Google DeepMind melds humans and AI agents to vet Signal's secure messaging techniques
Google DeepMind researchers have completed a formal verification of Signal's messaging security, marking what they claim is the first time AI has helped devise a proof that links protocol-level security guarantees to a widely used cryptographic implementation.
They did so using AlphaProof Code, a multi-agent framework for formal software specification and verification. AlphaProof Code relies on a human-guided agent that writes a Lean specification, assesses machine code semantics, and crafts an agent-authored proof that the Lean kernel checks against the specification.
In this instance, AlphaProof Code verified Signal’s post-quantum PQXDH handshake and Triple Ratchet, thereby validating the design of libsignal's forward secrecy, authentication, post-compromise security, and handshake secrecy.
In so doing, the Google/DeepMind team – Swarat Chaudhuri, Andrew Ferraiuolo, Anton Kovsharov, Tej Chajed, Sam Schlesinger, Karn Seth, Jonathan Katz, Charles Sutton, and Pushmeet Kohli – has taken a step toward a challenge the Beneficial AI Foundation issued in April to formally verify the Signal protocol and Signal app with Lean.
The AlphaProof Code process involves working with various models to turn Signal's security goals into a human-reviewed mathematical specification. Based on this spec, the researchers assigned Gemini Carbon agents to generate Lean code proving the correctness of the libsignal implementation. After the agents generated 6.5 million lines of Lean code, they undertook an auditing pass and flagged bits that required human review.
The result is theoretical in that it assumes perfect cryptography and doesn't guarantee the computational secrecy of bytes. But it's still a meaningful assertion of correctness.
"It's a system that is fundamentally built for human AI collaboration," said Swarat Chaudhuri, research scientist at Google DeepMind and a professor at the University of Texas at Austin, in an interview with The Register.
Traditionally, said Chaudhuri, you start proving theorems with well-defined problems formulated by a mathematician that get submitted to an AI agent for proof. In this case, the researchers had to figure out what to prove.
"In formal methods, we always had this belief that verification is the hard bit," he said. "There's thirty or forty years of work on how to scale up verification. Now we are able to do that. So now the question is what are we verifying? … That process is fundamentally human-in-the-loop, but we devised a process of trying to scale it up to the extent possible with AI."
As Chaudhuri and his colleagues note in their research paper, "AlphaProof Code: Verifying Signal’s Security at the Machine-Code Level," formal verification used to require heroic efforts. Formally verifying the seL4 microkernel took 20 person-years, while developing the verified CompCert C compiler took six years.
AlphaProof Code, they believe, can drastically reduce the cost of formal verification, though their Signal work still took four weeks for a team of five people and "quite a few tokens."
"The dream is definitely to scale this up," said Chaudhuri. "So you know there's been this rise in offensive AI capabilities, right? There are a lot of insecure systems around the world, and they're going to be exploited.
"So what we really need to do is to apply this kind of technology to code at large all over the world and figure out what is it that you want to guard against? How do you write those properties, how do we specify those properties? That's going to be super important, but we have to figure that out."
Pointing to a related DeepMind project, AlphaProof Nexus, which is focused on mathematics, Chaudhuri said the next step is to apply this technology during the software design process – not just to cryptographic protocols but code in general.
"We really believe that the next frontier is not going to be proof but specification in this kind of research," he said. "And so that's why we took on this domain where that was actually a hard problem. And I think that we have some really good insights now about how to go about this, although not the last word by any means." ®
Lookout tasted 11 pumpkin pies in Santa Cruz County. These two are the best.
How many ballots are left to count in Santa Cruz County? Here’s the latest
Microsoft is giving Claude the keys to UK Copilot tenants by default
Microsoft will enable access to Anthropic's Claude models by default for UK Copilot tenants next month, giving administrators a deadline to decide whether US-based processing fits their compliance requirements.
From December 9, UK tenants whose administrators have not already chosen a setting will have Claude access enabled. Administrators can disable it, but leaving the setting untouched means opting in.
In this instance, Anthropic operates as a Microsoft subprocessor, and Claude models are already on by default for most customers in the Windows giant's commercial cloud. The exceptions, notably, include the European Union, the European Free Trade Association, and the UK.
However, UK tenants aren't in scope for Microsoft's EU Data Boundary - launched at the start of 2023 - and so Redmond is flipping the switch for the country.
Anthropic processes the relevant data in the United States, Microsoft's documentation states. Administrators therefore have until December 9 to review whether that meets their organization's data-handling requirements and set access accordingly.
Microsoft is also retiring the setting that restricts Claude access to Microsoft 365 alone.
"This affirms Microsoft's commitment to offering choice between leading AI models while maintaining enterprise-grade security and compliance," the Redmond-based biz said.
So long as you don't mind processing happening in the US. ®
The 2026 Lookout List: Community & Events
Santa Cruz County is teeming with festivals and fairs: wine, art, food, crafts, you name it. For the Lookout List Community & Events category, our voters celebrated these local staples — as well as the volunteer opportunities that bring neighbors together. Find more Lookout List winners here.
Find your favorite … Art Fair/Festival Bite at the Santa Cruz County Fair Drink Festival Food Festival Local Maker Pop-Up Event Music Festival Non-Profit Awards Event Non-Profit Fundraiser Place to Volunteer Stop on a First Friday Santa Cruz Art Tour Stop on the Open Studios Art Tour (North County) Stop on the Open Studios Art Tour (South County) Street Fair/Festival Favorite Art Fair/Festival
Tents dot Capitola Village during the Capitola Art & Wine Festival. Credit: Instagram
Winner: Capitola Art & Wine Festival
Held in Capitola Village
Voters love the festival’s seaside setting in Capitola Village, the quality of its vendors and “so many wonderful booths” full of amazing artwork.
Runner-up: Open Studios — Arts Council of Santa Cruz CountySelf-guided tour of artists’ studios across the county each October
Back to all Community & Events categories
Favorite Bite at the Santa Cruz County Fair
Winner: Corralitos Market & Sausage Co.
Fairgoers praise the “unmatched flavor & quality” of Corralitos Market’s sausages.
Runner-up: Cinnamon RollsReaders call them simply “Delicious!”
Back to all Community & Events categories
Favorite Drink Festival Winner: Capitola Art & Wine FestivalHeld in Capitola Village
Voters call it an “excellent event,” with great ambiance in the Village and a beautiful seaside setting as they take in the art and wine on offer.
Runner-up: Scotts Valley Art Wine & Beer FestivalSkypark, 361 Kings Village Road, Scotts Valley
Attendees praise the “wonderful wine and beer with delicious foods.”
Back to all Community & Events categories
Favorite Food Festival
Chocolate-drizzled strawberries brought smiles to festivalgoers at this year’s Watsonville Strawberry Festival. Credit: Kevin Painchaud / Lookout Santa Cruz
Winner: Strawberry Festival
Held in downtown Watsonville
Readers love the “amazing food, music, vendors and energy from the community” at this family-friendly event. As one put it, it’s “the sweetest!”
Runner-up: Santa Cruz Clam Chowder Cook-OffSanta Cruz Beach Boardwalk, 400 Beach St., Santa Cruz
Back to all Community & Events categories
Favorite Local Maker Pop-Up Event Winner: Downtown Santa Cruz Makers Market1100 block of Pacific Avenue, Santa Cruz, on the third Sunday of every month
The monthly street market brings more than 40 local makers and artists to Pacific Avenue with a wide range of handmade goods.
Runner-up: Collective Santa Cruz — Holiday Mega MarketHeld in the former Logos Books & Records space
Founded in 2022 by two childhood friends.
Back to all Community & Events categories
Favorite Music Festival
Winner: Redwood Mountain Faire
Held at Roaring Camp, 5401 Graham Hill Road, Felton
Fans love the beautiful venue, great vibes and fun bands. “Going on my 12th year,” one voter wrote.
Runner-up: Cabrillo Festival of Contemporary MusicSanta Cruz Civic Auditorium, 307 Church St., Santa Cruz
Readers call it a “world class orchestra.”
Back to all Community & Events categories
Favorite Non-Profit Awards Event Winner: Volunteer Center of Santa Cruz County — Be the Difference AwardsAnnual awards from the Volunteer Center of Santa Cruz County
Voters call Be the Difference “the most energizing and inspiring recognition of our community volunteers that exists in Santa Cruz County,” an event that brings the whole county together to honor volunteers and the nonprofits they power. One community leader called it the place “where I fill my cup up each year.”
Runner-up: United Way of Santa Cruz County — United in PurposeAnnual celebration and awards from United Way of Santa Cruz County
Fans say United Way makes the event “fun and memorable,” and they appreciate that it honors young people as well as adults.
Back to all Community & Events categories
Favorite Non-Profit Fundraiser
Credit: Reynaldo Barrioz / Santa Cruz County Office of Education
Winner: Santa Cruz County Animal Shelter — St. Pittie’s Party
Santa Cruz County Animal Shelter, 1001 Rodriguez St., Santa Cruz
“Best event, hands and paws down!” one voter wrote. Supporters say the party is “great for all the animals, not just Pitties,” and celebrate the shelter as a great community partner.
Runner-up: United Way of Santa Cruz County — Stuff the BusUnited Way’s back-to-school supply drive
Volunteers say the drive brings people together to give kids who couldn’t otherwise afford school supplies “a successful start to the school year.”
Lookout Staff Pick
Stockings: A Holiday Cabaret, Motion PacificI look forward to Stockings: A Holiday Cabaret all year long! The dancing, the performers, the creativity – there’s truly nothing else like it in Santa Cruz. I love how Motion Pacific celebrates dance, self-expression and people of all kinds, with a brand-new theme every year. It’s a fundraiser that feels like a party, it’s always a beautiful performance and a celebration of everything that makes our community special.
My pro tip? If you can, spring for a table. You’ll get the best seats, a round of complimentary drinks and an incredible view of the show. Trust me, it’s worth it!
