Crackdown on UK medical record snooping after staff reported sneaking 300+ times this year
Britain's privacy watchdog has put healthcare bosses on notice after receiving more than 300 reports of staff snooping through medical records this year, demanding that executives personally confirm they're doing enough to keep prying eyes out of patient files.
The Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) said on Thursday that it had written to more than 200 senior health leaders across the UK, warning that employees accessing records without good reason put patient privacy and public trust at risk.
The ICO received and assessed more than 300 reports of medical record snooping between January and mid-October 2026. Staff were caught looking up people they knew, poking around patient files out of sheer curiosity, and sharing private information with people who had no business seeing it.
The figure covers reports submitted by healthcare organizations rather than confirmed breaches, and excludes cases still awaiting assessment.
ICO chief executive Paul Arnold wants health bosses to personally assure him that their organizations have safeguards in place to stop staff having a nose through records they aren't supposed to see.
"Accessing someone's health records without a legitimate reason isn't harmless curiosity. It can cause enormous distress to patients and jeopardize the vital trust people place in our health service," Arnold said.
In a three-page letter to chief executives, Arnold makes clear that simply trusting staff to behave themselves won't cut it. He wants to know who can access patient records, whether anyone is checking what they're looking at, and what happens when somebody gets caught snooping.
Health bosses are also expected to investigate suspected breaches without dragging their feet, work out whether patients need to be told, and take action against staff caught accessing records they shouldn't.
Executives have until November 27 to respond. Those who haven't reviewed their safeguards in the past six months, or aren't happy with what they find, have been given another three months to put their house in order.
The problem isn't necessarily that healthcare workers are hacking into systems, as many already have legitimate access to patient records as part of their jobs. The trouble starts when they use that access to look up someone they're not treating, whether it's a neighbor, an ex-partner, or somebody whose name has appeared in the news.
This isn't the first time health authorities have tried to stamp out the problem. In July, NHS England warned employees that accessing records without a legitimate reason could cost them their jobs or even land them in prison.
That crackdown followed incidents involving staff accessing the medical records of victims of high-profile crimes, including the Nottingham attacks. NHS England also published guidance encouraging organizations to use access controls and audit systems to catch employees poking around where they shouldn't.
Some newer electronic patient record systems can even flag suspicious access in real time, although the NHS acknowledged that monitoring capabilities vary depending on the technology organizations have installed.
The scale of the problem has been troubling regulators for years. In July, the UK government told Parliament that 1,445 cases of inappropriate access had been reported to the ICO between 2019 and 2025.
And the consequences can go beyond getting the sack. The ICO has prosecuted 16 healthcare workers for snooping through patient records over the past decade, with unauthorized access to personal information potentially amounting to a criminal offense under the Data Protection Act 2018.
Arnold warned that the regulator could also take enforcement action against healthcare organizations whose protections aren't up to scratch.
"I've written to chief executives across the UK asking them to personally assure me that their safeguards work in practice. Where they don't, we expect organizations to put that right," he said.
With hundreds of reports already landing on the watchdog's desk this year, healthcare bosses now have a fortnight to explain how they're keeping staff out of records they have no business reading. ®
Did the Midterms Kill Climate Politics?
Climate change was not a hot topic during this year’s midterm elections. Candidates who’d previously championed climate action walked those positions back this cycle. Abdul El-Sayed supported the Green New Deal when he ran for governor in 2018; he said he wouldn’t defend it now. James Talarico sponsored climate legislation as a state legislator in Texas and once said “fossil fuels are destroying the planet.” In his Senate run, Talarico embraced an “all of the above” energy strategy as part of a platform to protect jobs in the oil and gas industry while encouraging cleaner sources like solar and wind, which already proliferate in the Lonestar State. Looking at these shifts, Axios declared, “Democrats’ blue wave leaves climate behind.”
So are Democrats really done with climate politics? Not exactly. An analysis from the Climate and Community Institute points out that candidates in deep blue districts and swing states alike touted their support for clean energy investment and taking on polluting utilities. While these planks weren’t necessarily central, Republicans didn’t manage to sink campaigns by attacking Democrats’ past or present support for a “Green New Scam,” either. Climate politics may not be dead, then, but their future is going to look very different.
During the first years of the Biden administration, climate change was both a consistent White House talking point and treated primarily as an investment opportunity that would allow the United States to accomplish a range of goals for various factions within the Democratic Party: outcompete China in the twenty-first century’s most important growth industries; bring well-paid, potentially even unionized jobs back to deindustrialized areas, and thus win voters in critical swing states back to Democrats; rehabilitate the country’s global reputation after Trump; and reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Debates still rage over how successfully the Inflation Reduction Act—the Biden era’s highest-profile legislative achievement—was at accomplishing these aims. A year after its passage, polls showed that seven in 10 Americans had heard only “a little” or “nothing” about it.
Whatever the next era of climate politics holds, it will likely revolve less around the United States becoming some sort of global climate champion and pledges to reach “net-zero” emissions by some point far off into the future. Given the sheer force of the climate disasters now regularly battering the U.S.—from heat waves to wildfires, floods, and droughts—it should probably also engage with climate change as a force that is actively upending life here rather than as a problem still primarily hurting poorer parts of the world. It is difficult, that is, to imagine an affordability agenda that ignores how soaring energy costs make monthly bills unaffordable in scorching summer heat; how the skyrocketing cost of home insurance is driving up housing costs; or how persistent droughts have driven the U.S. cattle down herd to its lowest levels in 75 years and sent beef prices soaring. Addressing these sorts of climate-induced cost of living concerns might also mean a turning away from treating climate change as a distinct issue, and infusing it into a broader-based economic populism.
Will Lawrence—the Sunrise Movement co-founder who flipped his Michigan House seat last week—told the New York Times this week that climate is one of many “cascading crises” facing the country, on top of wars and rising costs: “Figuring out how to wrap that all up into one neat story is not easy for any of us.” His message, he added, was about security “in the sense of being able to look forward to the future and be secure at night knowing that we and our kids are going to be taken care of, that we’re going to be OK. Climate is as important to that as it’s ever been.”
Such an approach could entail broadening the focus of climate politics beyond the energy sector, where most climate policy and messaging in the U.S. has tended to focus. Although people care quite a lot about how much electricity costs, how those electrons are generated—and how they make their way to homes and businesses—aren’t especially pressing questions for most Americans. Decarbonizing the power sector is both a vital goal and a virtually incomprehensible statement. Fortunately for would-be green populists, some of the same companies that are profiting off of wildly unprofitable data centers are also responsible for rising electricity bills and excess carbon emissions. If greening a utility’s energy mixture doesn’t excite voters, holding its CEOs’ feet to the fire might. Candidates for public utility regulators in Georgia and Arizona focused on expanding renewable energy and reining in utility bosses’ attempts to raise rates for the sake of powering data centers.
The disturbing reality of the climate crisis is that it affects virtually every facet of life. For Democrats who want to help the country navigate a hotter and pricier century, the sheer scope of that crisis can be the grounds for a new climate politics that responds to voters’ concerns with more than abstract pledges.
America Has Entered a New Age of Propaganda
On July 16, Donald Trump went on prime-time television to repeat to Americans that an election he had lost nearly six years earlier had been stolen. Four months before the midterms, Trump turned a presidential address into another recital of the conspiracy theories that have sustained him since 2020. In an ominous and unhinged speech, he claimed that China’s attempts to acquire voter data were evidence of a plot to corrupt the vote, then returned to his familiar claims about widespread fraud.
ABC and NBC declined to carry the speech on their main broadcast channels. CBS aired it, then broke away after about 15 minutes to debunk Trump’s assertions. Trump answered that the networks were engaged in a “plot” and said those that did not air the speech should lose their licenses. Six days later, Federal Communications Commission Chair Brendan Carr said ABC’s snub would be considered in an unusually early review of licenses for eight Disney-owned stations. ABC and Disney have since sued the FCC, alleging retaliation.

America has entered a new era of truth manipulation and censorship in which journalists are faced with a self-sealing trap. Carry the speech and help spread the election lie, or refuse and be cast as part of the conspiracy supposedly suppressing it. Either response could be recruited into the government’s propaganda campaign.
The prospect of a society in which truth and falsehood are indistinguishable—one in which the difference doesn’t even seem to matter—troubles philosophers Avishai Margalit and Assaf Sharon in their book Captive Minds: A Study of Manipulation. Sharon is a political theorist who specializes in democratic legitimacy and the conditions under which citizens can genuinely govern themselves. Margalit is a preeminent philosopher best known for The Decent Society (1996), The Ethics of Memory (2002), On Compromise and Rotten Compromises (2010), and On Betrayal (2017). He has spent his career asking what degrades human dignity—humiliation, forgetting, rotten compromise, betrayal—and now, with Sharon, turns to the capture and domination of judgment itself.
Margalit and Sharon explain their personal stakes in the preface. Living in Jerusalem, they began writing Captive Minds while watching demagogues exploit the threat of terrorism to justify occupation and the horrors of occupation to excuse further brutality. “As more blood flows between the River and the Sea, the two peoples living on this punished land become easier prey to manipulators who exploit fear, hatred, and confusion,” they write. That blood is “the fuel of manipulation,” which then precipitates further violence. And the resurgence of authoritarianism in Europe and the United States threatens a similar vicious cycle on a global scale. Donald Trump, in their view, is more a symptom than a cause. Their subject is the set of conditions that makes such a figure possible.
The book is neither a conventional work of media criticism nor a narrowly academic philosophical treatise. It reads instead as an urgent work of late democratic anxiety. What if the greatest political danger of our time is no longer that governments force their subjects to obey, but that they induce citizens to surrender their judgment willingly? How did that become possible?
American propaganda has a long lineage, from the partisan press of the early republic to wartime mobilization and modern public relations. During World War I, the federal Committee on Public Information promoted the war through official news, posters, films, and more than 75,000 “Four Minute Men,” who delivered vetted speeches in movie theaters and other venues. After the war, veterans of such campaigns brought those techniques into commercial persuasion. One of the field’s principal theorists was Edward Bernays, who treated public opinion as something trained experts could engineer.
Bernays regarded the manufacture of public opinion as both legitimate and necessary. In his 1928 book Propaganda, he argued that democratic society was too complex for citizens to navigate unaided, and therefore required the “conscious and intelligent manipulation” of the habits and opinions of the masses by an “invisible government.” The following year, working for the American Tobacco Company, he arranged for fashionable young women to smoke cigarettes during New York’s Easter parade, while alerting the press that women’s rights marchers would light “torches of freedom.” A campaign to sell Lucky Strikes appeared as a spontaneous protest against a sexist taboo. Bernays’s method was to identify an existing desire, attach it to a product or policy, and make the desired behavior appear to originate with the public rather than the sponsor.
The darker connotations of propaganda are clear in its history in Fascist Italy, Nazi Germany, and the Soviet Union, where mass persuasion worked alongside censorship, surveillance, terror, and political violence. Nazi propaganda exploited prejudice, fear, humiliation, resentment, and the desire for restored greatness, supplying a story in which Germany’s defeats were caused by internal enemies and traitors. Soviet agitprop likewise defended the state, sanctified its leaders, manufactured heroic myths, and attributed failures to saboteurs and class enemies. In both systems, propaganda did more than circulate falsehoods. It organized a way of seeing the world. “If everyone always lies to you, the consequence is not that you believe the lies, but that no one believes anything at all anymore,” Hannah Arendt said in her final interview in 1973. “That means that the people are deprived not only of their capacity to act, but also of their capacity to think and to judge. And with such a people you can then do what you please.”
Church and state were once the main manipulators; now the giants of the attention economy join them as full partners.This subtlety is a theme of Margalit and Sharon’s book. One of their recurring contrasts, drawn from Cicero and Machiavelli, is between the lion and the fox: The lion rules by force; the fox by cunning, seduction, flattery, deception, and psychological leverage. Another text to which they repeatedly return is Shakespeare’s Othello. For the authors, Iago is the archetypal manipulator. He does not command Othello or threaten him. Instead, he asks insinuating questions, claims that Cassio spoke of a secret affair with Desdemona in his sleep, and arranges for her handkerchief to turn up in Cassio’s room. Othello’s love makes him vulnerable, and Iago converts that vulnerability into jealousy and self-destruction. By the time Othello murders Desdemona, he believes he is acting on evidence and exercising his own will, but he is carrying out another man’s design. “Instead of binding you in chains,” Margalit and Sharon write, “the manipulator pulls your strings.”
Iago’s art is ancient, but the scale on which it is being practiced is new. What used to be individual cunning has become commercialized by Silicon Valley, a transformation described in Franklin Foer’s World Without Mind: The Existential Threat of Big Tech, and most recently in Jill Lepore’s The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State. Church and state were once the main manipulators; now the giants of the attention economy join them as full partners.
