Donald Trump just admitted to CBS News that his mass deportations helped cause the GOP’s electoral bloodbath last week. In one way, this is absurd, since he also just elevated Stephen Miller, the architect of that agenda, to chief of staff. But in another way, Trump admitted to something that really does undercut the MAGA movement, and even undermines JD Vance heading into 2028. And the MAGA rage has begun.
We’re sorting through what this means with political scientist Julia Azari, who’s been writing well on this election’s deeper currents for the Good Politics/Bad Politics Substack. Julia, thanks for coming on.
Julia Azari: Yeah, thank you for having me.
Sargent: So let’s start with Trump’s admission. Here he was asked by Ross Douthat of CBS whether immigration hurt the GOP in the midterms. Listen to this.
Donald Trump (voiceover): I think it both helped and hurt. I think I got an A-plus for closing up the border. I get very high marks for getting the bad ones out. But I get hurt because we also took people that had good jobs, that created one violation, or breaking of the law, and that was that they came into the country illegally. Now, there is a large part of the country that think that they should be put out, and there’s a large part of the country that think that they should be allowed to stay. If they’re good people working in a landscaping company or working in a hotel or doing something, right? And in some cases paying taxes. And a large group of people think that they should be allowed to stay.
Sargent: Julia, let’s break this up into pieces. The first key point, I think, is that Trump admitted there that Americans view a lot of undocumented immigrant workers as good people, as if they’re legitimately here in the U.S. despite having come here illegally. That’s anathema to MAGA, isn’t it?
Azari: Yeah, I mean, I think the thing that’s really interesting is that when you look at American political opinion about immigration, it’s actually really sensitive to how the question is phrased and what the framing is. And, you know, Americans consider a lot of different things and have a lot of different kinds of mixed feelings about immigrants and immigration.
But MAGA has been very clear that they’ve used this kind of law framing, but really that they’re also after legal immigration. They’re also out to decrease the number of foreign-born people living and working in this country. That’s been a very, very clear priority. And here Trump really kind of undercuts all of that.
Sargent: The 2024 election was heavily about that. When they went after the Haitians in Springfield, Ohio, for supposedly eating dogs and cats, those people were here legally. They had actually helped revive a Rust Belt city, Springfield. And they were very much targeted by JD Vance, who simply dismissed the idea that they had come legally.
He just declared them illegal, sort of by fiat. And so, yes, MAGA is not about law enforcement. It’s much more about, let’s make the country whiter, let’s reduce the number of immigrants here.
Azari: I mean, I think that it’s also worth noting that once Vance and Trump and Miller have been in power in the White House, their decision that some people are illegal just by fiat is no longer just rhetorical.
There are ways in which the executive branch can make those decisions, and they did do that to the Haitian population living in Ohio on temporary protected status.
Sargent: They absolutely did. The other thing Trump admitted to there is that removing undocumented workers has turned out to be terrible politics for the Republican Party. And this, critically, I think, goes beyond admitting that ICE’s violent enforcement tactics—the paramilitary raids of U.S. cities, the mass kidnappings, and so forth—were politically alienating to people.
It goes further and admits that the underlying ideological goal of removing immigrants itself was unpopular. That’s something that even a lot of pundits wouldn’t admit to for a long time. What did you make of that piece of it?
Azari: Again, this is sort of multifaceted, right? Some of it is about ICE. Some of it is about the kind of broader American experience of watching these kind of masked agents attacking people, removing people, hurting people, in a couple of cases killing people.
And in other cases, it’s really thinking about the role that undocumented immigrants play in our society, and how deeply integrated they are into the economy, particularly the service economy.
And I thought it was very notable to me that Trump brought up these service examples and talked about people working in hotels. It’s a very Trump example of the work that undocumented immigrants do. And it turns out that having people filling those roles is very popular with a lot of people.
Sargent: Yes, he chose landscaping and hotel work and so forth, but he was actually speaking to the experiences of many Americans, who maybe don’t spend as much time in hotels as Donald Trump does, but constantly and very regularly encounter undocumented immigrants in their daily lives. They encounter undocumented immigrants who are integrated into the economy all around us, right?
And I think Donald Trump was quite conscious, if you look at how he said that stuff, that he was delivering a twist of the knife to MAGA in some ways. He was essentially saying a lot of Americans view these undocumented immigrants as good workers, as doing important things, as complementing American workers. And that is a striking thing.