Jamie Garfield, Director of Student & Community Engagement
Back to all Community & Events categories
Favorite Place to Volunteer
At the new facility, Grey Bears’ daily market will move to a permanent inside area designed like a corner store. Credit: Kevin Painchaud / Lookout Santa Cruz
Winner: Grey Bears
2710 Chanticleer Ave., Santa Cruz
Volunteers say “the people are the secret” at Grey Bears, which offers “lots of different ways to volunteer” to fit any schedule, a sustainable model built on reducing waste and, as several noted, a free lunch. One former volunteer called it “a model of what a sustainable world should strive for.”
Runner-up: Santa Cruz SPCA2601 Chanticleer Ave., Santa Cruz
Volunteers describe “a kind and compassionate community of animal lovers” at the SPCA. “Chilling with dogs is good for the soul, and walking is healthy for the body,” one wrote.
Lookout Staff Pick
Jacob’s Heart Children’s Cancer Support ServicesJacob’s Heart Children’s Cancer Support Services is one of those extraordinary places that reminds you just how much love, compassion, and generosity exist in the world. They offer comfort, hope, and meaningful support to families navigating one of the most difficult experiences imaginable. Being able to volunteer with this organization is a privilege. Jacob’s Heart is a beautiful reminder that even in the darkest moments, kindness and human connection can make a profound difference.
Kevin Painchaud, Photojournalist
Back to all Community & Events categories
Favorite Stop on a First Friday Santa Cruz Art Tour
Credit: Santa Cruz Museum of Art & History
Winner: Santa Cruz Museum of Art & History
705 Front St., Santa Cruz
Readers say the MAH has “great events for everyone,” a cool downtown vibe and free admission on First Friday.
Runner-up: Fruition Brewing918 E. Lake Ave., Watsonville
Fans love Fruition’s vibes and “fun beer flavors, even for someone who doesn’t particularly like beer.”
Back to all Community & Events categories
Favorite Stop on the Open Studios Art Tour (North County) Winner: Hawk and Hammer Creative StudioVisitors say Tina’s prints, calendars and stickers are “unique and fun,” and that stopping by her open studio “is always inspiring and informative.” One called her an “amazing artist and human!”
Runner-up: Susan Taylor Brown ArtVoters are wowed by Susan Taylor Brown’s fiber art, embroidered “wildscapes” and moss pieces that feel “grown rather than crafted.” “No other artist is doing this,” one wrote.
Back to all Community & Events categories
Favorite Stop on the Open Studios Art Tour (South County)
Artist Rhia Hurt in front of a Balancing Acts painting. Credit: Liz Sanders
Winner: Rhia Hurt
Visitors love Rhia Hurt’s brilliant colors, layered paintings and eye-catching jewelry, and her studio tucked into a gorgeous backyard garden. “Her work is dramatic and peaceful at the same time,” one wrote. Another said a piece she bought “brings me happiness and a sense of hope.”
Runner-up: Charles PrentissA former curator at the Santa Cruz City Museum of Natural History, Prentiss is known for paintings, prints and mixed-media pieces with bold color.
Back to all Community & Events categories
Favorite Street Fair/Festival
The Santa Cruz Pride parade, celebrating the 50th anniversary of Pride in the city, on Pacific Avenue. Credit: Cat Cutillo / Lookout Santa Cruz
Winner: Santa Cruz Pride
Parade and festival in downtown Santa Cruz
“It is SC and it is Pride, say no more,” one voter wrote. Others call it “a joyous occasion” that’s “very inclusive to all.”
Runner-up: Santa Cruz Dance WeekPresented by Motion Pacific at venues countywide
Readers say the celebration shows off the city’s “legendary” dance scene.
Back to all Community & Events categories
Get the winners in your inboxEach day’s Lookout List winners will be announced in Morning Lookout, our free weekday newsletter. Sign up so you don’t miss your favorites.
Sign upWinners are also being announced on Instagram. Follow along for daily reveals.
Follow @lookoutsantacruz
The post The 2026 Lookout List: Community & Events appeared first on Lookout Santa Cruz.
EU's €212M border IT project lands IBM and Atos in legal water
The European Union has dragged IBM, Atos, and Leonardo into court over years of delays to its troubled €212 million smart border system, which finally went live after missing a string of deadlines and leaving travelers stuck in airport queues.
The lawsuit dates back to December 22, 2025, when eu-LISA, the agency behind the EU's fingerprint-and-facial-image border checks for non-EU travelers, filed its claim in an Estonian court.
The lawsuit was buried in eu-LISA's 2025 financial accounts, published in July, with no mention of who was being sued. The Financial Times has since named the three companies after obtaining letters exchanged with the agency.
In a statement to The Register, eu-LISA confirmed it had initiated proceedings "in line with the Agency’s responsibility to protect the EU’s financial interests."
"The proceedings concern the system’s development phase and have no impact on its current operation. EES (entry exit system) is fully operational," the agency said, declining to discuss the ongoing case.
The EES was supposed to be ready in 2022 yet wasn't live until October 2025 and was only fully operational from April. Travelers have since had to contend with hours-long airport queues and fingerprint scanners that reportedly struggle with sweaty fingers. Behind the scenes, things weren't going much better, with the consortium and eu-LISA spending years arguing over missed deadlines, financial penalties and who was to blame.
IBM Belgium and Atos Belgium were already arguing over penalties back in October 2021, when they disputed a fine from eu-LISA and pointed to the COVID-19 pandemic and other factors beyond their control as reasons for the delays.
By February 2022, the consortium was pushing back against another set of deadlines, warning that the agency's timetable was unrealistic.
"Ignoring reality is not prudent and will not help to achieve the plan," the companies wrote, according to the FT. "On the contrary, working with an unrealistic plan will cause frustration for all stakeholders."
The consortium also criticized eu-LISA's "overall governance," suggesting relations between the two sides had become rather frosty.
The fallout wasn't cheap. The contract had already grown from €142 million to €212 million in 2021, and the delays kept adding to the bill.
In its 2022 accounts [PDF], eu-LISA acknowledged difficulties with the consortium and warned of additional costs, with the setbacks also holding up other EU IT projects. By 2023, it had nearly doubled its annual EES budget to €40 million by diverting funds from elsewhere, partly to cover rising hardware and software maintenance costs.
The FT also reported that IBM agreed in March 2022 to let eu-LISA withhold certain payments while the dispute over damages was resolved.
The original contract expired last year, with a new consortium taking over implementation, although IBM, Atos, and Leonardo remained responsible until August.
The project has attracted scrutiny for more than its ballooning budget. Last year, Atos reportedly used its Moscow office to procure software for the system, raising questions about Russian involvement in sensitive European border infrastructure.
The EU's anti-fraud office, OLAF, found sufficient grounds for further investigation, according to an internal report seen by the FT. However, it referred the matter back to eu-LISA despite describing the agency's initial assessment as insufficient.
Estonia's Harju County Court confirmed that the civil case had been filed, although no hearings have taken place or been scheduled.
IBM and Atos did not respond to The Register's questions.
The EES may finally be up and running, but the argument over who should foot the bill for getting it there looks far from settled. ®
Trump Has a Secret Plan to Evade Accountability. Will Dems Defeat It?
The scale of the victory came as a shock even to Democratic leaders in Washington—including veterans like Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries, both of whom pride themselves on their mastery of polls, cross-tabs, fundraising, and voting patterns down almost to the precinct level.
As Democrats delivered their victory speeches late on election night, it was clear that they had made history, winning the midterms by a landslide larger than any since the Watergate era. Amid such an unmistakable repudiation of Donald Trump, hopeful liberals around the world indulged fantasies of belated justice—a level of accountability and a check on presidential lawlessness that could ultimately result in the permanent disgrace of the most corrupt president in American history.
But several hours later, after the confetti settled, a different attitude prevailed. “The American people don’t want us to get even,” Jeffries, the incoming House speaker, told the hosts of Morning Joe on November 4. “We won on affordability. And now it’s our job to govern on affordability.” Jeffries has, of course, nodded to the need for “accountability,” vowing to impose it on “those who have visited unprecedented corruption on our country.” But Jeffries’s frame—either Democrats will deliver or they’ll seek retribution—raised immediate questions about how deeply Democrats will internalize one of the key lessons of this election. A huge majority of Americans nationwide identified corruption as a key consideration. Will Democrats deploy all the powers available to Congress to expose and put a check on it?
The outcome of this election was thrilling. Democrats are set to control over 250 House seats and at least 54 seats in the Senate. But we need to face something soberly. Once the celebrations stop and the new year begins, we all know exactly what will happen: Even if the Democrats move aggressively on the accountability front, Trump will order his administration to ignore subpoenas and toss sternly worded letters into the garbage. If Congress refers Trump’s allies for criminal prosecution, his coconspirators who run the Justice Department will erupt in laughter. Trump might even ignore Congress when it tries to cut off the thing that makes all of his corruption possible: money. Yet already, a debate among Democrats over how aggressively to pursue Trump, and fight his obstructive tactics, has spilled into the open.
In the weeks leading up to the election, we spoke to a number of House and Senate Democrats and senior congressional aides. We sought an answer to a question that now appears even more pressing: How aggressively will congressional Democrats wield their institutional powers once it becomes clear that Trump and his accomplices in the White House will stand in the way of every investigation the Democrats undertake—and every check they place on his abuses of power?
To put the question another way: What deeper mindset will Democrats take into these battles? Will they approach the next year as if we’re still locked in a deep crisis—as if the constitutional order still hangs in the balance, requiring maximal exercises of power? Or will they enter with a more lax posture, as though their midterm victory has brought things more or less under control, and the crisis has largely been averted?
“We’ll still be facing a lawless president,” Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland told us. While Van Hollen stressed that this would only be one piece of the Democratic agenda, he added: “And that will require complete pushback.”
“We’ll still be facing a lawless president.... And that will require complete pushback.”–Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland
But, unfortunately, not all Democrats see things in these crisis-like terms. And it’s unclear whether the ones who do will be willing to act accordingly, or will be able to persuade their reluctant colleagues to rise to the moment and be sufficiently confrontational.
Every Democrat we spoke with agreed that the Trump administration is world-historically corrupt, and most expected his lawbreaking to persist or even escalate. Some do seem willing to contemplate suspension of the regular order of things, if that’s what it takes to slow or stop the lawlessness. Others, though, seem more resigned to running a playbook for normal times, one that’s plainly unsuited to the coming moment.