What concerns Margalit and Sharon is that the liberal ideal of the open society, with free expression, a free press, and open exchange, may now function less as a safeguard than as “quicksand,” because under laissez-faire conditions it can enable “mind-numbing nonsense” to overwhelm the public sphere. More speech is not the answer, not when citizens are saturated with media to the point that the distinction between truth and falsehood begins to collapse. A public sphere flooded with conspiracies, grievance-optimized messages, fabrications, and artificial productions may remain formally open while leaving citizens increasingly vulnerable to domination. An open society permits expression, but a free society protects each person’s capacity to form a judgment genuinely their own.
The present danger is subtler and harder for liberal democracy to recognize and fight against, because the United States may remain formally democratic while losing the conditions necessary for meaningful self-government. Citizens may still vote, the press may remain legally free, and political speech may be abundant, yet public opinion may no longer be independently formed. Disinformation and conspiracy theories can shatter common factual ground into rival realities, while generative AI makes the fracture endlessly scalable.
Disinformation and conspiracy theories can shatter common factual ground into rival realities, while generative AI makes the fracture endlessly scalable.Because manipulation has become so pervasive and profitable, resisting it requires more than correcting lies one by one. Margalit and Sharon argue that public discourse should be treated as democratic infrastructure, as essential as fair elections and independent courts, and cannot be left to an unregulated market for attention. Society cannot eliminate manipulation any more than it can eliminate friction, they argue; it can only keep manipulation from becoming an organizing principle. That means reducing the emotional and economic dependencies that make people easy to control, fortifying institutions that earn epistemic authority, respecting genuine expertise, and cultivating a public culture that rewards rigor and punishes quackery.
Their argument points toward a useful principle for more specific reform: Regulate the business rather than political opinion itself. Specific efforts are already underway. Google restricts how election advertisers can target voters, while Google and Meta have stopped accepting political advertising in the European Union. Those measures should go further. Congress should ban behavioral political microtargeting, phase out surveillance advertising, make engagement-driven ranking opt-in, and tax digital advertising to fund independent local and public media. Regulators should be able to audit platforms and hold companies liable for the harms they cause. Courts should treat internet giants not as speech platforms but as corporations subject to consumer-protection, negligence, and product-liability law. Recent lawsuits against Open AI and Meta’s landmark $18 billion settlement with nearly every U.S. state are just a start. These reforms rest on the premise that a democracy is entitled to govern its information environment and reduce the incentives that make manipulation so ubiquitous and lucrative.
Finally, the survival of American democracy depends on citizens rediscovering the power to uncover manipulation and change their minds. Margalit and Sharon find a model in 427 BCE, when the city of Mytilene rebelled against Athens. In a fit of rage, the Athenians voted to kill every Mytilenaen man and enslave its women and children. When they reconsidered the next day, the demagogue Cleon chastised those having second thoughts and pandered to the people’s urge for revenge. His opponent Diodotus instead implored the Athenians to restore their sense of reason and compassion, and thankfully narrowly prevailed. A second trireme raced after the ship carrying the original order, arriving just as the decree was being read and averting the massacre.
For Margalit and Sharon, Mytilene’s escape offers hope for democracy, after all. Even when it seems too late—even after the ship has sailed—a free society might, just in time, still be able to send a second.
Nvidia’s Jensen Huang and Troubling Rise of the Imperial CEO
Jensen Huang resigned Thursday as chief executive of Nvidia, a company that he co-founded in 1993 with the modest goal of creating 3D graphics for video games, but which now dominates the global market for the advanced graphic processing units that power AI. Nvidia’s shares were, according to one September calculation, 8 percent of the entire S&P 500. Lately, they’ve slipped below 6 percent, but that’s still gargantuan. Under the best of circumstances, it’s very difficult to force out the chairman of a company making this kind of money for its shareholders. Huang made it even harder by eliminating potential sources of accountability.
Some will conclude Huang’s resignation shows that America’s system of corporate governance works, but that’s the wrong lesson. Huang kept his job long after it became evident to pretty much everyone working at Nvidia that he was abusing his executive power. What his story really illustrates is that big-shot tech chiefs—Huang, Mark Zuckerberg, Elon Musk, and Anthropic’s Dario Amodei come most readily to mind—tend to amass so much wealth and power that they make themselves almost impossible to fire. These corporations are, in effect, hostage to the merchant princes who run them.
Huang’s resignation wouldn’t have occurred, or anyway wouldn’t have occurred this week, without The New York Times reporting Thursday that he was caught on video last March canoodling during a company meeting with Nvidia’s vice president of health care. This came after Huang confessed Sunday to conducting an extramarital affair with Alice Huang (no relation), who, as the Times revealed last week, is a suspected Chinese spy. Conceivably Huang didn’t know this about her, but as the corporate governance expert Nell Minow pointed out to me, Huang was certainly aware that the company Alice ran, Megaspeed, was Nvidia’s biggest customer in Southeast Asia, making any such relationship, even if consensual, a violation of corporate ethics and potentially a violation of securities law. It would not astonish me to learn that Huang turned a blind eye to, or even collaborated with, his paramour’s alleged diversion of Nvidia AI chips to China, which the Times reported on more than a year ago. (Huang denies the diversion took place). The filing of class-action lawsuits has already begun.
“If involved in a situation that could present a perceived or actual conflict of interest,” the Nvidia ethics manual advises, “contact Employment Legal for guidance.” Had Huang followed his own company’s policies and confessed to Employment Legal that he was bumping uglies with a Nvidia customer and snogging with a Nvidia employee, he undoubtedly would have been told not to fish off the company pier.
Insinuations that Nvidia’s chief executive had an affair with Alice Huang have been public for more than a year. If Nvidia’s board never asked Huang about it, then the company was hostage to Huang to a greater degree than I think. More likely, it did ask; Huang lied; and the board pretended to believe him because to do otherwise would tank Nvidia’s stock. Which is exactly what happened after the Financial Times confirmed the affair. As I write, Nvidia has lost about $1 trillion in value, lending weight to Bloomberg’s Matt Levine’s observation that this is “the most expensive extramarital affair in human history.” We know that Huang lied about Alice last month to Bloomberg, saying, “Our relationship, our interactions, have been related to Megaspeed, and it was all completely normal and not unusual.” For at least as long, Nvidia company spokespeople have denied that Jensen and Alice were knocking boots.
We don’t know whether the board knew that Huang also got caught spooning with Nvidia’s Kimberly Powell (the Times used the term “being affectionate”) at a San Jose hotel where Nvidia employees stayed while attending Nvidia’s annual developer conference. A bystander recorded this on a cell phone; Huang’s security team observed the surveillance; and the security team then “sequestered the person,” the Times reported, and “asked the person to sign a nondisclosure agreement.”
The Times doesn’t relate whether this person signed the agreement. But assuming they were a Nvidia employee (I don’t see how Huang’s security team could “sequester” somebody who wasn’t), merely asking that person to remain silent would violate California’s 2021 Silenced No More Act. In any event, the video’s existence did not remain confidential, and the Times got confirmation of the smooch from no fewer than five Nvidia employees, suggesting that Huang’s brazen behavior was common knowledge at Nvidia, even perhaps to the board. Suppressing such information might also constitute securities fraud. In addition, Reuters reported yesterday a third “intimate relationship” with yet another Nvidia employee, this one unnamed. It isn’t clear how many people knew about that.
Why was Huang allowed to misbehave for so long, and why did so many people risk legal reprisals to protect him? Board members fearing a drop in the company’s stock price is only part of the story. Nvidia’s governance structure is a nightmare. Until Thursday, the company never had a board chair. Huang made sure there was no succession plan, and three years ago Huang said he expected to run Nvidia three or four more decades, by which time he would be aged 90 or 100. More than 60 Nvidia employees reported directly to Huang, and last year Huang claimed, “I probably read several thousand emails a day.” If you go to Nvidia’s website and click on “management team,” you’re shown a grand total of four company officers, one of whom, Colette Kress, was just named interim chief executive. What until recently was the world’s wealthiest company was managed like the corner drug store.
The financial world rushed to defend Huang after he admitted his affair with Alice. “I believe Jensen is irreplaceable for America’s AI leadership,” Shaun Maguire, a venture capitalist at Sequoia Capital, posted on X on November 8. “We should all support him and his family,” Bill Ackman posted. Ackman later added, “If indeed this is more than an affair, then it is an [sic] obviously a real problem,” failing to grasp than even without the espionage angle Huang’s affair with a leading Nvidia customer was a firing offense. Gavin Baker, managing partner of the investment firm Atreides Management, tweeted, “It would be a disaster for America—and a gift to China—if Jensen goes down.” After Huang resigned on Thursday, Musk tweeted that it “would be an honor” to hire him.
If nothing else, Huang’s resignation should serve to educate Wall Street that the planet doesn’t explode when the chief executive of a company valued at more than $5 trillion is forced to resign. But Huang is not the only chief executive to assume excessive control over a corporation by selling his board on his infallibility.
Mark Zuckerberg, as I explained last month, turned California’s billionaire wealth-tax ballot initiative, which failed last week, into an opportunity to extort a raise from his board. The raise was not an increase in compensation per se but rather an increase in liquidity; Meta created a new class of non-voting stock that had the effect of maintaining Zuckerberg’s control of 61 percent of all voting shares even if he were required to pay the state of California 5 percent of his net worth, which he won’t be. Zuckerberg persuaded the board not to condition this change on Proposition 40’s passage, which already seemed a pretty bad bet when Zuckerberg cut the deal. The arrangement had the effect of diluting Meta’s accountability to shareholders who weren’t Mark Zuckerberg.
Zuckerberg got what he wanted by threatening to move out of the state to avoid the tax. This was a transparently nonnsensical scenario because the wealth tax was structured in such a way that it was already too late for Zuckerberg to avoid it. But the threat so jangled Meta’s board that it gave away the store. Never mind that Zuckerberg’s stewardship of Meta in recent years has been less than stellar; his infatuation with the virtual-reality “metaverse” cost his company $85 billion.
Elon Musk famously extracted a $139 billion pay package from Tesla’s board outrageous enough to prompt a Delaware judge to throw it out on the grounds that it didn’t represent a good-faith negotiation, largely because Musk packed the board with personal friends. The ruling was overturned in December 2025. By then it was evident that Musk’s participation in DOGE had damaged Tesla sales. Tesla’s board nonetheless granted Musk that year another pay increase potentially valued at $1 trillion that could give him 25 percent voting control at the company. Musk had previously threatened to develop AI technology outside Tesla if he didn’t get it, which I find difficult to reconcile with a chief executive’s fiduciary duty to the company he runs.
“We live in the Age of the Imperial CEO,” The Wall Street Journal’s Tim Higgins wrote last month, citing Zuckerberg’s shakedown and Musk’s 85 percent voting control of yet another company, Space X. Higgins also cited the structure of Anthropic’s forthcoming IPO, which gives founders Dario and Daniela Amodei, along with five other investors, majority control so long as three of the seven remain. It’s a sort of tontine that could last for decades, provided AI doesn’t kill us all before then. (For an exegesis of the tontine I refer you to Robert Lewis Stevenson’s 1889 novel The Wrong Box and the hilarious 1966 movie that Bryan Forbes made from it with Peter Cook and Dudley Moore.)
Huang’s departure won’t likely destroy Nvidia because no matter who runs the company it still controls somewhere around 80 percent of its market. Even if Huang is a genius, it would take someone at least as dumb as Huang is smart to run this company into the ground. One hopes the lesson will be that it’s a very big mistake for corporate boards to yield so much power to chief executives. But don’t count on them noticing.
A Mediocre, Miserable Man
In the course in international relations I took with him as a Harvard undergraduate in the early 1960s, when he was still a mere professor of government, Henry Kissinger had certain personal observations that he would frequently reiterate, a main one of which was, “In retrospect, everything looks inevitable.” President Donald Trump, halfway through his second term in office, suddenly—and, I would guess, to a certain extent unexpectedly, to him—finds his political power severely circumscribed. Was this midterm election outcome, more extreme in its repudiation of his government than virtually anyone anticipated, foreordained by Trump’s egomaniacal approach to business, politics, and other people in general?