Again, he’s not going to do anything about it. We know that. But still, it’s interesting that he went there, I thought. What did you think?
Azari: Traditionally in Republican politics, I think they’ve really relied on this distinction between legal and illegal immigration. And I think one thing that has been sort of revealed over the last couple of years is that that distinction is not always super clear. Like I said, legal status is something that the executive branch can influence.
But also, what we’ve seen with ICE, and what I think is really worth pointing out, is that ICE has not been terribly discerning about the legal status of the people that they’ve gone after.
And there have been people who are perfectly documented, and people who are American citizens, who have either had encounters with ICE, or who have changed their lifestyle patterns to avoid having encounters with ICE.
Sargent: So in the interview, Trump also said he’s open to working with Democrats on immigration, which, again, is not going to happen, given Stephen Miller’s role. We’ll come back to that. But MAGA figures raged about this. I’m going to read a few.
One leading MAGA guy, Steve Cortes, said, “If President Trump softens on immigration enforcement, it will be a disaster.” MAGA influencer Nick Sortor went absolutely nuts, raging in all caps: “WITHOUT DEPORTATIONS, OUR COUNTRY IS GONE. PERIOD.” Still another MAGA guy, Joey Mannarino, posted: “If Trump does this, I’m done.”
Now, Trump won’t do it, but these MAGA figures are not wrong, in the sense that he admitted to something that’s anathema to them, i.e., that immigrants are good for America, right?
Azari: Yeah, I think that’s right. So I think there’s kind of two things, again, happening here. And one is, this is the danger of operating in polarized politics, is that you have this kind of unsavory choice between the politics—which is, a lot of your supporters are going to want you to demonize the other side—and the policy, which is, you’re probably going to have to work across party lines.
And I think that’s a problem that affects basically everybody in American politics. But I think it affects MAGA in particular, because kind of all they have is juicing up the base with grievance. That’s really an important foundation of the movement.
And so when you can’t do that, what are you left with? You’re left with a bunch of, you know, as you said, kind of angry online people who are very publicly breaking with you. And that’s, in a lot of ways, Trump’s political base.
Sargent: I think what you’re getting at is that MAGA, to an unusually dramatic degree, is all about enemy politics, right? And so whenever Trump is not demonizing the enemy, which he does very well and very frequently and very viciously—whenever he’s not doing that, it’s a big letdown to MAGA, right?
Azari: Yeah, exactly. There sort of is no MAGA without that. Like, Republicans, non-MAGA Republicans, and Democrats also are incentivized to demonize the other side, but there are other things going on in those politics.
Sargent: Yeah, absolutely. So this also breaks with JD Vance in an interesting way. In Vance’s now kind of infamous tweet blaming Trump’s war for the bloodbath, Vance also said he’s open to the idea of changing immigration enforcement.
Now, people have treated that as this big concession, but it just isn’t a concession, because Vance also said that the GOP absolutely cannot respond to this loss with, quote-unquote, amnesty. Vance won’t even entertain the idea that voters might have turned against the deeper ideological goal of ridding the country of immigrants. Yet Trump kind of said it.
Julia, I want to ask you this. I really wonder if this is going to become a real schism inside the GOP, because there’s still plenty of Republicans hanging around who would like to see immigration reform, even though they’ve been a lot quieter in the Trump years. And I wonder if a few of them start to step forward. In fact, we just saw one House member go quite forcefully in that direction. What do you think?
Azari: After I heard Vance’s comments initially, my prediction was that what we would see is a coalition that, instead of actually having it out over kind of core issues, tries to isolate the president. And I think this kind of happens when presidents are in their last two years and they’ve had a bad midterm.
And you kind of saw it with George W. Bush, right? It really becomes about the president and not about the broader political movement. And so, well, this is the person whose fault this is.
Sargent: Can you explain what you mean a little bit by isolate the president? So Vance is taking steps right now to sort of subtly push Trump into his own camp, kind of?
Azari: I think so, yeah. And really to blame bad things that have happened on things that you kind of pin on Trump specifically. So, you know, the decision to go to war in Iran, decisions that he’s made about immigration enforcement—and kind of say, well, these were specific Trump things. They weren’t about the broader kind of MAGA or populist ideology, or whatever it is that they’re going to want to maybe call it later on.