Checks and Balances? Under Trump?
To obstruct, all Trump has to do is say no. No, we will not cooperate with your investigations. No, we will not prosecute people who defy your subpoenas. No, we will not follow the law.
The key to understanding the dilemma Democrats now face is that our system of checks and balances rests on a shared baseline commitment to upholding the rule of law. Trump is the first president of the modern era to openly dispense with the notion that justice should be blind, and to declare the Constitution as nonbinding on his tribune-like powers. Trump feels exactly zero responsibility to act as steward of the constitutional order or preserve it for future generations. So the coming period of divided government could devolve into tests of will and raw power. Those, in turn, risk toppling us quickly into crisis. And the deeper problem is that when good guys blink, or appease transgressors, they don’t just end the acute crisis of the moment. They consign us all to new precedents. New double standards. New depths of doubt that a fair and just democracy can be restored.
Every Democrat we spoke to anticipates the very worst from Trump. They expect intense obstruction. Noncompliance with oversight requests and demands. Refusal to be bound by the strings attached to money, which the Constitution entrusts Congress to shell out and control. And a bottomless willingness to drag things out in court, with the undisguised goal of nullifying controversies by tying them up for months or years—perhaps even until this administration is over and the controversies are moot.
Normal checks and balances don’t have great answers to this.
In modern practice, Congress has leaned heavily on a standard set of tools for conducting oversight and seeking accountability. Committees request documents and testimony. Aides and members work behind the scenes to understand the often-opaque inner workings of the government. When they hit roadblocks, they demand depositions and further production of evidence. If the administration resists, they issue subpoenas. If officials flout their subpoenas, they can be held in contempt of Congress, at the risk of civil and criminal penalties, including big fines and even arrest and hard prison time.
These tools can be quite effective, even in adversarial conflict with an executive branch controlled by the other party. The oil that keeps it all functioning is a basic willingness, however reluctant, to preserve our system of government. This generally means officials don’t ignore their subpoenas sight unseen, they agree to appear at congressional hearings, and they don’t treat public money as theirs to spend or dole out to friends and allies.
When those assumptions no longer apply—and they certainly do not apply with Trump—Congress quickly runs out of normal tools to enforce compliance, and the majority has to choose: resign itself to being spat upon, or embrace significantly more aggressive tactics.
Josh Chafetz, a legal scholar at Georgetown who wrote the definitive book about Congress’s hidden tools, notes that the Democratic majority in the House struggled to respond to Trump’s obstruction of oversight in 2019 and 2020. The first Trump administration was historically contemptuous of congressional prerogatives, but it still honored some norms—for example, officials did attend hearings, and agencies did occasionally cooperate with oversight requests. Now things are likely to get more confrontational—much more so.
“The Democrats in the last two years of the first Trump administration sort of ran up against some of the limits,” Chafetz said. “Now they’re going to run up against those limits even harder.”
How Democrats Can Bring Down the Hammer—If They So Choose
So what would it look like if Democrats were to deploy maximal power against the administration next year? To escalate, Democrats would likely have to test one or all of the following approaches:
• Inherent contempt, a rarely invoked mechanism that allows Congress to imprison or otherwise penalize people who defy lawful commands.
• Impeachment, which threatens executive branch officials with the prospect of removal and places Congress at the height of its constitutional authority.
• The power of the purse, which allows Congress to place conditions on the money it authorizes the government to spend.
Unfortunately, as we learned in our conversations with lawmakers and aides, many Democrats are inclined to disclaim some of these methods.
That isn’t entirely a sign of weakness. Congress has not invoked its inherent contempt authority in almost 100 years, in part because it’s rarely been necessary, and in part because it’s messy.
The Supreme Court has repeatedly affirmed that the Constitution empowers Congress to enforce its own will; if a reluctant witness refuses to testify, Congress can punish him directly. In recent years, when members have flirted with inherent contempt, they’ve toyed with the idea of imposing fines on contemptuous witnesses.
But historically, Congress would dispatch its sergeant at arms and other law enforcement officers that he or she might deputize to arrest and detain those witnesses. For obvious reasons, this is thorny: If the witness is a member of the executive branch, with an executive branch security detail, what happens in an armed standoff?
“I have discussed inherent contempt with leadership and some of the oversight committee chairs.”–Representative Ted Lieu, a member of the incoming House Democratic leadership team
This tactic is being debated at high levels among Democrats, according to Representative Ted Lieu, a member of the incoming House Democratic leadership team. “I have discussed inherent contempt with leadership and some of the oversight committee chairs,” Lieu told us. Still, he cautioned, any such move would be litigated, just like more standard processes. And we are skeptical that the idea has much traction among other Democrats. As one senior Senate aide told us, inherent contempt is “really fun to talk about,” but because it seems politically onerous, radical, and difficult to implement, it’s a “long shot.”
Impeachment, by contrast, should be much less controversial, and can be very effective at speeding up investigations and prying information loose. That’s in part because courts will be more deferential to an impeachment inquiry than to congressional committees conducting normal oversight. Witnesses also feel especially compelled to cooperate and are uniquely protected if they do. In 2019, investigators in the Democratic-controlled House were mostly stymied—until Trump’s first impeachment, at which point administration officials came out of the woodwork to testify in astounding detail about his corrupt scheme to pressure Ukraine to subvert the 2020 election.
This is why we think Democrats should be prepared to deploy the impeachment power promiscuously—including against Trump’s most controversial Cabinet officials. To give just one example, they should seriously contemplate impeaching Attorney General Todd Blanche for his corrupt prosecutions of Trump critics and for concealing important chunks of the Epstein files. This would be justified on the merits, but it would also maximize Congress’s investigative power over the Justice Department, where all sorts of malfeasance surely remains hidden from view.
But to do all this, Democrats would have to be overwhelmingly united. And as of this writing, they plainly are not. As Senator Tammy Duckworth of Illinois recently pleaded: “Don’t be impeaching anybody. Let’s just get back to work, and maybe we can come to compromises.”
“I know [impeachment proceedings] will be very difficult for a lot of my colleagues. But Trump has simply become so dangerous that it needs to be done.”–Representative Adam Smith, a moderate from Washington state who’s the incoming Armed Services Committee chair
Representative Adam Smith, a moderate from Washington state who’s the incoming Armed Services Committee chair, backs impeaching Trump. Smith told us he anticipated that Democrats from swingy or red districts and states will be reluctant to support impeachment proceedings. “I know this will be very difficult for a lot of my colleagues,” Smith said. “But Trump has simply become so dangerous that it needs to be done.”
Coming Soon: The Democrats’ First Test
Which leaves the spending power. If inherent contempt and impeachment remain off the table, congressional budget authority will be Democrats’ only real power tool, and they’ll have to wield it aggressively: no money for agencies that obstruct investigations. No money for key Justice Department offices so long as they’re withholding the Epstein files or corruptly prosecuting Trump critics. No money for the illegal war against Iran or illegal executions of supposed drug smugglers on the high seas. And so on.
In the decades since Congress cut off funding for the Vietnam War, however, Republicans have been much more inclined than Democrats to wield this power in divided government—with one notable exception.
Last year, when Obamacare subsidies were on the verge of expiring, Democrats withheld their votes to fund the government, contingent on the demand that Congress extend those tax credits. Republicans refused, and appropriations lapsed. The government furloughed federal workers across agencies, impacting everything from air travel to IRS assistance to environmental cleanup projects. And here’s the kicker: Even though the Democrats could fairly be said to have caused the shutdown in the immediate sense, Republicans shouldered more of the blame. Democrats were wielding power and doing so effectively. Then, abruptly, a bloc of Senate Democrats decided they’d made their point. They folded a winning hand, and the shutdown ended.
To vindicate their power of the purse, Democrats in this coming Congress will have to show greater stamina and resolve. Senator Chris Murphy of Connecticut argues that it actually undermines the Democratic Party’s core complaints about Trump—that his authoritarianism is a threat to the republic—when Democrats are unwilling to deploy this power against those things. “I do not think it helped our messaging over the last year and a half that we broadly weren’t willing to deny them funding for departments that were operating clearly outside of the bounds of the law,” Murphy told us.
The first test of Democratic mettle will arrive much more quickly than you might think. In December, almost a full month before Democrats reclaim power, the current operating budget for the federal government will expire. Democrats could insist on defunding the Iran war straight away. But at the very least, they should agree to only a very brief extension of funding. This would prevent the government from shutting down over the holidays, which would surely be unpopular. But more to the point, a short extension would allow Democrats to preserve their leverage over Trump, because the budget would have to be renegotiated in early 2027. Trump and Republicans will want a longer-term extension for precisely this reason. And that could escalate into a standoff.
Most Democrats we talked to expect the party to dig in. “We’re going to be confronted very quickly with a decision as to whether we’re going to use appropriations as leverage,” Murphy said, adding that effective oversight will be impossible if Democrats refuse to hold the line.
“My view,” Van Hollen added, “is either Republicans work with us to begin to make changes that we think are necessary, or, yes, we have a short-term [budget] punting it into the beginning of next year.”
More broadly, for this method to work—for it to end the Iran war, rein in ICE, end Trump’s vindictive prosecutions, and secure the release of the Epstein files—Democrats would have to resolve themselves to potentially leaving large parts of the government unfunded, in ways that they find politically challenging.
“I hope we will use our appropriations power as a hammer against any further political persecutions of American citizens.”–Jamie Raskin, incoming chair of the Judiciary Committee
Some Democrats do appear prepared to refuse funding, even if it results in protracted standoffs, to accomplish things like thwarting Trump’s corrupt prosecutions. “I hope we will use our appropriations power as a hammer against any further illegitimate political persecutions of American citizens for their political speech,” Jamie Raskin, incoming chair of the Judiciary Committee, told us, stressing he will make this case to appropriators.
Representative Yassamin Ansari, a member of the Oversight Committee, agreed. “The Trump administration is using taxpayer resources to attack the president’s perceived enemies,” Ansari said. “We must stop funneling taxpayer dollars into Trump’s agencies that abuse their power and violate Americans’ rights.”