An argument could be made that the undoing of his presidency was bound to happen. Another concept I picked up in my undergraduate studies was that of “omnipotence of thought.” This is the conviction that one’s thoughts or beliefs can not only influence the external world but control it. Trump came into the business world and later political office with a set of misguided and inflexible beliefs and habits, instilled in him first by a stern and un-loving father, which were extended and fortified by the man who became not only his attorney but his political mentor, the notoriously ruthless and unprincipled Roy Cohn, chief counsel to Senator Joseph McCarthy’s communist witch-hunt hearings in the 1950s. In the three books that his niece, Mary L. Trump, has written about him, she has made clear that her uncle was raised by a cold, ruthless, mercenary father and a largely absent and sickly mother. The lack of love in the household, to Mary, is the most telling aspect of Donald’s upbringing. The film The Apprentice (2024), which highlights Cohn’s mentorship of him, makes clear the essence of Cohn’s tutelage of Donald: No matter what, no matter how wrong you might be or turn out to be about a given matter or issue, you must never bend, never give up your adherence to a position, no matter how misguided it might turn out to be. And incidentally, the film also highlights the instance in which “The Donald,” as his first wife, Ivana, called him, allegedly raped her as she was spurning his unwanted conjugal advances.
It should come as no surprise, therefore, that Trump would stake out positions that are autarkic in nature, for himself as an individual as well as for the country. Autarky is a state of self-sufficiency and self-absorption that is as complete as possible. Trump does not brook advice from other people as to what he should or should not do in a given circumstance. Therefore, in his first term as president, when anyone in the government or the White House of high caliber—say, for instance, his first chief of staff, retired Marine General John Kelly—tried to offer advice contrary to his own inclination, he would chafe against it in annoyance. In his second term, he stacked his Cabinet with pliant, mediocre individuals who would never dare challenge his inclinations, no matter how wayward or bizarre they might be. Over his entire adult life, he had nurtured the notion that tariffs were paid by businesses exporting goods rather than by the consumers in importing countries purchasing them, a delusion I ascribe to a belief instilled in him early on that other people are invariably out to undermine or savage you. Having managed to kidnap the president of Venezuela, which has an estimated population of 28.6 million and no more than 150,000 military personnel, he then fantasized that he could similarly subdue the vastly larger nation of Iran, with its estimated population of 93.4 million and approximately 610,000 military personnel, including its notoriously brutal Revolutionary Guard. In this latter case, U.S. bombardment killed the nation’s supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, and subsequent strikes did away with many of the country’s top leaders, including, it is believed, many of the identified moderate leaders, those who U.S. analysts believed would have been open to striking a reasonable deal with the United States over the issue of nuclear weapons.
But now let’s look at the positive side of Trump—and yes, there is perhaps a positive side to focus on. During his 2024 campaign, this magazine ran a picture of him with a faint mustache and short haircut that suggested he might be an American Hitler. We were far from alone in making such a comparison. But as it has turned out, he was not such. He is a tyrant, no doubt, but one whose nefarious program has been to attenuate America’s most commendable aspects without turning the country upside down and destroying it. He did not cancel the 2026 political elections, or make any serious moves to undermine them, much to the surprise of many. His reaction to the election results, so far, has been muted, and it appears that he may content himself with pursuing his various construction projects during the rest of his second term. Which is not to say that he won’t get up to some forms of mischief. His top priority, clearly—and one doomed to failure—is and has been trying to turn the United States back into an overwhelmingly white country; hence his attacks on all programs involving affirmative action and his relentless efforts to deport as many noncitizen residents of color in the country as possible as rapidly as possible (which may well amp up with Stephen Miller now elevated to chief of staff).
Beyond that, I think he aspires to reduce every aspect of excellence in the country to a level of mediocrity, which is to say, down to his very own level. And at this, I confidently predict, he will woefully fail, as he has failed so often at his major endeavors throughout his miserable life.
The Democrats’ First Move After Their Big Win? A Giveaway to Big Oil.
Last week, Democrats won historic majorities in the House and Senate, receiving an extraordinary mandate to take on the bad actors they campaigned against: President Donald Trump, the Republican Party, data centers, and Big Tech. This week, in their first major action since then, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer and 21 other Democratic senators voted to fast-track a Republican bill that would eviscerate America’s bedrock environmental laws in order to, in Trump’s words, “codify our America First Energy Agenda” of building “Pipelines, Mines, and Power Plants faster than ever before” so that America remains “Number One” in data center construction.
So what can explain this almost unimaginable betrayal—and can it be stopped?
The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, or BAAJA, which the Senate is expected to vote on next week, has been framed as a compromise to make it easier to build both clean energy and fossil fuel infrastructure. It was developed behind closed doors by Senate Republicans and two Democrats, Sheldon Whitehouse and Martin Heinrich. But there was a fundamental mismatch in this secretive drafting process. The fossil fuel industry has been all in for permitting reform—indeed, it has long been the top priority of the American Petroleum Institute, the lobbying arm and political face of major oil and gas corporations. So Big Oil was involved in BAAJA’s drafting.
Whitehouse and Heinrich, by contrast, kept Democrats’ traditional allies in the dark—not just environmental groups, which are uniformly opposed to the legislation, but tribal organizations (many of which released a joint statement condemning BAAJA provisions that “fundamentally undermine Tribal sovereignty” and “threaten sacred sites and cultural resources”); racial justice organizations like NAACP (which warned that BAAJA “directly threatens the health, safety, and future of Black and frontline communities”); and anti-ICE groups like Detention Watch Network (which condemned how BAAJA will “pave a path for detention expansion by making immigration detention facilities easier to build and much harder to stop”).
The upshot is that the staff of two Democratic senatorial offices were alone at the negotiating table, while Republicans had the full lobbying, analyzing, and bill-drafting capacity of the entire fossil fuel industry. So of course the Democrats got rolled. And BAAJA reflects this asymmetry in the severe lopsidedness of its ostensible “compromise.”
The positive pitch from BAAJA’s Democratic-leaning cheerleaders, like Democratic strategist Adam Jentleson’s Searchlight Institute, is that the legislation will be a huge boon to Democrats’ affordability and climate goals by lowering energy costs and supercharging the build-out of renewables. These claims are dubious at best. It’s essentially impossible to confidently model the full climate effects of a legislative package like BAAJA, but current analyses include predictions out of Purdue University that BAAJA will actually increase both “domestic energy-related greenhouse gas emissions” and “domestic mortality attributable to air pollution from fossil fuels.” The most optimistic modeling, from Rhodium Group, predicts a range: from BAAJA having zero effect on greenhouse gas emissions to a best-case scenario of reducing U.S. emissions by a negligible 4 percent by 2040. Rhodium’s modeling on affordability is similarly laughable, with a best-case scenario reduction of energy bills by $4–$7 a month by 2040.
So that’s what Democrats stand to gain from supporting this Republican bill. What are they giving up? From an environmental perspective, the costs are almost unimaginable. BAAJA severely weakens the Clean Water Act, robbing states and tribes of their ability to protect water quality and require adequate safeguards for activities that pollute or destroy water resources. It practically nullifies the Endangered Species Act by delegating its core responsibilities to the states, most of which either oppose the act’s wildlife protections or lack the expertise and resources to adequately fulfill these obligations. And it essentially repeals the National Environmental Policy Act, the bedrock environmental law that gives the public a voice in decisions that impact the environment, by prohibiting the enforcement of NEPA violations. These three legal frameworks are responsible for most the improvements in water quality, green space, and wildlife recovery in our country over the last half-century.
And that’s just the beginning. Other provisions of BAAJA go to even greater lengths to radically lock in fossil fuel development far into the future. The “disparate treatment” section of the bill effectively makes the permitting decisions of the Trump administration permanent. In the words of David Bookbinder, an environmental lawyer who has worked for both the left-leaning Sierra Club and the libertarian Niskanen Center, “The result of making these energy permitting policies permanent is that future administrations will be unable to effectively reduce GHG emissions.” BAAJA also guarantees not just the construction of fossil fuel projects but also their “operation at full capacity,” permanently blocking any future administration from regulating energy infrastructure.
If you’re thinking this legislative assault on the environment sounds like it was pulled straight out of Project 2025, well, you’re right—and the authors of Project 2025 are strong supporters of the bill. BAAJA is also the top legislative priority of API, ExxonMobil, Chevron, Shell, BP, ConocoPhillips, and other fossil fuel giants. So no wonder climate advocates have been sounding the alarm—and not just progressive leaders like Bill McKibben, but moderate climate advocates like Jody Freeman, John Podesta, and Al Gore, who recently warned that “now is not the time to give the Trump administration freer rein to double down on fossil fuels—which is what President Trump would surely do.” This point is crucial: Trump will be implementing BAAJA if it passes, and he very clearly has no intention of allowing the “supercharge clean energy” side of the bargain to move forward. Indeed, just this week Trump reiterated that he is not going to approve any wind turbines, even if Democrats submit to his desire to “codify our America First Energy Agenda” by passing BAAJA.
Of course, Big Oil companies aren’t the only villains that want to see this Republican legislation pass. Big Tech is also all in, from Marc Andreessen’s tech venture firm to ITI, the trade association for OpenAI, Nvidia, Meta, Amazon, Google, and other tech giants, which praised BAAJA as “essential to America’s ability to build, compete, and lead—especially in the AI era.” Advocates of BAAJA, including Trump, have tried to obscure this support by pointing to provisions in the legislation that would require data center developers to pay for the grid and transmission upgrades their projects require. But Americans have made overwhelmingly clear—not least through the massive victories they just handed to Democrats who pledged to support data center bans and moratoriums—that they don’t just want AI data centers to help pay for some of their own costs. More than anything, they want the ability to say “no” to these monstrosities coming into their communities. They want to be able to decide their own futures, rather than having Big Tech billionaires make those decisions for them.
BAAJA is a direct response to this democratic backlash. AI corporations want to cut the public out of these decision-making processes, and BAAJA is laser-focused on overcoming the two most important roadblocks the public can use to check the explosion of Big Tech’s data center build-out: permitting and easy access to fossil gas. (Abigail Dillen, the president of Earthjustice, recently explained exactly how BAAJA enables “the dirtiest version of the data center build-out to move even faster.”)
The antidemocratic betrayal here really cannot be overstated. Democrats just won their biggest congressional majorities in 50 years—to say nothing of victories in places like Texas, where Democrats swept every single statewide office and flipped the state House—in large part by promising to respond to the massive voter backlash against the AI industry’s out-of-control expansion of hyperscale data centers. Just a week later, Democrats’ Senate leadership team—not just Schumer but incoming Majority Whip Brian Schatz and DSCC chair Kirsten Gillibrand—joined Trump and the GOP to pass a catastrophic giveaway to the Big Tech billionaires who spent hundreds of millions of dollars trying to defeat their incoming colleagues, directly rebuking the massive voter mandate their party just received to stand up to those billionaires.
And that, maybe more than anything, helps explain the timing of this push. It’s not just that BAAJA was developed without hearings or any of the other review procedures that a bill of this magnitude would normally go through. It’s that Democrats like Whitehouse, Heinrich, Schumer, and Schatz are trying to ram this Project 2025 atrocity through a GOP-controlled lame-duck session weeks before Democrats take control. BAAJA advocates have argued that the legislation needs to move now because Trump would never sign a bill passed by a Democratic Congress, but that’s an absurd claim. We have no idea how Trump will respond to the Democratic majority. There are myriad ways he could be brought to the table on a clean transmission bill—name the legislation after him, insert some shady Trump Organization business opportunity in the text, send in Zohran Mamdani to sell it ...
The reason top Senate Democrats are working to pass BAAJA now, before their majority is seated, is that this rotten handout to Big Oil and Big Tech—and massive “screw you” to the voters who just gave Democrats their majority—would never pass in a Democratic Congress. BAAJA is a radical MAGA bill that takes a sledgehammer to America’s most important environmental laws, permanently locks us into an expansion of fossil fuels, disempowers local communities’ ability to decide their own futures, and opens the door to a radical expansion of methane-powered hyperscale data centers. It needs to pass now because it is fundamentally a Republican bill.
BAAJA is on a fast track through the Senate, with a final vote only days away. But we must not accept this as a done deal. The Congressional Progressive Caucus, which represents more than 100 members of Congress, just announced its opposition to the legislation. So did the Democratic attorneys general from California, Colorado, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New York, Oregon, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, and Washington, D.C., who sent a letter asking Senate leadership to halt the upcoming votes on BAAJA in order to “protect our natural resources, historic and tribal sites, and state regulatory prerogatives.” And it’s not just elected officials who can weigh in. Everyone can make a difference by calling and emailing their representatives and senators and looking out for further mobilization opportunities. If all else fails, at the very least, we must make sure that Democrats understand that their voters are paying attention to who is selling out our futures to Big Oil and Big Tech—and that 2028 is not so far away.
These part-time professors make big money teaching dozens of classes online. Are their students learning?
This story was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for its newsletters.
As online classes proliferate, community college professors have found a hack — repackaging similar courses for hundreds of students at a time and teaching more than a dozen classes in a single semester.
Professor Thien-Huong Ninh Villarreal has at least two tenured, full-time community college jobs, plus recurring part-time gigs over the past 12 months at UC Berkeley, Cal State Sacramento, and seven other community colleges. This fall, she’s teaching 30 sociology, ethnic studies and business classes to about 1,100 students.