Sargent: It is really interesting. Let’s bring in Stephen Miller’s role here for a second. The New York Times reported something that I thought was of interest. I’m just going to read it, speaking about Miller here: “His top priority, aides said, is rebuilding the fractured MAGA coalition and pursuing policies that will energize the voters who elected Mr. Trump in 2024.” That’s by way of explaining Miller’s desire to continue with a hard-line agenda.
Julia, it seems like there’s, like, a core contradiction here that’s worth drawing out. Like, on the one hand, what Miller is saying is that what went wrong is that the MAGA coalition fell apart. On the other hand, he’s also saying hardcore MAGA voters need to be energized.
But those two things are, like, in contradiction with each other, because it’s the hard-line policies that fractured the MAGA coalition. Yet Miller wants to now double down on the violent white nationalism to energize those very core voters. I just don’t see the way forward for MAGA if that’s their fundamental understanding of the situation. Do you?
Azari: Yeah, I think there’s sort of a version of this, again, that’s kind of typical in American politics, which is that you have to make this trade-off between energizing your core voters and building a broader coalition. But I think this tension really has animated the Trump project from the beginning. And it’s always been a pretty narrow project.
And so if we’d been having this conversation eight years ago, I would say, well, what we’ve seen is, this is a president who lost the popular vote, and blah, blah, blah. But in 2024, there was, like, this glimmer of a broader Trump coalition. This more multiracial—it was more voters.
And so I think there was sort of, like, this glimmer of that. And I think nobody—not Stephen Miller, not people on podcasts, not Democrats—actually has, like, a clear picture of what that coalition was and kind of where it went.
Sargent: Right.
Azari: Yeah. I think it’s really complicated. But yeah, I mean, I think that’s sort of what Miller’s laying out. And he’s basically saying what you would expect anybody to say after a really bad midterm. But it’s interesting, because the merging of chief of staff and top political adviser, that’s a very complicated merging of roles. I have a lot of thoughts about that.
Sargent: Well, it just strikes me that if you’re going to respond to this election loss by doubling down on the violent white nationalism, you’re just never going to get back to anything close to the coalition that they got in 2024. And I don’t claim to understand that coalition. It is complicated.
I think maybe it’s an anti-inflation coalition, and kind of an anti-incumbent coalition to some degree, and a lot of young people who felt really, really, really disoriented by the upheavals of the post-Covid trauma and stuff. B
ut it just seems to me that Miller is such an ideologue that he is going to claim he wants to rebuild this coalition, but he doesn’t actually give a shit about that. He really just wants to make the country whiter. That’s what he wants, you know?
Azari: Yeah, I mean, everything about his background illustrates that. I mean, just to speak to just observable facts, right? He has no background in kind of building a national coalition. He’s not the architect of any kind of Trumpist 50-state strategy. He’s the immigration guy. He’s the homeland security guy.
And he’s been very clear on his take and his viewpoints. And when you combine that with an administration that can’t run again anyway, I mean, what is he even talking about?
Sargent: I guess the bottom line, though, is that, judging by this MAGA fury at this tiny little admission by Trump, you can really not see Vance get through a primary by moderating in any sense, I don’t think, can you?
Azari: No, I think that’s probably right. And I think that the safest prediction about what the 2028 primary will look like will be a situation in which candidates are really pressured to throw red meat to the base. I don’t know if we still use that terminology. This is, like, Bush-era terminology. But I think that that will be the set of pressures in that primary campaign.
And then when those pressures are really strong in a primary, then there are a lot of questions about whether that can be adaptable to a general election electorate. And that’s what Vance or Rubio or Ron DeSantis, or whoever is going to pursue that nomination in 2028, is probably going to face, some version of that dilemma.
Sargent: And Democrats have an opportunity to really torment Vance by just driving this wedge very deep, by pushing, I don’t know, for example, legislation creating new legal pathways for undocumented workers and stuff.
Sort of saying, well, the president said that these undocumented workers are good workers and good people. Well, does Vance not agree? And that could essentially force both Trump and Vance into some very uncomfortable positions, it seems, no?
Azari: Yeah, I think so. And those types of things that you’re talking about are quite popular and poll quite well. People generally support folks who’ve been living here having a path to legalization. But one thing Vance won’t have to do is cast the fifty-first vote in the Senate, so he’s off the hook for that.
Sargent: That is a very smart observation, and many of your observations today were. Folks, if you want to follow Julia Azari, go to Good Politics/Bad Politics on Substack. Julia, thanks so much for coming on.
Azari: Thank you so much for having me.