“We must stop funneling taxpayer dollars into Trump’s agencies that abuse their power and violate Americans’ rights.”–Representative Yassamin Ansari, a member of the Oversight Committee
Murphy, who is an informal leader of a similarly stalwart faction in the Senate, is ready for long struggles, too. He says Democrats should hold up Defense Department spending entirely to force an end to the Iran war. “I think it would be a pretty popular move for us to draw a hard line and say, ‘We are willing to fund the military, but only if this war ends,’” Murphy told us. “It would force Republicans and the administration into spending more time and oxygen defending the war.”
But Murphy readily allows that he can’t force that dilemma on Republicans unless the Senate Democratic caucus is with him. “I think there will be a question,” he acknowledged carefully, “as to whether Democrats are willing … to hold up the entirety of the defense budget over a commitment to end the war.”
Affordability vs. Accountability: A False Choice
We see another problem lurking in the Democratic mindset. Some Democrats have taken to arguing that the threshold test for the party’s agenda—legislative or oversight—should be a simple one: Does it improve the lives of ordinary people? Yes, or no?
We’re not disputing that members of Congress are elected to deliver benefits to their constituents—to make people’s lives better. Obviously, they must pass such measures, even if Trump vetoes them. But there’s a problem with formulating this standard as a hard-and-fast rule: It creates a back door for some Democrats to avoid doing difficult things in defense of the rule of law, in defense of immigrants or other marginalized groups, even in defense of their own powers as leaders of a coequal branch.
There will quickly come a point when House Democrats must decide whether to take politically difficult stances on things that aren’t obviously connected to the immediate material circumstances of their constituents. If, for instance, Trump orders the DOJ to prosecute more of his critics, and Democrats confront whether to withhold funding from that office to end another outbreak of lawlessness, would that tangibly make ordinary people’s lives better? What about the debate over how to rein in Trump’s mass-deportation regime and his lawless ICE agents? Democrats will want, at a minimum, to draw hard lines against things like ICE’s warrantless searches, ICE’s mask-wearing, and Customs and Border Patrol—which has been responsible for a great deal of brutality—operating in the country’s interior. Some Democrats, at least, hope to use government funding as a lever to force an end to those things. Would that improve ordinary people’s lives, or not?
This mindset, we fear, will create additional cover for Democrats who are already inclined to avoid confrontation for other reasons. When very difficult political choices arise—over, say, whether to defund offices within DOJ to derail a corrupt prosecution—those Democrats will argue that their election victory was about “affordability,” and that defunding DOJ will do nothing to ease voters’ kitchen-table concerns.
Party strategists and a subset of commentators will no doubt agree. But Democrats should think hard right now about what such a surrender would look like after millions and millions of voters handed them an array of powers and authorities to check a lawless authoritarian president.
We’re arguing for this not just because we think our approach has more merit in the abstract. It’s also that the supposed tension between cost-of-living issues and accountability is mostly fictitious.
Consider, first, that there’s very little chance Trump will sign legislation that Democrats pass to ease cost-of-living concerns. He has shown no appetite for signing measures that redound to the political benefit of Democrats. And so, practically speaking, if kitchen-table issues crowd out accountability measures, Democrats will be choosing to focus on symbolic advances—cost-of-living legislation that Trump vetoes—over doing things where their power actually can slow or stop Trump.
Second, there is no fixed budget for congressional priorities. Democrats can do many things at once. Joe Biden signed the Inflation Reduction Act in August 2022, just days after the last substantive hearing of the House January 6 Committee in late July. Why can’t this incoming Congress impeach Pete Hegseth one day and send Trump a bill restoring Medicaid coverage the next? Of course it can.
We also think that, in the minds of voters, when the economy is stagnant and the president is looting the country for personal gain, there is no clear distinction between anti-corruption politics and pocketbook politics. Exposing, ending, and punishing corruption will make economic life in America fairer by definition. And that will place Democrats on the side of the people who play by the rules.
Framed in this way, anti-corruption politics can unite the caucus and avoid the divisions that flow from establishing a false choice between kitchen-table concerns and checks and balances.
“If we want this government to work for the people, then we have to put an end to corruption and restore the rule of law.”–Virginia Representative James Walkinshaw, a prominent member of the moderate New Democrat caucus
Some Democrats appear to agree with us. “If we want this government to work for the people, then we have to put an end to corruption and restore the rule of law,” Virginia Representative James Walkinshaw, a prominent member of the moderate New Democrat caucus, told us. “I don’t think there’s any conflict between being substantively centrist or pragmatic [and] recognizing that Congress has a responsibility to assert its constitutional role. I don’t think those two things are in tension.”
Going After the Abettors
None of this is to say conventional oversight tools indicate weakness in and of themselves. These tools have their place, and they can function as intended, even against a lawless president like Trump. They did in his first term, and they surely will again.
After all, it was Michael Cohen’s 2019 testimony to Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, obtained during a standard congressional hearing, that established the basis for New York Attorney General Letitia James’s sprawling lawsuit against the Trump organization.
Trump may rage and sputter. He may test our ability to imagine the outer limits of “high crimes and misdemeanors.” But he is also entering his lame-duck years a loser. He will become a more diminished figure, whose power to bully elites and underlings into line will ebb. Congressional aides tell us they expect some administration officials to grow more willing to appear before Congress—if not to turn over documents—as Trump weakens. If they’re right, this will create more incriminating moments, as when Cohen testified nearly eight years ago.
Aides also expect the pace of whistleblowing to pick up. The protections that a congressional majority can offer will render people “more willing to come forward,” one aide told us, adding that recent conversations she’s had with would-be whistleblowers left her persuaded that “there are a lot of people who have stories to share.” After the country rejected Trump so overwhelmingly, their willingness to speak out is likely to grow.
Civil contempt is another option. This mechanism outsources subpoena enforcement to judges, who can levy fines on noncompliant officials. It avoids the obvious problems associated with inherent contempt, though it operates at a much slower pace. And it’s very plausible that officials will grow less willing to risk a big financial hit on behalf of a sunsetting Trump, particularly with many in his party looking beyond him.
“In theory, you could have an individual fined on a daily, weekly, or monthly basis for the time that they’re not complying with a subpoena,” Walkinshaw tells us. “We absolutely have to be willing to do that.”
Also in this bucket: private-sector actors who abetted Trump’s corruption. Multiple Democrats privately told us that they will be looking for creative ways to bring oversight to bear on entities—law firms, media companies, universities—that capitulated to pressure to make “deals” that in effect handed money or resources to Trump’s pet causes. Other Democrats are already discussing oversight of corporations that handed thinly veiled bribes to Trump in the form of “donations” to his imperial projects and campaign committees and were rewarded with favorable treatment from the government, such as the companies that received government contracts after donating to Trump’s ballroom.
The key nuance here is that this creates a route to direct oversight of Trump’s corruption that he can’t obstruct. These entities can’t simply defy oversight demands without creating serious legal and financial risk for themselves. With Democrats taking power, Trump in decline, and the public clearly arrayed against him, incentives will align for executives to divulge internal communications about their decision to bandwagon with Trump’s corruption.
“By focusing on outside actors, you have a better chance of getting information,” a senior Senate aide told us. Yet some Democrats are already balking at this approach: One bafflingly told Politico that such oversight would constitute “banana republic” conduct, when in fact it would be about undoing Trump’s efforts to turn us into a banana republic.
These entities will plead that they only surrendered to Trump under duress. But caving was optional. Every company and firm and university that held to principle survived—even flourished. As for those that didn’t, to the extent that they want to contend they played ball with Trump’s corrupt schemes only because they felt they had no choice, Democrats should confront them with a new demand: that they show meaningful public support for new anti-corruption legislation to set things right.
Finally, there’s the simple tactic of gathering information that might be usable for future prosecutions if Democrats win the presidency in 2028 and a real attorney general takes over. That becomes germane if Congress is able to discover clear violations of federal law—actual, legitimate violations, as opposed to the fake ones drummed up by Trump’s DOJ—on the part of Trump officials or outside actors who corruptly collaborated with them. Indeed, Lieu told us he intends to question witnesses with this in mind. “One of the main things we should do is get evidence for the next Department of Justice,” Lieu said, adding that such evidence could also be grist for prosecutions by state attorneys general.
As Ocasio-Cortez proved, this can work under careful questioning of cooperative witnesses. But it works by delegating and deferring accountability. The damage Trump can do in the meantime—to immigrants, to alliances, to our constitutional system—will be incalculable.
A Fight Caucus
One of the frustrating things about this lack of consensus among Democrats right now is that past congresses have shown more mettle in less perilous times.
The House impeached Andrew Johnson for improperly firing a Cabinet official, and while that was controversial, it’s a reminder that impeachment should remain a tool when serious circumstances warrant it. In 1879, the House of Representatives arrested a U.S. envoy to China—an executive branch official—for the comparably small sin of concealing official ledgers, which Congress believed might show evidence of waste or theft. Why should this approach be verboten when Congress has so many more pressing affronts to its authority to beat back?
Some outside voices are starting to make the case for hardball tactics like inherent contempt. “I do not think that’s a dead end,” Georgetown’s Chafetz said. He asked us to envision a scenario in which Congress detains Elon Musk, who enjoys extraordinarily lucrative government contracts, for refusing to testify about his conversations with Trump about their quid pro quo corruption. Trump would undoubtedly claim executive privilege applies, and his claim would be litigated in court—possibly for months or years. Meanwhile, Musk could plead with the courts to order his release—but while those cases are pending, he’d be stuck in some kind of holding facility. “It doesn’t seem particularly outlandish for a private citizen who is defying a congressional subpoena to be held in custody while that defiance is litigated,” Chafetz told us.
In the end, we think that Democrats who resist this sort of approach will be susceptible to a combination of factors: public pressure, Trump’s escalating lawlessness, and cajoling from more energetic peers. Leaders who believe we’re still in the midst of crisis, and who feel pained when Democrats shrink from challenges, should prod reluctant colleagues to join them.