In 2024, with roughly the same courseload, she made nearly $800,000, according to public payroll records. CalMatters reached out to her three times for comment, but she never responded.
Community college professors are expected to evaluate student progress and provide direct support without the help of teaching assistants, though that’s nearly impossible at such a scale, said Sarah Thompson, president of the Faculty Association of California Community Colleges. “Obviously no one has enough time in a week to teach 30 classes and do a good job, so that’s very problematic.”
However Chris Ferguson, an executive vice chancellor at the office overseeing California’s community colleges, said having multiple teaching jobs is not, by itself, evidence of poor instruction. In an emailed statement to CalMatters, Ferguson, who leads finance and strategic initiatives for the office, said multiple jobs would be a problem if the “faculty member’s workload is preventing the required level of engagement, feedback, assessment, or student support.” In that case, he said the college district — not the statewide college system — should be accountable.
CalMatters analyzed public payroll records from the non-profit Transparent California and corroborated those records with college course data. The analysis found at least 70 adjuncts, or part-time professors, who were paid by five or more community college districts, California State University or University of California campuses in the same year, including many who taught more than 10 classes in a semester.
Some of these professors were among the highest paid employees across California’s 116 community colleges. Ninh Villarreal made more than every community college administrator in 2024, even more than Sonya Christian, the chancellor of the state’s community college system, according to CalMatters’ analysis.
Most of the 70-plus professors did not respond to multiple requests for comment. Others asked CalMatters not to publish the data, which is publicly available, for fear of how it might affect their employment.
These professors aren’t breaking any rules. In fact, there are no rules that prevent community college adjuncts from teaching at more than one district.
Andrew Vanden Heuvel, an adjunct astronomy professor, told CalMatters he teaches roughly 50 online classes and labs from the office above his garage in a small town on the shore of Lake Michigan.
Almost all of his lectures are pre-recorded, and students can listen at any time. It’s called asynchronous instruction. At the UC, Cal State and especially at the state’s community colleges, these kinds of online classes are popular and widespread, a major shift since the COVID-19 pandemic.
Vanden Heuvel said he has taught as many as 1,000 students a semester across the country, including in Santa Monica, Salinas, San Jose and Visalia, plus schools in New Mexico, Michigan, Washington and Florida. He said the classes use different iterations of the same, largely introductory content about stars, galaxies and the solar system. Students read information online, interact with online astronomical simulations, watch videos or submit labs.
“In its current form, I am not grading anything (by hand),” said Vanden Heuvel. All quizzes are multiple choice and computer-graded — a common feature among many online classes, not just Vanden Heuvel’s. Some students also submit written assignments, which he said he usually grades using an algorithm that only checks whether the work was submitted or not.
About 20% of his course load is in California, he said. “In California, I can get paid as much as eight times as much as I can in Florida.” In 2024, California schools paid him a total of about $320,000, according to the CalMatters analysis. Nationally, he made much more, he said. “Looking over my records, I can tell you that 2024 was the high water mark.” He said he made $758,485.12 that year.
Full-time professors cash inBy law, adjunct faculty are generally limited to teaching three classes per semester at a single community college district, with each district setting its own rules. Most part-time jobs are precarious, with no healthcare, no guarantee of employment and all work assigned on a contract basis. Colleges can strip adjuncts of their classes — and their wages — with little notice.
For union and faculty leaders, who have long said adjuncts are underpaid and overworked, the workload of professors like Ninh Villarreal and Vanden Heuvel comes as a shock. “I don’t know how you can earn that much money, how you can have that many assignments. I mean that’s pretty wild,” said Jim Mahler, the president of the community college council for the California Federation of Teachers. He said he suspects some professors are simply recording their lectures and “just hitting play.”
Students on their laptops in the quad area at Fresno City College. Credit: Larry Valenzuela / CalMatters/CatchLight Local
To make more than $400,000, many of California’s highest earning adjuncts had full-time tenure or tenure-track positions too, the records show. For example:
- Bobby Seals, an ethnic studies professor, has a full-time position at Evergreen Valley College in San Jose. He also teaches 14 more courses across four other community college districts, plus San Jose State — a total of about 930 students this semester.
- Faramarz Mortezaie is the chair of the computer science department at Mission College in Santa Clara. Part time, he also teaches 11 classes at other campuses, including San Jose State.
- Nicholas Nardi, a full-time psychology professor at Santa Ana College, is teaching 11 more classes at six other schools, including Cal State Los Angeles.
- Timothy Durfield, a full-time business professor at Citrus College, teaches an additional 10 classes at four other community college districts.
- Walter Meyer, a full-time art history professor at Santa Monica College, teaches 10 additional online classes to students in Los Angeles and Kern counties.
None of these professors responded to requests for comment.
Ninh Villarreal, the top earner, has often had at least two full-time jobs, according to college officials and public records. She’s been a tenured professor at Cosumnes River College in Sacramento since 2016. In 2023, she got a second full-time job at Reedley College near Fresno, though she returned to part-time status less than a year later. In 2025, she got tenure at San Joaquin Delta College in Stockton, and the same year, official college documents show she was the inaugural tenure-track faculty in the ethnic studies department at West Valley College in Saratoga, near San Jose. Cade Story-Yetto, a spokesperson for the district encompassing West Valley College, said Ninh Villarreal is no longer employed there and refused to answer other questions.
CalMatters reached out to nearly every one of the state’s 73 community college districts, seeking feedback on our methodology before publication. Transparent California, part of a nonpartisan think tank advocating for limited government, obtained payroll information directly from the college districts. CalMatters then used that data to compile a list of professors who taught at five or more community college districts, Cal State or UC campuses in 2024, which is the most recent data. The data was corroborated using course catalogs, faculty directories and college hiring documents.
While some of the professors taught a few in-person classes, usually at Cal State or UC campuses, CalMatters’ analysis found that many of those who taught at five or more college districts relied heavily on online, asynchronous instruction.
No one is tracking itUniversities treat online courses the same as in-person classes: students get the same amount of credit, and teachers are generally paid the same amount. As online courses have become more common, the UC, Cal State and community college systems have spent millions in state funding to ensure they have the same rigor as in-person courses.
Community colleges evaluate the quality of all courses, but they have no way of knowing what a professor’s workload really is. California’s community college districts are independently governed, and no one tracks who teaches across districts or how many classes they teach.
The Cal State and UC systems, which are smaller and more centralized than the community colleges, track employment and limit the number of courses each professor can teach. If the instructor is also teaching at a community college, however, they may have no way of knowing.
Vanden Heuvel, the astronomy professor, said he believes his students are getting an excellent education. “I teach at a certain number of schools because that portfolio gives me the stability I need as an adjunct to survive and thrive,” he said, pointing to his three kids, his wife, who is an elementary school teacher, and the need to be present with his family instead of driving from campus to campus each day. “Now, did I push it further than some people think is morally conscionable? I don’t think so.”
Researchers say it’s not clear whether online courses are worse, or better, than traditional in-person education. Students, especially working adults who predominate the community college system, praise online courses for their convenience, but there are known drawbacks. Asynchronous classes in particular have historically offered students less interaction with their professors, which research has found is detrimental to student success.
Students work in the library at San Bernardino Valley College. Credit: Lauren Justice for CalMatters
How to teach 50 classes in a semester
Vanden Heuvel posts much of his course material on YouTube, where his channels collectively have nearly 5 million views, spread out over more than 300 videos. In his videos, he’s charismatic and personable, taking students into his car, even posting videos while on vacation at Disney World. His location isn’t a secret, he said — he has always been open about where he lives, both with California’s colleges and his students.
In fact, the first lesson in one of his classes is a video in which he introduces himself and takes students to his favorite place, Lake Michigan, where he first developed a love of astronomy.
State and federal laws require professors to interact with their students, especially in asynchronous online courses. Interaction could include fostering engagement in the classroom or monitoring students’ academic performance, wrote Ferguson, the finance vice chancellor, in his emailed statement. “These requirements apply to every course, regardless of how many colleges or districts employ the instructor.” The federal government has strengthened its own rules for online classes over the past few years.
Vanden Heuvel said he gives out his personal cell phone to all students and gets as many as 30 emails a day from them, mostly asking to extend assignment deadlines. He said he answers every email.
It would be very easy for students to cheat using AI, he said, especially because quizzes are multiple choice and most written assignments are graded only on completion. “The logic is the equivalent of the Scantron [a multiple-choice grading machine] at the large lecture hall. It’s a defensible instructional practice to assess that way. It’s how lots of assessments are run, be that the GRE or LSAT. I don’t love it.”
The promise of online education is to reach students at scale and lower the cost-per-student of education, he said — and that’s exactly what he’s doing by teaching 50 online classes and labs to as many as 1,000 students across the country. In some schools, especially in rural areas, Vanden Heuvel is the only astronomy professor.
He said his large-scale teaching practices represent his “most successful” experiment, though he acknowledged that many faculty won’t look so favorably upon it.
‘I’m not a factory of education like that’Part-time faculty, who are cheaper to employ, outnumber tenure-track professors at every one of California’s 73 community college districts, in some cases by more than 5-1. The same imbalance is evident at many Cal State campuses, though their adjuncts, known as lecturers, can work full time and receive benefits. The UC, with a focus on research, has faculty categories that don’t exist at the Cal State or community college system, making comparisons tricky.
It’s well-known that adjuncts teach at multiple districts, but unions often say that they do it out of necessity. Tina Leonard, who teaches American Sign Language, is a perfect example. In 2024, she made just over $84,000 teaching at five community college districts.
“I am Deaf,” she wrote in an email, “and it is very difficult and competitive for a Deaf educator to get a full-time tenure-track position in ASL.” She said she took additional teaching jobs in 2024 to cover the cost of her taxes. “Each college withholds as if it is your only job, so when you add them all together, you can end up owing.”
K. Frindell, the president of a federation of faculty unions, the California Community College Independents, said she wasn’t surprised to see many faculty teaching in multiple districts, even some who are earning hundreds of thousands of dollars. “A loophole has been created,” she said — one that allows districts to cut costs by hiring adjuncts and allows adjuncts to teach at multiple districts.
In fact, the total number of community college adjuncts in California is unknown because statewide tallies do not account for professors who teach at multiple districts, said Ferguson. The Cal State system has the same data problem.
Adjuncts are often hired for the academic year and then rehired each fall. Numerous legislative proposals have tried but failed to give adjuncts opportunities for additional pay, benefits or full-time employment. In 2022, legislators tried to increase benefits for community college adjuncts, sending $200 million to districts that would then reimburse part-time faculty for health insurance. In the 2024-25 academic year, nearly 7,000 adjuncts used the program, very few of whom were teaching at multiple districts. Many districts chose not to participate, and most of the money remains unspent.
Noah Thomas, a professor in the art department at Long Beach City College, on campus in Long Beach. Credit: Ariana Drehsler for CalMatters
Noah Thomas, a community college art professor, said he looked into the new healthcare benefits but found them lacking. “It’s such a convoluted system and the subsidies are kind of pretty low,” he said. “The coverage only applies to me and not to any of my dependents and it’s only for 10 months out of the year because my contract is only 10 months.”
Thomas made just over $100,000 in 2024 by commuting among five community college districts in Orange and Los Angeles counties, where he taught in-person studio arts classes. Sometimes, the drives are so long, and the days so jam-packed that he eats lunch in his car, he said. “Financially I’d love to teach as many classes as I could. $800,000 sounds amazing. But I’m not a factory of education like that. I really love teaching students one-on-one and showing them how to actually cut out a piece of cardboard and use a band saw.”
The moral dilemmaFrindell, who represents the independent community college unions, said the solution is not to focus on the professors who teach multiple online classes and earn high six-figure salaries. She wants to see an end to the low pay, precarious employment, and restrictive laws that force adjuncts to teach at multiple districts in the first place.
CalMatters asked higher education leaders in the state Assembly and Senate about adjuncts who are teaching at multiple schools. Alhambra Democratic Assemblymember Mike Fong, San Diego Republican Assemblymember Carl DeMaio and Riverside Democratic Sen. Sabrina Cervantes did not respond.
Because of state and federal rules that require professors to engage with their students, Vanden Heuvel redesigned some of his courses, adding new types of assignments. At times, he said the rules seem like they were “invented to prevent people from doing what I’m doing,” though he added that they are often ineffective if so. “What it feels like in practice is an administrative checked box that is not really connected to meaningful student experience.”
Still, he said he has sought reassurance from other educators about the moral implications of teaching so many students in so many classes, even if legally he is within bounds. “What they say to me, whether they’re just being nice or not, is this sense that adjunct faculty are systematically taken advantage of by higher education, and if you have built a system that allows you to thrive while still providing excellent education, then more power to you.”