Democrats Will Dominate Georgia Utility Regulator for First Time in 30 Years
This story was originally published by Grist and WABE and is reproduced here as part of the Climate Desk collaboration.
Beginning in January, three of the five officials on the Georgia Public Service Commission will be Democrats. It will be the first time the party has controlled the powerful energy regulation board in 30 years. The commission, which regulates utilities including the state’s largest electric provider, Georgia Power, has come under more scrutiny in recent years due to rising power bills and the high energy demands of data centers.
“It’s not just this obscure regulatory body like it used to be treated. Its decisions directly affect household budgets.”
Now, Democrats plan to focus on affordability, clean energy, and closer scrutiny of Georgia Power. “There’s a long laundry list of things that need to be looked into,” said Democratic Commissioner Peter Hubbard, who won his reelection bid this week. “And so we’ll have to triage, in fact, and decide how best to move forward.”
One of his first priorities will be launching an affordability docket, he said—a series of hearings that would delve into the reasons for high power bills and ways to save customers money. Hubbard said he and his fellow Democrats also plan to bring close scrutiny to upcoming Georgia Power requests around making more energy and adjusting customer rates. Shelia Edwards and Alicia Johnson are the other two Democrats on the Public Service Commission, or PSC.
But any changes, especially to power bills, will likely take time. “We may not be able to expect immediate effects on our wallets,” said Emory University associate professor Kristin Phillips, who studies energy burden and the PSC. “But I think we can expect immediate change in the types of decisions that are made.”
Affordability and high energy bills were driving issues in the campaigns both this year and last year; the two elections together resulted in the commission’s new Democratic majority.
“We knew that we had to connect the dots between energy and affordability,” said Brionté McCorkle of Georgia Conservation Voters, a group that campaigned for the Democratic candidates and worked to draw attention to the PSC elections. “It’s not just this obscure regulatory body like it used to be treated. Its decisions directly affect household budgets, communities, health, and our energy future.”
Chris Womack, the CEO of Southern Company, Georgia Power’s parent company, also acknowledged the central importance of affordability during the company’s third-quarter earnings call on Thursday. But Womack said he’s confident the utility can address those concerns with the new commissioners.
“If you look at what we have been doing with rate freezes, with benefits, with how we are providing benefits from growth to customers—existing customers—as well as to the communities, we think that’s a strong platform to stand on,” he said.
Since the beginning of the data center boom, Georgia Power has maintained that the increased revenue would more than pay for the new infrastructure needed to serve the centers, which the utility argues would keep rates lower for residential and small business customers. The utility calls this “downward pressure.” It doesn’t mean rates will go down, but rather that any increases would be offset by the influx of revenue from data centers.
“I absolutely think transparency is potentially one of the biggest impacts here.”
The utility recently doubled down on that promise as part of its deal to serve a massive new OpenAI data center. The deal, Georgia Power said, would bring $15 not of savings but of downward pressure per month for what Georgia Power calls the “typical” residential customer.
Separately, Georgia Power also credited the increased revenue from data centers for the temporary rate freeze approved last year. But the rate freeze received criticism from some advocacy groups. Instead of first holding a PSC hearing to give advocates a chance to verify the utility’s financial claims, Georgia Power announced the temporary rate freeze. Advocates feel that the backward process left them unable to confirm whether the company was delivering on its promises and fully shielding ordinary customers from data center costs.
It’s part of a broader criticism often leveled at the PSC and Georgia Power: lack of transparency. The OpenAI contract was entirely redacted, and only a summary was provided to the public after it was approved. Specific details involved in service contracts, deals to buy energy, and construction costs are often redacted from the utility’s public filings under the auspices of trade secrecy.
“I absolutely think transparency is potentially one of the biggest impacts here,” said Phillips of the election results. “It has been often on advocates to push on the way that the PSC communicates about the decisions that it’s making, and I’m hoping that there will be more clarity and transparency.”
The Democrats on the commission have promised to bring increased scrutiny to the next rate-setting process, due in 2028, along with Georgia Power’s long-term plans to make and deliver energy, its forecasts about rising demand, and other issues. Hubbard has also proposed conducting a rate case for the state’s natural gas utilities, which he said hasn’t been done in over a decade. And he said they’ll push for other changes going forward.
“We’ll continue with an agenda next year and the year after that to take advantage of this four-year period when we have the majority and can push for long-lasting reforms and shifting the direction of the state in terms of energy,” Hubbard said.