Indeed, we think these energetic Democrats should formally organize for what’s coming by creating Fight Caucuses—one in the House, one in the Senate. Large blocs of members in the Freedom Caucus, Progressive Caucus, Blue Dog Coalition, and other caucuses routinely bring influence to bear that changes the strategic direction of whole parties.
A Fight Caucus in the House could do the same. It can demand enforceable concessions from Jeffries, who will want a free and easy path to the speakership. We similarly hope that outside advocacy groups—existing ones, or new ones—will treat constitutional hardball as a litmus test that Democrats must meet, no less than support for abortion rights, universal health care, or environmental protection. They can give each member a Fight Score, and provide direction to Democratic Party primary voters: This candidate was a stalwart fighter for democracy, constitutional governance, and the rule of law. That candidate was not.
Ansari, for her part, says she’s open to the idea of Fight Caucuses. And she makes a critical point: Organizing within the caucuses in defense of the rule of law could improve party cohesion. “It’s a great way to unify people,” Ansari said, noting that “fighting corruption and authoritarianism” has adherents in “every part of the caucus.”
Perhaps the best message for hesitant Democrats is to remind them of who Trump is. He is incorrigible. Much as some may want to proceed as if everything’s normal, he will leave them no choice. All they do by resisting confrontation is let him set the terms on which inevitable power struggles unfold.
We are entering a period that will be defined by a paradox. On one hand, Trump will take his abuses of power and assaults on the constitutional order to dangerous new lows. On the other hand, in the eyes of the public—and even in the eyes of many in his own party—he will be seen as a naked and exposed tyrant, an increasingly ludicrous figure who’s passing from the political scene. The best way to resolve this paradox is for Democrats to mount a full-on offensive to save the country. The emergency remains; but the despot’s attempt to cement authoritarian rule has been dealt a potentially fatal setback. Now is the time to bury this national nightmare once and for all, by deploying every last shred of congressional power to that end.
Leftists Weren’t the Only Ones Who Moderated In the Midterms
In the week since Democrats won their most commanding victory in recent memory, the party’s so-called moderates have been eager to claim victory for their faction. Despite firebrand progressives winning Senate seats by healthy margins in states like Michigan and Minnesota, an advisor for the centrist think tank Third Way told the Financial Times that the “majority-makers were mainstream and centre-left Democrats.” The empirical argument here is that moderate candidates were both more numerous and over-performed their progressive counterparts that also won. Third Way likewise credits Democrats’ commanding battleground and red state margins to candidates’ willingness to recant more traditionally progressive positions on issues like immigration and energy. But what does it actually mean to be a moderate, and to moderate one’s views? And why does that responsibility only ever seem to fall on progressives?
Given that most campaign pledges and talking points tend to be pretty watery, pundits of all political stripes can fish around in Tuesday’s results for something to flatter their faction. Texas Senator-elect James Talarico said in September that he would support a national ban on gender-affirming care for minors, and supported an “all of the above” energy platform embracing oil and gas as well as wind, solar, and geothermal. Meanwhile, his victory speech would have been at home in a Bernie Sanders campaign stop; he called for universal healthcare and to “unrig this economic system that only benefits the top 1 percent.” The most online members of various camps within the Democratic coalition have spent the last week volleying these data points back and forth at one another, attempting to claim Tuesday’s massive victory as evidence of their own strategic brilliance.
This all feels a bit silly. For starters, Democrats won enough for everyone to have something to celebrate. Democratic Socialists won well beyond New York City’s so-called “Commie corridor.” DSA has sent six new representatives to the House, and elected its members as mayors in Washington D.C. and Los Angeles. But most candidates who won were not DSA members or endorsed by DSA chapters. Many took up positions that progressives generally oppose while also bashing billionaires and Big Tech. The vast majority of voters, moreover, were not voting for one faction or another because most people don’t possess coherent political ideologies. These intra-party debates matter mostly insofar as they shape how Democrats will use their Congressional majority, and—relatedly—whether they can convince voters to keep voting for Democrats in 2028. As moderate centrists make the case that moderate centrists won, they’re accordingly arguing that Democrats should govern as moderate centrists.
Vibes-based assessments of who counts as a moderate, however, and what it means “to moderate”—feel relatively divorced from the material factors that determine how politicians campaign and govern once they win. Although much of the discourse around Tuesday’s results has focused on how candidates “moderated” certain traditionally left-wing positions in order to win, there’s a case to be made that centrists walking back their own unpopular stances made just as big of a difference.
On one critical issue—U.S. support for Israel—Democrats have moderated enormously over the last two years. The party wouldn’t even agree to let a Palestinian State Representative from Georgia address the Democratic National Convention in 2024. Democrats’ own autopsy of their loss that year concluded that Kamala Harris’s support for the Biden administration’s continued funding of Israel’s genocide in Gaza cost her critical support, particularly among younger voters. Public opinion has changed rapidly since then. An October 2024 Gallup poll of Americans’ views on the Middle East found that 51 percent sympathized more with Israelis, compared to the 27 percent that sympathized more with Palestinians. When Gallup polled the same question this year, 41 percent sympathized more with Palestinians, while 36 percent sympathized more with Israelis.
This year’s elections reflected that shift, and the erosion of a long-held bipartisan consensus in Congress to unconditionally back Israeli government policy. Out of the 26 races where AIPAC spent more than $100,000 this cycle, 21 of the lobby group’s preferred candidates lost. A tally from the Quincy Institute for Responsible Statecraft found that two-thirds of contributions from AIPAC, the AIPAC-linked United Democracy Project, and similar groups were aimed at helping candidates that lost, including Mike Rogers in Michigan and Susan Collins in Maine.
Far from left-wing candidates who’ve accepted generous donations from AIPAC in the past have also denounced the group and its preferred policies. In 2022, for instance, Politico notes that AIPAC spent $2.1 million backing North Carolina Democrat Valerie Foushee’s successful primary campaign against a pro-Palestine progressive Nida Allam; Foushee won by 10 points. In 2024, Foushee received blowback for appearing in pictures with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who called her and other members of a Congressional delegation to Israel “longtime friends” of the country. Facing another primary challenge from Allam this cycle, Foushee officially distanced herself from AIPAC and cosponsored a bill to block certain arms sales to Israel.
Centrists who are currently arguing in favor of moderation insisted back in 2024 that the smart, moderate position was to continue backing Israel as it bombarded Gaza. Matt Yglesias encouraged Democrats to avoid the kind of “contentious, unpopular foreign policy takes” the left was urging them to support. As Matt Breunig noted this summer, Yglesias at some point deleted several tweets to this effect and—like many Democrats—changed his tune.
This is a good thing, of course. It should also cast some doubt on the idea that Democrats should never take up less popular positions or be responsive to the movements and organizations that advocate for them. While political consultants have tended to consider foreign policy a relatively niche and low-salience topic in recent years—i.e. something most voters don’t care about—U.S. support for Israel undergirded many of voters’ top concerns this election. The U.S. entered the war in Iran in no small part at the behest of Trump’s friends in the Israeli government; exit polling showed that 74 percent of voters considered the Iran War a crucial or major factor when voting for members of Congress last week. That illegal, destructive conflict is continuing to drive up fuel prices here, raising the cost to drive gas-powered cars; warm homes and businesses with heating oil; cool them with electrons generated in gas-fired power plants; and transport goods flown in from overseas via diesel trucks. Eighty-nine percent of voters considered the cost of living a crucial or major factor in their vote, per the same exit poll.
It wasn’t only the obviousness of Israel’s crimes in Gaza or the Trump administration’s recklessness that changed how growing numbers of politicians talk about this country’s relationship with Israel, however. Long before October 7, 2023, Palestinian organizers and Palestine solidarity movements around the world drew attention to the Israeli government’s genocidal policies and the U.S. government’s continued support for them. In making a stink about AIPAC and UDP election spending over the last several years, organizers and politicians that support Palestine in the U.S. made it politically toxic for even middle of the road Democrats to take money from those interest groups. That stigma freed candidates from having to embrace those groups’ now broadly unpopular positions in exchange for campaign contributions. This year’s midterms showed that Democrats can win while courting the ire of the groups that have—through campaign donations and lobbying—kept Democrats from questioning the United States’ unconditional support for Israeli government policy.
As they consider what to do with their majorities in the House and Senate—and how to deliver for voters angry about the rising cost of living—Democrats will necessarily have to push to end the war in Iran. That will put them at odds with AIPAC, decades of bipartisan foreign policy consensus, and the Israeli government itself. That such a conflict now feels possible is thanks in no small part to people and politicians that were willing to take up positions they believed in when they were much less popular.
By certain accounts, public opinion would appear to be entirely separate from the work of electoral politics, where candidates’ primary responsibility is to choose from a basket of positions that poll well at that particular moment. Just about every politician would argue that they want to make people’s lives better. Progressives and left-wing politicians have traditionally argued that doing so requires confronting the monied interests that have spent decades pushing for policies that have made the country crueler and more unequal. Happily for those of us on the left, plenty of moderates now espouse a similar view. Let’s hope their faction will also moderate its view on the question of whether electoral politics can help change public opinion rather than merely react to it.
Developing! The Democrats Are (Almost) the Working-Class Party Again
Did the working class win the 2026 midterms? That depends on whether you’re talking about candidates or voters. Working class candidates did very well. Duke sociologist Nicholas Carnes, and Vanderbilt political scientist Noam Lupu count seven midterm general-election candidates for Congress who held working-class jobs immediately prior to entering politics. Four out of the seven won, and if you ignore Tim Rogers, a delivery driver who ran as a Republican in Wisconsin and lost, fully two-thirds of them won.
For those keeping score, the seven working class candidates are: the aforementioned Rogers; Brian Poindexter, an iron worker in Ohio who ran as a Democrat and won; Rebecca Cooke, a waitress in Wisconsin who ran as a Democrat and won; Sam Forstag, a smokejumper in Montana who ran as a Democrat and won; Ray Pooley, a machinist in Michigan who ran as a Democrat and lost; Christopher Reichard, an electrician in Missouri who ran as a Democrat and lost; and Troy Jackson, a logger in Maine and the sole Senate candidate in this group, who ran as a Democrat and won.