At the end of each semester, Vanden Heuvel said he asks his students to evaluate the course and that they consistently say it’s far above average in quality and knowledge gained and about average in difficulty. “There’s always the sense of like, ‘Is what I’m doing OK or not OK? Am I pushing it a little too far or not?’”
He self-published a 600-page book that collects student reflections, mostly about how their relationship with planets, stars and galaxies changed because of his class. He said the book sits in his office, right near his desk.
Have something to say? Lookout welcomes letters to the editor, within our policies, from readers. Guidelines here.
The post These part-time professors make big money teaching dozens of classes online. Are their students learning? appeared first on Lookout Santa Cruz.
Transcript: Trump Shivs Vance as Election Meltdown Takes Unhinged Turn
The following is a lightly edited transcript of the November 13 episode of The Daily Blast podcast. Listen to it here.
Greg Sargent: This is The Daily Blast from The New Republic, produced and presented by the DSR Network. I’m your host, Greg Sargent.
Donald Trump unraveled in a series of crazed Truth Social posts on Thursday, and one thing stood out. Trump instructed JD Vance to stop seeking a deal with Iran, instead telling him to focus on investigating alleged corruption in blue states. This really shivs Vance. It also illustrates that Trump and MAGA will never come to terms with why they just suffered the massive electoral rebuke they did, which Vance badly needs them to. And all of this creates major openings for Democrats and liberals to make a new kind of case to voters.
We’re talking about all of it with Zack Beauchamp, who has a great new newsletter called Public Reason that’s all about how to restate the liberal case after these Democratic victories. Zack, thanks for coming on.
Zack Beauchamp: Hey, happy to be here, Greg. It’s always fun, especially after a big launch like this.
Sargent: Congrats on the launch, Zack. So Trump erupted on social media, declaring that he’s asked JD Vance to focus entirely on largely invented blue-state “CORRUPTION.” He said this: “Corruption is in the Democrat leadership’s blood. We don’t need a deal with Iran. Those days have long since passed. We’ve got their money, hundreds of billions of dollars, and we’ve got their strait.”
Zack, none of this is real. Iran remains a total catastrophe for us. But note how Trump won’t allow Vance, who’s eyeing a 2028 run, to become the guy who fixes Trump’s Iran fiasco. It’s telling, isn’t it?
Beauchamp: Yeah, look, I want to say two things. First, I love how your intonation changes when you’re reading a Trump quote. Like, it sounds like Trump when you’re talking, right?
Sargent: Thank you.
Beauchamp: See the hands moving back and forth. Second, obviously a lot of what you quoted is nonsense blather, right? It’s like the president just saying what he feels like he needs to say to make it sound like he’s succeeding in Iran.
The Vance stuff, that’s real, and it’s fascinating. Because if you read the post very carefully, when Trump says he’s moving Vance off of the Iran portfolio—he doesn’t quite say that.
But what he does say is we don’t need to make a deal with Iran, and JD, I’m moving you full time to be focusing on fraud at home. That is essentially saying you’re off the case.
Which, in light of Vance’s comments right after the election, right, where he said basically the election was lost because of Iran—it’s clear to me, anyway, from the totality of this messaging, that Vance is being punished for the way that he talked about Iran after the election, blaming the entire election on Iran, and for stepping out from the company and party line on what you’re supposed to say about Iran, and basically blaming Trump for the election loss.
Sargent: That’s really fascinating. I agree that it really, really puts Vance in a box as a kind of punishment. It’s like a penalty box or something.
So Trump also angrily reopened his threat to prosecute Democratic members of Congress. He also raged that the GOP’s failure to pass the so-called Save America Act was “devastating” to Republicans in the midterms.
Zack, Trump suffers the biggest GOP defeat in a half-century, and his answer is to threaten to ramp up the authoritarian lawlessness and the voter suppression. What do you make of that?
Beauchamp: I mean, a leopard can’t change its spots, right? It’s like Trump has one playbook. It’s not that this electoral defeat happened by accident, right? It happened largely, but not entirely, because of Iran. Largely, but not entirely, because of tariffs. And largely, but not entirely, because of Trump’s immigration policy, and specifically the crackdown in Minneapolis, that seems to have been incredibly self-defeating.
But it’s all of those things. And it’s all the other things, too. It’s the constant chaos of the administration. It’s the way in which he betrayed elements of his base on Epstein. It’s who he is, right, as a person. It is his character asserting itself in office.
And what he’s done—I wrote about this actually in the first piece for Public Reason—is removed all the guardrails that prevent policymaking from being checked by anyone other than the president. That was, like, the number one authoritarian priority early in the administration. And what it’s meant is that there’s no transmission layer blocking Trump’s impulses from turning into policy.
And it means that just, like, the craziest things that he thinks and feels and that he believes as a person, the most aggressive things that he thinks, they just go straight into action a lot of the time. And so he just does what he’s going to do. And I don’t think he’s capable of rethinking premises at a deep and fundamental level. It’s just not who he is.
Sargent: Well, all this seems symptomatic of a broader problem gripping MAGA right now. You had a very good piece on this for your newsletter—folks, check it out, it’s called Public Reason, it’s very good. MAGA thinkers are saying, essentially, that the real MAGA agenda has been failed by poor execution.
The war was handled incompetently, the tariffs were poorly done, Trump failed to communicate effectively about the reasons for the ICE invasions of Minneapolis and other places. That’s their emerging argument. You wrote very well on this. Can you talk about it?
Beauchamp: Yeah. The thing that’s interesting about this line that is emerging for Trump’s empathetic right is that they’re framing what happened as, like, a combination of a stabbed-in-the-back narrative and a real-Trumpism-has-never-been-tried. It’s, like, kind of both of those blended together, right?
The argument is that Trump did a really bad job implementing the things they care about. And in addition to that, he then betrayed one of the core MAGA principles, which was no new wars. Allegedly—I’ll come back to the allegedly, right?
But that was, in these commentators’ views—and in some ways this is implicit, I think, very clearly, in the way that Vance wrote about the election afterwards—that they think that they’ve strayed from what Trump won on in 2024.
But the problem here is that there’s, like, a fundamental misconstrual of what Trump and Trumpism was, what his supporters want from them, and what the ideology they were standing for was.
There just wasn’t really any kind of principled no-new-wars plank in MAGA ideology, for the simple reason that Trump has been a hawk for his entire life. Trumpism is just Trump. It’s not something separate. There’s no MAGA set of principles you can appeal to, to say Trump has gone wrong.
And so the right now is in this predicament where the one stable thing that sort of determined what it was about, and that papered over these deep divisions in the conservative coalition—Trump himself—is now obviously weakened and on the outs.
And so these people are trying to set up a narrative in which they’re the true heirs of the movement that brought Trump to power. But it’s not at all obvious that they’re going to be able to win that. And I think Vance personally will lose it, for the simple fact that, as Kamala Harris showed us, it’s very difficult to run against an administration when you were part of it.
Sargent: Right. And I think this idea that MAGA was betrayed, that true MAGA principles weren’t brought to fruition or whatever, and that’s the reason for the loss, also misses the immigration story in a big way. In other words, it misses what actually happened in this election with immigration. I think, by the way, a lot of liberals miss this as well.
The failure here isn’t just that Trump’s immigration agenda was unpopular. It’s that the underlying ideological goal of ethnically purging the country was also roundly rejected. And that’s core MAGA.
The exit polls showed a huge majority think immigrants are good for our country. People like James Talarico made an extremely powerful pro-immigrant argument. He won the debate on this issue in the polling with Ken Paxton.
Zack, I think liberals—and this connects to your new project—I think liberals were too quick to conclude that Trump’s 2024 win signaled a durable anti-immigrant shift in the country.
Now that we know this didn’t really happen, is there an opening for liberals to make a more robust case for immigration as a positive good, using the type of liberal language that you’re advocating be brought forth?
Beauchamp: Yes. Yes. I think, absolutely. I feel like it kind of sort of dovetails with trade. And people don’t always admit this, but what you’ll see is that Trump’s tariff policy has led to a total 180 in polls on how Americans view free trade.
Right now, Americans are free traders all of a sudden again. And it turns out that what people thought was this durable protectionist backlash in American politics was really just the fact that a bunch of people didn’t like the status quo, and they blamed free trade for some things that were happening in the status quo. Once they saw the alternative, they swung back.
And so there’s now a question of how to redefine not just, like, how you talk about it as a liberal and what your specific policy stance is, but the terms of the conversation. Like, for a long time, the background theory of American politics has been, American voters have turned against, quote-unquote, globalism, right?
They don’t like more people coming in here. They don’t like interfacing with other countries. And they want to shut the door in a variety of different ways. And I just don’t think that is true on a values level. I think that was a fundamental misread.
But there’s an opening now to give people a new set of concepts, right? To be able to say, well, actually, sure, I get it, you didn’t like the chaos in the Biden administration. And sure, I get it, there were problems with integrating China into the global trade order. But guess what? The United States benefits when we open the doors to cooperation with other countries.
We benefit, as we always have throughout our entire history, when we let in people who contribute to the United States, and keep our population growing, and keep our economy humming, and bring in new kinds of people with new ideas, who end up winning Nobel Prizes in the United States.
Like, this is the classic self-interested case for immigration, but it also is, at a deeper level, a liberal case. It’s an argument that openness is good for people. And I think you saw that a lot in—you pointed to Talarico. You saw it a lot in his campaign rhetoric.
Sargent: Very much so. And I think if you step back even a little bit more, you can sort of frame the whole thing this way. If you think about the three main pillars of MAGA, right—tariffs, mass deportations, America First foreign policy—those kind of make up, I think, basically the entirety of what was rejected in this election by a very, very broad majority of people.
And with the tariffs, I think it’s self-explanatory why Trump is kind of getting people to take another look at global trade as a positive for the country. The mass deportations are getting people to take another look at the fact that they like immigrants.
And America First, which you’ve been very eloquent on—I think you were ahead of the curve on this, in fact. America First is probably best understood not as isolationism, but more American unchecked militarism and utter contempt for international commitments and human rights norms and alliances.
That, I think, is what gives, you know, liberals an opening to restate the case for a more interconnected world, liberal international human rights norms, and so forth. Don’t you think there’s, like, a very big argument to be made right now?
Beauchamp: Yeah, yeah, there is. The way that I think about this is, after 2016, the United States entered a period of ideological rupture, where it’s clear that the old settlement that we had—which was, like, a competition between a sort of center-left Democratic Party and a center-right Republican Party that were both, I think, broadly and in their main contours, liberal politically—that was broken, right? That old consensus was broken. And there was a need for new ideological innovation.
And for a long time, part of the reason why the debate was happening on the terms that it was is that liberals felt very defensive and were having a lot of trouble coming up with new ideas to fill this vacuum. And the right felt not only emboldened by Trump, but also, I think, there was a lot of imagination, a lot of effort going into ideological reimagining on that side of the aisle.
And also, I would think, among a certain set of anti-liberal socialists. So that’s why liberalism has seemed so defensive, in large part. It was intellectually defensive and wasn’t coming up with these new ways of reacting to the collapse of the old liberal settlement.
And what you saw in this election—I don’t want to overread it, right, the same way that Trump people overread things in 2024 on their side. But I do think that the scale of this defeat—like, 2024 was a very narrow victory for Trump; 2026 is the biggest midterm landslide since Watergate, right?
It really is historic, and maybe we should start thinking about it in these historic terms. I think what it suggests is that people aren’t satisfied with the narrative that was on offer from the MAGA types as an explanation for what happened in the world and what it is now.
There’s a tremendous opportunity if someone like Talarico or Jon Ossoff, who I think maybe is the most plausible political actor to do this, can rebuild a new vocabulary for describing what it is people don’t like about the political status quo. Because they don’t like it.
Sargent: Right. And I think we really need to be clear that when people talk about this election as being about affordability, they’re hamstringing us from making this case. They’re hamstringing liberals from making this case.
What we need to be saying, I think, is that the core ideas of right-wing populist nationalism, right-wing authoritarian nationalism, have all kind of fallen apart, right? Tariffs, mass deportations, America First.
This wasn’t just a reaction to costs. The data is very clear that the public rejects the idea of imposing tariffs. The public is now much more pro-trade, as a positive good for the country. The data is also very clear that the public is rejecting the idea that the way to restore proper American identity, or a purified American identity, is to ethnically purge the country of non-white immigrants and their descendants.
And the data’s clear that nobody seems to really like the way Trump is treating our allies. And nobody seems to like Trump’s unilateral war in Iran. So America First, also rejected. The core pillars of right-wing populist nationalism have collapsed. I’d like to see that understood as the basis for our case going forward. Does that make sense?
Beauchamp: Yeah. I don’t want to dismiss the affordability point, because it is sort of objectively true, right, that the reason that voters voted against Trump is because of affordability.