Meet the “Thielbillies” Reshaping the Republican Party
On four successive Monday evenings this fall, hundreds of people filed through metal detectors and past armed guards into the Grand Lodge of Tennessee, a Masonic temple in Nashville, for a very special closed-door event. Culturally, it was a world away from the cowboy-boot-clad bachelorette parties and honky-tonks of Broadway, the city’s nearby tourist drag. The “largely male and suit-wearing,” according to an account by Pirate Wires—had come to hear billionaire techno-optimist Peter Thiel lecture on the Antichrist.
By the final session, Thiel had spent a total of some six hours traversing political, economic, and religious history for his audience. He closed with a plea to the locals. He’d told the crowd he’d often been asked, “‘Why are you speaking in Nashville?’” according to leaked recordings obtained by Nashville investigative reporter Phil Williams. “In that question, I hear a mild inferiority complex.”
Nashville is “arguably the global capital of Protestantism,” Thiel said, and its residents should not leave “finance, technology, and politics to other people in other cities.” His exhortation was blunt: “Get over your inferiority complex and fight.”
Nashville is “arguably the global capital of Protestantism,” Thiel said, and its residents should “Get over your inferiority complex and fight.”
Two weeks later, the tech-right and the Republican Party finally got their fight—they lost. Democrats surged across the map, powered in part by a sharp swing among 18-to-29-year-old men. Texas, the right’s proving ground for a decade, fell outright: Democrats James Talarico and Gina Hinojosa beat Ken Paxton and ousted Greg Abbott. Tennessee was different, though. Sen. Marsha Blackburn won the governorship and state Republicans kept their legislative supermajorities.
Which is why the election’s most revealing post-mortem isn’t happening in Washington, but in Tennessee’s burgeoning right-wing intellectual scene—a red bubble inside a blue bubble inside a red state. Here, a well-heeled crew of tech workers, financiers, and edgelords—heavily dominated by men—are converging on a single conviction: that America is not an idea but a people, rooted in particular places, and that its wars and its borders must answer to them first.
Call them the Thielbillies. They’re into regionalism with a nativist edge—the politics of roots. Over the coming months, they are likely to define the reshaped GOP.
To understand the Thielbillies, start with The Pamphleteer, the right-leaning riff on an alt-weekly that Davis Hunt, a 36-year-old Nashville native, founded five years ago. With a staff of five, the publication, Hunt says, is writing for “an audience that’s kind of neglected by local media, which is people with perspectives like my own who are interested in Nashville, want it to do well, and don’t really have a home in local politics.” Only about 20 percent of Nashville’s registered voters turn out for city races, Hunt told me, and most of the Republicans who vote in midterms and presidential races “are not voting in metro elections.” The Pamphleteer wants them back in local politics, where conservatives have been losing.
Arguably more influential than The Pamphleteer’s coverage is its event series, which included Thiel’s Antichrist lectures. Last month, it hosted “Building on the Cultural Frontier,” a gathering that promised to inform its audience about a “cultural and educational revival” that includes “boys’ schools to properly educate the next generation of American men” and “conference circuits to facilitate robust intellectual discourse, especially on issues neglected or suppressed in academia.” In July, another Pamphleteer event featured Kevin Dolan, who organized last year’s NatalCon, a conference in Austin, Texas, that brought conservative Christians and techies together to strategize about how to get people to have more babies. Dolan has since turned his attention to running EXIT group, a “fraternity of like-minded men.”
Around the publication sits a constellation of related ventures. There’s Meriwether Academy, “a men’s group in Nashville built on great books, serious conversation, and the outdoors.” Meriwether has also co-hosted events with The Piraeus, a project of the Nashville-based writer Nick Gallo that offers “Grassroots Western Civ Revival” of salons, civic clubs, and retreats. (“Saving Western Civilization” from the libs and immigrant hordes has become a trendy pet project of the right.)
There’s also Delphica Society, which describes itself as a “decentralized, invitation-only club dedicated to the unapologetic pursuit of excellence, trust, capital, and a beautiful culture.” Last November, it partnered with Pamphleteer to host an event it called the Southern Revival Salon; the invitation instructed guests to “Expect a sensory feast: Tennessee whiskey-based cocktails paired with decadent caviar, live bands setting the stage ablaze, and the signature Delphica energy that blends refined elegance with raw vitality.” Featured guests included alt-right social media influencer Douglass Mackey, whose 2023 conviction for interference in the 2016 election was overturned on appeal last year, and Andrew Isker, a far-right pastor and the author of the 2023 book The Boniface Option: A Strategy for Christian Counteroffensive in a Post-Christian Nation.