If you define “working class” more broadly to include anyone who ever held a union card, then, as TNR’s Monica Potts pointed out last week, at least 17 union members will be sworn in as Democrats in the House, 15 of whom turned red districts blue. In the Senate, in addition to Jackson, the Democrats James Talarico in Texas and Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan are both former union members. According to the AFL-CIO, when you take all state and local elections held on Nov. 3 into account, no fewer than 639 union members won elective office.
But did working class voters win the midterms? That is to say, did Democrats, in winning back the House, secure a working-class majority? That’s a harder question to answer.
According to exit polls, an imperfect metric in these matters, Democrats did not win the working-class vote. That’s disappointing given what a blowout election this was for Democrats generally. Working-class voters are conventionally defined as voters who completed high school but did not receive a college degree. Education level is not a flawless class yardstick, but it’s the best we have. According to exit polls (which are even more flawed; we’ll have better numbers in a few months derived from a Census survey and complete state voting files) Democrats did not capture a majority of non-college voters. They captured 48 percent of them, against 50 percent who voted for Republican candidates.
Some commentators see this glass as half-empty. “The Democratic Coalition Still Has a Class Problem,” wrote Jared Abbott of the Center for Working Class Politics in Jacobin. Ruy Teixeira, co-author with John Judis of the 2023 book Where Have All the Democrats Gone?, bemoaned in The Free Press the likelihood that Democrats will move recklessly to the left (and therefore away from “winnable voters,” by whom he means working class voters). Indeed, a few days before the election Teixeira predicted in The Washington Post that a blue wave “may cripple” the Democrats because “the better they do in 2026, the more likely they are to ignore their party’s weaknesses with working-class and rural voters.” For Teixeira, who’s been drifting rightward in recent years, this borders on self-caricature.
The exit polls show a substantial improvement for Democrats drawing working class voters compared to 2024. In 2024, 43 percent of the non-college vote went to Kamala Harris and to House Democrats, against 56 percent for Trump and House Republicans. That means the Democrats narrowed the Republican advantage from 13 points to two points. In the 2022 midterms, the Republican advantage was a similar 12 points (43 percent for Democrats and 55 percent for Republicans). In essence, Democrats have returned to the status quo of 2020, when Joe Biden, a candidate with strong blue-collar credentials, captured 48 percent of non-college voters to Trump’s 50 percent. (If you go by the voter database Catalyst’s figures for 2024, which are better than exit polls, the Republican advantage that year was more like 11 points. But you get the idea.)
I have written previously that over the past century no Democrat, excepting Biden in 2020, ever won the presidency without winning a majority of non-college voters—and that Biden won under the non-replicable circumstance of Trump’s bungling the deadly Covid pandemic. Judged in that light, the Democrats’ 48 percent support among working-class voters is indeed disappointing, because 48 percent won’t likely be sufficient to elect a Democrat president in 2028. If, in a blowout midterm victory, Democrats failed to secure the working-class majority that’s probably necessary to win the presidency, what hope is there next time?
But I don’t see the glass as half-empty. I see it as half full. No, the Democrats didn’t re-capture a working-class majority in the midterms, according to exit polls, but they made substantial headway toward that goal. I mentioned that Democrats shrank the Republican advantage from 13 or 11 points to two. They may even have done better than that.
The New York Times has some complicated voter trends data gleaned from polls, interviews, turnout records, etc. The idea is to improve on the many drawbacks of exit polls (which, among other things, don’t sample mail-in voters). Whether the Times achieves that goal I can’t say. But according to the Times, the Democrats won non-college voters by four percentage points, picking up 17 percentage points compared to 2024. Hooray! The biggest pickup was for Latino non-college voters (up 35 points), followed by white non-college voters (up 14 points) and Black non-college voters (up 11 points).
The Associated Press has a voter poll that, like the Times, tries to do better than the exit polls. It, alas, tells the precise opposite story about the working class vote. It says the Democrats lost non-college voters by about five percentage points, a worse showing even than in the exit polls. Even so, my glass-half-full self observes that the Democrats, according to the AP, picked up 8 percentage compared to 2024, which represents improvement, no?
We’ll be hearing a lot in the next few weeks about the crucial divide within the Democratic party between moderates and democratic socialists. I don’t think that’s where the action is. I think the divide to which we should pay attention is between non-college voters and college voters. In Abbott’s analysis, that divide has gotten only slightly narrower according to the Times data and somewhat wider according to the AP data, the reason for both being that many more college voters than non-college voters moved from the Republican to the Democratic column. But I’m not going to sweat that finding too much because both groups are swimming in the same direction.
I nonetheless agree with Abbott that the Democrats are going to have to work hard to hang on to those non-college votes. Doing so doesn’t mean hewing more either to centrism or to democratic socialism. Probably it means taking a centrist tack on culture-war issues and a democratic socialist tack on economic ones. The main task, however, is to focus on what working-class voters want going forward. The path to victory in 2028 is not about choosing the right ideology. It’s about choosing the right constituency, and that constituency is the working class. The proles deserve the Democrats’ full attention.
The Much Maligned “Groups” Are the Reason Democrats Won the Midterms
After Kamala Harris lost two years ago, some Democratic-leaning commentators came up with a boogeyman: “the groups.” Left-leaning organizations had forced Harris and other Democratic politicians to adopt progressive stances, particularly during the 2020 presidential primary Those positions doomed those candidates in 2024, these pundits claimed. Therefore, a Democratic (and therefore a democratic one) revival would require a diminished role for left-leaning organizations.
The groups didn’t close their doors or stop pushing for a more progressive, anti-MAGA Democratic Party. Now that the midterms are over, we can say this emphatically: Thank goodness. The resounding victory for Democrats last week came in part because liberal institutions spent the last two years both forcefully attacking the Trump administration and organizing their communities to resist him—often as elected Democrats stood pat. People with titles like governor and senator would seem the logical leaders of the anti-authoritarian movement in America, but in reality, the heads of groups such as Indivisible are offering the courage and wisdom we desperately need.
Like almost all intra-Democratic debates, “the groups” narrative was in part about ideology and identity. Left-leaning groups tend to have fairly progressive positions. And in particular, they push left wing stances on issues involving gender, race, and ethnicity and are often led by women and people of color. Those lambasting the groups were largely center-left white people—the kind of people not under the gun over the past two years. The white centrists were just using new words for an old argument: A generation earlier this bloc of Democrats said the party was too beholden to “special interests,” then personified by Jesse Jackson.
In the months right after Trump’s reelection, anti-left, anti-group sentiment pervaded the Democratic Party. In January 2025, dozens of congressional Democrats backed an anti-immigrant bill called the Laken Riley Act, over the objections of civil rights and progressive groups. Blocs of Senate Democrats, desperate to cast themselves as reasonable and not beholden to liberal activists, voted for many of Trump’s radical, unqualified cabinet nominees. Not a single Democrat voted against Marco Rubio’s confirmation as secretary of state. (Now, many congressional Democrats say they regret their Laken Riley and cabinet votes. As they should)
Democratic lawmakers whined in closed-door meetings that liberal groups were encouraging rank and file Democrats to call members’ offices and demand they stand up to Trump.
Democratic Party officials distancing themselves from activists and groups essentially gave a greenlight to centrist media, which always revels in bashing the left. “The Resistance is Not Coming. It’s Tuning Out,” claimed Politico. “Goodbye, Resistance,” declared The New York Times magazine.
Then, reality struck. The Trump administration was laying off federal workers en masse, shaking down law firms, universities, and other institutions, terrorizing liberal cities, and filing charges against dissenters. It turns out that citing poll-tested talking points about the economy wasn’t sufficient to stop authoritarianism, no matter how often center-left pundits and politicians insisted that the key was to essentially “roll over and play dead.”
Groups and activists decided to fight Trump, despite the risks of an authoritarian regime potentially jailing them. A grassroots network started protesting at Tesla showrooms across the country, trying to weaken the business of Elon Musk, one of the architects of Trump’s destruction of the federal government. Those protests helped drive up Musk’s unpopularity and he left Washington a diminished figure.
After Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer allowed a Trump-backed government funding bill to pass with little resistance, Indivisible called for his resignation. He didn’t, but Schumer and Senate Democrats were shamed into not greenlighting Trump’s budgets in the future. Indivisible organized anti-Trump rallies in cities across the country in April 2025, ending the dumb discussion about the resistance’s demise. The protests organized by the group in October were even larger, drawing out more than 5 million people.
Left-leaning groups in Los Angeles, Chicago, and mostly notably Minneapolis organized aggressive opposition to Trump’s immigration raids in their communities, even as Democratic Party officials largely followed the advice of the anti-groups contingent, which argued any discussion of immigration benefits Trump.
Amid this resistance, Trump’s poll numbers keep plunging. Those on the center-left and many in the media act if the president’s unpopularity is entirely self-inflicted, particularly his decision to join Israel in going to war with Iran, which caused gas prices to shoot up. But it’s hard to imagine that American voters decided entirely on their own that Trump’s actions went too far. It was critical to have a strong activist community loudly casting the administration as authoritarian, essentially forcing the media and Democratic officials to stop ignoring the obvious.
Trump was unpopular before the Iran war even started. The percent of Americans who disapprove of Trump had jumped from 39 percent at the start of his term to 58 percent long before he kicked of the military misadventure. Lest we forget, the 2025 election, held before the war, was also a blue tsunami.
Many of those groups also did campaign work. In the run-up to the election, Black Voters Matter and other groups mobilized African-Americans in the South, resulting in an unusually high-Black turnout that helped flip key districts and states.
The groups didn’t just lead an electoral turnaround. They also defended the targets of the Trump administration directly. Groups such as the NAACP, National Education Association, and the American Civil Liberties Union filed hundreds of lawsuits against the Trump administration, often leading to his policies being stopped.