But I think what you’re saying points to is that sometimes, in people’s minds, affordability was a proxy for some other concerns that they had. When they said things weren’t affordable, yeah, they blamed those policies for the fact that they had trouble affording things. And not unreasonably, by the way. The Iran war really did drive up gas prices. Tariffs really did make some things more expensive.
And the immigration, I think, is a kind of different case, because it also played out unevenly. Immigration wasn’t as important in, I don’t know, let’s say, the Michigan Senate race as it was in Texas, or in House races in Texas in particular, because the impact was uneven.
In some places, there was a real sense that the federal government was snatching their friends and neighbors. And that had this very concentrated effect. And you can see—if I have the data right in my head—you can see pretty clear shifts, disproportionate shifts, in high-immigrant, high-ICE-targeted communities, or areas that have large populations that might have been really punished by Trump. And so there’s a backlash. It’s just a different thing that wouldn’t show up in the same way in the aggregate national data.
And so, yes—like, this is a roundabout way, Greg, of saying, well, I have some issues with the way that you framed it and phrased it. Like, I agree with the underlying point 100 percent.
Sargent: And I want to return to something you said earlier, because I think it gets at the stakes of all this, right? Which is this idea that I think a lot of liberals have in their heads, that they have to tiptoe around Trumpian populism.
They have to sort of say to themselves, well, the reason Trump won in 2024 is voters decided that Trump was, in some sense, right about trade, about immigration, and about the liberal international order.
Now, I don’t want to dismiss entirely the idea that voters did think that there was something to Trump’s case. But a lot of liberals really overread that, especially after 2024. And we’ve got to stop doing that.
To get to the point where we correct our own ideology and make a good case for our own, right, we kind of have to be clear that we’re not afraid to say that right-wing populist nationalism has failed and is very unpopular. And then there’s a starting point there, I think. What do you think of that?
Beauchamp: Yeah. The way I conceptualize it is that the public hasn’t made up its mind on what it wants to be affirmatively, right? The American public doesn’t have a sense of what—maybe no public has an ideological sense, but the American public is unusually unsettled as to where it stands right now.
And so what it suggests to me is that they’re open to persuasion, because they’re not happy with the way things are going, and they haven’t seen anyone come up with a way to channel what they think is wrong with the status quo into a political agenda that seems to address their concerns.
I think one advantage Democrats have here, particularly, is that their agenda is not inherently inflationary. Whereas getting rid of immigrants, and, you know, putting big tariffs on other countries, and starting expensive foreign wars in the name of, like, seizing stuff for America—that makes things more expensive. That is just what it does. And there’s no way to avoid that with tariffs and immigration crackdowns.
Sargent: Yeah. In a sense, there’s a political economy of Trumpism. Like, I think we need to sort of rehabilitate the concept of political economy. And maybe this is the place to sort of end this. It connects everything together. This idea that the election was about affordability takes the political out of political economy, right?
And so people decided that trade is good, people decided that they like immigrants, people decided that they like our international alliances and human rights norms and so forth. Yes, as you pointed out, the starting point for that, or the entry point, the tip of that spear, was the high costs. But they connected those high costs to a set of values that they thought was off. And so liberals, I think, can now step forward and do what you’re calling for, which is kind of a refocusing on what worked for Democrats in this election, connecting liberalism to everyday politics by saying, these are the values that make an economy that will be fairer for all of us. Is that sort of where you want this to go?
Beauchamp: Yeah. My view of it is that there was, like, a baby step in the right direction when Democrats started picking up on some of the themes in abundance. I don’t think it’s the whole solution. But what that package did, like that sort of package of beliefs and ideas, is it said, hey, there’s this ambient concern people have about things not really working, and things being too expensive, and, you know, government not operating in the smooth way that corporations do sometimes when you interface with them. And those are, like, sort of everyday complaints people have about the state.
And being like, no, there’s a liberal way to think about these, to surface these problems and to bring them into the sort of ordinary political agenda, through very specific policies like permitting reform—that was an act of ideological innovation that seems to have actually worked pretty well in a lot of cases.
Like, I don’t think that swung the election for Democrats. I think it has led to some good policy changes in blue states particularly, that may end up helping build power long term, or, like, sustain a blue-state model.
And what you need to do is do that kind of work on a grander scale, right? Tell not just a story about, you know, fixing government and making more things. Tell a story about building a society that people want to live in, right? A society, not just an economy, right? A place in which we feel like we have purpose, meaning, connection, and value.
Sargent: In a way, the simplest way to put it might be that we need people to start really making the case for a liberal political economy. Zack Beauchamp, your website is really starting us off on this thing. Public Reason, it’s called. Check it out, folks. Zack, awesome to talk to you. Thanks so much for coming on.
Beauchamp: Hey, Greg, I’m always happy to be here. Public-reason.com. I just have to do that at the end of every episode. I was going to say my agent makes me do that, but that was for my book. I don’t have an agent. I just have me, for a Substack.
Sargent: Cool, man. Well, I’m glad you got it in. Zack, thanks for coming on, man.
Beauchamp: Thanks.
Brit police watchdog says cops' use of facial recog risks wrongful arrests
UK police forces must do more to prevent the wrongful arrests of people subjected to retrospective facial recognition (RFR) searches, according to a Criminal Justice Inspectorate that holds deep concerns about the way in which the technology is used.
According to a report from His Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services (HMICFRS), there is a large gap in understanding among police forces and the National Crime Agency about how RFR should be used in responsible policing.
The inspectorate blamed "fragmented and underdeveloped" frameworks for governance and legislation.
It pointed to a lack of bespoke legislation to provide a uniform approach to police facial recognition use – and said existing laws have not kept pace with the technology. HMICFRS also said the rules governing each force's use of RFR are mismatched, and called for a statutory code to be included in the forthcoming Police Reform Bill to set nationwide standards.
Illustrating the breadth of misunderstanding across forces, the report noted that despite the message being routinely communicated by National Police Chiefs' Council (NPCC) reps, individual investigators "often" thought RFR results constituted evidence rather than intelligence.
In many cases, they are unaware that RFR results require further enquiries before enforcement action can be taken.
"We found that some investigators didn't always carry out enough corroborative enquiries before acting on potential matches," the report stated. "In a small number of cases, officers relied too heavily on RFR results, which led to inappropriate investigative action.
"Although some forces had strengthened their processes after such incidents, practice remained inconsistent."
Later in the report, the inspectorate described the findings as "deeply concerning."
Some of the excuses police staff offered included acute demands on response teams leading to reduced opportunities to carry out further enquiries before acting on RFR matches. In one force, managers were known to encourage officers to "progress investigations quickly" after getting a match on the RFR system.
However, the inspectorate clarified that just because an arrest is made, it does not necessarily mean it is wrongful, as investigators may need to rule out subjects from their inquiries.
The onus for taking action should also be placed on the police forces themselves, given that some lack formal procedures regarding how RFR enquiries should be carried out, the report noted.
The best forces had centralized facial recognition teams, which generally provided better governance and consistent processes.
Officials fear long-term misuse of RFR, and other forms of facial recognition, will erode public trust in the technology, which it insists remains generally high.
Surveys carried out in 2025 by the likes of the Ada Lovelace Institute and Alan Turing Institute, as well as the King's College London Policy Institute, showed a generally favorable view of facial recognition use in UK policing, with support ranging from 91 percent and 53 percent respectively.
Home Office figures released on Thursday to complement the report show similar positivity toward the technology among police officers, with only 4 percent reporting a negative experience.
The Register's comments section often paints a vastly different picture of public perception of facial recognition.
Kathryn Stone, his majesty's inspector at HMICFRS, said facial recognition has transformed policing, allowing officers to compare images in seconds, allowing them to solve crimes more quickly, but echoed the report's main concerns.
"Police forces must be able to show that appropriate safeguards are in place, risks relating to bias and data retention are effectively managed, and decisions are still subject to human judgment," she said.
"A clearer statutory framework, stronger national standards and improved governance and oversight arrangements are essential to maintaining public confidence."
As well as legislative and governance-related concerns, HMICFRS also noted in its report that officers' training around the use of RFR remains inconsistent, and if improvements were made, this would lead to more effective and lawful use of RFR across the UK.
Another major issue was police forces' failure to meet their image retention obligations. Forces were found too often to retain custody images taken of suspects on the Police National Database, against which many RFR queries are made.
Police guidance sets out the scenarios in which custody images can and cannot be retained, and the inspectorate found that forces have failed to delete images that should have been wiped.
The Police Reform Bill includes a provision to group custody images with the likes of DNA and fingerprints, bringing about more robust measures to ensure they are retained or deleted in line with legal requirements.
A Home Office review previously found in 2017 that introducing such a statutory framework was untenable. It concluded that police could not automate the deletion of these images, and doing so manually would be too time-consuming.
Jasleen Chaggar, senior legal and policy officer at Big Brother Watch, said UK police cannot be allowed to continue to use RFR when it risks wrongfully arresting individuals.
"The revelations that officers are treating facial recognition as bona fide evidence rather than a probability score is alarming," she said.
"This approach significantly increases the risk that more innocent people will have officers knock on their door to arrest them for crimes committed in towns they've never visited, as we've seen before.
"Worse still, police aren't even logging their use of retrospective facial recognition, meaning people could wrongfully become suspects in criminal investigations without any record of why they've been accused."
Chaggar called on the government to "urgently step in" and help the UK's police forces to sort out the new frameworks needed for effective RFR use. ®
Trump Shivs JD Vance as Meltdown over GOP Losses Takes Unhinged Turn
Palantir's NHS cancer app gets plenty of praise, precious few users
Only a handful of NHS trusts are using the cancer app on the controversial £330 million Federated Data Platform (FDP) run by Palantir, while newly released figures raise questions about which trusts are benefiting.
Cancer 360 was designed to bring cancer patients' data from disparate spreadsheets and electronic health records into a central system, helping health professionals prioritize treatment.
Pilots began four years ago, and trusts are not charged directly for the FDP. Yet official figures put Cancer 360's uptake at just five or six trusts. Freedom of Information responses gathered by grassroots campaign group No Palantir in the NHS also reveal discrepancies between reported benefits and recorded use.
In June 2025, NHS England said that Cancer 360 "drastically cut down diagnosis times" and referred to a pilot at Chelsea and Westminster NHS Foundation Trust, which saw the proportion of patients diagnosed within 28 days climb from 72 percent to 85 percent.
The trust began trials in 2022, while working with Palantir under a £23 million contract awarded without competition, before the US firm was awarded the FDP contract in late 2023. Critics argued the FDP procurement was flawed as Palantir had developed use cases under £60 million in non-competitive contracts which were then carried over to the FDP.
Last year, NHS England said Cancer 360 served 46 registered teams and 239 active users, and processed 52,000 patients.
In June 2026, NHS England said there were five trusts using Cancer 360 as of March 2026. Of those, only two were listed as benefiting. In July, health minister Preet Kaur Gill repeated the five-trust usage figure in a Parliamentary answer.
Official data released in October said that as of June, six trusts were using Cancer 360 and five were benefiting, but did not identify the trusts or explain the increase. The stats have since been removed from the NHS England website but are archived here.
In June, NHS England responded to a Freedom of Information request. It said six trusts reported unique users logging into the Cancer 360 app over the last 12 months.
However, two trusts cited as having run successful pilots – Chelsea and Westminster Hospital and Royal United Hospitals Bath – were listed as having zero unique users logging into the system during that period, according to NHS England's reply.
Both trusts were said to have received benefits from the system, according to a FoI response sent to campaign group Foxglove in June this year.
The Register asked both trusts and NHS England to explain the discrepancy.
One of the six trusts said to be logging into the cancer app, East Lancashire Hospitals, reported just one unique user. It later confirmed in an FoI response in August that it was not live with the FDP. It had planned to adopt the platform, leading with Cancer 360, but did not have a date for going live with the app.
No Palantir in the NHS also identified trusts that considered Cancer 360 but decided against adopting it.
East Kent Hospitals University NHS Foundation Trust considered using the app but rejected it because there was "no immediate requirement for it," according to its FoI response.
In its FoI response, Bedfordshire Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust said it did not adopt the app because of issues around the metadata requirements.
Meanwhile, official figures on cancer diagnosis waiting times show wider improvements across England. Given Cancer 360's limited uptake, those national gains cannot simply be credited to the app.
In July this year, the UK's statistical regulator told NHS England to ensure ministers are briefed accurately following a row over data used to promote the purported benefits of the Palantir-run FDP.
Campaign group Foxglove had found that nearly a third of NHS trusts using Palantir's health data platform were performing fewer patient procedures than before it went live and that Chelsea and Westminster Hospital accounted for 84 percent of the reported fall in outpatient waiting lists, while only 16 trusts were using the FDP tool. The Office for Statistics Regulation began assessing NHS England's claims about the FDP's performance and the quango included more caveats on its website.