In Nashville, the Thielbillies have real institutions to work with. “You also have country music, which is red-coded culture,” Hunt says. The Grand Ole Opry, he adds, is “inherently inflected with a Christian conservative” bent, and “the cultural output of the city is ingested mostly by conservative, red-blooded Americans.” Even Vanderbilt University has distinguished itself against academia’s activist drift, recently welcoming Education Secretary Linda McMahon to campus.
Nashville is a hub, but the Thielbilly movement is expanding. There’s Heritage Hubs Knoxville, an eastern Tennessee group that last month co-hosted an immigration forum featuring former Border Patrol Commander Gregory Bovino, followed by a watch party of the Tennessee–Arkansas college football game with the hard-right Mass Deportation Coalition. In Atlanta, there’s the 1903 Club, an invitation-only discussion and supper club for “the finest men in Dixie.” In St. Louis, there’s Oyarsa, a men’s salon series “working to make the city a home for intellectual and cultural life again and to inspire others in heartland cities to do the same.”
One event featured former Border Patrol Commander Gregory Bovino and a college football watch party with the hard-right Mass Deportation Coalition.
And then there’s the Highland Rim Project, a real estate initiative in rural northern Tennessee, the project of a conservative Christian venture capital firm called New Founding. The project is spearheaded by Josh Abbotoy, a former fellow at California’s arch-conservative Claremont Institute. He describes the Highland Rim Project as a group of “charter communities” organized around “traditional American values like faith, family, and freedom, in a rural and vintage small-town American setting.” It’s also a tech-forward project: Promotional materials note that the communities will be designed around “digital self-governance,” including cryptocurrency, and a culture “in which our patrimonial civic rights, chiefly those of property, free political speech, and civilian armament, can be maintained and perpetuated.”
The midterm election results will likely be a boon for Abbotoy’s project. That’s because Texas, the tech right’s adopted home since the pandemic, voted blue and Tennessee didn’t. Governor-elect Blackburn is, as Hunt puts it, “favorable towards data center development”—the state has no income tax, and the federally owned Tennessee Valley Authority is pursuing small modular nuclear reactors to power data centers. Oracle plans to break ground soon on a sprawling new campus across the river from downtown Nashville.
Texas’ loss is Tennessee’s gain, says Abbotoy, who believes his state is poised to become “the ‘it’ place for tech investment.” It can do this, he argues, without giving up its sense of place and predominant culture. “The whole point of it is to plant a flag and say ‘This small town is where our people are gathering,’” Abbotoy noted in a promotional video for Highland Rim Project. “The question is, who’s going to grab the land? Is it going to be good, based people who want to build something inspiring, something that’s culturally authentic to the region’s history? Or is it going to be Bill Gates and BlackRock and hippies from California?”
As The Pamphleteer‘s Hunt sees it, Tennesseans differ from Californians and New Yorkers—they’re “even different from people in Georgia.” He and the others espouse a localized version of what has become an article of faith among the new right: that place makes a people, and that a nation is, at its foundation, a people rooted in a place.
JD Vance is an especially prominent champion of this idea. At the July 2024 National Conservatism Conference, he described America as “not just an idea” but “a homeland.” A week later, while accepting the VP nomination, he called America “a group of people with a shared history and a common future.”
Tennessee is the kind of place a candidate running on rootedness would want in his corner. “Most of my circle would still love to have Vance,” Abbotoy says, “if we could just wave a wand and get him in.”
William Wolfe, a self-described Christian nationalist and former Trump administration official who also has spoken at a National Conservatism Conference, appears to agree. “My message?” he wrote on X. “More George Washington, less Nazi hunting, and JD Vance is our guy.”
In his own (lengthy) post on X the day after the midterms, Vance wrote that a pollster he called “one of the smartest people I know in politics” had told him some Trump 2024 voters “were angry and planning to vote for Democrats.” They wanted to “end the war,” “focus on cost of living/inflation,” “put America First,” and “change our relationship to Israel.” In the same post, Vance warned that “anyone pushing amnesty is lying to you.” It was basically an update of his 2024 homeland speech.