The groups of course will not get much credit. Center-left politicians and pundits want to attribute the massive Democratic victory to anti-Trump sentiment, good Democratic candidates, bad Republicans ones, and centrist messaging, despite little evidence that the messaging in particular mattered much. The anti-left, anti-groups narrative was advanced the last two years by the Times news and opinion pages, many other prominent centrist news outlets, and by many staffers at left-leaning organizations such as Pod Save America, The Atlantic, and The Bulwark. This collective hivemind isn’t going to admit that it said people should ignore those fighting the fascists hardest for electoral reasons and were wrong about both the fighting and the elections.
But Leah Greenberg and Ezra Levin, the heads of Indivisible, have been much smarter and tougher in fighting fascism than Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer the last two years. Greenberg and Levin won’t get titles like Speaker and Majority Leader. But we can recognize that pair and people like them as the actual leaders of America’s anti-authoritarian movement. Let’s hear it for the groups.
Years of warnings, mounting deaths: Who’s responsible for Santa Cruz’s North Coast?
Royal Navy stands up first autonomous boat squadron
Britain’s Royal Navy has formally commissioned its first uncrewed boat squadron, operating seaborne drones on front-line operations as part of its “Hybrid Navy” strategy.
The force says the 1st Autonomous Squadron officially entered active service on November 5 at a ceremony in Portsmouth Naval Base. It comprises around 180 personnel, about the same as a Type 23 frigate, split into two watches to enable operations around the clock.
This active squadron replaces Project Beehive, the navy’s experimental program to build a fleet of autonomous and remotely operated vessels, through which it obtained 20 uncrewed boats from UK-based Kraken Technology Group.
The force is understood to be using both Kraken’s K3 Scout, and the SM400 from SYOS Aerospace, known by the Royal Navy as the Rattler.
The K3 Scout is an 8.4 m boat capable of 55 knots and can carry a payload of up to 600 kg. It has a range of up to 650 nautical miles and endurance of up to 7 days. The maker describes it as capable of a range of missions, including anti-ship and anti-submarine to detecting and countering other drones and even casualty evacuation.
The Rattler boat is 7.2 m and has a 500 kg modular bay, with a range of up to 950 nautical miles. It was used last year in a demonstration during which 5 of the uncrewed boats were remotely-piloted to escort patrol ship HMS Tyne and mine countermeasures mothership HMS Stirling Castle
Part of the new squadron’s mission will be to act as pathfinder for drone operations, working on bringing additional types of uncrewed surface vessel (USVs) into fleet service and conducting a range of operations alongside other organizations – both as single vessels and as part of a task group.
The “Hybrid Navy” concept was outlined by First Sea Lord General Sir Gwyn Jenkins earlier this year, who made the case that uncrewed vessels would be vital in filling the gaps left by the Royal Navy’s much depleted surface fleet.
Speaking at the launch of the autonomous squadron, Fleet Commander Vice-Admiral Steve Moorhouse hailed it as an historic occasion, but warned that the seas are becoming more contested, more dangerous and harder to operate in.
“A hybrid navy is about giving our people better tools. It means more reach, more striking power and more options,” he stated.
Last week, the force also launched strike drones from one of its aircraft carriers for the first time. Nyan one-way drones made by BAE Systems were launched from the deck, as well as a Tekever AR5 fixed-wing uncrewed aircraft, the same kind the British Army has selected to replace its troublesome Watchkeeper fleet.
Elsewhere, the Ministry of Defence (MoD) says it has launched a British-built satellite called Titania into orbit, claiming it “gives the Armed Forces a new pair of eyes in space.” However, the original purpose of the orbiter was understood to be to test high-speed optical communications from low Earth orbit directly to Earth, using laser beams that are harder to intercept than radio links.
Titania is the second satellite in the UK’s growing constellation of military satellites in orbit, following the launch of Tyche in October, and will be operated by UK Space Command as part of the ISTARI* program.
The latter aims to deliver satellites and supporting ground systems to expand space-based intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance, the MoD said.
However, while the satellite is British-made, it got into space via an American rocket, riding on SpaceX’s Transporter-18 mission. ®
* What is it with the tech industry and Tolkien references?
L.A. had its worst mosquito year this decade. El Niño could make it even worse
This story was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for its newsletters.
When temperatures rise above 70 degrees, tiny West Nile viral particles begin to rapidly replicate in the gut of Culex mosquitoes, which then go hunting for their next “blood meal,” injecting virus-laden saliva into their prey when they feast.
This year, California’s warm, wet summer and fall produced the most West Nile activity in five years. As of Nov. 6, the virus has seriously sickened 528 people and killed 32, according to the California Department of Public Health.
Most people who are infected never feel sick, but about 1 in 5 may develop fever, headache and body aches. For the rare few — 1 in 150 — things get serious: The virus can hitch a ride to the brain, causing inflammation, neurological problems and even death. There is no cure, only supportive medical care.
Southern California bore the brunt of infections, with Los Angeles County accounting for more than half of all reported human cases.
Residents there could soon notice a reprieve from mosquitoes, as cooler nights slow both mosquito breeding and growth of the virus. But experts still worry about what comes next, as climate change and extreme weather create conditions for mosquito-borne illness to surge, particularly along the coast and in floodplains.
“We’re all scared of next year,” said Paula Macedo, chair of the Mosquito and Vector Control Association of California. “With the amount of activity that we already saw this year and having the forecast of being an El Niño year, we are all bracing ourselves.”
Whether next year brings relief or another surge depends on a tangle of birds, mosquitoes and weather that even experts struggle to predict.
Coastal California at risk of increased diseaseIn September, a warm storm swept past Southern California’s coastal and inland regions. The outer tendrils of Hurricane Marie poured an inch-and-a-half of rain across much of the westside of Los Angeles; downtown L.A. broke a rainfall record from 1965. In the following days, temperatures reached a high of 104 degrees, with overnight lows failing to dip below 77 degrees.
Mosquitoes thrived in the following days. The rainfall flushed mosquito-killing treatments out of more than 3,000 miles of underground storm drains, according to the Greater Los Angeles County Vector Control District.
“One of our biggest sources for Culex [mosquitoes] are our underground storm drains,” said Susanne Kluh, the district’s general manager. “It’s pretty much 72 degrees down there and humid all year round.”
The district treats storm drains monthly, but with the larvicide washed out to sea, mosquito populations surged. At one point this summer, Kluh said more than 70% of mosquitoes trapped for sampling carried West Nile virus. That share has fallen in recent weeks to about one-third.
Research suggests that climate change will increase risk of West Nile transmission along Southern California’s coast. A UC Berkeley-led study of Los Angeles-area data from 2006 to 2016 found a narrow tipping point: when average temperatures stayed below about 70 degrees, the virus was much less likely to turn up in mosquitoes, and when they rose above about 73, it became much more likely. Higher temperatures were also linked to more human infections.
Coastal Los Angeles sits right at that edge. Summer averages hover in the high 60s to low 70s, and a few degrees of warming can push it over. That’s precisely what happened this year.
“The longer that those temperatures are appropriate, the more opportunity there can be for human cases,” said Tristan Hallum, scientific director for San Gabriel Valley Mosquito and Vector Control District.
The virus moves in a complex loop driven by birds, mosquitoes and weather conditions. A female mosquito feeding on an infected bird can ingest the virus and subsequently infect other birds and sometimes humans. But birds that have been previously infected and survived become immune to West Nile, and their blood no longer carries virus for feasting mosquitoes to consume.
That immunity tends to produce a natural three- to five-year cycle of West Nile activity, meaning Los Angeles, Orange County and other areas with many cases may get a reprieve next year, but other parts of the state remain vulnerable.
Virus flourishes during extreme weatherFederal forecasters give a very strong El Niño a greater than 90% chance this winter, raising the odds of heavy rain, particularly in Southern California. That worries public health and vector control officials: if floodwaters linger into spring as temperatures rise, mosquitoes could boom.
That’s happened before. In 2023, heavy precipitation and flooding filled the long-dry Tulare Lake basin in the Central Valley, submerging vast stretches of agricultural land and reviving wetland habitats. The lake persisted for roughly a year, temporarily changing bird migration patterns and behavior; it also created prime habitat for the state’s native Culex mosquitoes.
That year health officials recorded 433 human cases of West Nile.
Drought matters too, and in a counterintuitive way. In 2014 and 2015, more than 1,600 people contracted West Nile during some of the driest years on record.
“One hypothesis is that the dry conditions bring birds and mosquitoes into closer contact due to the water being more limited across the landscape,” said Chris Barker, a professor at UC Davis who studies mosquito-borne illnesses and helps run the state’s West Nile surveillance program.
Because West Nile depends on a shifting mix of birds, mosquitoes and weather, cases won’t climb steadily year after year as climate warms, Barker said. Instead, extreme weather — both floods and drought — will create more years when conditions line up for outbreaks, making the virus harder to fight.
“Climate change has the effect of tipping the scales against us just a little bit more,” he added.
Experts seek vaccineThere is no vaccine to protect against West Nile virus. Aaron Brault, a top West Nile expert and researcher with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, said in an email that the U.S. needs one.
“Despite West Nile virus being an important cause of illness in the United States for more than 25 years, our overall toolbox is limited,” Brault said.
The CDC accepted only written questions and would not make Brault available for an interview.
Repellent and long sleeves help to decrease risk, but people frequently forgo these measures, Brault said, and those measures “have not adequately reduced the number of West Nile virus disease cases or deaths in the United States.”
The CDC is exploring new ways to combat West Nile and encourage development of a vaccine, new treatments and better diagnostic tests, but it’s difficult work. West Nile outbreaks are unpredictable, making it tough to run the large clinical studies vaccines require.
“Viruses do defy us sometimes, especially the people trying to predict them,” Barker said.
Climate change supercharges that uncertainty and makes it harder for the people trying to keep mosquito numbers low.
Vector control faces new challenges, limited fundingVector control districts across California spend millions each year trapping and killing mosquitoes. Residents fund the work locally through property taxes, typically $4 to $10 a year, according to the Mosquito and Vector Control Association of California. New pests and longer mosquito seasons challenge their work.
The mosquitoes most Southern California residents swatted and scratched at this year were likely not the West Nile-bearing Culex mosquito, but an invasive species called Aedes aegypti.