Scrutiny of the FDP's reported benefits comes as the government decides whether to continue the Palantir-led contract beyond February 2027. The initial contract was provided for a term of up to seven years, with a maximum value of £330 million.
Reports this week suggest the government is set to renew the contract, but run a parallel procurement to find an alternative to Palantir as pressure mounts to reduce lock-in to a single vendor and boost sovereign technology.
Palantir was founded with startup money from a CIA-linked VC firm and has relied on close ties with the US intelligence, military, and immigration services since its inception, although its recent growth in the wider business market is notable. ®
C++26 stumbles at finish line over Contracts dispute
The next version of the C++ programming language may be delayed at the last minute due to a dispute over a security-enhancing Contracts feature.
Contracts have deeply split C++ technical maintainers. One group backs the C++ creator Bjarne Stroustrup, who is against the technology in its present form in grounds it was hastily implemented. But others are eager to see Contracts implemented, even arguing the tech's detractors are poisoning the C++ development process itself.
The disagreement boiled over just before a vote to ratify the new version of the language.
In October, the Draft International Standard (DIS) of C++26 failed its ISO ballot — the next-to-last stage in the International Organization for Standardization’s approval process during which a standard's technical details are formally ratified by a set of national standards bodies.
The ballot saw 13 votes cast in favor, 9 against, and 12 abstentions, failing to meet the ISO requirement of having no more than 25 percent negative votes. Contracts was the major sticking point for those voting nay.
Contracts disputeContracts allow developers to add preconditions and postconditions to code, as well as assertions that check whether specified conditions hold. Such checks can help catch programming errors that might otherwise lead to undefined behavior.
Design by Contract has long been a feature of languages like Ada and Eiffel.
Developers have proposed adding Contracts to C++ for at least a decade, after when they were abruptly yanked from C++20 owing to concerns over dangerous defaults.
But Stroustrup roasted the revised proposal (P2900) that made it into C++26.
“The P2900 contracts and extensions aim to change the nature of C++ and are an existential threat to C++, adding complexity and bloat,” Stroustrup and his colleagues wrote in a paper last August. They noted that the implementation is messy, outdated, not sufficiently tested, and could be more effectively implemented as a library.
Not everyone agrees. Andreas Fertig, a member of the C++ standardization committee, feels that the criticisms have already been vetted and that vetoing the proposal this late in the C++ release process is damaging to C++ itself.
“The topic has been worked on for years and has received a majority vote multiple times in its current form. By voting ‘no,’ an established system, one based primarily on trust and respectful collaboration, has been shaken,” Fertig wrote in a blog post.
The elephant in the room is, of course, the ongoing criticism of how easy it is for developers to accidentally create security holes in C++, leading more than a few projects to adpot Rust. Adding controls might, as Stroustrup notes, hamper C++’s chief attribute of being a blazing-fast language.
Sore losersFertig accused Stroustrup and Co. of being sore losers.
“Every ISO standard is simply a set of compromises. Everyone loses sometimes, and everyone wins sometimes,” he wrote. But in this case, “the losing parties refused to accept their loss. The question that primarily determines how to move forward is whether the group can rebuild trust."
Unlike Fertig, Harry Bott, CEO of the C++ Alliance – which maintains the open source EDG C++ compiler front end – does not see the Contracts discussion as disruptive to C++ itself.
“The draft being sent back isn’t a failure of the process—it’s the process working as intended,” he wrote to The Register by email. “That doesn’t mean the process can’t improve. The goal should be to learn from this and strengthen the process so C++ can continue to evolve in a way developers can rely on.”
Where to now?With the ballot failing at this late point of the standardization process – a rarity in C++ history – the language risks missing its expected shipping date of this year. That outcome may force everyone to refer to the new version as “C++27” rather than C++26. (That’s only the informal name; the official name of this eighth version of the language, should it be released next year, would be “ISO/IEC 14882:2027.”)
ISO C++ working group WG21 is meeting next week in Búzios, Brazil, for the confronto final.
According to a blog post from Thibault Ricord-Marchal, a software engineering consultant at the Paris-based Margo consultancy, the group faces a number of choices.
They can carve Contracts out of the spec so the rest of C++26 can ship. That will be messy work, though. The undo button has to be smashed on a lot of library hardening already done using Contracts.
Another option is moving Contracts into a separate technical specification, where work can continue to refine the technology.
Or they could do a minor revision, vote again and hope the balmy Brazilian weather chills everyone out.®
Microsoft's massive M365 outage stretches past 12 hours as its fixes keep failing
In Australia, they’re calling it the “Microsoft long weekend” – an outage so pervasive it’s just about made Friday a write-off at organizations which rely on Redmond’s online services, especially Exchange Online.
As The Register reported yesterday, the outage started on Thursday at around 18:00 UTC and saw Microsoft 365 users unable to access email, attend Teams meetings, use cloud PCs, consult Copilot, or enjoy full access to another 15 hosted services.
The software giant says the outage impacts Microsoft 365 services “that interact with Exchange Online and email services.” Services that don’t need Exchange Online remain functional.
The software giant initially blamed the outage on a mysterious “problem that's causing servers to fail automated health checks and become unavailable.”
Microsoft thought it found a fix but quickly admitted “Actions taken thus far have not provided the anticipated relief.”
In the hours since, the situation has not improved markedly, and Microsoft is still struggling to restore service.
It’s also using changed the language it uses when discussing the possibility a cyberattack is the reason for the outage.
As of 04:11 UTC, the company said it could find “no indication this is the result of malicious activity.” An update time-stamped 05:46 UTC stated “As of now, we are not aware of any malicious activity that is causing this incident.”
Microsoft’s status page preserves only the company’s most recent update, but its RSS feed preserves each missive. That feed tells a tale of woe that we have distilled into lowlights and present in chronological order:
We’re applying infrastructure capacity improvements where possible in an effort to help support traffic in regions coming online;
We’ve monitored the status of the changes applied to improve serviceability and confirmed that change is not taking as expected;
We’re reviewing traffic flows and affected infrastructure to identify opportunities to optimize routing. This includes verifying the reasons for service failures so we can develop specific actions to improve stability;
We’re identifying alternate workstreams that can be applied to increase capacity in the face of sustained traffic management imbalances;
We're observing partial recovery across regions in which we've applied these adjustments; however, these actions aren't resulting in sustained recovery;
Current actions we are taking include scaling up virtual machines to increase capacity and reduce load. However, we are encountering issues with the machines being stuck in a bad state, preventing our changes from syncing as expected.
Microsoft’s latest status update doesn’t suggest this will be over any time soon.
“We’re continuing to pursue multiple workstreams to pinpoint the underlying cause of the traffic influx and advance the recoverability of the backend servers,” Microsoft wrote. “We’re taking a measured approach to identify and repair affected infrastructure to improve the ability to confirm the developed changes were applied. We’re tracking the results of this approach to verify the servers are showing the anticipated recovery and performance intended.”
Hopefully, Australia and other countries in nearby time zones won’t be the only ones to get an unscheduled long weekend. ®
Developer cleverly shrank 2,600 lines of C into a six-line script but still ending up losing sleep
Working in tech support can be thankless when gormless colleagues leave you sleepless. Which is why, each Friday, The Register runs a new instalment of On Call – the reader contributed column which ensures your work to keep tech alive doesn't remain unnoticed.
This week, meet a reader we'll Regomize as "Tim" who told that while working for a phone company he once rewrote 2,650 lines of C as a six line shell script.
He performed that feat after being asked to fix a data transfer program that, strangely, included a bespoke implementation of the venerable File Transfer Protocol (FTP).
"Writing the script took eight hours, most of it tracking down the source code of FTP so I could see if it would do what I wanted," Tim wrote.
This story took place before the World Wide Web became the way to find information online. To find the code he needed, Tim therefore used a Wide Area Information Server (WAIS) to search remote databases.
"In those days, there was no Linux and AT&T had licensed the Unix source code to universities with the struct proviso that it never be made publicly available," Tim explained. "It took me quite some time using WAIS to track it down – the security could have been better – and read the code."
Having found what he needed, Tim wrote his script, which ran overnight to collect data from the telco's switches, tidied up the raw info, and uploaded it to a mainframe.
"It would automatically page me if it couldn't connect to a switch or mainframe after three attempts," he explained.
The script worked fine, but the telco's networks didn't. Tim's pager was soon going off two or three times a night, every night.
After two weeks of interrupted sleep, Tim's manager kindly told him to give the pager to a colleague.
But that colleague habitually left the pager at work, forgot to turn it on, or conveniently placed it out of earshot.
So Tim reluctantly took back the pager and endured another few weeks of nightly interruptions.
How many consecutive sleepless nights have you endured while On Call? If you have enough energy, click here to send your story with On Call so we can share it on a future Friday. ®
Singapore says US authorities, and Supermicro, hardly helped investigation of Jensen Huang’s Chinese friend
The government of Singapore’s Ministry of Home Affairs has revealed it investigated Alice Huang, the woman who is an alleged Chinese intelligence asset and had an intimate relationship with former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang, and a possible entanglement with troubled server-maker Supermicro. US authorities provided only “limited assistance” in the matter, despite Singapore asking for help.
The Ministry outlined its activities in a statement published late on Thursday, Singapore time.
The document reveals that Singapore’s Police Force (SPF) and Customs agency commenced an investigation into Ms. Huang’s company, Megaspeed, in February 2025.
“The suspected domestic offences pertained to potential false declarations in relation to the purchase of servers and other related offences,” the Ministry wrote, adding that the exec “was not investigated for espionage.”
Singaporean authorities wanted to know if servers bought by local companies, but exported to Malaysia without ever touching Singaporean soil, might have ended up in a third country.
It is not unusual for Singapore-based companies to acquire goods that never reach the island, because it promotes itself as the ideal spot from which to run an operation that trades across Asia. Singapore does so because it is tiny – the whole nation is the same size as the five boroughs of New York City.
That small size means Singapore restricts the number of datacenters that can operate on its soil.
Those limits are a big reason why Malaysia’s Johor region, which is under 20kms from the border with Singapore and a joint special economic zone, has become a major datacenter province.
Singapore needs deals like that to thrive but works hard to ensure its hospitality is not abused.
Which is why it felt Megaspeed’s activities worthy of investigation.
US authorities were interested too. On 24 June 2025, the Bureau of Industry and Security, which regulates sensitive goods subject to export controls, visited Megaspeed in Singapore to check the hardware it bought arrived at its intended destination.
Ms. Huang attended that event and later met the SPF for an interview.
That meeting ended with the SPF impounding her passport, so it could keep her in Singapore while the investigation continued.
As the matter progressed, the SPF suspected perennially troubled server-maker Supermicro had a role in this situation.
Readers may recall that the US Department of Justice indicted two Supermicro execs for conspiring to ship servers to China in contravention of US law. Supermicro investigated the matter and parted ways with three staff who acted improperly. The company has denied ever selling to Megaspeed.
Singaporean authorities say they received only “limited cooperation” from Supermicro, so in July 2025 the office of the nation’s Attorney General asked US authorities for help.
“Since September 2025, SPF has repeated this request on several occasions to the US Department of Justice and the Federal Bureau of Investigation,” the statement reveals. “Despite these repeated requests, Singapore has to date received limited information or assistance in respect of the company.”
In February 2026, the SPF “concluded that there was insufficient evidence to establish that Huang had committed any offences relating to the possible inaccurate declarations for which Megaspeed was being investigated.”
But the police did decide that Ms. Huang provided inaccurate information “to downplay her role in Megaspeed.”
“She was issued a stern warning and barred from re-entering the country.”
The police returned her passport and Ms. Huang left Singapore on the same day.
The Singaporean statement shows the island nation wants the world to know it does not facilitate sanction-busting activity and takes even the hint of it seriously.
That matters to Nvidia, too, because Singaporean buyers sometimes account for over 20 percent of its quarterly revenue and may continue to do so. Whoever replaces Jensen Huang as Nvidia’s CEO will surely face many questions about the company’s practices. Singapore may just have made answering those queries a little easier. ®
YARR reports ICE agents, vehicles near Santa Cruz County Jail
Santa Cruz County Your Allied Rapid Response (YARR) reported Thursday afternoon that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents and four vehicles were in the area near the Santa Cruz County Jail, prompting a community alert.
In a social media post timestamped 5 p.m. Thursday, YARR said trained responders were on site monitoring the situation. The group shared photographs of several vehicles it said were associated with the federal agents.
View this post on InstagramAround 5 p.m., a black Chevrolet Escalade and a blue Ford Explorer were still parked outside the jail. Legal observers at the scene declined to speak with a Lookout reporter.