His amnesty line was a reminder that a nation’s “people” is an exclusive group. As Texas slipped away this cycle, conservative candidates dabbled in nativism. Republican primary voters ousted the incumbent railroad commissioner in favor of Bo French, a former Tarrant County GOP chair who has called for deporting 100 million people, purging the nation of Muslims, and emulating apartheid-era Rhodesia. As my colleague Tim Murphy reported in September, French’s rise is “in many ways the defining story of the era.”
Incoming Rep. Jace Yarbrough, whose campaign received $7,000 from Thiel, has accused Muslims of “attempting to set up Sharia law here in the United States.”
French lost by roughly seven points but his worldview thrives on social media. An unmistakably AI-generated video purporting to explain why Texas flipped showed caricatured Indians, heads waggling, dancing in traditional dress before idols and McMansions, and grinning Muslims waving Islamic flags outside mosques. One X post sharing the video has been viewed 1.8 million times.
The Thielbillies are worried about how immigrants are changing their communities, too. Hunt noted that suburbs southeast of Nashville bucked the statewide trend—Democrat Victoria Broderick unseated Rep. Scott DesJarlais in the 4th congressional district, and three state House seats flipped—partly, Hunt says, because Murfreesboro has been absorbing newcomers priced out of Nashville. “There’s also a very large immigrant population down there,” he added, “which I think played into that.”
The silver lining of last week’s Republican loss, Abbotoy told me, is that the election “flushed out a lot of stultified establishment people” and will “reset the bench” for younger operators. His models are two Texans who outran their collapsing ticket: Reps. Brandon Gill and Rep.-elect Jace Yarbrough. Gill responded last year to a video of Zohran Mamdani eating rice with his hand by declaring that “civilized people in America don’t eat like this,” and that Mamdani should “go back to the Third World.” Yarbrough, who received a $7,000 campaign donation from Thiel, has accused Muslims of “attempting to set up Sharia law here in the United States” and lamented that “we no longer share common values with people that we see in the grocery store or at our public schools.”
Both lawmakers, Abbotoy says, talked about immigration “in sensible, responsible ways” and could “translate these political issues into kitchen-table issues.” The fact that nativist rhetoric worked for Yarbrough and Gill but not for French suggest that their red districts are distinct from Texas as a whole, and that they understood the voters there.
Abbotoy isn’t the only one who believes such messages can win. On Monday, a new conservative candidate recruitment group called American Ascent launched with an initial $12 million from Thomas Klingenstein, the Claremont Institute board chair and a Yarbrough donor. Helmed by former Heritage Foundation chief of staff Ryan Neuhaus, the group aims to find and equip a new generation of conservatives to replace older Republicans in 2028.
American Ascent has strong ties to Vance: It will partner with a PAC run by the vice president’s close advisor Andy Surabian. In the Politico interview, Vance was the first name Neuhaus’ mentioned in his list of Republicans he considered “inspirational to the base.” He also mentioned Gill and Yarbrough. American Ascent communications director Bradley Devlin, a former editor of the Daily Signal, told Politico, “Republicans lost on the economy. They did not lose on the immigration agenda, which voters time and time again say is the number one best issue for Republicans to run on.”
The emergence of the Thielbillies gives Abbotoy more cause for optimism: “The whole scene is going to be on the upswing.” He’s based in the Highland Rim, but also hangs out in Nashville—Abbotoy and Hunt are friends. He likens the Thielbilly scene to Dimes Square, the downtown Manhattan post-left salon circuit, while conceding that it’s not a perfect comparison. Dimes Square is “a little bit more counterculture,” he says. “Nashville’s different.” The rooms here are full of investment bankers, marketing executives, country-music brass and stars, and “a lot of crypto whales that have been moving to Nashville.”
Less bohemia, in other words, than a right-wing chamber of commerce with better parties. A red bubble inside a blue bubble inside a red state convinced that America is a people, that it lives here, and that, as Thiel suggests, it is worth fighting for.
Oligarchs Got Crushed on Election Day, But Still Managed to Kill California’s Wealth Tax Dreams
America’s oligarchs fared badly overall on Election Day, but they dodged a bullet in California, and perhaps then some.
California’s Prop. 40, the Billionaire Tax initiative, would have been the nation’s first-ever tax on excessive wealth, a concept Americans have supported in poll after poll. Despite its flaws, the measure would have broken the glass. It would have showed that curbing excessive fortunes is possible in an America whose wealth distribution has grown so skewed that it now resembles that of a kleptocratic developing nation.