A female Aedes aegypti mosquito. Credit: James Gathany / U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
Native Culex mosquito species bite between dusk and dawn and prefer birds to humans, though they’re opportunistic biters. In contrast, the black-and-white striped Aedes hunts during the day, and its meal of choice is human blood. It doesn’t transmit West Nile virus, but it can spread other infectious diseases such as dengue, zika, chikungunya and yellow fever.
Aedes is also harder to control. It breeds in as little as a teaspoon of water, and its eggs can also survive months of drought, reviving whenever wet weather returns. Some vector control districts in California have spent hundreds of thousands of dollars releasing sterile male Aedes mosquitoes to reduce the overall number of mosquitoes, taking away from the ability to fight Culex mosquitoes.
Disasters can add to the strain. The Eaton fire, which destroyed 9,000 structures in 2025, left behind 1,400 stagnant swimming pools.
“Budget over time has been stretched really thin by having to respond to these additional mosquitoes and additional causes,” Macedo, with the Mosquito and Vector Control Association of California, said.
State law limits how much local governments can raise fees for these services, though some vector control districts have gone to voters to ask for more money.
Still, Macedo said, no budget can cover every backyard.
“We cannot enter every property. We cannot treat every mosquito source,” she said. “We need people to understand how they can prevent the situation.”
Supported by the California Health Care Foundation (CHCF), which works to ensure that people have access to the care they need, when they need it, at a price they can afford. Visit www.chcf.org to learn more.
Have something to say? Lookout welcomes letters to the editor, within our policies, from readers. Guidelines here.
The post L.A. had its worst mosquito year this decade. El Niño could make it even worse appeared first on Lookout Santa Cruz.
MAGA Fury Erupts as Trump Blurts Out Damning Admission about GOP Loss
In an interview with CBS News, Donald Trump acknowledged that a big reason for the GOP electoral bloodbath was his mass deportations. In one sense, this is absurd, given his elevation of Stephen Miller as chief of staff. But in another sense, Trump did admit to things in the interview that are anathema to MAGA: That undocumented immigrants are good workers, and that Americans think immigration is good for our country. MAGA erupted wildly over this. One influencer raged that if Trump does amnesty, “I’m done.” Another insisted that this would be a “disaster.” Still another fumed: “WITHOUT DEPORTATIONS, OUR COUNTRY IS GONE.” We sorted through all this with political scientist Julia Azari, who’s been writing well on this election for the “Good Politics/Bad Politics” Substack. We discuss what Trump revealed about the MAGA coalition’s crackup, the deeper forces driving it, why JD Vance will struggle to knit it back together, and how Democrats can drive wedges deep into it going forward. Listen to this episode here.
Microsoft teaches schools that free email was just a phase
Microsoft is retiring its free education email service, leaving schools, colleges, and universities facing new licensing bills if they want to keep students' mailboxes.
The company announced plans last week to retire Office 365 A1, the Student Use Benefit program, and free Exchange Online for Alumni. The changes generally take effect at institutions' first renewal or extension on or after January 1, 2028.
Office 365 A1 provides eligible institutions with web-based Office applications, Teams, and email at no charge. Its replacement, Microsoft 365 Education A0, excludes Exchange Online, SharePoint Online, and Teams. Eligibility also depends on paid faculty licensing and students actively using Windows devices for education.
A spokesperson for the UK's Department for Education told The Register: "We are disappointed that Microsoft has made this decision. However, we are pleased to have successfully negotiated some additional concessions for the UK, giving schools, colleges and universities the time they need to be able to successfully transition to new licensing agreements."
An industry insider said the loss of free Microsoft-hosted email could add thousands to institutions' bills. Another organization noted "significant concerns… around affordability, equitable treatment across the sector, and the longer-term implications of the changes."
A spokesperson for UK education technology body Jisc told The Register that its "focus has been on ensuring that UK education providers are well supported and have sufficient time to assess their options."
"We continue working closely with Microsoft and sector partners to support those discussions and help institutions make informed decisions about their future requirements."
Also being retired are free Exchange Online for Alumni - which lets graduates retain their mailboxes - and the Student Use Benefit, providing student licenses at no additional charge when institutions purchase qualifying faculty licenses. Microsoft plans a paid alumni replacement.
The Windows giant is also changing storage entitlements and introducing Microsoft 365 Education A7, its "most advanced education offering," which adds AI, security, governance, and device-management features.
Asked why it was removing those services from the free tier, Microsoft framed the overhaul as a response to institutions' changing needs.
A spokesperson told The Register: "Education institutions are evaluating AI, security, privacy, governance, and teaching and learning as connected priorities rather than separate technology decisions.
"Microsoft is updating the portfolio now to provide a clearer path from foundational access to advanced capabilities, while enabling institutions to adopt technology according to their needs and readiness. This evolution reflects both the value Microsoft 365 Education has gained since the last pricing change nearly a decade ago and the structure of the new portfolio.
"Microsoft's broader goal is not technology adoption for its own sake. It is to support AI and digital experiences that strengthen learning, preserve educator judgment and give institutions the controls they need to manage data, privacy, and responsible use."
Office 365 A1 stopped accepting new web-direct orders on November 5, 2026, with partner-channel sales ending on May 1, 2027. Retirement is scheduled for January 1, 2028, but existing agreements remain valid through their current terms. Institutions that need continued service must move to replacement licenses at the applicable renewal or contract expiry. ®
Otter AI can now follow conversations across 30+ languages
California’s proposed ‘billionaire tax’ fails to pass
Jensen Huang’s alleged honeypot scandal has inspired some top-notch memes
Cisco to link all future products to its SaaS-y Cloud Control management tool
Cisco will no longer create products that don’t integrate with Cloud Control, its SaaS-y management platform that offers netadmins a single tool to manage all of the networking giant’s devices and much of its software portfolio.
The networking giant announced Cloud Control in June 2025 and only made it available to customers in the USA. Cisco has previously told The Register that slow rollout reflects the fact that Cisco needs to nail privacy and other regulatory niceties, and deploy infrastructure, before introducing the service to other markets.
It appears Cisco is now satisfied it has sorted out those issues. Jeff Schultz, Cisco’s senior vice president for portfolio strategy and marketing, today told the company’s Live conference in Australia that Cloud Control will come online in the European Union, UK, and Down Under in February 2027. Japan, India, and Canada will get their turn in May.
Schultz said Cisco is “working tirelessly” to deploy Cloud Control across the world as soon as possible.
He also revealed that, starting next year, Cisco will no longer ship products that don’t integrate with Cloud Control.
That doesn’t mean those products will be manageable only if they can connect to Cloud Control. Instead, the decision reflects Cisco’s belief that the main thing stopping its customers buying more of its products is the complexity of operating them in concert. Schultz also feels that Cloud Control represents “platform advantage” for Cisco, because when users integrate networking, security, and observability the result is better manageability and resilience.
Schultz also told the conference that Cisco will bundle its Thousand Eyes observability and security tool with the “Essentials” and “Advantage” licenses. “We admit it was hard to license and deploy,” he said during his keynote speech, adding that the tool will be deployed automatically with Wi‑Fi 6E and Wi‑Fi 7 hardware.
Another product Cisco plans to bring to more customers is Live Protect, a tool that implements compensating controls for flaws that organizations can’t immediately patch. Live Protect currently works on some switches, plus SD-WAN and WLAN controllers. From December, Cisco will extend it to 8000 series routers, secure firewalls, campus gateway, and to Cloud Control itself. From May 2027, Live Protect will work with Cisco’s ASR 9000 series service aggregation routers and Network Convergence System. ®
DA declines to charge suspect in Moss Landing double homicide
The Monterey County District Attorney’s Office announced Monday that it will not file charges against an 18-year-old Greenfield man arrested in connection with the Nov. 2 shooting on Jetty Road in Moss Landing that left two teenagers dead.
District Attorney Jeannine Pacioni said there is insufficient evidence at this time to charge Donald William Breeden, who was arrested last week on suspicion of two counts of murder with criminal street gang enhancements.
The shooting occurred around 1:48am during a party attended by dozens of juveniles and young adults, some of whom were associated with Norteño gangs from Salinas and Greenfield, according to the District Attorney’s Office.
The victims, 13-year-old Nathaniel Flores and 15-year-old Marco Antonio Perez, both of Salinas, were killed in the shooting. A young adult from Greenfield was shot twice and survived.
According to prosecutors, the confrontation began as a verbal dispute between the two groups over allegations of theft, vandalism and threats of violence by members of the Salinas group.
Investigators corroborated some of those allegations, including a witness account that someone from the Salinas group had stolen necklaces from female partygoers. Deputies later found multiple gold necklaces in that person’s backpack.
The argument escalated, with witnesses reporting that members of both groups exchanged gang-related insults.
Some witnesses said people on both sides displayed firearms or held their waistbands as though they were armed.
But investigators have been unable to determine who fired the first shots.
“Some of those present said the Salinas group shot first, while others said the Greenfield group shot first,” the District Attorney’s Office stated.
Investigators recovered 21 shell casings from the scene, fired from at least two guns. No firearms have been recovered, and forensic analysis is pending.
Prosecutors also noted that the shooting occurred in darkness and that many witnesses were underage, intoxicated or involved in the confrontation.
The two teenagers who died were shot seven and five times, respectively.
Under California law, prosecutors must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that a defendant did not act in lawful self-defense once the issue is raised.
“At this time there is insufficient evidence to prove that Donald Breeden did not fire in self-defense,” the District Attorney’s Office stated.
Breeden was arrested after Monterey County Sheriff’s detectives, assisted by the Sheriff’s Office SWAT Team, Monterey Peninsula Special Response Unit and California State Parks, executed search warrants Nov. 5 in Greenfield and King City.
The first warrant was served on the 900 block of Maple Avenue in Greenfield, where three people were detained. A second warrant was served on the 45000 block of Crown Avenue in King City.
Breeden was subsequently booked into Monterey County Jail, with bail set at $2.035 million.
The District Attorney’s announcement does not rule out charges if additional evidence emerges.
The investigation remains ongoing.
Anyone with information is encouraged to contact Monterey County Sheriff’s Office Detective Richard Geng at 831-.759.7279.