YARR urged community members to follow its social media accounts for updates and asked anyone whose family member or someone they know had been detained to call its support line at 831-239-4289.
Lookout has reached out to the Santa Cruz County Sheriff’s Office for comment but had not received a response as of publication.
Have something to say? Lookout welcomes letters to the editor, within our policies, from readers. Guidelines here.
The post YARR reports ICE agents, vehicles near Santa Cruz County Jail appeared first on Lookout Santa Cruz.
Alibaba's Qwen3.8 re-educated with a more Western worldview
An American AI lab has re-educated Qwen3.8-27B, a popular open-weight large language model from Alibaba, so the software forgets its Chinese ancestry.
Nous Research, an Austin, Texas-based AI lab, has subjected the model to re-education through training, not to be confused with China's "Re-education Through Labor" system.
With the help of a post-training process, Qwen3.8-27B has been reborn under the name Arete "to reinforce Western values on a Chinese-trained model."
What qualifies as a "Western value" remains open to interpretation.
"Open-weight Chinese models are among the strongest available, but they ship with state-aligned behavior baked into the weights," Nous Research wrote in a blog post.
Your correspondent tested this with a variant model, Qwen3.8-27B-MLX-6bit, locally. Asked about events during 1989 in Tiananmen Square, the model either refused to discuss the topic or provided euphemistic response. What's perhaps more surprising is that Anthropic claims operators affiliated with Alibaba's Qwen lab used outputs from its Claude models to train competing AI models via distillation.
Nous Research, maker of the Hermes Agent, cites that sort of censorship as a risk for users of AI models trained in China. The concern comes amid broader scrutiny of Chinese influence in the tech industry, heightened by Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang's resignation following controversy involving a woman US intelligence has accused of spying for China.
Nous says the risk posed by Chinese-made AI models go beyond promoting Beijing's worldview. Some Middle Kingdom models have been found to produce more vulnerable code under certain conditions, according to a study by Booz Allen Hamilton, which does a lot of business with the US government.
Hirundo, a vendor which says it is building "the first Machine Unlearning Platform to ensure that AI models only know what they should," makes the same argument. The company also notes that its efforts to apply "unlearning" to Qwen3.6-35B-A3B saw a dramatic drop in output that reflects Communist Party of China's preferred censorship, propaganda messaging, or bias. 89.8 percent of the model's output reflected those values before unlearning reduced the incidence to 2.8 percent.
Nous Research did not achieve such dramatic results, but did see an overall reduction in viewpoints deemed to be propaganda.
"On our evaluation, Arete-27B raised its fact score from 2.32 to 2.98 out of 5 and cut answers containing propaganda from 22 percent to 1 percent, in line with the Western models we tested," the company said.
To handle Arete's unlearning, Nous Research says it briefly considered Nvidia's Nemotron 3 Ultra, "but had found evidence that it too had a checkered record on China-related topics."
"We don't know definitively, but theorize that the bias imparted to Nemotron came from working with Chinese open models during the training process," the company said. "We have experienced similar contamination, because the vast majority of high quality open models are Chinese, and only open models have terms of use that permit this kind of tinkering and experimentation."
In the end, the biz tapped Inkling, an open weight model from US-based Thinking Machines Lab, to act as the teaching model.
Nous Research says its model re-education efforts show that the propaganda layer is shallow and, with 50 million tokens worth of supervised learning, is relatively easy to remove. ®
Meet Marnûkh: RINGS OF POWER Showrunners Talk Orc with an Arc
- The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season three’s showrunners and cast explained new character Marnûkh, an orc with an arc.
If there was one character that was close to my heart in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power‘s first two seasons, it was that of the Orc (Uruk) Father, Adar. Adar knew that every one of his children “has a name, a heart… Are creations of the One, Master of the Secret Fire, the same as you. As worthy of the breath of life, and just as worthy of a home.” And although his execution lacked a little bit to be desired, Adar’s aim to create a life for his orc children, one where they could thrive and be seen as just as important as any other race, was a truly noble one. Alas, Sauron, the Great Deceiver, turned Adar’s softest parts against him, convincing his children to slay their own father. “They are not children anymore,” Sauron told Adar as he lay dying. But is that so? Are the orcs now definitively orcs, or are they Uruk? For me, it has been a central question of The Rings of Power. And now, a new “orc with an arc” has come to the forefront of the narrative, ready to test the question of nature vs. nurture one more time. At SDCC, I spoke with The Rings of Power‘s showrunners and cast about Marnûkh, the latest and greatest hope for Uruk Nation. Here’s what I learned about his new orc with an arc.
Prime Video
At The Rings of Power season three’s San Diego Comic-Con panel, it was revealed that Marnûkh, played by Adam Young, “claims that he has turned his back against Sauron and he wants to now help the elves defeat the Dark Lord. But can you trust an orc?” That is THE quandary. And it’s not an easy one to come to a conclusion on, share The Rings of Power showrunners, J.D. Payne and Patrick McKay, when I ask after Marnûkh in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season three.
And it turns out Marnûkh, himself, doesn’t make it any easier. Payne revealed more about the orc with and arc in The Rings of Power, “Marnûkh and [actor]Adam Young bring such a wonderful quality to this orc character, where part of you thinks, ‘Oh, he’s sort of sweet and funny, and there’s something sensitive to him.’ And even dare I say, poetic and soulful about him. But then, also, he’s constantly sort of undercutting things, and there’s part of him that’s gross and frightening. And so he constantly keeps everyone guessing.” Listen, who among us isn’t sometimes sweet and funny and sometimes gross and frightening? It sounds to us like Marnûkh is just a multi-faceted character trying his best to be more than what fate has decided for him on The Rings of Power season three.
But what will Marnûkh’s relationships with the other characters in his orc-arc, Galadriel and Arondir, look like this season on The Rings of Power. Payne notes of Galadriel meeting Marnûkh, “It puts Galadriel in a really interesting place, because as we’ve seen in previous seasons, she despises the orcs and she’s fought against them for years and years and years because they’ve taken everything from her that she loves. But now in this season, she’s in a position where she has to decide if she can trust an orc or not.”
Of course, Galadriel went on something of a journey with Adar in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season two. And though she doesn’t ever quite apologize for slaying many of his children on her quest for vengeance, she does appear to come around to the idea that orcs/Uruk may have a purpose for existing beyond just evil, and potentially a heart worth saving, by the end of The Rings of Power season two. But does she remember those times with Adar after so many years of war against Sauron and the Orcs?
Prime Video
McKay laughs when I ask that very question, “Well, I think Marnûkh is hoping she does.” When I follow up wondering if Marnûkh remembers Adar, I don’t receive a clear answer. So we’ll have to wait and see.
Of course, Galadriel isn’t the only elf that Marnûkh will have to win over in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season three. The trio becomes complete with Arondir. At the SDCC panel, Arondir’s actor, Ismael Cruz Córdova, shared about Arondir and Marnûkh, “We have this relationship, this odd couple relationship, we don’t trust each other, we don’t like each other. He stinks.” But despite everything, Cruz Córdova shares with me that Arondir wants to trust the orcs.
RELATED ARTICLE
The Orcs, The Ents, and the Question of Peace on THE RINGS OF POWERCruz Córdova reveals, “I think Arondir has been surrounded by darkness from minute 1, second 27, of the first episode of The Rings of Power. And he hasn’t been able to really have a lot of redemption from that. And I think that experience of leaning into that darkness and being curious about that darkness is at the core of who he is. That deep curiosity of ‘What’s at the other side, what is my purpose? Who are the ones that I can trust?’ But also, I think he wrestles with not liking orcs because I think he sees them… I think he sees them as one of his own. I think he sees orcs as victims. I think his vendetta with Adar was because I respected him in a certain way. And then he still turned around and killed the love of my life. So I think it’s a very emotional knee-jerk reaction and it’s understandable, but I don’t think he’s completely has given himself to that darkness.”
Prime Video
We’ve said it once, and we’ll say it again: Arondir is the most elfy elf of all. And his ability to see beyond the hard lines drawn in the sand to the common origin of orcs and elves, and the way the orcs could not help but become what they were, is truly so beautiful. For Arondir and Marnûkh, this understanding could be a key to both their healing, if they can find a way to fully trust one another. Cruz Córdova concludes, “There’s a softness and openness and different colors that we placed in this story this time around.”
More About Marnûkh (Updated 11/12/26)Since San Diego Comic-Con, we’ve had the pleasure of hearing more about Marnûkh from the showrunners and cast. Of course, the first episodes have now aired, allowing us all to meet Marnûkh and see his odd-couple x2 relationships with Arondir and Galadriel.
Payne and McKay recently told us the relationship between Arondir and Marnûkh really touched them. They share, “Arondir develops a friendship with an orc, Marnûkh, which is the most unexpected and unlikely of journeys for him to go on. I mean, I think of all our principal elves, he’s perhaps the most mistrustful of orcs. Orcs killed the woman he loved in his mind. So we find it quite touching and even at times, funny, the way that he goes from enemies to frenemies with Marnûkh the orc. And we sort of jokingly would call it orc-elf bromance by the time you’re deep into the season.” We would certainly call it a beautiful friendship by the time of The Rings of Power episode four, one we’d have loved to see bloom. But alas, Arondir met his death, and Marnûkh’s fate remains unknown.
Speaking also of Galadriel and Marnûkh, the showrunners call up one of my favorite characters, Adar, and the relationship he shared with Galadriel. They note, “There’s something ironic in the trio with Galadriel because there was a time when Galadriel said to Adar, “I’m going to kill every last one of your children. I’m going to kill all of the orcs.” And now she’s in a position of having to actually be more Marnûkh sympathetic. Galadriel developed some kind of trust with Adar in the prior season, so she is slightly more willing to trust Marnûkh and finds herself in the very strange position of having to hold Arondir at bay at certain times and keep the relationship with Marnûkh just positive enough that they can find out if he’s really telling the truth.” We think Adar would have been proud to see Galadriel using Uruk more times than orc… At the very least, in Marnûkh’s presence.
Meanwhile, Ismael Cruz Córdova, who plays Arondir, says it’s Arondir’s compassion and curiosity that ultimately allow him to forgive Marnûkh and forge a kind of friendship and a path forward. “He has compassion, and he has curiosity that I think one comes before the other,” Cruz Córdova shares. “I think curiosity can lead you to compassion. Curiosity can lead you to many, many positive places, really. And that’s what he had with Adar. And I think he has that with humans, and I think he brings that always to himself, distills that into a being. Who is this person? Who is this being? Who is a father, a mother, a brother, a sister? But as you say, there are so many times that he’s done this by this point that have ended up in loss and in pain. And he’s lost his best friend; he lost his commander that was like his dad. He loses all of his soldiers; he loses the love of his life. Where is Theo? So this goodness has gotten tried and tested. So I would expect that there’s perhaps a wall that had to be built up for this, and definitely Marnûkh triggers him quite a bit. But he has that desire for compassion.”
As for Marnûkh himself. Although his fate remains unknown in The Rings of Power, we know his heart. Showrunners Payne and McKay reveal that Adar’s dream of a free Uruk nation “did not die with him.” And it’s Marnûkh who has picked up the mantle.
“Not all the orcs and Uruk are happy to be under the control of their new master Sauron.” The pair share, “In fact, some of them see Sauron as an existential threat to the entire Uruk race and still have Adar’s dreams for a free orc nation really deep in their hearts. And so one of those characters in particular, Marnûkh, is going to be one that we are going to be following over the course of the season. We talked about an orc with an arc last season. I think we’re going to go even deeper with that, where an orc proves to be truly three-dimensional and who part of you doesn’t trust because they’re an orc, and you have an inherent distrust in them, but part of you can laugh with and smile at and really kind of fall in love with.”
And fall in love with him, we have. Whatever happens to Marnûkh, we know this is one The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season three storyline that we’ll be seated for.
The Rings of Power season three premieres on Prime Video on November 11. The full release schedule can be found here.
Originally published on July 30, 2026.
Rotem Rusak is the Editor-in-Chief at Nerdist. She is a great lover of the anti-hero and is always ready for a new ship to set sail. In her work, she likes to combine fandom passion with journalistic sensibilities. Follow her on Instagram.The post Meet Marnûkh: RINGS OF POWER Showrunners Talk Orc with an Arc appeared first on Nerdist.
Costa Rican authorities make arrests in killing of Santa Cruz surfing legend Kurt Van Dyke
The SAVE America Act wouldn’t have stopped the blue wave
President Donald Trump went on a posting bender Thursday, and among his rants was this one: His passive-aggressive dig at Thune was fun, not gonna lie. But is it true that the SAVE America Act would’ve spared Republicans from devastation this election? Trump highlights two key components of the SAVE act: a voter ID requirement and proof of citizenship. But look at the states where…