“The reason [billionaires] don’t want to pay the tax is they don’t want to pay the tax.” —US Rep. Ro Khanna
But some of the state’s billionaires had other plans. After a healthcare workers union sponsored Prop. 40, they put up more than $330 million to create an advocacy group that would plant doubts and fears in voters’ minds, with an assist from prominent Democrats, most notably Gov. Gavin Newsom.
The billionaire opposition effort not only doomed Prop. 40, but may have convinced voters to pass Prop. 42—one of two competing measures they sponsored—which bars the state from enacting future taxes on many types of wealth. On Monday night, with 83 percent of the votes counted, AP called Prop. 40’s defeat. It has not yet made the call on Prop. 42, which remained ahead by 3.2 percentage points.
Prop. 40 was imperfect. As I wrote in a story prior to the election, it was a one-time tax, with revenues earmarked mainly for one purpose (healthcare), which may have convinced rival unions to oppose it. Critics claimed, among other things, that passing Prop. 40 would compel many of California’s roughly 250 billionaires to flee, decimating the state’s tax base and startup culture.
Silicon Valley congressman Rep. Ro Khanna, a Democrat who supported Prop. 40 to the chagrin of his tech billionaire constituents, dismissed the wealth-flight threat as “total propaganda.” The notion that losing a gaggle of tax-avoiding 0.0001 percenters would significantly harm California’s tax base and culture of innovation also struck him as nonsensical. “If anything,” he told me, “more and more wealth is going to accumulate in Silicon Valley as we see the AI revolution. The reason they don’t want to pay the tax is they don’t want to pay the tax.”
The No on Prop. 40 campaign, in the end, was mainly about greed. But money is power, and the billionaires used theirs to muddy the waters. They provided safe opt-out arguments for unions and for Democrats who have relied on campaign cash from the superwealthy, including former US Rep. Katie Porter, governor-elect Xavier Becerra, and Newsom, who needs the billionaires on his side if he runs for president in 2028. (The California Democratic Party supported Prop. 40.)
Prop 42’s backers tried to trick people into thinking their retirement savings were at risk. It worked.
Of course billionaires should pay their fair share, the argument basically went, but Prop. 40 was the wrong way to accomplish it. Newsom et al. repeated the claims that it would harm the economy, and that you can’t tax wealth at the state level, because that’s like playing Whac-a Mole as the mega-rich scurry from jurisdiction to jurisdiction to avoid taxation. You’ve got to tax wealth at the federal level, Newsom and others have said, likely knowing full well a federal wealth tax is never gonna fly—certainly not with this Supreme Court.
At the same time, Newsom (though not Becerra) endorsed Prop. 42, which, as the state legislative analyst explained, “could reduce future tax revenues. When and by how much future revenues would be reduced is unclear.” (This, ironically, was one of the key arguments against Prop. 40.)
Prop. 42 could reduce state revenues in two ways: First, by prohibiting retroactive taxes—a potential poison pill for Prop. 40, which was retroactive to January 1, 2026. If Prop. 42 passes, as seems likely, it will amend the state constitution to eliminate California’s ability to levy future wealth taxes, as the ballot guide explains, “on the ownership of personal property (all things people own other than real estate).” The current constitution, the Yes on 42 ballot argument warned, allows the Legislature to tax personal property, business interests, and financial assets, including assets in retirement and investment accounts “even though you already paid taxes on that money when you earned it!”
That was a dirty trick. Beyond run-of-the-mill property taxes on homes and businesses, state lawmakers have never so much as proposed any wealth tax on ordinary Californians. The “pro” argument points vaguely to a handful of past legislative attempts to tax people’s nest eggs, conveniently neglecting to mention that those bills (which all failed) only targeted assets in excess of $30 million, and typically much more.
That is, the “you” in their scenario was actually “them”—families with excessive wealth.
The double-taxation claim, too, was smoke and mirrors. Yes, your $5,000 stock investment or Roth IRA contribution probably did come from your post-tax earnings, but when that investment eventually grows into $25,000, your $20,000 profit isn’t being taxed. And again, the only wealth taxes state or federal lawmakers have ever introduced apply only to the households that wealth managers and estate lawyers categorize as “ultra-high net worth.”
The threat of state tax authorities coming for people’s retirement savings proved powerful, though. Powerful enough to sway many Californians who may not have fully realized they were actually voting to protect the largely untaxed megafortunes of some of the richest human beings on the planet—who now, encouraged by their victory, will keep using their vast hoards to bend government policy to their will, public be damned.